Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Use of the word "hater" does nothing for your credibility.

There is no other way to describe the behaviors of someone who IGNORES THE MATH AND PHYSICS provided by someone like Alfven or by Mann and Onel, and yet thinks "reconnection" happens in the *ABSENCE* of any plasma! It's like chatting with creationists. The data is irrelevant.
 
Do you know ANYONE that professes to be able to explain the INTERNAL structure of the neutron to TIM'S PERSONAL SATISFACTION? I don't.

Michael? Buddy? Stop pulling credentials on me. I'm a professional nuclear physicist, with particular expertise in stellar interiors, neutrinos, dark matter, and (you keep stumbling into my field) some experience with the structure of the proton and neutron. I haven't met Miller (just missed him recently) but I know five or six of the authors he cites.

The quantity you're talking about (the positive shell and negative core) is the electromagnetic charge radius. It's determined primarily by observing the scattering of electron beams on deuterium and 3He targets, from which data you subtract the contribution from the protons (measured using hydrogen targets); that data gives you an electromagnetic form factor, as a function of momentum-transfer squared, whose Fourier transform gives you information about the charge.

Why use electron beams? Why not proton or neutron beams? Because neutron-neutron interaction has virtually nothing to do with electromagnetism. Neutron-neutron forces are due to the strong interaction, Michael, and they don't give a hoot about the neutron's tiny residual charge distribution. All of your statements about neutrons repelling each other "because of" a shell of charge have been blisteringly ignorant of any actual facts about nucleons.

(The other funny thing is, if you hypothesize a world in which nucleon-nucleon interactions were due to the shapes of charge form factors, this doesn't do what Michael thinks it does. The proton-neutron potential, in this world, would be weakly attractive down to r=0 with no hard core. The neutron-neutron potential would have a weak bound state with r=0.5fm. The proton-proton potential would be strictly and strongly repulsive, such that no multiproton nuclei are stable. And so on.)
 
Michael Mozina said:
Maxwell didn't ignore the relationship, just modern astronomers, and particularly EU haters. Everything in the media from astronomers, and in their papers is dumbed down to the B orientation. In fact, the mainstream's emotional attachment to the word "reconnection" and their irrational aversion to the term "electrical discharge" demonstrates this bias. Dungey himself made that connection himself when he coined the term 'reconnection', yet the haters can't handle the truth!

Anytime I hear a mainstream solar physics interview, its' "magnetic yada yada yada". Never do you I hear the term "ELECTROMAGNETIC*, nor any reference to the ELECTRIC CURRENTS that are present in those "coronal loops". It's always dumbed down to B and ONLY B. That's why that paper by Mann and Onel is so NOTEWORTHY. It's the EXCEPTION, not the rule.
Just as I (and everyone else here) thought. You have no clue* about the meaning of:

[latex]\nabla\times \mathbf E = -\dfrac{\partial \mathbf B}{\partial t} [/latex]

... so, all your pretensions to the contrary, you are totally unqualified to have any opinions about solar physics.

*Amazingly, even after Almo provided the meaning of the operators to make it easier for you.
(bold added)

B orientation? E orientation? Only marriages between an E and a B permitted?

Basic civil rights are being trampled upon, I say! Let's start a movement to legalize EE and BB marriages (and trans-orientation ones too)! :p

PS is right, though; if MM is so (obviously) profoundly ignorant of the basics of classical electromagnetism, there seems to be no possibility of meaningful dialog with him on this topic.
 
Just as I (and everyone else here) thought. You have no clue* about the meaning of:

[latex]\nabla\times \mathbf E = -\dfrac{\partial \mathbf B}{\partial t} [/latex]

... so, all your pretensions to the contrary, you are totally unqualified to have any opinions about solar physics.

*Amazingly, even after Almo provided the meaning of the operators to make it easier for you.

Huh? What is it with you and your pet equations? First you threw one of Einstein's field equations at me and you evidently didn't like my response, and you went into a tizzy. This time you pull a Maxwell-Faraday's induction equation out of your back pocket and go ballistic? Huh?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maxwell's_equations

I'm not bitching about induction equations, I'm bitching about the fact that the mainstream insists on "dumbing down" an ELECTROMAGNETIC process in plasma to ONE orientation, in this case the B orientation. I also rejected ALFVEN'S "dumbing down" of the process to the E orientation as well! It's nothing PERSONAL. Stop making it PERSONAL.
 
