MM explains his confusion, part 11
There is nothing uncivil about noting when someone is in denial of scientific fact.
Michael Mozina is in denial of scientific fact.
I'm glad
Michael Mozina agrees there is nothing uncivil about noting his denials of scientific fact.
The major point of contention at the moment is Mozina's highly iconoclastic claim that magnetic reconnection is not physically real, in clear opposition to mainstream physics (also see the thread
Magnetic reconnection and physical processes).
I never made any such claim Tim.
Oh yes you have!! You can't sneak out that easy. "Magnetic reconnection" is an extremely explicit description of an extremely well defined process: The literal reconnection of magnetic field lines. You are adamant and explicit in your repeated claims that the reconnection of magnetic field lines is impossible.
But that's just it. The process does NOT describe the literal reconnection of B field lines. That would require a monopole!
No. As has been explained countless times, literal reconnection of
B field lines does not require a monopole.
I have presented
mathematical proof of magnetic reconnection in a time-varying
B field.
I have also presented mathematical proof that those
those B fields contain no monopole.
Michael Mozina may not be competent to understand mathematical proofs. If so, he can use his incompetence as an excuse for his denials of scientific fact.
On the other hand,
Michael Mozina claims to have "studied Calculus formally for years". I suppose it is possible to study calculus for years without acquiring any competence, but most people who take two years of calculus at the college level acquire some basic competence in vector calculus.
If
Michael Mozina is competent in vector calculus, as he wants us to believe, then he is simply lying when he claims that
B field reconnection implies monopoles. If
Michael Mozina is not lying about monopoles, then he is either lying about his competence or is
vastly overestimating his competence.
Because the
Dunning-Kruger effect is real, we cannot eliminate the possibility that
Michael Mozina's denials of scientific fact have less to do with dishonesty than delusion.
Michael Mozina is the only person here who wants to change the name.
Magnetic reconnection is the accepted name for the reconnection of
B field lines that Hannes Alfvén described in his 1986 keynote address:
Hannes Alfvén said:
[Maxwell] defined a magnetic field line as a line which everywhere is parallel to the magnetic field. If the current system which produced the field changes, the magnetic field changes and field lines can merge or reconnect.
Michael Mozina wants to change the name of magnetic reconnection.
The reason
Michael Mozina gives for wanting to change the name is that he believes it is current that reconnects, not field lines.
As can be seen from Alfvén's statement above, when
Michael Mozina denies reconnection of magnetic field lines,
Michael Mozina is arguing with Hannes Alfvén.
See W.D.Clinger's webpage
Deniers of Magnetic Reconnection.
...snipped detailed refutation of Michael Mozina's argument...
Mozina calls
Clinger's website "an outright lie". As we can see above, in
Mozina's own words, he definitely does deny the reality of
magnetic reconnection as it is defined by mainstream science, and that is the claim that
Clinger in fact makes. I submit these facts as objective evidence, using
Mozina's own words, that
Mozina lies about
Clinger lying, by falsely claiming that
Clinger makes claims that he does not make.
Clinger is explicit about
Mozina denying
magnetic reconnection, and
Mozina in his own words is equally explicit in denying the reality of
magnetic reconnection.
Just moments ago,
Michael Mozina denied a basic scientific fact about J W Dungey's 1958 paper, which
Michael Mozina has been citing incessantly for most of the past year:
But those "lines of force" are NOT simple magnetic lines Tim! He's talking about an ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE process from the neutral to the X,Y axis. Those LINES OF FORCE from the neutral to the X,Y axis are in the form of CURRENT, and the source and sink of the kinetic energy of the discharge are the E fields, not Origin the great NULL, the great NOTHING, the great FRAUD!
The fraud here is being perpetrated by
Michael Mozina.
As can be seen from
J W Dungey's figure 1, the lines of force lie within the xy plane. The current that Dungey considers is parallel to the z axis. Hence Dungey's lines of force cannot be current.
While denying the scientific facts of Dungey's paper,
Michael Mozina reveals his mathematical incompetence. The neutral point of Dungey's figure 1 is at the origin, but
Michael Mozina twice writes "from the neutral to the X,Y axis". Since the origin already lies at the intersection of the x and y axes, that makes absolutely no sense.
Furthermore there are no
E fields in Dungey's paper outside of the first paragraph of section 4, which has nothing to do with the lines of force in figure 1. Just nine days ago, on 18 November,
Michael Mozina admitted he had been jabbering about an "E field" when he had intended to jabber about "electrical current". Almost immediately, he went back to jabbering about
E fields.
That may be what
Michael Mozina's doing in the quotation above, but who can tell?
Michael Mozina's denials of scientific fact are often so bizarre as to become not even wrong, but completely meaningless.