Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
You have made that particular claim now multiple times in this thread, and it's just plain wrong. Of course you will get induced fields in a vacuum. How could you possibly not get induced fields in a vacuum?

[latex]
Faraday's Law of Induction:
\nabla \times \hbox{{\bf E}} = \frac{\partial \hbox{{\bf B}}}{\partial t}

Ampere's Law:
\nabla \times \hbox{{\bf B}} = \mu_0 \hbox{{\bf J}} + \mu_0 \epsilon_0 \frac{\partial \hbox{{\bf E}}}{\partial t}
[/latex]

Faraday's law of induction works like gangbusters in a vacuum. Set the current density (J) in Ampere's Law to zero and we are back to the vacuum again. Change the electric field and you get an induced magnetic field. Of course in a vacuum there are no charged particles to accelerate, but there are still fields (which you can check by putting test charges into your vacuum and watching them bend to the will of the fields present). Yes, you certainly can induce B and E fields in a vacuum.

As you and The Man have surmised and correctly pointed out, that particular statement of mine is both sloppy and factually incorrect. I should have used (and been using) the term "electrical current", not "E field". My apologies, and thank you both for pointing it out. I amend my statements to read: "You can't INDUCE an electrical current in a PURE VACUUM that is utterly devoid of plasma particles. No induced current will occur in the vacuum.

FYI Tim, I'll spend some time this weekend to see if I can find the paper in question by Priest about monopoles.

In the meantime, since you and The Man have a proven track record now of pulling the splinters and twigs out of my eye over my errors in this discussion, how about spending some time with Clinger explaining to him that *IN A VACUUM* (not a plasma) B field lines have no source or sink, no beginning or ending and that a NULL is not a "beginning" nor an "ending" of any B line? That would really help move things along.
 
Last edited:
FYI Tim, neither of those two papers is the monopole paper in question. The particular paper I'm thinking of was by Priest only (no other author that I recall), and it didn't discuss plasma physics to my recollection. It was pretty much a fully B oriented paper as I recall.
 
Holy Cow! Is Priest a paper writing machine or what? He makes Alfven look lazy! ADS has over 500 listings by Priest! This is a bit like looking for a needle in a haystack. I'll work on it Tim, but I have a real job to work today as well. I'll find it, but it will take me some time.
 
The properties of sources and sinks of a linear force-free field
Demoulin & Priest; Astronomy and Astrophysics 258(2): 535-541 (May 1992)

Tim, check out section 3.1 between equations 16 and 17 where Priests mathematically turns moving charged particles (aka current) into "magnetic charges" (aka monopoles). Are you sure that you and I can't just agree on "current reconnection" and be done with it and move on to "magnetic flux tubes"? You of all people should be able to see how Priest is converting electrons into monopoles between equations 16 and 17.
 
In these papers, monopolar fields are used as a device to simplify calculation.

You hit the nail on the head IMO, but that's the WHOLE PROBLEM. They're basically CONVERTING current into monopoles mathematically to "simplify" the equations for B Tim. It's still CURRENT at the level of physics, even if it's "magnetic charge" for the purposes of simplifying for a B orientation. I really don't understand why you and I cannot just agree on the term "current reconnection" and move on.

I DO NOT DOUBT is it's a useful tool for simplifying the math to call it "magnetic charge". I DO DOUBT that monopoles actually physically exist, and I do not doubt that it's actually CURRENT that does the 'reconnecting'.
 
Last edited:
Tim, think about how confusing that "device" as you call it, must be to poor Clinger about now. Holy smokes! IMO basic theory is hard enough, and plasma physics is CHALLENGING for anyone, but taking "poetic license" with physics is unacceptable IMO. I really do feel for sorry for any poor uninitiated soul trying to unravel all this "piss poor" naming nonsense. Even a really good mathematician like Clinger is bound to completely confuse the PROCESS as he's been doing now since day one. If a good mathematician gets confused, what hope is there for a struggling college student to grasp the "magnetic reconnection" process correctly? If you simply called it "current reconnection", it would make perfect sense to that graduating freshman.

Honestly, someone competent, BESIDES ME on basic theory and sources and sinks needs to set Clinger straight. I'm dying to find out if he's coming out of the closet in part five and this is just annoying at this point. Please Tim or The Man explain to Clinger that B field have no source, no sink, no beginning and no ending. Do so privately if you prefer. If and when anyone finds a REAL monopole rather than an an ELECTRON RENAMING DEVICE that allow mathematical equations to be simplified for B, then you can call it "magnetic reconnection" with my blessings. What poor Clinger has gone through over the past year however DEMONSTRATES CONCLUSIVELY that the name selected by Dungey to describe an electrical discharge in a plasma *STINKS TO HIGH HEAVEN*. It's TOO DAMN CONFUSING!
 
Last edited:
"Current Reconnection" and Magnetic Monopoles

Why Not "Current Reconnection"?

I really don't understand why you and I cannot just agree on the term "current reconnection" and move on. { ... } I do not doubt that it's actually CURRENT that does the 'reconnecting'.


Because "current reconnection" is a very poor description of what actually, physically happens. Currents "reconnect", if that word is even applicable, only after the magnetic field topology has changed ("magnetic reconnection" is a change in the topology of the magnetic field). The energy that powers the "reconnection" of the currents is derived directly from the magnetic field, which has topologically transformed into a lower energy state. The energy source is the reconnection of the magnetic field and therefore "magnetic reconnection" is the correct and proper description of what physically happens. I do not doubt that it is actually the magnetic field that does the reconnecting. The physics is really obvious.

Magnetic Monopoles and Magnetic Reconnection

In these papers, monopolar fields are used as a device to simplify calculation.
You hit the nail on the head IMO, but that's the WHOLE PROBLEM. They're basically CONVERTING current into monopoles mathematically to "simplify" the equations for B Tim. It's still CURRENT at the level of physics, even if it's "magnetic charge" for the purposes of simplifying for a B orientation.


It is certainly physically correct that all magnetic fields are generated by the motion of electrically charged particles, and I have no problem calling those moving charged particles a "current", so long as we understand that electrically neutral currents are allowed (meaning that the number of negative charged particles is equal to the number of positive charged particles).

I DO NOT DOUBT is it's a useful tool for simplifying the math to call it "magnetic charge". I DO DOUBT that monopoles actually physically exist, and I do not doubt that it's actually CURRENT that does the 'reconnecting'.


Well, whether or not magnetic monopoles actually physically exist is irrelevant anyway. Their actual physical existence is not assumed in the paper, which in fact goes on to prove that magnetic monopoles cannot exist in a linear force-free field. So I don't see any problem.

You see, the magnetic field has a geometry, a shape. We know that the magnetic field is actually generated by electrical currents, but that same shape could be generated by an arbitrary collection of magnetic monopoles. So the authors replace the current by magnetic monopoles, which they can then use as sources and sinks to create a multipole expansion of the magnetic field. Like I said, and you apparently agree, this is "a device to simplify calculation", and it really is not supposed to have anything at all to do with the physics of what is going on, it's just a computational trick. And actually, it's not a very useful tool and I don't think it has been done again since then. If you look at the book "Magnetic Reconnection: MHD Theory and Applications" by Priest & Forbes, Cambridge University Press, 2000, you will not see any mention of magnetic monopoles or monopolar fields anywhere. I can find no other papers that use this trick either. It was a passing fad that has passed, and is in fact no longer relevant to any real discussion of magnetic reconnection.

I will address Clinger and the termination of field lines in another post.
 
Magnetic field lines end at null points

Honestly, someone competent, BESIDES ME on basic theory and sources and sinks needs to set Clinger straight.

I don't think Clinger needs to be set straight since I don't think he has done or said anything wrong. He never said there was a "source" or a "sink" for the magnetic field lines, he simply said that they can end at a null point, and on that hs is completely correct. It is certainly true that a magnetic field line cannot end in the "flapping in the breeze" sense and the reason is easy enough to understand. If the end of the field line were "flapping in the breeze" then it would be easy to obtain a non-zero divergence over a Gaussian surface element circumscribed around the end point, violating Gauss' Law. In the case of a null point, there is no such surface; every surface circumscribed around a null point will show a zero divergence and satisfy Gauss' Law. You are confusing the issue yourself by appealing to popular language and ignoring the physics. The one and only real physical principle involved is Gauss' Law, and any magnetic field configuration that does not violate Gauss' Law (or some other law) is allowed. "Field lines cannot end" is not a law of physics, but Gauss' Law is. Magnetic field lines cannot end at a "source" or a "sink", either of which would be a physical magnetic monopole. However, a field line certainly can terminate ("end") at a null point or neutral point, which, as one might guess from the name, is neither a source nor a sink, therefore respecting Gauss' Law.

Clinger is correct, Mozina is wrong.
 
Clinger is correct, Mozina is wrong.

IMO, it's highly disappointing you chose "hate" over science Tim. :(

You certainly didn't do Clinger any favors. I can't believe that response even *AFTER* I took the time to SHOW YOU which EQUATION Priest used to convert electrons into monopoles (magnetic charges). The *SOURCE* is the ELECTRIC field, and the electrons in that paper Tim, not the magnetic NULL! GRR.

I'm taking the night off. I'll deal with your nonsense later.
 
Last edited:
What "reconnects"?

Ok Tim, what do YOU PERSONALLY expect to "reconnect" in part 4, in a vacuum, *WITHOUT* plasma?

Physically: Nothing "reconnects", that's just a word we use to name the process. What physically happens is that the magnetic field changes from a higher energy state to a lower energy state, and the energy lost by the field escapes as electromagnetic photons. In the presence of a plasma, that energy will transfer to the plasma and manifest itself as an impulsive increase in plasma kinetic energy.

Mathematically: Field lines are the mathematical tool of choice to describe and analyze any field, ever since Maxwell. Mathematically, the lines of force representing the physical magnetic field literally reconnect, resulting in a change in the topology of the field. The name, "magnetic reconnection", comes from this mathematical reconnection of field lines.

That's what I, personally think.
 
Physically: Nothing "reconnects", that's just a word we use to name the process.

You mean an electrical discharge process that requires an INDUCED E field followed by an electrical discharge? How can that POSSIBLY NOT involve "current reconnection"?

What physically happens is that the magnetic field changes from a higher energy state to a lower energy state, and the energy lost by the field escapes as electromagnetic photons. In the presence of a plasma, that energy will transfer to the plasma and manifest itself as an impulsive increase in plasma kinetic energy.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7668879&postcount=3861

I suggested that experiment to you because it would have helped you to understand that

Dungey is describing magnetic reconnection.
There is no "circuit reconnection" in Dungey's paper.
There is no "current reconnection" in Dungey's paper.
The magnetic reconnection described in Dungey's paper can be reproduced without plasma.
The magnetic reconnection described in Dungey's paper can occur with a near-zero electric (E) field.

Which of these statements by Clinger is true and which is false Tim?
 
The name, "magnetic reconnection", comes from this mathematical reconnection of field lines.

That's what I, personally think.

I personally think that unless you or Clinger has a monopole in your pocket, no B field lines have a source, a sink, a beginning or an ending Tim. You're playing with fire at this point IMO. I've even taken the time to show you WHICH equations were involved in Priests "magic" where he turns a E field source into a B field "source" by turning electrons into "magnetic charges"! Come on! What's it going to take?
 
What "reconnects"? II

You mean an electrical discharge process that requires an INDUCED E field followed by an electrical discharge? How can that POSSIBLY NOT involve "current reconnection"?
It certainly involves currents, but for the most part "reconnection" is a pretty lousy description of what the currents physically do. They accelerate. They energize. Say that the process involves "current acceleration" or "current energizing" and that's fine with me. But see your own statement: The E-field comes first, and then the currents accelerate. That's just what I have been saying all along. The electric field that accelerates the charged particles comes into existence as a result of the "reconnection" of the magnetic field. It's called "magnetic reconnection" because that reconfiguration of the magnetic field is the local energy source for everything else.

I suggested that experiment to you because it would have helped you to understand that
  • Dungey is describing magnetic reconnection.
  • There is no "circuit reconnection" in Dungey's paper.
  • There is no "current reconnection" in Dungey's paper.
  • The magnetic reconnection described in Dungey's paper can be reproduced without plasma.
  • The magnetic reconnection described in Dungey's paper can occur with a near-zero electric (E) field.
Which of these statements by Clinger is true and which is false Tim?


The first 4 are obviously true. The last one about a near-zero electric field probably is, at least in principle. But I would want to look at Dungey's paper again to make sure there is a specific compatibility with that specific paper. Some of these experiments are performed with external applied fields in addition to the fields generated in the experiment.
 
Priest & Monopoles & Magnetic Reconnection II

I personally think that unless you or Clinger has a monopole in your pocket, no B field lines have a source, a sink, a beginning or an ending Tim.


No sources & no sinks, I agree. But I already said that, you know, ...

It is certainly true that a magnetic field line cannot end in the "flapping in the breeze" sense and the reason is easy enough to understand. If the end of the field line were "flapping in the breeze" then it would be easy to obtain a non-zero divergence over a Gaussian surface element circumscribed around the end point, violating Gauss' Law. { ... } Magnetic field lines cannot end at a "source" or a "sink", either of which would be a physical magnetic monopole. However, a field line certainly can terminate ("end") at a null point or neutral point, which, as one might guess from the name, is neither a source nor a sink, therefore respecting Gauss' Law.


So why do you think it is still relevant? And what have you got against Gauss' law?

You're playing with fire at this point IMO. I've even taken the time to show you WHICH equations were involved in Priests "magic" where he turns a E field source into a B field "source" by turning electrons into "magnetic charges"! Come on! What's it going to take?


And I have taken the time (post 5059 & post 5068) to show you that it is all entirely irrelevant to any real discussion of magnetic reconnection. Come on! What's it going to take?
 
It certainly involves currents, but for the most part "reconnection" is a pretty lousy description of what the currents physically do. They accelerate.

No, magnetic reconnection is a lousy description because no B field lines "reconnect". They simple change over time (flux).

They energize. Say that the process involves "current acceleration" or "current energizing" and that's fine with me. But see your own statement: The E-field comes first, and then the currents accelerate. That's just what I have been saying all along. The electric field that accelerates the charged particles comes into existence as a result of the "reconnection" of the magnetic field. It's called "magnetic reconnection" because that reconfiguration of the magnetic field is the local energy source for everything else.
It's BASIC INDUCTION Tim! There's nothing "unique" about MR theory. It's a pure acceleration process of charged particles do to FLUX CHANGES, nothing more!

The first 4 are obviously true. The last one about a near-zero electric field probably is, at least in principle. But I would want to look at Dungey's paper again to make sure there is a specific compatibility with that specific paper. Some of these experiments are performed with external applied fields in addition to the fields generated in the experiment.

That's just pure BS. Without plasma, Priest cannot do that manipulation with electrons at equation 17 Tim. Without "current", none of the "electrical discharge" processes work at all! No "acceleration". No "reconnection". All that occurs in the vacuum is FLUX CHANGES OVER TIME!

Honestly Tim, I have no idea why you stepped back into this mess. You're only going to make yourself look bad. Tell me how you expect to get an "electrical discharge" in step four with no plasma?
 
Last edited:
No sources & no sinks, I agree. But I already said that, you know, ...

Then no "beginning or ending" either Tim. The CURRENT is being redirected. The CHARGE transfer occurs via a CHARGED PARTICLE, not the magnetic field. Equation 17 is a CONVERSION related to the CURRENT flow. The SOURCE in equation 16 is the E field and the SINK is the E field. The CURRENT simply transfers FLUX to a specific location which they then convert to "magnetic charge".

So why do you think it is still relevant? And what have you got against Gauss' law?

The better question is what YOU have got against it? If X isn't s source or a sink for B field lines, then it's not the "beginning or the end" of them either! Man are you doing mental gymnastics to try to waltz around that issue.

And I have taken the time (post 5059 & post 5068) to show you that it is all entirely irrelevant to any real discussion of magnetic reconnection. Come on! What's it going to take?

This is just pure denial now. I showed you CONCLUSIVELY that X is not a "source" of anything related to the MAGNETIC field. It's just a PASSING THROUGH point for CURRENT. That CURRENT is then being CONVERTED by Priest at equation 17 into "magnetic charge", AKA MONOPOLES!

This whole conversation is silly Tim. You NEVER should have gotten back into this conversation. You're only going to come out looking silly unless you have a monopole in your pocket. Unless you've got one, no B lines "reconnect". They don't "begin". They don't "end". They have no source and no sink! Any other mental gymnastics you try to do are only going to reinforce these FACTS!

You will NOT get an electrical discharge in vacuum and therefore the PROCESS of "reconnection" cannot be achieved in a vacuum. PERIOD! Get REAL!
 
Last edited:
The first 4 are obviously true.

Boloney. Only 1 is "true". The rest are pure BS. "Reconnection" is a PROCESS in PLASMA. It doesn't happen in a "vacuum". Without current flow, no electron/monopole conversion is possible between equations 16 and 17 Tim. You NEED plasma and CURRENT! They are not optional. If equation 16 is ZERO, equation 17 is zero too Tim.
 
Last edited:
Physically: Nothing "reconnects",

FYI, that is the whole point Tim. NOTHING physical ever could "reconnect" in a vacuum. No particle acceleration is possible. No discharge can occur.

Mathematically: Field lines are the mathematical tool of choice to describe and analyze any field, ever since Maxwell. Mathematically, the lines of force representing the physical magnetic field literally reconnect, resulting in a change in the topology of the field. The name, "magnetic reconnection", comes from this mathematical reconnection of field lines.

That's what I, personally think.

Mathematically speaking, Priest specifically converts current into "magnetic charge" between equations 16 and 17. If you don't have CURRENT at that location Tim, you'll get no magnetic charge in equation 17. I'm going to keep harping on those two equations (16&17) from the source and sink paper by Priest until you admit that you NEED current and plasma to get "reconnection" Tim.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom