Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
B *LINES* are incapable of having a beginning or an end, a source or a sink. The only thing that 'reconnects' inside of plasma are CURRENTS charged particles. There's no monopole, so there's no "magnetic charge". Get over it already.
 
http://www.enotes.com/topic/Magnetic_field#B-field_lines_never_end

B-field lines never endMain article: Gauss's law for magnetism

Field lines are a useful way to represent any vector field and often reveal sophisticated properties of fields quite simply. One important property of the B-field revealed this way is that magnetic B field lines neither start nor end: A generic field line either extends to infinity or wraps around to form a closed curve. Special field lines (or all field lines in special magnetic field configurations) form closed curves ("loops"), but they are not generic. (Mathematically, the fact that magnetic field lines never start nor end means that B is a solenoidal vector field.) To date no exception to this rule has been found. (See magnetic monopole below.)

Uh oh, you guys didn't change the enotes page that obviously was a copy of the *OLD* Wiki page. :)
 
Last edited:
How many of these 'B lines don't begin or end' references would you folks like? You might be able to change a WIKI page, but you're never going to change basic EM theory unless and until one of you produces a monopole.
It is basic EM theory that states that magnetic field lines end.
W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection

And you are continuing wth the delusion that MR involves a monopole.

MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point II

MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting
 
Last edited:
http://helios.gsfc.nasa.gov/qa_gp_elm.html

Can You Stop a Magnetic Field?

Is there any way a magnetic field can be stopped or broken?

You can't cut magnetic fields, but you can slow them down.

There are a couple of ways to describe why you can't cut magnetic field lines in the sense that you would create two "ends" of a string when you cut it, but it all comes back to the assumption that there are no magnetic monopoles. If there were magnetic monopoles, then at that point in space there would be more magnetic field lines exiting a region than entering it (or vice versa), the same way you CAN have electric field lines entering or exiting a region where there is a net charge like a single electron. So far, in spite of many experiments looking for magnetic monopoles, none have been found.
 
http://www.newworldencyclopedia.org/entry/Magnetic_field

As discussed above, the magnetic field is a vector field. (The magnetic field at each point in space and time is represented by its own vector.) As a vector field, the magnetic field has two important mathematical properties. These properties, along with the corresponding properties of the electric field, make up Maxwell's Equations.
The first is that the magnetic B field never starts nor ends at a point. Whatever magnetic field lines enter a region has to eventually leave that region. This is mathematically equivalent to saying that the divergence of the magnetic B is zero. (Such vector fields are called solenoidal vector fields.) This property is called Gauss' law for magnetism and is one of Maxwell's Equations. It is also equivalent to the statement that there are no magnetic monopoles (see above).
 
Michael Mozina delusion that there are monopoles needed for MR

B *LINES* are incapable of having a beginning or an end, a source or a sink. The only thing that 'reconnects' inside of plasma are CURRENTS charged particles. There's no monopole, so there's no "magnetic charge". Get over it already.

Wrong:
a source or a sink.
That is correct - there are no sources or sinks of magnetic field.
MR for example does not have any.

BThere's no monopole, so there's no "magnetic charge".
You are persisting with this fantasy (now a delusion) so I will point out the science one last time:
There are no monopoles needed for MR.
​
What is not mentioned in introductory EM material (as in your links)
but is covered in plasma physics material (MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting) is that any magnetic field line that crosses a null point breaks. It ends before the null point and starts again after the null point. There is no source. There is no sink. There is no violation of Gauss's law for magnetism.
A source or sink is where there is an excess of field lines in or out.
A null point breaks the field line. There is an equal number of of field lines in and out of the null point. It is not a source or sink.
​
That there is a pair of field lines means that the number of lines crossing a surface remains the same as without the null point and their opposite orientation means Gauss's law for magnetism is obeyed.

Introductory EM courses do no mention this exception to "B lines do not end" because they are introductory courses :eye-poppi!

ETA
I will add that this position that monpoles are needed to allow MR is understandable, especially in your case. There are is a lot of lies to children in educaiton. Rather than confuse students with the exception, undergraduates are not taught the exception. When students take plasma physics courses , they are told about the exception. When students read plasma physics textbooks, they read about the exception.
 
Last edited:

All those examples *REQUIRE* plasma RC! No plasma, no "reconnection".


EPIC FAIL!

You are persisting with this fantasy (now a delusion) so I will point out the science one last time:
There are no monopoles needed for MR.
​

Evidently you horribly confuse yourself with your own BS because I have never once claimed that monopoles were required to produce the electrical discharge process in plasma known as "magnetic reconnection". I said that monopoles were required for magnetic LINES to have beginnings and endings.

What is not mentioned in introductory EM material (as in your links)
but is covered in plasma physics material....

...is the fact that the process of "magnetic reconnection" requires *PLASMA*. Unfortunately you and Clinger don't own a plasma physics textbook between you. :(
 
Last edited:
Magnetic field lines end at null points IV

A reminder in case anybody missed it the first time around:

In every single case, for every source that Mozina has provided, and for every source that he will provide, without any exception, the following statement is absolutely true:
The source is wrong or the source is correct but misinterpreted by Mozina.


The claim that magnetic field lines do not ever end at a null point, in light of a formal proof that they do, is stupid. Just plain stupid. The incessant repetition of that which is stupid will not suddenly make it un-stupid after a sufficient number of times. It just makes it stupid more often that it would otherwise have been.

All of the rapid fire examples provided by Mozina, without any exception, adhere to my previous statement.
 
A reminder in case anybody missed it the first time around:




The claim that magnetic field lines do not ever end at a null point, in light of a formal proof that they do, is stupid. Just plain stupid. The incessant repetition of that which is stupid will not suddenly make it un-stupid after a sufficient number of times. It just makes it stupid more often that it would otherwise have been.

All of the rapid fire examples provided by Mozina, without any exception, adhere to my previous statement.

No matter how many times you repeat the same stupid claims that a NULL is the beginning or the ending of any B line, it's not! No matter how many times you call Clinger's handwaves a "proof", it's not. It's a NEVER TO BE PUBLISHED EPIC CATASTROPHE! B lines do not "begin" in a NULL in a vacuum Tim. That's just a STUPID idea.

The only way for a B line to have a "beginning" or an "ending" is for you to pull a monopole out of your pocket. Got one?
 
Last edited:
Dungey & Magnetic Reconnection VII

You can't OBJECTIVELY call it "magnetic reconnection" as described by Dungey and SUBJECTIVELY dismiss the "electrical discharge" process described by Dungey. Your notion of "objective" is something YOU PERSONALLY agree with. :)


Neither can you OBJECTIVELY call it "electrical discharge", as described by Dungey and SUBJECTIVELY dismiss the "magnetic reconnection" process described by Dungey. Your notion of "objective" is something YOU PERSONALLY agree with. :)

Tell us the truth: You think that Dungey is a moron who can't tell the difference between a "line of force" and a "line of current", don't you?

Get over it, and admit already that electrical discharges occur in plasmas and flares and Dungey claimed! You can't use only 1/2 his work and ignore the other half *ENTIRELY*. :)


Does your admonition to others not apply equally to yourself?

Dungey's paper discussed *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES* in PLASMA.


Dungey's paper (and Dungey himself one might assume) also explicitly identify the source of energy for the electrical discharges as the reconnection of the lines of force of the magnetic field. See below:

See The Neutral Point Discharge Theory of Solar Flares. a Reply to Cowling's Criticism, J.W. Dungey, 1958 (this is the paper that Mozina's "Dungey" comment above refers to).

"Certain other features of flares may be accounted for by the bulk motion resulting from a discharge at a neutral point. The effect of the discharge is to 'reconnect' the lines of force at the neutral point, and this happens quickly. The 'reconnection' upsets the mechanical equilibrium in the neighborhood in a way that can be visualized, if the lines of force are seen as strings. Then the mechanical disturbance will spread from the neutral point and may have energy comparable to the energy of the spot field in the solar atmosphere."
Dungey, 1958, page 139
​


So, did Dungey correctly identify the energy source or not?


Sure, but his "lines of force" were in the form of charged particles flowing up through the Z axis Tim. They weren't massless, simple B lines.


OK, now I have to understand this more clearly ...
Did Dungey say "lines of force" but actually mean something else?
Was Dungey unable to tell the difference between "lines of force" and "lines of current"?

You see, what's going on here is that Dungey is quite explicit in the words he uses, "lines of force", but you have decided to substitute other words in their place. Why should we trust you and your words, instead of simply taking Dungey's own words at face value, and assume that Dungey actually said what he intended to say?


You work hard to make hay out of the fact that it was Dungey who used the words "electric discharge".

The claim that Dungey actually meant anything other than an electrical discharge when he said electrical discharge, having been demonstrated unsupportable, has been rejected. Denial won't save you.


Does your admonition to others not apply equally to you? You are adamant that Dungey meant "electrical discharge" when he said "electrical discharge". So why do you refuse to believe that when Dungey said "The effect of the discharge is to 'reconnect' the lines of force at the neutral point, and this happens quickly." that he also meant what he said in this case as well?
 
Magnetic field lines end at null points V

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7801935&postcount=5628

It doesn't say that they don't start ANYWHERE EXCEPT a NULL Tim. It says ANYWHERE! A NULL in a vacuum is just a NULL in a vacuum. NOTHING cannot be the "beginning" of a B line Tim.

I don't care what it says, it's wrong!. Magnetic fields absolutely do end at null points, that's physics. I don't care how many sources you link to, and I don't care who you think the authority figure is. They are all wrong. I am an authority in physics, and I will stand up to any physicist you can find and prove to their satisfaction that magnetic field lines absolutely do end at null points.
 
I don't care what it says, it's wrong!. Magnetic fields absolutely do end at null points, that's physics.

Then demonstrate your claim with a PUBLISHED REFERENCE Tim. I've provided you with over a DOZEN that claim you're wrong.

I don't care how many sources you link to, and I don't care who you think the authority figure is. They are all wrong.

I've heard creationists make similar arguments Tim. You're treading on VERY thin ice.


I am an authority in physics, and I will stand up to any physicist you can find and prove to their satisfaction that magnetic field lines absolutely do end at null points.

Show me something you've published on THAT SPECIFIC TOPIC Tim.
 
Neither can you OBJECTIVELY call it "electrical discharge", as described by Dungey and SUBJECTIVELY dismiss the "magnetic reconnection" process described by Dungey.

Oy Vey. *I* don't do that. I *INCLUDE* plasma in the PROCESS called "reconnection". You're trying to EXCLUDE PLASMA and CURRENT and still claim it's the SAME process. Baloney.
 
No RC it does not. The literature on "reconnection" relates to *PLASMA* physics, not PLASMA-LESS processes! Nothing "reconnects" without plasmas and currents. Nothing could reconnect in Origin the Null because Origin is NOTHING without plasma.

That is only because in the presence of a plasm (like in the Earth's magnetotail) more interesting stuff in happening. MRx in vacuum is rather boring, it's only field lines making new connections as the move through the X point (null-point) for the rest nothing happens.

If there is plasma, then you get the nice stuff going on like plasma acceleration of plasma perpendicular to the direction of the magnetic field,through the relaxation of the tension of the magnetic field, and we arrive e.g. at the nothern and southern lights.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom