Michael Mozina
Banned
- Joined
- Feb 10, 2009
- Messages
- 9,361
Ok Clinger,
Do electrical discharges occur in plasmas and flares? Yes or no?
Do electrical discharges occur in plasmas and flares? Yes or no?
(Giovanelli was still assuming that the large current density would be generated by induction, and was trying to figure out how induction could generate a large current density fast enough to be consistent with observation. It is my impression that modern researchers have pretty much given up on induction as the source of these particular large current densities, because induction processes can't go fast enough.)
Honestly Tim, I have no idea why you stepped back into this mess. You're only going to make yourself look bad. Tell me how you expect to get an "electrical discharge" in step four with no plasma?
Tim! I think you did a great job explaining once more what Clinger and I and you yourself have explained at least a hundred times to MM already. It's a lost cause.
Ya, nice work LYING through his teeth when he said he would duplicate Dungey's reconnection process IN A VACUUM! Nothing like bait and switch advertizing.
Not a SINGLE magnetic line "begins or ends" in his experiment, either in a vacuum or in plasma. ORIGIN is neither a sink, nor a source of B field lines. All the lines simply traverse ORIGIN at a zero energy strength. Whatever kinetic energy occurs occurs due to the ELECTRIC field, not due to Origin the big fat zero.
No plasma, no DISCHARGE. No plasma, no INDUCED current. No CURRENT, no "magnetic charges" in Priests paper at equation 17, and no "magnetic reconnection". After BSing his way through the entire presentation, KLUDGING basic theory to hell in terms of B line sources and sinks, and then FINALLY doing a bait and switch at the end, yes indeed, he CAN come up with an 'electrical discharge' *IN PLASMA*.
Oy Vey. His *ENTIRE* presentation was pure BS. He accomplished NOTHING in his VACUUM in terms of the release of kinetic energy and he *STILL* thinks induction didn't do it. Pathetic.
please tell us what is the magnitude and direction of the magnetic force vector (what the field lines represent) at a null point (hint the answers to both questions is given in the named of the point)?
The magnetic reconnection described in Dungey's paper can be reproduced without plasma.
I *REALLY* cannot understand how you can *ALL* let Clinger slide on his little bait and switch routine. I mean, how blatant can it get? First he *INSISTS* that he can demonstrate Dungey's brand of "reconnection" *WITHOUT* plasma:
Then in step 5 he finally cops to the fact he *NEEDS* plasma to accomplish an "electrical discharge". Even then he's cowering from admitting that it's an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE.It's almost comical if it weren't so sad.
Magnetic reconnection is not an electrical discharge.
Magnetic reconnection is a change in the topology of a magnetic field.
It is not a flaw in an explanation of magnetic reconnection if it doesn't eventually work back around to being an electrical discharge.
Wow what an easy questionLet's do a little give and take? How about addressing equations 16 and 17 in Priest's source/sink paper and tell me how that is NOT an example of "current reconnection"? Is the E field the source and sink of electron kinetic energy into X?

3. Study of the particular case l=0
3.1 Singularity along the negative z-Axis
Equation (15) gives a singular field only on the negative part of the z-axis. Here both currents and magnetic charges are present:
Ampere's theorem gives a current along the z-axis of magnitude
[equation 16]
Gauss' theorem applied to a core starting from the origin gives a density for magnetic charges along the z-axis of
[equation 17]
while Gauss' theorem applied to a sphere of radius r gives a total magnetic charge in the volume of radius r of
[equation 18]
So now electric fields cannot exist without a plasma?
The X point with zero magnetic field strength where two field lines cross can indeed be assumed to be the end and the beginning of a field line and note that that comes together begin and end, so that in the end there is continuity.
P.S. Why are you ignoring equation 18?
I'm curious to know what kind of fantasy lead you to think that it was anyone on this forum that modified or twisted someone's arm into modifying the WIKI page on magnetic lines?I'm curious to know if it was RC or tusenfem who modified or twisted someone's arm into modifying the WIKI page on magnetic lines?
The page was changed by TStein who has been maintaining the page since 2008.I've seen weird and pretty bizarre hater behaviors in my time, but WOW! I've never seen a "fundy" change a WIKI page in the hope of winning a debate before.
I'm curious to know what kind of fantasy lead you to think that it was anyone on this forum that modified or twisted someone's arm into modifying the WIKI page on magnetic lines?
For example, Gauss's law states that an electric field has sources at positive charges, sinks at negative charges, and neither elsewhere, so electric field lines start at positive charges and end at negative charges. (They can also potentially form closed loops, or extend to or from infinity). A gravitational field has no sources, it has sinks at masses, and it has neither elsewhere, gravitational field lines come from infinity and end at masses. A magnetic field has no sources or sinks (Gauss's law for magnetism), so its field lines have no start or end: they can only form closed loops, or extend to infinity in both directions.
False. It is a PHYSICAL PROCESS, *INSIDE PLASMA* which induces an E field resulting in an "electrical discharge" in plasma. Deal with it.
No, that is called a "magnetic flux change". Such a process can and will induce current in PLASMA.
If you expect to explain SOLAR FLARE ENERGY, you're definitely going to need more than a NULL point in a vacuum.
Get off the denial-go-round already.
The dishonest attempt to redefine perfectly good physics terminology is noted. The electric Sun conjecture will not be wished into reality by trying to change the meanings of words.


There is nothing magic about equations 16 and 17. They are the application of Gauss's law:I'm ignoring them because any idiot can see that the "magic conversion" of current and charged particle kinetic energy into "magnetic charge" in Preist's paper occurs between equations 16 and 17. The equations before and after the "current/monopole switcheroo" process in 16 and 17 are irrelevant.
3. Study of the particular case l=0
3.1 Singularity along the negative z-Axis
Equation (15) gives a singular field only on the negative part of the z-axis. Here both currents and magnetic charges are present:
Ampere's theorem gives a current along the z-axis of magnitude
[equation 16]
Gauss' theorem applied to a core starting from the origin gives a density for magnetic charges along the z-axis of
[equation 17]
while Gauss' theorem applied to a sphere of radius r gives a total magnetic charge in the volume of radius r of
[equation 18]
(emphasis added)In conclusion, the multipole expansion of a linear force free field can be used to study the topological properties of magnetic fields. Previous studies with potential fields have shown the relevance of this approach in order to understand solar flares. It will be the subject of another paper (Demoulin wt al. 1992).
!