Last edited:
As a self-proclaimed expert on the "hundreds of papers on circuit theory by Alfvén" it seems strange that I will have to explain to you the how and what of circuit theory. I think you should try to understand chapter II of Alfvén's cosmic plasma a bit better where you will see that everything are large scale integrated properties, and no plasma physics comes in anymore. Similarly in the Önel & Mann paper.

I was complaining because you said it's LARGER than the system. The "system" is a circuit, or a series of circuits in the case of the Onel and Mann paper. As they demonstrated, the circuit arrangement can be made more complex as needed.

Naturally you can "break it down in smalle circuits" but that still will not give you the underlying plasma physical processes that are actually taking place.

It does tell you what's taking place at the level of current and the flow of current. It does not adequately describe all the physical properties of the plasma however. That much I agree with. That's why I do not reject the B. :)

It is not so difficult to understand this, in a circuit you e.g. just add together: ion-ion, ion-electron, ion-neutral, electron-electron, electron-neutral collisions, wave-particle interactions and call it resistivity R, take just a value for R and be done with it. Clearly, this cannot describe the detailed interactions that are happening in a plasma, but it CAN give an estimate of the overall effect.

True. I agree that there are LIMITS with only looking at it from ONE perspective rather than both.

Naturally, this is incorrect, as the field aligned currents in this Bennett pinch cannot generate the field that they are flowing along. This is created below the photosphere.

When did I suggest otherwise? I'm confused.

The field aligned currents do create the secondary toroidal magnetic fields that are creating the pinch. This is NOT taken into account in circuit theory at all. There the field lines that exit the photosphere are just the wires along which the current is flowing.

My point is that what you're calling a "coronal loop" is nothing more than a Bennett pinch that is part of a "circuit" of current. That's why I have no problem calling it "current reconnection" or "circuit reconnection" when the topology changes over time.

Aside from that, a Bennett pinch cannot be described by a circuit approximation.

No, but it's important to know that the filament is acting as part of a circuit.

I'm really having a hard time finding our EXACTLY where we disagree and there's not point in responding to your inane insults, so I'll just stop here.

My whole intent is to demonstrate that *BOTH* orientation are related and relevant. It's SILLY to claim only ONE ORIENTATION IS RIGHT, just at it was SILLY for Alfven to reject the B orientation of these same events JUST because he didn't like the name.
 
Last edited:
Huh? What is it with you and your pet equations? First you threw one of Einstein's field equations at me and you evidently didn't like my response, and you went into a tizzy. This time you pull a Maxwell-Faraday's induction equation out of your back pocket and go ballistic? Huh?
...
Huh? I "threw one of Einstein's field equations at" you to confirm (for all to see) your lack of knowledge and skills in a discussion about the cosmological constant and dark energy. Now I have done something similar to demonstrate your lack of knowledge and skills (for all to see) about electromagnetism, which is critical to any discussion of solar physics. How simple!
 
Huh? I "threw one of Einstein's field equations at" you to confirm (for all to see) your lack of knowledge and skills in a discussion about the cosmological constant and dark energy. Now I have done something similar to demonstrate your lack of knowledge and skills (for all to see) about electromagnetism, which is critical to any discussion of solar physics. How simple!

Huh? How did you get that from my original response? What answer were you EXPECTING me to give you (assuming you were wrong about me)? I don't read minds you know. :)
 
When the mainstream starts using terms like "electrical discharge" in relationship to solar flares, and it talks about the ELECTROmagenetic effects in plasma, THEN and ONLY THEN can you claim there isn't a blind BIGOTRY toward the E orientation of events in space.

This thread underscores that point PERFECTLY. Your side latched on to the term "reconnection", yet you have a blind aversion to the term ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE. Your side claims electrical discharges cannot occur in a conductor and you all let him slide! Hoy Vey.
 
It seems there has been a complete failure to achieve the intended result.

That is because there has been a complete failure to embrace reality on your side, including your denial of the fact that electrical discharge occur in conductors, plasmas and solar flare events. That's not MY failure anymore than it's my fault there are still creationists in the world that reject the theory of evolution.
 
OK, one more try:

As an E field hater, I am seeking redemption. Mozina, please help! Yes I do love the B side. In fact i sometimes fantasize about fondling immature B fields and I struggle to control my deviant passions. So that I can control these aberrant urges and embrace the E side, perhaps Mozina can help me.
Let's forget B for a moment. Just describe for me the meaning of:

[latex]\nabla\times \mathbf E [/latex]

so that I can be liberated. Perhaps then we can discuss why this expression is equal to the negative of the partial differential of B with respect to time.
 
First things first: I congratulate Michael Mozina on his 2549 posts within this thread (so far), which constitute just over 40% of all 6372 posts (so far) within this thread.

It's nothing PERSONAL. Stop making it PERSONAL.


If it's nothing personal, then why do so many of your posts say things like this:

Use of the word "hater" does nothing for your credibility.

There is no other way to describe the behaviors of someone who IGNORES THE MATH AND PHYSICS provided by someone like Alfven or by Mann and Onel, and yet thinks "reconnection" happens in the *ABSENCE* of any plasma! It's like chatting with creationists. The data is irrelevant.


The data are irrelevant to Michael Mozina. The rest of us know full well that magnetic reconnection is a simple consequence of Maxwell's equations, and can be demonstrated under controlled laboratory conditions, within a vacuum, using magnetic fields that are generated by ordinary direct currents confined to wires that lie outside the vacuum chamber or region in which the magnetic reconnection occurs.

No plasma is needed to demonstrate magnetic reconnection within a vacuum. Michael Mozina has been denying that fact of physics.

What you consider "proof" is a mathematical demonstration that 0+0=0! You utterly ignored the need for PHYSICAL PLASMA to get an "electrical discharge/reconnection" process, not just MATH! Holy cow!


None of those claims are supported by evidence. All of those claims are objectively false. The person who made those claims is known to be incompetent at both math and physics, and has provided ample evidence of his incompetence within his 2500+ posts to this thread.

Your concept of PROOF is highly SUBJECTIVE.


If our concept of proof were subjective, then you would be able to name someone who
  • understands the relevant math and physics,
  • has taken the trouble to look at what has been written in this thread, and
  • disagrees with us while agreeing with Michael Mozina.
You cannot name any competent person who has examined this thread and disagrees with us. We, however, can name at least a dozen competent persons who have contributed to this thread and disagree with you. If anyone here is using a subjective concept of proof, it is you.
 
What you consider "proof" is a mathematical demonstration that 0+0=0! You utterly ignored the need for PHYSICAL PLASMA to get an "electrical discharge/reconnection" process, not just MATH!

He started with Maxwell's equations, which are concise mathematical statements of basic physics. Then he deduced magnetic reconnection from these. That is how doing real physics works.

Like the particle that was discovered by symmetry in a matrix. The guys looked at this matrix of particles, and said, "We haven't found one here. If there were one here, and it kept the matrix symmetric, it would look like this, and we would have to do this experiment to detect them."

Guess what happened when the experiments were done? They found a new particle, right where the mathematics showed them it would.

1) Start with a mathematical statement of some basic physics.
2) Make a prediction.
3) Verify the prediction.

This is how science works. Magnetic reconnection has gone through all of these steps, and is therefore accepted by those of us who understand physics and how it functions as an endeavor.

Perhaps someone can remind me which particle it was that was found in the story above.

ETA:
Michael Mozina said:
The data is irrelevant.

Apparently, the data are irrelevant. To you, not to us. We are on the side of the court where all of the data are.
 
Last edited:
I was complaining because you said it's LARGER than the system. The "system" is a circuit, or a series of circuits in the case of the Onel and Mann paper. As they demonstrated, the circuit arrangement can be made more complex as needed.

It does tell you what's taking place at the level of current and the flow of current. It does not adequately describe all the physical properties of the plasma however. That much I agree with. That's why I do not reject the B.

No, I said larger than the largest spatial scale of the system which does not mean larger than the system, although I guess you can interprete it that way. But all processes of the system have a certain scale, and only things larger than the largest scale can be described by circuit theory.

And it does not matter if you can make it as complex as a Japanese locked box, you still will not get to the basic plasma physics. You think that one can describe everything with a circuit, but that is not the case, because as a certain small scale the circuit model breaks down.

A circuit will tell you what takes place on a current scale, again large scale. And indeed it does not describe microphysical properties of the plasma.

True. I agree that there are LIMITS with only looking at it from ONE perspective rather than both.

So that's why you just keep on claiming that e.g. Önel & Mann totally explain solar flares etc. with their circuit model, and from what you keep on writing one really gets the impression that circuits are the alpha and omega of plasma physics. You do not look at both perspectives, you keep on hammering on circuits.

When did I suggest otherwise? I'm confused.

You said that "Ya, and the B field is an average of the current flow through the coronal loop/Bennett Pinch too. So?" as a reply to my comment that in circuit theory "All quantities are put together in averaged/integrated large scale properties." Now I see here magnetic field of the coronal loop/Bennett Pinch, apart from the fact that these two things are not the same, and that the latter (BP) can happen in the former (CL), which leads me to conclude that you think that the currents through the coronal loop are generating the magnetic field of the coronal loop. You have claimed that before in some of the other threads, maybe even in this one.

My point is that what you're calling a "coronal loop" is nothing more than a Bennett pinch that is part of a "circuit" of current. That's why I have no problem calling it "current reconnection" or "circuit reconnection" when the topology changes over time.

No a coronal loop is a coronal loop, if the current happens to become strong enough through e.g. footpoint shearing then a Bennett Pinch may happen. A coronal loop is a structure which is in balance with its surroundings and itself and there is no reason for it to form a Bennett Pinch unless the current gets cranked up through external processes.

So, it would be interesting to see how you are going to model a Bennett Pinch with a circuit. Please show us how to do this.

No, but it's important to know that the filament is acting as part of a circuit.

Yeah, the filament can be described as a circuit, but now show me how you model a Bennett Pinch with a circuit. (I won't hold my breath tho until you do) For someone claiming that "there are limits looking only at one perspective" you definitely seem to be hung up on circuits.

I'm really having a hard time finding our EXACTLY where we disagree and there's not point in responding to your inane insults, so I'll just stop here.

My whole intent is to demonstrate that *BOTH* orientation are related and relevant. It's SILLY to claim only ONE ORIENTATION IS RIGHT, just at it was SILLY for Alfven to reject the B orientation of these same events JUST because he didn't like the name.

But you don't use *BOTH* orientations, from all the comments you given above you claim you do, but in the end you want everything in a circuit and you cannot have it. And Alfvén never rejected the B orientation, but claimed, as some other well respected plasma physicist do, that the currents and electric fields should be looked at too. Tim Thompson already discussed this whole stuff with respect to the wonderful book of Eugene Parker, and there are various other peer-reviewed papers where a close look is made to what is driving what exactly in magnetospheric plasma physics (because in the Earth's magnetosphere we at least have bezillion observations for this kind of stuff). Are the currents driving the magnetic field or is the magnetic field driving the currents (Vitenis Vasiliunas comes to mind, one of the great space plasma physcis thinkers, and an excellent church organ player, the problem is can one understand his papers).
 
There is no other way to describe the behaviors of someone who IGNORES THE MATH AND PHYSICS provided by someone like Alfven or by Mann and Onel, and yet thinks "reconnection" happens in the *ABSENCE* of any plasma!
That is totally hypocritical of you, Michael Mozina.

By that logic you are a science hater because you have been
  • IGNORING THE MATH AND PHYSICS provided by anyone at all, like Alfven or Mann and Onel or any of the dozens (hundreds?) of papers and books cited in this thread.
  • IGNORING the simple physicl fact that magnetic reconenction happens in the *ABSENCE* of any plasma.
 
Last edited:
I'm simply noting that neutrons have *INTERNAL STRUCTURE* that allows them to have a negative charge on the OUTSIDE, the side they present to protons, other neutrons and the world around them.
...gibberish snipped....
Science simply notes that neutrons have *INTERNAL STRUCTURE* that allows them to have a negative charge on the OUTSIDE and a positive charge on the INSIDE. That means that neutrons are electrically neutral as is measured.

Science simply notes that any electrostatic forces can be overcome by gravitational forces.
 
What you consider "proof" is a mathematical demonstration that 0+0=0! You utterly ignored the need for PHYSICAL PLASMA to get an "electrical discharge/reconnection" process, not just MATH! Holy cow!
Total gibberish from Michael Mozina. Holy cow who would have expected it :rolleyes:!

MM: Explain your "0+0=0 and NOTHING begins there" statement
First asked 5th December 2011 (81 days ago and counting)

You totally ignored your delusions about Somov's book where he describes reconnection in a vacuum:
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VI
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section V
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VI
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section III
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section II
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section

Also MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting II that includes REAL PUBLISHED REFERENCES to MR in vacuum (where field lines also break and reconnect):
shich do support W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.
 
Shorter Michael Mozina:

"I'm tired of people disagreeing with me all the time. I want to construct some statement, really anything whatsoever, that (a) preserves my self-image as outsider-physics-promoter and (b) I can get people to actually agree with. But I don't know enough actual plasma physics to construct such a statement. How about "equality for E and B"? No? "Circuit orientation a better word for reconnection"? No? Why not? You're just haters!"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom