Priest & Monopoles & Magnetic Reconnection
My "introduction" to MR theory in debate started over at space.com. It's a pity they took down the boards, or I'd cite the conversation for you. The very first paper that I was handed to evaluate on the topic of MR theory just so happened to be a paper written by Priest that was ENTIRELY oriented around the B orientation of Maxwell's equations. From a mathematical orientation, it was actually pretty simple. There weren't very many equations to translate. I thought it might be interesting to see if I could personally translate the formulas to an E orientation. I got to a specific equation however and found out that the energy transfer mechanism Priest was using was a "monopole", something that literally violates the laws of physics, specifically Gauss's law of magnetism. I cried fowl over the whole notion of "magnetic flux transfer" using such a device. Everyone went ballistic and tried to defend the concept even though it clearly violated the laws of physics.
DISCLAIMER: In *FAIRNESS TO PRIEST*, it wasn't his best paper on this topic. I've read MUCH better materials from him since that date and time.
I was then handed a new paper to evaluate from an author called "Birn". It was a MUCH better paper in the sense that it clearly described the "current' that flowed along the magnetic line that created and sustained the "magnetic field" along that so called "line". That "line" however turns out not to be a simple "line", is a "field aligned current". The total "energy flux" through that line is directly related to the flow of current through that field aligned current "line".
I understand the difference on *PAPER* Clinger, but when I wrote that line you decided to build a federal case over, I was specifically thinking of that first paper by Priest that attempted to 'dumb down' an entire current carrying event to a "magnetic flux' event. That's all I meant by that particular sentence. If you can't accept that rather LENGTHY explanation, I really don't know what else to offer you. You go right ahead and harp on that one sentence all you like, but you'll need to come clean on one of my two issues as well.
This is an interesting story that invokes several questions.
Can you identify the paper by Priest that you falsified?
Can you show us the "monopole" equation you wound up with and its derivation?
Can you identify the paper by Birn?
Can you identify specific points, in the paper by birn, where you can demonstrate where his "magnetic field line" is in reality a "field aligned current"?
Mozina's original post was 20 October, back on page 101 and my query is 22 Oct and on page 103. A sufficient response showed up 13 November on page 123:
{ ...}
I'm also sorry that Space.com took down their board because I personally did not save the very first paper on "magnetic reconnection" that I was asked to read through on a public forum. I'd like to find that paper so you can fully appreciate where I'm coming from.
The paper was by Priest. In retrospect it taught me something very important, and Priest did me a great favor. That *particular* paper (I'm sure he's written many others because I've personally read many others) just so happened to be a "speculation" paper, a "what if" sort of paper. He was speculating mathematically about "B field line reconnection" *IF* monopoles actually existed in nature. It's important in my learning process in retrospect that I started there actually because I could "in theory" understand what an actual "B field line reconnection" might look like if B field lines *DID* have a "beginning and ending", if they could be taken apart into discrete units. I could CLEARLY understand what he was trying to convey, but I DISMISSED the paper because monopoles do not exist in nature and they violate Gauss's law of magnetism.
I have searched as thoroughly as I can and find no indication of any paper written by anyone which makes any assumption about the actual existence of magnetic monopoles being required for magnetic reconnection. However, I did find these:
Magnetic Null Points due to Multiple Sources of Solar Photospheric Flux
Inverarity & Priest; Solar Physics 186(1/2): 99-121 (May 1999)
Abstract: "How common are magnetic null points in the highly complex magnetic field of the solar atmosphere? In this work we seek to model the magnetic structure of quiet regions by placing magnetic sources and sinks on a hexagonal network of supergranule cells to represent the intense magnetic fields that occur at the boundaries of these cells. The resulting potential coronal magnetic field is then computed analytically and searched numerically for magnetic null points, which are classified according to their types and spine directions. Two relations from the theory of vector fields relate the numbers of null points to the numbers of sources and sinks and these are used to check the numerical results. Previous results relating these quantities for monopolar and dipolar magnetic fields are described and a new one for a particular class of quadrupolar fields arising in this study is derived. We model a three-cell configuration and study the effects of increasing the strength of a central sink and of moving the central sink. A twelve-cell configuration is studied in lesser detail."
The properties of sources and sinks of a linear force-free field
Demoulin & Priest; Astronomy and Astrophysics 258(2): 535-541 (May 1992)
Abstract: "In a highly conducting plasma, the magnetic field topology determines where, for example, current sheets can form, which is of great importance as a potential coronal heating source. With the classical extrapolation of a continuous weak photospheric field, the determination of topology is in general a difficult challenge. Because of the concentration of the photospheric field at intense flux tubes in supergranulation boundaries a more realistic field representation may be a description in terms of magnetic singularities located just below the photosphere. In this paper we analyze in detail the generalization to linear force-free fields of the standard multipole expansion for singular potential fields. Solutions are presented in spherical coordinates with the constraint that all singularities are located in the half-space z is less than 0 below the solar photospheric plane (z = 0). A great variety of solutions is shown to exist depending on two continuous and one discrete parameter. The properties of monopole and dipole solutions in particular are discussed and it is shown that isolated magnetic charges exist only in the potential limit and not in a linear force-free field."
The 1992 paper introduces the idea of monopolar magnetic fields from multipole expansion. It pointedly includes a forma proof that there cannot be any real magnetic monopoles involved. The 1999 paper, which cites the 1992 paper, uses monopolar magnetic fields as "sources" and "sinks" to create magnetic dipoles that look like electric dipoles (where the charged particles are sources & sinks). Neither paper assumes the existence of actual monopoles, but rather seeks to use monopolar fields as a computational device.
Michael Mozina: Is it possible that one of these was that first paper by Priest that you refer to? I cannot find anything else in the literature that includes any monopolar fields in a discussion of magnetic reconnection.
In these papers, monopolar fields are used as a device to simplify calculation. This calculational device is not found in any of my books on plasma physics or magnetic reconnection, nor can I find any recent papers that do this. I can only surmise that the rapid increase in computational power has rendered this kind of computational simplification unnecessary.
Of course, with no more clues than this, I cannot reliably guess which of many papers by Birn might be the one that is relevant here.
I will also add a footnote comment that, while it is certainly true that magnetic monopoles are not consistent with Maxwell's Equations, it is not obviously true that magnetic monopoles violate the laws of physics.
Dirac, 1931 proves that if magnetic monopoles exist, then all electric charge must be quantized. Since we now know that all electric charge is in fact quantized, then there is an implication (but no necessity) from Dirac's work that magnetic monopoles could exist. They are in fact predicted by various grand unified theories of particle physics. There are no unambiguous observations of magnetic monopoles on record, and they may indeed not exist. But one cannot assert with confidence that they
cannot exist.
I can assert with confidence that magnetic monopoles are not at all involved in any formulation of magnetic reconnection that I have seen, and I cannot find any indication of magnetic monopoles in any papers by Priest other than what I have shown here.