Magnetic field lines end at null points III
Since Clinger's presentation is consistent with established science,
BZZZT. I've provided you with almost a half dozen different references that claim it is NOT consistent with established science. Try again.
In every single case, for every source that
Mozina has provided, and for every source that he will provide, without any exception, the following statement is absolutely true:
The source is wrong or
the source is correct but misinterpreted by Mozina.
In light of my claim, I provide here 3 supporting arguments:
One
No published source can overcome the extraordinary effect of a valid formal proof.
Clinger has provided a valid formal proof. I have also provided a valid proof, though not stated in a formal manner. This proof, by itself, invalidates all claims to the contrary and absolutely negates everything
Mozina have to say, and
every source that
Mozina can cite or quote, with no exceptions allowed, save a formal invalidation of the formal proof offered here. Anyone with real experience in mathematics (which
Mozina claims to have) will surely recognize that this must be true.
Two
Most of the sources cited are, quite simply,
wrong. But how can this be? MIT wrong? Universities & PhD physicists wrong?
Yes, all of them wrong. Anybody who actually works in this, or any other profession, will hardly be surprised at the notion that anybody could earn a PhD and then make a mistake.
The explanation is simple enough, but requires an understanding of how physics is taught & learned. When I was a student, there were no specialty courses in plasma physics for undergraduates. That is probably still the case, since I notice that UCLA does not have an undergraduate course in plasma physics (
UCLA physics course listing). There is an undergraduate plasma physics laboratory, but that course is not required in any of the bachelor's degree options. This establishes that one can, and commonly will, receive a bachelor's degree in physics with no more than a very general, "survey" level exposure to plasma physics. UCLA does have a 3-part graduate course in plasma physics, but whether or not it deals with magnetic reconnection in particular I cannot tell from the course description (but I would presume that it does, since MHD is an included topic). But graduate students specialize, and anyone not specializing in plasma physics will probably not take that specialty course. So we can establish as a matter of unsurprising fact that one can achieve a PhD degree in physics, from a major university, without ever taking even one single course devoted to plasma physics. This should be common.
There is
one and only one exception to the "myth" that magnetic field lines neither begin nor end, and that one and only one exception is the neutral point found in magnetic reconnection. if one does not specialize in plasma physics
and encounter magnetic reconnection, then one will likely never hear of such a thing and be quite unaware of it. This is the case for the example of myself; I have an M.S. degree in physics, never formally studied plasma physics beyond the "survey" level, and never heard of magnetic reconnection at all until I encountered
Mozina and his claims. Since then I have made an effort to teach myself plasma physics, and to examine for myself the physics of magnetic reconnection. I have come to the conclusion, as a result of my own study of plasma physics that
Mozina is wrong in all of his claims regarding plasma physics, and in particular, magnetic reconnection.
The majority of published sources in plasma physics will quite naturally, and predictably, be wrong on the topic of magnetic field lines not ending, either because the author is unaware, for reasons cited above (this is possible but less likely), or because the single exception is not relevant to the scope & purpose of the course (this is probable and the most likely reason). Introducing null points into a course where they are otherwise not relevant is simply confusing & distracting, and therefore ignored. One can spend an entire lifetime in plasma physics without ever encountering a null point, and even if one does, whether or not the field lines actually end at the null point does not matter anyway, and the explanation for that comes next.
Three
I don't think Clinger needs to be set straight since I don't think he has done or said anything wrong. He never said there was a "source" or a "sink" for the magnetic field lines, he simply said that they can end at a null point, and on that he is completely correct. It is certainly true that a magnetic field line cannot end in the "flapping in the breeze" sense and the reason is easy enough to understand. If the end of the field line were "flapping in the breeze" then it would be easy to obtain a non-zero divergence over a Gaussian surface element circumscribed around the end point, violating Gauss' Law. In the case of a null point, there is no such surface; every surface circumscribed around a null point will show a zero divergence and satisfy Gauss' Law. You are confusing the issue yourself by appealing to popular language and ignoring the physics. The one and only real physical principle involved is Gauss' Law, and any magnetic field configuration that does not violate Gauss' Law (or some other law) is allowed. "Field lines cannot end" is not a law of physics, but Gauss' Law is. Magnetic field lines cannot end at a "source" or a "sink", either of which would be a physical magnetic monopole. However, a field line certainly can terminate ("end") at a null point or neutral point, which, as one might guess from the name, is neither a source nor a sink, therefore respecting Gauss' Law.
Clinger is correct, Mozina is wrong.
The key is this:
The one and only real physical principle involved is Gauss' Law".
Look at this webpage that
Mozina cites:
In every case, on this webpage, the English language statement that field lines never end is indelibly tied to Gauss's Law.
Reference quotes (all emphasis from the original):
"if ∇∙
B = 0 then
B is a
solenoidal vector field. In other words, field lines of
B never begin or end."
"Thus, the statement that all magnetic fields are solenoidal, or that ∇∙
B = 0, is equivalent to the statement that
there are no magnetic monopoles."
"in conclusion,
all steady magnetic fields in the universe are generated by circulating electric currents of some description. Such fields are solenoidal: that is, they never begin or end, and satisfy the field equation ∇∙
B = 0."
Of course, all solenoidal fields do satisfy Gauss's Law, ∇∙
B = 0. However the reverse is not true,
not all fields that satisfy Gauss's Law are solenoidal. The exception, the non-solenoidal case, is the case of the null point encountered in magnetic reconnection. Any surface, finite or infinitesimal, that circumscribes a null point will always satisfy Gauss's Law. This webpage is correct in so far as always qualifying the English with the rigorously valid statement of Gauss's Law. However, this webpage (
and all other published or unpublished sources everywhere), are incorrect in the English statement that
B field lines cannot or do not end or begin, because they all overlook the reverse case of a null point satisfying Gauss's Law. This is no surprise, since that case of the null point is of no relevance concerning the scope & purpose of this course.
For us here the bottom line is this:
The one and only real physical principle involved is Gauss' Law.
If
Mozina denies this, then he denies physics altogether.