Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Your inability to read makes is clear why you have so many delusions.
ETA: Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section III
  1. Somov has no experiment.
  2. Somov has no plasma in his example.
  3. Somov excludes all plasma from his example because he only includes
    1. a vacuum
    2. 2 electric currents with no cause specified. They are just there. They just exist.

Your denial process is why you have so many delusions. That "current" Somov describes and uses translates to "non-neutral plasma" in the realm of plasma physics.

Clinger has no plasma. He needs a wing, a prayer and a monopole to get "B *LINE* reconnection* without plasma. Face the physical facts. Clinger is up a metaphysical reconnection creek without plasma particle or monopole to his name. :)
 
For the record, I said that a solar flare *IS* an electrical discharge.


That was almost a year ago, and no objective support has been offered for that nonsense either.

It was presented a year ago in Dungey's work on electrical discharges in flares and plasmas. You've simply been in denial for a year.


I specifically said no objective support has been provided. Objective means that when the alleged support is independently assessed, others will come to the same conclusion. So no, it has not been objectively supported. Absolutely not by anyone in this conversation, and absolutely not within the contemporary view of solar physics. Objective does not mean petulant insistence decorated with a few cherry picked words and phrases gathered from sometimes outdated, mostly irrelevant sources.
 
DeiRenDopa said:
If you set the bar that low, there are - very likely - at least a half dozen others, possibly more (not counting the physicists (etc) who have - for various reasons - posted there, briefly, before being permabanned). Anyone want names?
They would have eaten Clinger alive.

It's highly unlikely they'd ever have a chance, as long as they stay within their echo chamber (W.D.Clinger, should he ever choose to post there, would likely be permabanned within a day or two).

Rather an odd response, though, MM ... given your amazing track record here (you've convinced precisely no one of the validity of your ideas), I thought you'd have been delighted with my news, and keen to learn who these Thunderdolts forum members are. I mean, wouldn't you welcome some support?
 
Well, now. The fact that you don't know what a plasma is certainly explains a lot.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_(physics)#Definition_of_a_plasma

Non-neutral plasma

The strength and range of the electric force and the good conductivity of plasmas usually ensure that the densities of positive and negative charges in any sizeable region are equal ("quasineutrality"). A plasma with a significant excess of charge density, or, in the extreme case, is composed of a single species, is called a non-neutral plasma. In such a plasma, electric fields play a dominant role. Examples are charged particle beams, an electron cloud in a Penning trap and positron plasmas.
 
It's highly unlikely they'd ever have a chance, as long as they stay within their echo chamber (W.D.Clinger, should he ever choose to post there, would likely be permabanned within a day or two).

Rather an odd response, though, MM ... given your amazing track record here (you've convinced precisely no one of the validity of your ideas), I thought you'd have been delighted with my news, and keen to learn who these Thunderdolts forum members are. I mean, wouldn't you welcome some support?

Not really. Clinger seems to have skewered himself without much help from me or anyone else. His steadfast prayer to Origin the false B line Null god of the vacuum is absolutely HYSTERICAL. :D
 
Not really. Clinger seems to have skewered himself without much help from me or anyone else. His steadfast prayer to Origin the false B line Null god of the vacuum is absolutely HYSTERICAL. :D

This is the kind of nonsensical blathering that makes you look so foolish. I have recently made an effort to reread all of Clinger's five part demonstration of magnetic reconnection, and I have reviewed your responses. I did my best to follow the discussion, but as hard as I have tried, although I was able to, more or less, follow Clinger's argument, I cannot fathom the basis of your objections. What is "Origin the false B line Null god" supposed to mean? Do you have any real scientifically based counter-argument to his demonstration? Is the above kind of adolescent babble the best you can do? Don't you care how much you embarrass yourself? Perhaps I missed some critical part of this convoluted thread. If I have missed something, show me where you have a substantive objection to Clingers argument!
 
This is the kind of nonsensical blathering that makes you look so foolish. I have recently made an effort to reread all of Clinger's five part demonstration of magnetic reconnection, and I have reviewed your responses. I did my best to follow the discussion, but as hard as I have tried, although I was able to, more or less, follow Clinger's argument, I cannot fathom the basis of your objections. What is "Origin the false B line Null god" supposed to mean?

It's supposed to mean that an extremely ordinary and boring NULL is not the "beginning" nor the ending, not the source, nor the sink of any B line! The lines (actually whole *FIELDS*, not lines) all are 'created' as non-ending loops by the current running through the four (or five) poles.

Do you have any real scientifically based counter-argument to his demonstration?

Yes, and I provided about a 1/2 dozen or so PUBLISHED references, including one from MIT (Clinger's Phd "hood").

Is the above kind of adolescent babble the best you can do? Don't you care how much you embarrass yourself?

Me? I'm personally amazed that Clinger still posts here after his ridiculous nonsense. I'd be ASHAMED to have posted the nonsense he's posted to this thread. I'm simply pointing out how ABSURD it is to be calling a NULL (NOTHING) a 'beginning' or the source of a B line!

Perhaps I missed some critical part of this convoluted thread. If I have missed something, show me where you have a substantive objection to Clingers argument!

Perhaps you missed all those links I provided earlier, including the one from MIT? You folks can change a couple of WIKI pages if you like, but you can't change BASIC EM THEORY! It would technically take a MONOPOLE for B lines to "begin" or to have a "source". That's not going to happen for hapless, plasmaless, hopeless Clinger. He doesn't have a monopole up his sleeve and we all know it.
 
It's supposed to mean that an extremely ordinary and boring NULL is not the "beginning" nor the ending, not the source, nor the sink of any B line! The lines (actually whole *FIELDS*, not lines) all are 'created' as non-ending loops by the current running through the four (or five) poles.



Yes, and I provided about a 1/2 dozen or so PUBLISHED references, including one from MIT (Clinger's Phd "hood").



Me? I'm personally amazed that Clinger still posts here after his ridiculous nonsense. I'd be ASHAMED to have posted the nonsense he's posted to this thread. I'm simply pointing out how ABSURD it is to be calling a NULL (NOTHING) a 'beginning' or the source of a B line!



Perhaps you missed all those links I provided earlier, including the one from MIT? You folks can change a couple of WIKI pages if you like, but you can't change BASIC EM THEORY! It would technically take a MONOPOLE for B lines to "begin" or to have a "source". That's not going to happen for hapless, plasmaless, hopeless Clinger. He doesn't have a monopole up his sleeve and we all know it.

Exactly where is the flaw in Clingers demonstration?
 
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section IV

Your denial process is why you have so many delusions. That "current" Somov describes and uses translates to "non-neutral plasma" in the realm of plasma physics.
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section III
Firstly there no plasma in Somov's example of MR in vacuum.

Now you have the delusion that his theoretical current I is a non-neutral plasma. That is really ignorant because an electric current
Electric current is a flow of electric charge through a medium.[
is not any kind of plasma
In physics and chemistry, plasma is a state of matter similar to gas in which a certain portion of the particles are ionized.
A plasma can have currents in it but this is not required. Even a non-neutral plasma can just be a bunch of charged particles with no current.

Clinger has no plasma.
W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection starts with MR in a vacuum. It is obvious that there is no plasma!
 
Phew. Well at least he didn't lie in general.


Actually I didn't lie at all. The word "objective" means one thing to pretty much all people engaged in legitimate science. "Objective" is just a few meaningless syllables to folks trying to peddle an electric Sun conjecture.
 
Actually I didn't lie at all.

Yes you did.

The word "objective" means one thing to pretty much all people engaged in legitimate science. "Objective" is just a few meaningless syllables to folks trying to peddle an electric Sun conjecture.

You can't OBJECTIVELY call it "magnetic reconnection" as described by Dungey and SUBJECTIVELY dismiss the "electrical discharge" process described by Dungey. Your notion of "objective" is something YOU PERSONALLY agree with. :)
 
It was presented a year ago in Dungey's work on electrical discharges in flares and plasmas. You've simply been in denial for a year.
You are still wrong even after a year :jaw-dropp!
Dungey's work was on magnetic reconnection.
Citing Dungey's work is explicitly (and objectively) disproving your assertion:
Originally Posted by Michael Mozina
For the record, I said that a solar flare *IS* an electrical discharge.
For the record, Dungey said that a solar flare *IS* magnetic reconnection.

For the record, your original assertion was nonsense because the definition of an electrical discharge means that it cannot happen in a plasma. Other then Dungey's obsolete usage you have not found any scientific literature on electrical discharges on plasma - see Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom