Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
The simpler and more logical option is that Michael Mozina continues to make mistakes.

That doesn't explain why all those other PHd's, including the one at MIT disagree with YOU, not me.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7795745&postcount=5452

Your entire argument is a pure handwave. You're just as bad as the WORST type of creationist on the planet, because YOU PERSONALLY are *THE* authority of "magnetic reconnection" theory, without *EVER READING A BOOK ON THE TOPIC OF PLASMA PHYSICS*! Honestly, most creationists hold an *OUTSIDE* source up as their "oracle". You're your own oracle. :)

Other physicists be damned, they all lied when they claimed B lines have no source or sink, no beginning or end. You're the only opinion that counts. :)

Let me see you put your reputation where you mouth is in terms of actual physics. Let's see you present that KLUDGE to a real publication and you post the results, positive or negative in terms of the peer review process? Or does that sound "too scientific" for your blood?
 
Last edited:
If you set the bar that low, there are - very likely - at least a half dozen others, possibly more (not counting the physicists (etc) who have - for various reasons - posted there, briefly, before being permabanned). Anyone want names?

They would have eaten Clinger alive.
 
Michael Mozina
Where are the magnetic monopoles in a plasma?
Why can we not detect them?

WTF? Did you confuse yourself or what?

As I've explained to you over and over and over again, the only thing that "reconnects" in plasma are CURRENTS. There are no monopoles, so no B lines have a beginning or an end, a source or a sink and no ability to "disconnect" nor to "reconnect" to any other B line. Honestly RC, you're just sounding weirder and weirder by the day. I think you're actually starting to believe your own lies.
 
Last edited:
Currents that run through conducting rods are plasma?

No, currents that run through a VACUUM are plasma. Don't confuse your kludged experiment *WITHOUT* plasma with Somov's comments about multiple currents flowing through and reconnecting in a "vacuum".
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by Perpetual Student
Really? Is the current in a vacuum tube, which consists exclusively of electrons, traveling from the cathode to the anode, a plasma?

Yes. It's certainly not a solid, a liquid or a gas.

That's interesting. How do you reconcile that with this:
Definition of a plasma
Plasma is loosely described as an electrically neutral medium of positive and negative particles (i.e. the overall charge of a plasma is roughly zero).
LINK
 
Last edited:
WTF? Did you confuse yourself or what?

As I've explained to you over and over and over again, the only thing that "reconnects" in plasma are CURRENTS. There are no monopoles, so no B lines have a beginning or an end, a source or a sink and no ability to "disconnect" nor to "reconnect" to any other B line. Honestly RC, you're just sounding weirder and weirder by the day. I think you're actually starting to believe your own lies.
WTF - then you are truly deluded because the definition of magnetic reconnection is that magnetic field lines break and reconnect as we have explained to you over and over and over again.
You can verify this by simple Google Book or Google Scholar searches.

You might read Somov but you clearly cannot understand his textbook, e.g. he has a section on MR in a vacuum that gives an example of MR in a vacuum and you continue with your delusion that he is describing MR in a plasma (his next section :eek:) - Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section III

You might read any other textbook on MR but your inability to accept the fact that they define MR as filed lines breaking and reconnecting will prevent you from understanding them.

You have the delusion that the only thing that reconnects are currents.
That is physically impossible because the observed energy release from magnetic reconnection (e.g. in solar flares)cannot be explained by currents merging:
  • Currents merging do not release energy.
  • Creation of currents requires energy, e.g. that released by magnetic reconnection.
 
FYI RC, Somov's current reconnection in a vacuum description is NOTHING like Clinger's experiment *WITHOUT* plasma.
FYI MM, Somov's current reconnection in a vacuum example is similar to W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.

Figure 4.17 is Dungey's Figure 2 ("A 'figure 8' field") which W.D. Clinger replicated.

[SIZE=+1]Dungey's figure 2[/SIZE]

B2 looks like this:

http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/figure2zoom.png

That reproduces the "figure eight" field of the second figure in [Dungey 1958]:

http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/dungeyFigure2.png
 
WTF - then you are truly deluded because the definition of magnetic reconnection is that magnetic field lines break and reconnect as we have explained to you over and over and over again.
You can verify this by simple Google Book or Google Scholar searches.

No, it's not which is why you cannot have not provide any such reference.

You might read Somov but you clearly cannot understand his textbook,

I love how you're somehow "more knowledgeable" in your mind *WITHOUT* have read *ANY* plasma physics textbook, and without EVER having read an entire book by Somov as I have. :)

Talk about bizarre behaviors. You'll quote mine ONE OR TWO WORDS OR SENTENCES from a book you've never read and ignore *EVERYTHING ELSE* in it. :(

Your personal delusion begins and end with your clairvoyant "understanding" of plasma physics, without ever bothering to read a book on the topic. :covereyes
 
Michael Mozina explains his confusion, part 13

No, currents that run through a VACUUM are plasma. Don't confuse your kludged experiment *WITHOUT* plasma with Somov's comments about multiple currents flowing through and reconnecting in a "vacuum".
Michael Mozina is the only person here who's confusing the experiment I described, which does not involve plasma, with hallucinated experiments that do involve plasma.

Here, for example, is Michael Mozina repeating his false claim that my simple derivation of magnetic reconnection involved plasma:

So what? Clinger said he didn't NEED plasma in the first place and he claimed this was a FRESHMAN experiment Tim. He needs to show lines beginning and ending *WITHOUT* plasmas, not with them.
As everyone but Michael Mozina understands perfectly well, part 4 of my derivation demonstrated magnetic reconnection without plasma. I didn't discuss the relevance of that magnetic reconnection to plasma physics until part 5.

Magnetic field lines form and, as they move,
Combine: nor can thy shouts of "NULL!" remove
The math that says they reconnect sans
Plasma, in a vacuum, though you disapprove:
​

http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Epheme...s/MR/mr100.gif

Other physicists be damned, they all lied when they claimed B lines have no source or sink, no beginning or end. You're the only opinion that counts. :)
Michael Mozina doesn't understand that when we're discussing a mathematical question (such as whether magnetic reconnection is a mathematical consequence of Maxwell's equations, or whether Maxwell's equations allow magnetic field lines to begin or end), the only opinion that counts is mathematics.

As a non-barker of math, you'd think that would leave Michael Mozina out of the conversation.

Not so. He can't bark math, but he can bark mad.

Originally Posted by Perpetual Student
Really? Is the current in a vacuum tube, which consists exclusively of electrons, traveling from the cathode to the anode, a plasma?

Yes. It's certainly not a solid, a liquid or a gas.

That's interesting. How do you reconcile that with this:
Definition of a plasma
Plasma is loosely described as an electrically neutral medium of positive and negative particles (i.e. the overall charge of a plasma is roughly zero).
LINK
That's a quote from Wikipedia. Michael Mozina has three choices:
  1. Admit he was wrong.
  2. Admit Wikipedia's fallibility.
  3. Accuse, bluster, obfuscate, lie, Gish gallop, ...
I see he has already made choice 3.

(Thornhill has not, ever, to the best of my knowledge, demonstrated an understanding any deeper than MM's).
:jaw-dropp
I sit corrected and dumbfounded.
 
I reconcile it by calling it "current reconnection", not "plasma reconnection". :)

Generally speaking the Wiki page is accurate, although a lot of plasmas are 'current carrying' plasmas (like a lightening bolt).
This creates an interesting linguistic or logic problem. Since you say currents are plasmas, your statement above can be converted to: plasmas are '(plasma) carrying' plasmas.
 
[/B]This creates an interesting linguistic or logic problem. Since you say currents are plasmas, your statement above can be converted to: plasmas are '(plasma) carrying' plasmas.

You're right, but in that case it's just plasma in motion. It's doesn't have CARRY anything more than itself. :)

It's still "current reconnection" in Somov's experiment.
 
That's a quote from Wikipedia. Michael Mozina has three choices:
  1. Admit he was wrong.
  2. Admit Wikipedia's fallibility.
  3. Accuse, bluster, obfuscate, lie, Gish gallop, ...

When you get your UTTER KLUDGE published, *THEN* talk to me about admitting I was wrong.

I noticed you avoided my question about publication. Which publication did you intend to submit your work to for peer review and for publication?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom