Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Look folks, it's very simple. Until Clinger gives up his "religion" in the beginning and ending of B lines *IN A VACUUM*, he's not moving on to part 5, it's that simple.

Clinger himself explained to us that his freshman physics textbook (evidently still in his personal possession) never once mentioned the term "reconnection". Clinger then should be able to explain that quadrapolar magnetic field experiment *IN A VACUUM* without once mentioning "reconnection", and he should do so based upon "the party line dogma of physics" that monopoles do not exist, and magnetic lines have no beginning, nor any ending.

He needs to provide NO MORE MATH, nor ANYMORE GRAPHS. All I want is a clear VERBAL EXPLANATION of an ordinary quadrapolar magnetic field in a vacuum WITHOUT the term "reconnection" and WITHOUT claiming that B lines begin and end. Every single freshman has to be able to explain it to move on. Clinger has to do that too. I'm not asking for much.
 
Last edited:
By the way...

Any of you that would like to help Clinger out *PRIVATELY*, are free to do so. I've already provided all the help he needs, but I doubt he will listen to me. Maybe some of you might set him straight so his next presentation passes muster? I'm personally itching to know if he comes out of the closet in part 5. The suspense is killing me. :)
 
MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point

Do the B field lines begin (and end) at X *IN A VACUUM* (no particles whatsoever), not even a "monopole"?
The answer is so obvious, MM: Yes.
This is what all of the textbooks on magnetic reconnection state. No one's opinion (tusenfem, mine, W.D. Clinger or even yours) will change this physical fact. So it is ridiculous to basically do a poll on a forum thread that you will probably ignore (given your record of ignoring the science so far).
Read the textbooks, MM.

This is also what the definition of magnetic fields lines states. Which is why I asked:
Since you want to be spoon-fed the answer, here it is
The precise definition of a field line is
Precise definition
A vector field defines a direction at all points in space; a field line for that vector field may be constructed by tracing a topographic path in the direction of the vector field. More precisely, the tangent line to the path at each point is required to be parallel to the vector field at that point.
A complete description of the geometry of all the field lines of a vector field is sufficient to completely specify the direction of the vector field everywhere. In order to also depict the magnitude, a selection of field lines is drawn such that the density of field lines (number of field lines per unit perpendicular area) at any location is proportional to the magnitude of the vector field at that point.
The magnitude of the vector field (the magnetic field) at a neutral point is zero. Thus the density of field lines at the neutral point is zero.
A density of zero means that no field line passes though the neutral point.

In magnetic reconnection in a vacuum, the magnetic field lines form an X that crosses at the neutral point. By definition these field lines cannot go through the neutral point. They have to end and begin at the neutral point.

This is what scientists have been stating for over 60 years now.
 
The answer is so obvious, MM: Yes.

BZZT!

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_field

B-field lines never endMain article: Gauss's law for magnetism

Field lines are a useful way to represent any vector field and often reveal sophisticated properties of fields quite simply. One important property of the B-field revealed this way is that magnetic B field lines neither start nor end (mathematically, B is a solenoidal vector field); a field line either extends to infinity or wraps around to form a closed curve.[nb 8] To date no exception to this rule has been found. (See magnetic monopole below.)

Unless you've got a monopole hiding in that magic hat of yours, FOREGETABOUTIT! Epic WRONG ANSWER!
 
Look folks, it's very simple. Until Clinger gives up his "religion" in the beginning and ending of B lines *IN A VACUUM*, he's not moving on to part 5, it's that simple.
...snipped embarrassing display of ignorance...\
Look, MM, it's very simple. Your ignorance of the physics will not stop W.D. Clinger from going onto part 5.
The insanity of thinking that you can force anyone to stop posting in an Internet forum is obvious :eye-poppi.

W.D. Clinger is stating the science that B lines *IN A VACUUM* begin and end at a neutral point when they cross it, he's moving on to part 5, it's that simple.

Maybe this is something else you cannot understand: MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point
 
He needs to provide NO MORE MATH, nor ANYMORE GRAPHS. All I want is a clear VERBAL EXPLANATION of an ordinary quadrapolar magnetic field in a vacuum WITHOUT the term "reconnection" and WITHOUT claiming that B lines begin and end. Every single freshman has to be able to explain it to move on. Clinger has to do that too. I'm not asking for much.


Do physics without math! No, that isn't asking for much. :boggled:

Demanding, uncivilly and impolitely as it is, that other people should somehow demonstrate the validity of the electric Sun conjecture is shifting the burden of proof. It's a dishonest logical fallacy, and as an argument, it's intellectually bankrupt.
 
BZZT!
Try reading what you quote and looking at the footnotes.
Try reading W.D. Clinger's posts about the limitation of the Wikipedia article.
Try reading any of the many MR textbooks that state that magnetic field lines do end and begin at a neutral point.
Try reading any of the many sceintific papers state that magnetic field lines do end and begin at a neutral point.
 
By the way...

Any of you that would like to help Clinger out *PRIVATELY*, are free to do so. I've already provided all the help he needs, but I doubt he will listen to me.
By the way ....

You are wrong if you think that you have been trying to help W.D. Clinger.
Helping him would involve you showing that you understand his posts and pointing pout the math or physics errors that he has made.

All you have been doing is whining about his posts from a stance of ignorance. That whining and ignorance is why he may not be listening to you.

W.D. Clinger has been doing a great job *PUBLICALLY*.
He does have an advantage over you (and me!) in that he has the relevant textbooks to work from.
 
Last edited:
Helping him would involve you showing that you understand his posts and pointing pout the math or physics errors that he has made.

Been there, done that twice now. I made him fix the graph the first time, hoping he would stop confusing the origin of the graph with the origin of the magnetic lines. He didn't take that hint. I then FULLY explained his errors, which he then HIGHLIGHTED in full. I don't know what more I can now do for him. His graph is fine, his math is fine, his understanding of that math and WHAT that graph actually means stinks to high heaven. :confused:
 
Last edited:
Try reading any of the many sceintific papers state that magnetic field lines do end and begin at a neutral point.

Try finding one *IN A VACUUM*. Hint: The "exception" to the no beginning, no ending rule would be a MONOPOLE RC, not a NULL point in the line!
 
Last edited:
Do physics without math! No, that isn't asking for much. :boggled:

It's not his math or his graph that is FUBAR, it's his UNDERSTANDING of WHAT THAT MATH MEANS that is FUBAR. When he UNDERSTANDS what he wrote, I'll be a happy camper.


So the math is correct, and the graph is correct. And the math shows no magnetic field lines pass through the neutral point indicated by the origin on the graph. So there doesn't seem to be a problem.

Of course demanding that other people need to demonstrate the validity of the electric Sun conjecture is shifting the burden of proof, a dishonest logical fallacy, and an intellectually bankrupt argument.
 
Try finding one *IN A VACUUM*. Hint: The "exception" to the no beginning, no ending rule would be a MONOPOLE RC, not a NULL point in the line!
How stupid: The X point that you have been talking about in W.D. Clinger's posts is a neutral point *IN A VACUUM*. You have even called it that! It is
  • a neutral point and
  • *IN A VACUUM*.
Hint: There is no "no beginning, no ending rule".
There is a statement in many places that B lines do not end or start for magnetic fields from a single current or a magnet. This is true.
Some sources say that Gauss's law means that B lines do not end or start. This is true for the stated situations but not in general.

Counterexample:
Look at the field at a neutral point. Draw any surface around it and integral of the field at the surface is zero (any B.dA is matched by an opposite B.dA so the sum is zero). Gauss's law is obeyed.
But at the neutral point there can be no magnetic field lines by definition :eye-poppi !

MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point
 
Do the B field lines begin (and end) at X *IN A VACUUM* (no particles whatsoever), not even a "monopole"?

A fact that you seem to be keep on missing is that magnetic fields (as generated e.g. by the current rods of Clinger) does not need a plasma or anything to exist. It is a field, which is generated by the currents, and has a very simple vacuum solution. So there is no need for any plasma.

Now on to the X point (or line, if you extend the figure that Clinger provided out of the page). There are various kinds of field lines and you can split them up into groups:

the U in the "north" region
the < in the "east"
the > in the "west"
the ⋂ in the "south"

Now, there is a place (line) in space which separates these regions, that is called the separatrix, and in the figure that is the big X that goes from top-left corner to bottom-right corner and from top-right corner to bottom-left corner. These separatrices are actual field lines of the vector field (which is a continuum as you so like to impress on us), and a field line does no more than show how the vector field is shaped, and the direction of the field is given by the tangent to the field line and the field strength is given by the density of the field lines.

Now, of course there is a "problem" with the separatrices, because ... they cross eachother! Field lines cannot cross eachother, or can they? If they cross that would mean that the field as two different directions at that point, which is physically impossible, unless ... the field is zero at that point where the field lines cross.

Let us now look at the figure by Clinger, lo and behold the separatrices cross eachother exactly in the middle of the figure, where oh-my-gawd the field is zero.

What does this have for philosophical consequences? We can follow a certain field line in the vector field (which is a continuum) which is just next to the separatrix, say in the north. It will move along the separatrix towards the origin of the figure (which is well chosen to be in the middle of the figure), but when it gets very close to (0,0) it starts to veer off (in a very low magnetic field strength) and makes a curve and moves up again along the other separatrix.

The separatrix itself cannot escape the crossing point (otherwise it would not be a separatrix) so it must continue on its course towards (0,0) in the figure, where the field is also zero. And here comes the philosophical question, when a field line reaches a location where the field is zero and thus there is no direction to the magnetic vector field? One thing you can say is that the field line ends there, because it has nowhere to go at that point. However, we must take into account that there are four parts to the separatrices that make the X. Note how two of them point away from the X and two of them point towards the X.

Then we have the situation that can be interpreted in the following way: there are two field lines that are going towards the X and end there and there are two field lines that are goina away from the X and start there. So, the one's end is the other's beginning. There is still continuity, but the crossing of the field lines implicitely means that the field has to be zero at that point.

There is no need for plasma, there is no need for monopoles. There is however need for reconnection of the field lines when the current in two diagonally opposite current rods is changed, because the separatrices will change their location. In that square box the X will not be at right angles anymore but will be at a sharp(blunt) angle, depending on which wind direction you look, and thus new connections will have to be made.
 
A fact that you seem to be keep on missing is that magnetic fields (as generated e.g. by the current rods of Clinger) does not need a plasma or anything to exist. It is a field, which is generated by the currents, and has a very simple vacuum solution. So there is no need for any plasma.

Nobody disputed that the field exists without plasma in the first place.

Wow did you do a 180 degree turn there or what?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7745713&postcount=4798

Why on Earth would they "begin at the X" that makes no sense at all!

Again, read up on the first chapters of a book on reconnection, that you actually understand the basics of Petschek and Sweet-Parker.

Talk about back peddling on a dime tusenfem. The moment you discovered it was Clinger that made the claim, not me, now you're doing everything in your power to sweep his bush-league mistake under the carpet? Really?

My full response may have to wait until the morning, but you're absolutely wrong in terms of any magnetic lines BEGINNING and ENDING at X. Magnetic flux changes might take place when he futzes with the power, but that's it. No monopoles, no begining or ending of magnetic lines.

When are you even claiming this "beginning" of a B line at X happens? When it's just "on", or when someone changes the field of the poles and MAGNETIC FLUX DENSITY CHANGES OCCUR?
 
Last edited:
What does this have for philosophical consequences?

Philosophical consequences? I thought we were talking physics?

We can follow a certain field line in the vector field (which is a continuum) which is just next to the separatrix, say in the north. It will move along the separatrix towards the origin of the figure (which is well chosen to be in the middle of the figure), but when it gets very close to (0,0) it starts to veer off (in a very low magnetic field strength) and makes a curve and moves up again along the other separatrix.

I guess this your "low field strength of the gaps" argument? In term of kinetic energy, what is *IT* that starts to "veer off", and why in the world would it "veer off"? You do realize that magnetic fields aren't really LINES at all, right, they are whole fields?

The whole FIELD is suddenly veering off for no reason, or one MONOPOLE jumps from one field to the other?

How would ANY of this explain any B lines "beginning and ending" at X as Clinger claimed?
 
Last edited:
There is no need for plasma, there is no need for monopoles.

Boloney. No plasma, no induced E field, no electrical discharge. No monopole, no BEGINNING or ENDING of any magnetic lines. Those are the physical facts.

There is however need for reconnection of the field lines when the current in two diagonally opposite current rods is changed, because the separatrices will change their location.

The only thing that will happen is the WHOLE FIELD (not one line) is going to change, and magnetic flux densities with shift along with magnetic field topologies. Since there is no plasma, there will be no inducement of an E, and no electrical discharge. No lines/fields have to "reconnect". All that has to happen is MAGNET FLUX CHANGES. IMO you're evoking a "small veering of the gaps" argument where none is warranted or required. Basic theory can explain the changes in the field strengths *WITHOUT* the term "reconnection"!
 
Cranks and crackpots
The cranks and crackpots examine unconventional ideas, but become strongly attached to them. Any error in their analysis, even basic errors that can be easily demonstrated, are not acknowledged. In the rare case where they do provide a reasonably testable scientific model, the one successful prediction it might make, in their minds, outweighs the dozens of predictions where it fails.

The cranks rarely use good scientific methodologies, instead claiming 'logic', or the 'obvious' interpretation of some data-driven image or movie is the basis for their knowledge. They make extreme claims about how their theories explain every observation, yet it is difficult to impossible to get these theories into a form that others can do calculations which can be compared to actual measurements. The theories of cranks and crackpots flunk the important scientific test of reproducibility. Their theories are often only supported by a tiny set of cherry-picked, anecdotal, events extracted from a much larger body of contrary evidence.
LINK:hit:
 

Link :id:

Haters are all alike. The topics change, but the behaviors are identical. When you don't want to embrace the fact that E induced fields and electrical discharges can *ONLY* occur in a plasma, not his vacuum contraption, you just keep attacking the individual. How sad that that you can't get yourself off the hate-go-round.

The fact all four of you haters *STILL* believe that Origin is the great beginor and endor of magnetic B lines from a VACUUM, is a RIOT!
 
Last edited:
Then we have the situation that can be interpreted in the following way: there are two field lines that are going towards the X and end there and there are two field lines that are going away from the X and start there. So, the one's end is the other's beginning. There is still continuity, but the crossing of the field lines implicitly means that the field has to be zero at that point.

There is no need for plasma, there is no need for monopoles. There is however need for reconnection of the field lines when the current in two diagonally opposite current rods is changed, because the separatrices will change their location. In that square box the X will not be at right angles anymore but will be at a sharp(blunt) angle, depending on which wind direction you look, and thus new connections will have to be made.
Like this:

mr100.gif


That animation shows the spatial region immediately surrounding the neutral point of B4 (see below). It shows how the magnetic field lines will change when the current running through the north and south rods is varied between 999.9 and 1000.1 amperes. That animation was generated from equations that are themselves straightforward consequences of Maxwell's equations.

When are you even claiming this "beginning" of a B line at X happens? When it's just "on", or when someone changes the field of the poles and MAGNETIC FLUX DENSITY CHANGES OCCUR?
As explained previously, exactly four magnetic field lines begin or end at the neutral point in every xy plane of the static magnetic field B4 defined by

[latex]
\[
\begin{align*}
\hbox{{\bf B}}^{(p)} &= \hbox{{\bf B}}^{(p)} (x, y, z, t) = \hbox{{\bf B}}^{(p)} (t) (x, y, z) \\
&= \frac{\mu_0}{2 \pi} \frac{I^{(p)}(t)}{(x-x_0)^2+(y-y_0)^2}
\left( - (y-y_0) \, \hbox{{\bf e}}_x + (x-x_0) \, \hbox{{\bf e}}_y \right)
\end{align*}
\]
[/latex]​
(which is the equation for the magnetic field generated by a conducting rod orthogonal to the xy plane at <x0, y0>) and

[latex]
\[
\hbox{{B}}_4 = \hbox{{B}}_E + \hbox{{B}}_W + \hbox{{B}}_N + \hbox{{B}}_S
\]
[/latex]​
where BE, BW, BN, BS are the magnetic fields generated by steady 1000-ampere currents running through four conducting rods positioned on the x and y axes exactly 1 meter from the origin, with the currents running in the positive z direction for the east and west rods but in the negative z direction for the north and south rods. For a false-color graph of B4, click on this link:

[qimg]http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/figure1zoomout.png[/qimg]

As was proved in a previous post, no magnetic field lines of B4 go through that neutral point at the origin:

The magnetic field lines of a magnetic field B are the curves that run parallel to B. By a curve in three-dimensional space, we mean a one-parameter function c(γ) that maps values of its real parameter γ to points in 3-space. By parallel to B, we mean that the derivative of c(γ) with respect to γ is B(c(γ)) at every point on the curve (in other words, for every real number γ). Formally:

[latex]
\[
\begin{align*}
\frac{\partial c}{\partial \gamma} &= \hbox{{\bf B}}(c(\gamma))
\end{align*}
\]
[/latex]​

In other words, a magnetic field line is a curve that satisfies that differential equation.
B4=0 at the origin, so no magnetic field line can enter or leave the origin.

The magnetic field lines on the x=y diagonals point directly toward the origin and are making progress toward the origin at all nonzero values of x=y (because B4 points toward the origin for all nonzero values of x=y), so those two magnetic field lines end at the origin.

The magnetic field lines on the x=-y diagonals point directly away from the origin and are making progress away from the origin at all nonzero values of x=-y (because B4 points away from the origin for all nonzero values of x=-y), so those two magnetic field lines begin at the origin.

How would ANY of this explain any B lines "beginning and ending" at X as Clinger claimed?
See above.

No plasma, no induced E field, no electrical discharge. No monopole, no BEGINNING or ENDING of any magnetic lines. Those are the physical facts.
As shown above, the highlighted statement is false. The other statements are true: Magnetic reconnection is a direct consequence of Maxwell's equations, and can occur without plasma, with an arbitrarily small induced E field, with no electrical discharges, and with no currents at all within a region that extends quite some distance beyond the neutral point where reconnection occurs.

Do the math.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom