Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Actually, solar flares were associated with "electrical discharges" in Birkeland's works. There is over a century of documented scientific evidence, including empirical laboratory experiments that link "electrical discharges" to solar flares. Deal with it.
 
Actually, solar flares were associated with "electrical discharges" in Birkeland's works. There is over a century of documented scientific evidence, including empirical laboratory experiments that link "electrical discharges" to solar flares. Deal with it.

Documented scientific evidence that the Earth is the centre of the Universe has existed much longer. Doesn't make it right.
 
The notion that physicists take a "side" for or against E or B fields when considering Maxwell's equations is patently absurd. They are not rooting for a football team: as in the B team against the E team. When considering astronomic phenomena (including solar behavior) the whole body of knowledge of the behavior of matter and energy is actively considered.
Nevertheless, I have come to learn that crackpot physics groupies are so lacking in their understanding of physics fundamentals and mathematics that they will believe any fable that enables them to persist in their delusions.
 
Last edited:
IMO that paper by Mann and Onel is PRICELESS. It ties together the work of Lee (although I don't think they cite his work), Alfven (they do cite his work) and modern satellite imagery. It's a fundamentally GREAT paper in terms of using CIRCUIT theory to explain solar flares.

Funny story about that. I clicked your link to this paper---which, by the way, has never been cited by anyone other than Mann and Onel---and what I found had so little relevance to your claims that I assumed I had clicked the wrong link.
 
Um, you're starting with a conceptual misunderstanding of the fundamental nature of science and the HISTORICAL aspects of science. My ego was pretty much CRUSHED the moment I read Birkeland's book and realized that Birkeland had not only beaten me to the idea of an electrically active sun, he experimented with it in the lab, figured out the voltages that were likely involved. He figured out the energy source. He NAILED pretty much every electrical "discovery" I could hope to take personal credit for.


Interesting that no progress has been made by other people writing on Birkeland's behalf. Maybe he would do better if he were allowed to speak for himself rather than be represented by people who continue to fail at presenting his solid-iron-surface solar-flares-are-lightning "model".

From that moment on, my website became a tribute to his team's work and it's not about "Mozina" anymore. It's a historical look at the first real "electric sun" theory put forth, updated with satellite data. Period.


Actually many of the same criticisms apply to that web site as apply to Oliver Manuel's nonsense as I described in Post #6316. What appears to be intentional misrepresentation of the work of legitimate scientists and organizations, pretending it actually supports the nonsense notions presented there, makes it scientifically fraudulent.

I also discovered on my journey of solar physics discovery that Sir William Herschel personally beat me to the idea of "solid surface" under the photosphere by 200 years!


He was demonstrably incorrect, too. Of course complaining about being late to a game that was lost more than a century ago seems a little silly. But since Herschel was supposedly a pioneer in discovering the truth about solar physics, how are these new fangled satellites coming on spotting the inhabitants of the Sun? The ones Herschel believed live there? The ones he calculated to have huge heads otherwise they would explode? Yes, that Herschel was ahead of the curve alrighty.

It's not about me ben. It's about TRUTH.


The truth is, there has been no quantitative support offered yet that would lead anyone to objectively determine the Sun is powered by electricity or has a solid iron surface. If it's about truth, let's not neglect that little tidbit.

IMO that paper by Mann and Onel is PRICELESS. It ties together the work of Lee (although I don't think they cite his work), Alfven (they do cite his work) and modern satellite imagery. It's a fundamentally GREAT paper in terms of using CIRCUIT theory to explain solar flares.


And Ben said...

Funny story about that. I clicked your link to this paper---which, by the way, has never been cited by anyone other than Mann and Onel---and what I found had so little relevance to your claims that I assumed I had clicked the wrong link.

Having reviewed the material myself, I'd agree it has little relevance. And "little relevance" is being generous.

Until and unless one accepts BOTH sides of Maxwell's equations, it's impossible to see the FULL picture. I'd be willing to call the "process" *ELECTROMAGNETIC RECONNECTION* even. What I won't do is ignore the B side like Alfven, or the E side like the mainstream. I think it's just SILLY to dumb down a fundamentally ELECTROMAGNETIC process in plasma to ONE part or the other (E OR B).


There is no rational reason to call the process of magnetic reconnection by any other name. It is certainly not rational to call it something else just because some people would be happier if it had a different name. And as Perpetual Student said...

The notion that physicists take a "side" for or against E or B fields when considering Maxwell's equations is patently absurd. They are not rooting for a football team: as in the B team against the E team. When considering astronomic phenomena (including solar behavior) the whole body of knowledge of the behavior of matter and energy is actively considered.

The important part of that is, "the whole body of knowledge of the behavior of matter and energy is actively considered." It's not a rational argument to suggest the entire body of scientists are either too stupid to consider it, or involved in a conspiracy to intentionally ignore it.

Until you folks start embracing the E side of physics in space, solar physics is never going to make any sense to any of you. GM, the self professed "expert" among you on solar satellite imagery, still thinks that the color around the horizon of an iron line composite image is somehow related to an ALIGNMENT PROBLEM, and electrical discharges in conductors are IMPOSSIBLE! OMG. This crew knows NOTHING about solar satellite images. You really should read that paper by Mann and Onel and ACKNOWLEDGE it, and ACCEPT it.


As for my part in analyzing the graphics presented here, I have come to my position objectively and quantitatively, through study, practice, and experience, and the results of my skill have been verified by the same people who do that sort of work for NASA. No against-the-mainstream proponent can truthfully say the people at NASA or LMSAL or Stanford agree with their assessment of any of that satellite imagery. They may say it, but absolutely not truthfully.

I make those RGB composite solar images every day. I know what original material is used and how the software treats that data to produce the results. No quantitative objective explanation has been offered to counter my assessment. None. Nobody has described a better way to quantitatively and objectively interpret the images. Nobody has demonstrated the simple ability to produce such an image or to understand why any pixel is the color that it is. I know these things. The electric Sun advocates do not and are lying when they say they do. Note that the only objections to my analyses have been uncivil badgering and unsupported assertions. But seriously...

To suggest that the SDO team made that one image, that one time, the first one out of the satellite, and that was the only one that showed the alleged green iron surface 4800 kilometers below the point where no light can escape from the Sun is just a plain unadulterated stupid argument. And to suggest that PR image shows something that proves a notion that contradicts pretty much all of solar science as we know it, and to refuse to take the few hours required to learn how to make those composite images is the epitome of unscientific laziness. Maybe they don't have any time left to do that with all the time they spend complaining about failing. Really.

Perpetual Student also said...

Nevertheless, I have come to learn that crackpot physics groupies are so lacking in their understanding of physics fundamentals and mathematics that they will believe any fable that enables them to persist in their delusions.

There's much truth to that.
 
Interesting that no progress has been made by other people writing on Birkeland's behalf.

It's more interesting that folks use pure denial to filter out the data they don't want to deal with, like that Mann and Onel paper, that electrical discharge paper by Dungey and Alfven's life's work, just as creationists use pure denial in much the same fashion.

Maybe he would do better if he were allowed to speak for himself rather than be represented by people who continue to fail at presenting his solid-iron-surface solar-flares-are-lightning "model".

Birkeland "failed" to win mainstream support during his lifetime for even AURORAL theories. The mainstream preferred Chapman's theories for 60 years until satellites in space finally put that nonsense to rest. It's only a matter of time before the mainstream embraces his solar theories and they are not actually limited to "solid surface" models, just CATHODE models.

Actually many of the same criticisms apply to that web site as apply to Oliver Manuel's nonsense as I described in Post #6316. What appears to be intentional misrepresentation of the work of legitimate scientists and organizations, pretending it actually supports the nonsense notions presented there, makes it scientifically fraudulent.

What's "scientifically fraudulent" IMO is you trying to pass yourself off as "knowledgeable" in either the field of nuclear physics, or the field of plasma physics/solar physics. "Electrical discharges in plasma? What discharges?" PFFT! Your head is so stuck in the audio/visual world you *STILL* think the green horizon around the sun is in ANY composite image is due to some kind of "misalignment" of the RED BLUE OR GREEN overlays! Holy COW! Utter fail in terms of your understanding of plasma physics in general and high energy solar satellite imagery specifically.

He was demonstrably incorrect, too. Of course complaining about being late to a game that was lost more than a century ago seems a little silly. But since Herschel was supposedly a pioneer in discovering the truth about solar physics, how are these new fangled satellites coming on spotting the inhabitants of the Sun? The ones Herschel believed live there? The ones he calculated to have huge heads otherwise they would explode? Yes, that Herschel was ahead of the curve alrighty.

Why on EARTH did the mainstream name a satellite after him?

The truth is, there has been no quantitative support offered yet that would lead anyone to objectively determine the Sun is powered by electricity

Nobody in this thread is claiming it's "powered by electricity" in the first place. In Birkeland's work and Alfven's work it's an "electrical generator", it's not powered by external currents.

or has a solid iron surface.

Nobody in this thread has claimed it has a "solid iron surface" either. I guess you have a scientific and emotional need to 'dumb down' your arguments so you can tilt at windmills and strawmen of your own design.

If it's about truth, let's not neglect that little tidbit.

And Ben said...

​

Having reviewed the material myself, I'd agree it has little relevance. And "little relevance" is being generous.

To my knowledge, unlike you, ben is NOT in pure denial that electrical discharges occur in conductors like plasma. Dungey wrote about electrical discharges in solar flares over 60 years ago. Ben is NOT in pure denial of the fundamental usefulness of the E/Circuit orientation to solar physics to my knowledge, so therefore it's not something he simply has to RUN from like you. I can understand why he doesn't quite "get it" since he hasn't been following the coronal aspects of this discussion evidently.

There is no rational reason to call the process of magnetic reconnection by any other name.

Yes, there is. It is fundamentally an ELECTROMAGNETIC process, not a MAGNETIC process or an ELECTRIC process. It's BOTH, not one or the other. You personally can't seem to accept the CIRCUIT orientation to coronal loop activity, and ONLY embrace a MAGNETIC/ dumbed down version of events that PRECLUDES ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES IN CONDUCTORS! Clueless! Such self imposed cluelessness demonstrates there's a need for a change.

As for my part in analyzing the graphics presented here, I have come to my position objectively and quantitatively, through study, practice, and experience,

You already demonstrated the fundamental uselessness of your "expertize" in this area when you *FALSELY* accused me of NOT creating those RD images. Your AV skills are useless IMO.

and the results of my skill have been verified by the same people who do that sort of work for NASA.

No. Nobody at NASA told you that electrical discharges cannot occur in conductors. Nobody at NASA told you the bright horizon line COLOR around a COMPOSITE iron line image is due to a "misalignment" of the image. You made that stuff up on your own.

The rest of your post is a pointless personal attack from a guy who is utterly incapable of admitting that electrical discharges occur in CONDUCTORS and PLASMA. You've demonstrated repeatedly that your scientific opinions are meaningless, including your claim I did NOT create those RD images, because you are blinded by your own hatred.
 
Last edited:
Funny story about that. I clicked your link to this paper---which, by the way, has never been cited by anyone other than Mann and Onel---and what I found had so little relevance to your claims that I assumed I had clicked the wrong link.

That's evidently directly related to the fact that you haven't been following the coronal loops aspects of this debate ben.
 
The notion that physicists take a "side" for or against E or B fields when considering Maxwell's equations is patently absurd.

So you accepted that paper by Mann and Onel and that double layer paper by Alfven as mathematical support for a CIRCUIT oriented explanation for coronal loop activity?

Yes or no?
 
So you accepted that paper by Mann and Onel and that double layer paper by Alfven as mathematical support for a CIRCUIT oriented explanation for coronal loop activity?

circuit theory is the long wavelength approximation of the equations describing plasma physics. It is valid only on scales much larger than the largest spatial scale of the system. All quantities are put together in averaged/integrated large scale properties.

A circuit can well explain the energy that is stored in a coronal loop.
A circuit cannot explain how the magnetic explosion is happening as this is happening on small spatial and on short temporal scales.

So:
Circuit Theory
A coronal loop with current I, resistance R, induction L, ... stores an energy as calculated by this equivalent circuit model ... some equation. When a flare happens, this quantity of stored energy can be released. Whatever makes the flare happen cannot be determined through this model.

Plasma Physics:
A coronal loop with current density j, gets sheared and energy is stored in the system. Integrating the plasma physical model over the loop gives this energy (which interestingly is equivalent with the circuit theory model). Instabilities and small scale changes in the magnetic field lines will lead to reconnection of the magnetic field, which will explosively release the energy.

Now, ofcourse even in plasma physics there is a variety of approximations that can be used, some more others less useful.
 
Originally Posted by Perpetual Student
The notion that physicists take a "side" for or against E or B fields when considering Maxwell's equations is patently absurd.
So you accepted that paper by Mann and Onel and that double layer paper by Alfven as mathematical support for a CIRCUIT oriented explanation for coronal loop activity?

Yes or no?

:confused:Typical Mozina non sequitur.:confused:
 
What's "scientifically fraudulent" IMO is you trying to pass yourself off as "knowledgeable" in either the field of nuclear physics, or the field of plasma physics/solar physics. "Electrical discharges in plasma? What discharges?" PFFT! Your head is so stuck in the audio/visual world you *STILL* think the green horizon around the sun is in ANY composite image is due to some kind of "misalignment" of the RED BLUE OR GREEN overlays! Holy COW! Utter fail in terms of your understanding of plasma physics in general and high energy solar satellite imagery specifically.


Leaving aside the incivility and personal attacks above, I have provided a qualified objective analysis of the PR image, not the least important to this discussion being that it was a public relations piece. Looking pretty was the highest priority in its production. But maybe most important, no alternative objective explanation has been offered that somehow supports an electric Sun conjecture, and without that, it has no relevance.

Birkeland "failed" to win mainstream support during his lifetime for even AURORAL theories. The mainstream preferred Chapman's theories for 60 years until satellites in space finally put that nonsense to rest. It's only a matter of time before the mainstream embraces his solar theories and they are not actually limited to "solid surface" models, just CATHODE models.

[...]

Nobody in this thread is claiming it's "powered by electricity" in the first place. In Birkeland's work and Alfven's work it's an "electrical generator", it's not powered by external currents.


The above arguments seem to express some confusion. Is the Sun a generator or is it a cathode?

To my knowledge, unlike you, ben is NOT in pure denial that electrical discharges occur in conductors like plasma. Dungey wrote about electrical discharges in solar flares over 60 years ago. Ben is NOT in pure denial of the fundamental usefulness of the E/Circuit orientation to solar physics to my knowledge, so therefore it's not something he simply has to RUN from like you. I can understand why he doesn't quite "get it" since he hasn't been following the coronal aspects of this discussion evidently.


I'm not in denial of anything nor am I running from anything, the persistent uncivil personal attacks like those above notwithstanding.

Yes, there is. It is fundamentally an ELECTROMAGNETIC process, not a MAGNETIC process or an ELECTRIC process. It's BOTH, not one or the other. You personally can't seem to accept the CIRCUIT orientation to coronal loop activity, and ONLY embrace a MAGNETIC/ dumbed down version of events that PRECLUDES ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES IN CONDUCTORS! Clueless! Such self imposed cluelessness demonstrates there's a need for a change.


Leaving aside the incivility and personal attacks above, there has been no quantitative objective description of any electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth that can also occur within a conductor.

You already demonstrated the fundamental uselessness of your "expertize" in this area when you *FALSELY* accused me of NOT creating those RD images. Your AV skills are useless IMO.


There are a couple of problems with the 35 images that could be cleared up with a quantitative objective description of exactly how they were produced and what the results mean. Otherwise it seems quite irrelevant.

No. Nobody at NASA told you that electrical discharges cannot occur in conductors. Nobody at NASA told you the bright horizon line COLOR around a COMPOSITE iron line image is due to a "misalignment" of the image. You made that stuff up on your own.


I came my conclusion through objective quantitative analysis. Dean Pesnell, head of the science team for the SDO, agreed that my analysis was likely correct. Since the time the PR image was originally discussed I've examined it further and made a more specific determination. There was a black circle with a transparency of about 25% overlaid on the red channel before the image was combined into the composite. No alternative quantitative explanation has been provided, and there have been no quantitative objections to my explanation. If there are any specific questions about my analysis, I'll be glad to explain it further.

The rest of your post is a pointless personal attack from a guy who is utterly incapable of admitting that electrical discharges occur in CONDUCTORS and PLASMA. You've demonstrated repeatedly that your scientific opinions are meaningless, including your claim I did NOT create those RD images, because you are blinded by your own hatred.


Leaving aside the incivility and personal attacks above, the rest of my post was...

As for my part in analyzing the graphics presented here, I have come to my position objectively and quantitatively, through study, practice, and experience, and the results of my skill have been verified by the same people who do that sort of work for NASA. No against-the-mainstream proponent can truthfully say the people at NASA or LMSAL or Stanford agree with their assessment of any of that satellite imagery. They may say it, but absolutely not truthfully.

I make those RGB composite solar images every day. I know what original material is used and how the software treats that data to produce the results. No quantitative objective explanation has been offered to counter my assessment. None. Nobody has described a better way to quantitatively and objectively interpret the images. Nobody has demonstrated the simple ability to produce such an image or to understand why any pixel is the color that it is. I know these things. The electric Sun advocates do not and are lying when they say they do. Note that the only objections to my analyses have been uncivil badgering and unsupported assertions. But seriously...

To suggest that the SDO team made that one image, that one time, the first one out of the satellite, and that was the only one that showed the alleged green iron surface 4800 kilometers below the point where no light can escape from the Sun is just a plain unadulterated stupid argument. And to suggest that PR image shows something that proves a notion that contradicts pretty much all of solar science as we know it, and to refuse to take the few hours required to learn how to make those composite images is the epitome of unscientific laziness. Maybe they don't have any time left to do that with all the time they spend complaining about failing. Really.​

It contained no personal attack, of course, but did question the fact that only a single PR image from the SDO program allegedly shows a physically impossible surface thousands of kilometers below the optically opaque photosphere. It also questioned why, in almost two years since that image was published, no electric Sun proponents appear to have taken a few minutes of time to learn how the image was made and to provide an objective, quantitative analysis of it. Apparently no explanation of those issues is forthcoming.
 
circuit theory is the long wavelength approximation of the equations describing plasma physics. It is valid only on scales much larger than the largest spatial scale of the system.

Please explain. The circuit *IS* the "system" from an E orientation. It can be "broken down" into smaller "circuits", as required, as the Mann and Onel paper demonstrates.

All quantities are put together in averaged/integrated large scale properties.

Ya, and the B field is an average of the current flow through the coronal loop/Bennett Pinch too. So?

A circuit can well explain the energy that is stored in a coronal loop.
A circuit cannot explain how the magnetic explosion is happening as this is happening on small spatial and on short temporal scales.

It can do so on short TEMPORAL scales, just not small enough PHYSICAL scales to describe *SOME* events IMO.

So:
Circuit Theory
A coronal loop with current I, resistance R, induction L, ... stores an energy as calculated by this equivalent circuit model ... some equation. When a flare happens, this quantity of stored energy can be released. Whatever makes the flare happen cannot be determined through this model.

Boloney. You can describe a "short circuit" this way too.

Plasma Physics:
A coronal loop with current density j, gets sheared and energy is stored in the system. Integrating the plasma physical model over the loop gives this energy (which interestingly is equivalent with the circuit theory model).


It's equivalent with the circuit theory because it attempts to describe the same basic kinetic and electromagnetic energy. It's simply the E view/perspective of the VERY SAME event.

Instabilities and small scale changes in the magnetic field lines will lead to reconnection of the magnetic field, which will explosively release the energy.

Ultimately energy is released from the circuit. Mann and Onel describe one way to achieve that result and how it relates to solar satellite imagery.

Now, ofcourse even in plasma physics there is a variety of approximations that can be used, some more others less useful.

I simply embrace *BOTH* ways of looking at the same event, the E side and B side.
 
Last edited:
Leaving aside the incivility and personal attacks above, I have provided a qualified objective analysis of the PR image, not the least important to this discussion being that it was a public relations piece. Looking pretty was the highest priority in its production. But maybe most important, no alternative objective explanation has been offered that somehow supports an electric Sun conjecture, and without that, it has no relevance.

It's only relevant in demonstrating that you have no idea what you're talking about. The green color is NOT caused by any misalignment of images. It's a BLENDING effect due to an OVERLAY OF COLORED IMAGES! Get a clue!

Your expertize in audio/video skills is MEANINGLESS in this conversation as your LIES about my RD image demonstrate. You aren't interested in truth, just hate.

The above arguments seem to express some confusion. Is the Sun a generator or is it a cathode?

Both.

I'm not in denial of anything nor am I running from anything, the persistent uncivil personal attacks like those above notwithstanding.

There's nothing uncivil about noting that your are in stanch denial of the fact that 'discharges happen' in conductors and plasma. It's a simple statement of historical fact.

Leaving aside the incivility and personal attacks above, there has been no quantitative objective description of any electrical discharge like lightning here on Earth that can also occur within a conductor.

BS. Dungey and Lee (and many others) have provided such evidence.

There are a couple of problems with the 35 images that could be cleared up with a quantitative objective description of exactly how they were produced and what the results mean. Otherwise it seems quite irrelevant.

I already explained how they were produced, which software I used and everything. The only thing that's relevant about the image is the fact that you personally have no interest in 'truth' or you would NOT have claimed I did not personally create it. Your entire show is based on lies and hate and personal attacks devoid of any truth WHATSOEVER!

I came my conclusion through objective quantitative analysis. Dean Pesnell, head of the science team for the SDO, agreed that my analysis was likely correct.

BS! Please quote him where he claimed the green *COLOR* was related to an overlay misalignment problem.

Since the time the PR image was originally discussed I've examined it further and made a more specific determination. There was a black circle with a transparency of about 25% overlaid on the red channel before the image was combined into the composite. No alternative quantitative explanation has been provided, and there have been no quantitative objections to my explanation. If there are any specific questions about my analysis, I'll be glad to explain it further.

Your explanations are meaningless because you don't understand the light source of ANY basic iron ion image since you deny the fact that discharges occur in plasmas. You have no idea how they COMBINE the actual images, or you would realize that the COLOR has NOTHING to do with an "alignment problem". It's directly related to the COMBINED COLORS they assign to the original images!

There's nothing PERSONAL in pointing out that YOU do not know anything about solar satellite images. It's simply a statement of fact based on your other statements in this thread, starting with your claim that electrical discharges do not occur in conductors, plasmas and flares! CLUELESS!
 
You claimed that I did NOT create the RD images in the RDQUIZ video myself. You staked your reputation on that "professional opinion". If you can't produce the original RD images from some OTHER source to prove your case, your professional expertize as an audio/visual "expert" is utterly MEANINGLESS and shown to be MEANINGLESS. Which is it going to be? Put up or shut up.
 
Last edited:
On the Solar Neutron-Star Core

At some point the outside shell of the neutron repulses other neutrons to the point that further compression due to gravity is offset by far stronger EM forces that push them apart. Somewhere I've posted a paper about recent experiments that show that a neutron actually looks more like an Oreo cookie with out outside negative shell, a positively charged middle and another negatively charged core. Manuel's work does suggest there is an upper limit to the amount of compression you can hope to get before it simply won't compress any further.

http://www.livescience.com/4601-discovery-understanding-neutrons.html

This is the link I was looking for ben. The outside shell of the neutron acts to "repulse" other neutrons. Gravity is no match from EM forces at small enough distances, and the neutron soup simply grows in size, it no longer compresses.


To begin with, this description of how neutrons avoid compression is not logically self consistent. After all, if you are going to argue that electrostatic repulsion of the negative outer layer is the explanation for neutron-neutron repulsion, then why don't you argue with equal force that the positive inner layer is electrostatically attracted to the negative core and negative outer layer, destroying the layered structure altogether? Or, ignoring that, just notice that while each negative shell sees another negative shell next door, they also each see a positive core a mere 10-13 centimeters away behind that other negative shell. Clearly the positive-negative attraction will do much to weaken the negative-negative repulsion, such that the net repulsive effect is quite weak, considering the small distances involved and the inverse square Coulomb repulsion/attraction forces. Obviously, the logic embedded in these comments has problems that must be dealt with.

The webpage in question, Discovery Changes Understanding of Neutrons is dated 17 September 2007. That webpage says, in part:

Live Science Webpage said:
Since 1947, physicists have thought the neutron, an electrically neutral elementary particle and a primary component of an atom, actually carries a positive charge at its center and an offsetting negative charge at its outer edge.

But new research shows the setup is more complex.

The neutron has been found to have a negative charge both in its inner core and its outer edge, with a positive charge sandwiched in between to make the particle electrically neutral. "Nobody realized this was the case," said Gerald A. Miller, a University of Washington physicist. "It is significant because it is a clear fact of nature that we didn't know before. Now we know it.


The webpage also tells us that the results were published in Physical Review Letters. Here is that paper: Charge Densities of the Neutron and Proton, Gerald A. Miller, Physical Review Letters 99: 112011 14 September 2007 (paper published online 13 September 2007; you will need a subscription to read the paper or you will need to purchase it).

The abstract reads thus:

Miller said:
A model-independent analysis of the infinite-momentum-frame charge density of partons in the transverse plane is presented for the nucleon. We find that the neutron-parton charge density is negative at the center, so that the square of the transverse charge radius is positive, in contrast with many expectations. Additionally, the proton’s central d quark charge density is larger than that of the u quark by about*30%. The proton (neutron) charge density has a long range positively (negatively) charged component.


The abstract is not quite so informative in this case, so here is a relevant paragraph, which I think is more pointed in telling us what is being done here, short of simply reproducing the paper in its entirety:

Miller said:
A proper determination of the charge density requires that the quantity be related to the square of a wave function or of a field operator. The technical solution to the problem of determining the relevant density operator has been known for a long time [2], and has been elegantly explained recently [3, 4] in terms of generalized parton distributions GPDs. The charge density ρ(b) [5] of partons in the transverse plane is a two-dimensional Fourier transform of the F1 form factor. Here we present the first phenomenological analysis of existing data to determine ρ(b) for the neutron and proton. The results for the neutron contradict the long standing notion, derived from both gluon-exchange and meson-cloud models [6, 7], that the nonvanishing charge density at the center of the neutron is positive.


If we pay attention to the language of the paper, rather than the language of the PR website, we can see what is the problem I previously alluded to. Mozina's model of neutron-neutron repulsion relies on a classical interpretation of electromagnetism, the low-energy limit where Maxwell's equations rule. Even in that context, it happens to be quite wrong, ignoring the part of the physics that would destroy the charge-layered structure instantly, and ignoring the fact that the repulsion would be weak anyway on account of the presence of attractive positive charges only 10-13 centimeters away. But, aside from being internally self-contradictory, it is also the wrong basic physics to begin with. Classical electromagnetism does not apply in this scenario, where the physics of quantum mechanics holds sway. The square of a wave function in quantum mechanics is interpreted as a probability distribution, so we are not talking about any kind of classical charge carrier distribution inside the neutron, but rather a quantum mechanical probability distribution for the electric charge. In such circumstances, Maxwell's classical equations do not apply.

We already know the root of neutron-neutron repulsion, and have known it at least since Oppenheimer & Volkoff, 1939. Neutrons are fermions and are therefore restricted by the Pauli exclusion principle, which forbids two neutrons from sharing the same energy state. It's the same principle which allows electron degenerate matter to form white dwarf stars.

Gravity is no match from EM forces at small enough distances, and the neutron soup simply grows in size, it no longer compresses.


This is another statement that has been known to be wrong for a long time. In fact, gravity always overwhelms all other forces, even over very short distances, in the high energy limit. This is a fundamental principle of general relativity, and if Mozina sticks to his guns, then he must deny the validity of general relativity, whether he likes it or not (see for instance, Tolman, 1939). Electrostatic repulsion is insignificant to the stability of a neutron star, for the fairly obvious reason that neutrons have no net charge to repel with. It's the Fermi pressure from the Pauli exclusion principle (see above), which is far stronger than electromagnetic forces in any case. Were it not for the overwhelming force of gravity, a neutron star would blow itself to bits instantaneously due to the enormous Fermi pressure. The only reason that a neutron star can exist at all is that gravity overwhelms all other forces.

{ ... } Start by explaining to me WHY you think a RAW NEUTRON STAR is somehow going to experience "runaway fusion" just because it spits out protons and electrons around itself?
Why would they be ejected in the first place?


As for why the neutron star will experience runaway fusion, ben_m answered well enough in post #6304. But Phunk asks a perfectly reasonable question, which has thus far gone unanswered. As one might guess by now, the correct answer is that a neutron star will not spit out neutrons, protons, electrons, or much of anything else, in quantity sufficient to explain any observed phenomena. This should not be surprising, since the surface gravity of a neutron star is on the order of 2x1014 cm/sec2 or roughly 2x1011 Earth surface gravities. If anything is going to escape from that, it will be only the extraordinarily high velocity tail of the velocity distribution of particles in the neutron star crust. But this also explains the point ben_m has made. If you put an object into the core of a main sequence star like the sun, with that kind of surface gravity, how do you not get runaway fusion?

For the technical detail & scientific background to support my claims, I refer the reader to the book Compact Stars: Nuclear Physics, Particle Physics, and General Relativity by Norman Glendenning (2nd edition, Springer-Verlag, New York, 2000) and to the book Theoretical Astrophysics Volume II: Stars and Stellar Systems by Thanu Padmanabhan (Cambridge University Press, 2001, particularly chapter 5, "White Dwarfs, Neutron Stars and Black Holes"). A few good examples of recent papers on neutron star physics are The Physics of Neutron Stars (Aleksandr Potekhin, Physics Uspekhi 53(12): 1235-1256, December 2010; The Physical Properties of Neutron Stars (J. Trümper, Proceedings of the 9th International Conference of the Hellenic Astronomical Society, proceedings of a conference held 20-24 September 2009 in Athens, published July 2010) and Nuclear Physics of Neutron Stars (J. Piekarewocz, BULK NUCLEAR PROPERTIES: 5th ANL/MSU/JINA/INT FRIB Workshop. AIP Conference Proceedings, Volume 1128, pp. 144-153, May 2009). Most of these cited sources are dedicated either to an overall review or primarily to the internal physics of neutron stars. This discussion of ours depends mostly on the physics of the crust of a neutron star; see The Physics of Neutron Star Crusts (Nicolas Chamel & Pawel Haensel, Living Reviews of Relativity {this is an open access online journal}, volume 11, published online 12 December 2008; this is a book-length paper with in-depth analysis of the topic).

Faced with the realities of the known physics of neutron stars, I assert that the idea that our own sun could have a neutron star or neutron star fragment anywhere inside itself is absurd in the extreme.
 
As for why the neutron star will experience runaway fusion, ben_m answered well enough in post #6304. But Phunk asks a perfectly reasonable question, which has thus far gone unanswered. As one might guess by now, the correct answer is that a neutron star will not spit out neutrons, protons, electrons, or much of anything else, in quantity sufficient to explain any observed phenomena. This should not be surprising, since the surface gravity of a neutron star is on the order of 2x1014 cm/sec2 or roughly 2x1011 Earth surface gravities. If anything is going to escape from that, it will be only the extraordinarily high velocity tail of the velocity distribution of particles in the neutron star crust. But this also explains the point ben_m has made. If you put an object into the core of a main sequence star like the sun, with that kind of surface gravity, how do you not get runaway fusion?
In fact, as I think ben mentioned somewhere, we know what happens when we start to add hydrogen and helium to the surface of a neutron star. We get X-ray bursters. Here the H and He is compressed and we get runaway nuclear fusion producing elements up to nickel and perhaps beyond up to around mass 100. These events release something like 1032 to 1033 J over the course of 10-100 seconds. For comparison, the Sun has a power output of about 4*1026 W, meaning in 100 s it releases about 4*1028 J.
 
Please explain. The circuit *IS* the "system" from an E orientation. It can be "broken down" into smaller "circuits", as required, as the Mann and Onel paper demonstrates.

As a self-proclaimed expert on the "hundreds of papers on circuit theory by Alfvén" it seems strange that I will have to explain to you the how and what of circuit theory. I think you should try to understand chapter II of Alfvén's cosmic plasma a bit better where you will see that everything are large scale integrated properties, and no plasma physics comes in anymore. Similarly in the Önel & Mann paper.

Naturally you can "break it down in smalle circuits" but that still will not give you the underlying plasma physical processes that are actually taking place. It is not so difficult to understand this, in a circuit you e.g. just add together: ion-ion, ion-electron, ion-neutral, electron-electron, electron-neutral collisions, wave-particle interactions and call it resistivity R, take just a value for R and be done with it. Clearly, this cannot describe the detailed interactions that are happening in a plasma, but it CAN give an estimate of the overall effect.

Ya, and the B field is an average of the current flow through the coronal loop/Bennett Pinch too. So?

Naturally, this is incorrect, as the field aligned currents in this Bennett pinch cannot generate the field that they are flowing along. This is created below the photosphere. The field aligned currents do create the secondary toroidal magnetic fields that are creating the pinch. This is NOT taken into account in circuit theory at all. There the field lines that exit the photosphere are just the wires along which the current is flowing.

Aside from that, a Bennett pinch cannot be described by a circuit approximation.

It can do so on short TEMPORAL scales, just not small enough PHYSICAL scales to describe *SOME* events IMO.

Oh it can do things on the LRC timescales, sure, the natural oscillation frequencies of an LRC circuit. It cannot, and I cannot repeat this often enoug, it cannot describe the importantplasma physical processes that are taking place in the plasma on small scales, e.g. magnetic reconnection works within the ion-diffusion scale and most likely the most important parts are on the electron diffusion scale, which are both on the ion/electron inertial scale (wayyyy to small for a circuit theory) and added to that, the ions and electrons are no longer magnetized there, so they don't even follow the "wires" of the circuit that you are trying to use. So, complete breakdown.

Boloney. You can describe a "short circuit" this way too.

How do YOU describe a short circuit this way, please enlighten us.

It's equivalent with the circuit theory because it attempts to describe the same basic kinetic and electromagnetic energy. It's simply the E view/perspective of the VERY SAME event.

Look above, for what one actually is looking at in real plama physics!
YOU just seem to want to have a global picture, and not care chickens about any details of the processes involved. That is not science. It also makes your claims that "magnetic reconnection is actually electric/current/particle reconnection" unfounded as you are not interested in the details at all, and thus are in no place to make any of these kind of claims.

Ultimately energy is released from the circuit. Mann and Onel describe one
way to achieve that result and how it relates to solar satellite imagery.

No, the energy is released from the coronal loop, which can be estimated by taking a circuit model. However, the how and what of this energy release is unknown in the circuit theory. That is why Önel & Mann then go on to discuss electrons accelerated by electric fields which generate X-rays through bremsstrahlung. Apparently, you are only interested in getting a number (which one can using circuit theory) and care chickens about the details of how this energy is released and under which conditions it can be relased (why don't all coronal loops flare ?????).

I simply embrace *BOTH* ways of looking at the same event, the E side and B side.

No, you clearly embrace lemme get ah numbah and to hech widda details.
 
Mozina:
You often claim mainstream physicists ignore the "E side" in favor of the "B side." The equation below was a groundbreaking discovery, linking these two aspects of electromagnetism and it is fundamental to our understanding of electricity and magnetism.
Your credibility and knowledge in this area has been questioned. Why don't you demonstrate your knowledge of electromagnetism so you can establish some credibility here. Personally, I would pay more attention to your rants and read the papers you worship (and often link) if you can describe each of the symbols below and explain the meaning of the equation:

[latex]\nabla\times E = -\dfrac{\partial B}{\partial t} [/latex]

Correct me if I am wrong, but I would imagine understanding the above equation would be important for the comprehension of the papers by Alfven and the others you so often refer to.
BTW, this is not asking you to "bark math."
I am asking you to bark physics, which you claim to understand.
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
[latex]\nabla\times E = -\dfrac{\partial B}{\partial t} [/latex]

Here's my answer, which is entirely from reading the symbols in the equation:
The curl of the electric field is equal to opposite of the partial differential of the magnetic field with respect to time.


I suspect you mean E and B to be in bold since they are vector quantities. :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom