Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

...We've been assured that there would be no way that the officer could be separated from the immunity against being sued for the performance of lawful official duties.
We were told in no uncertain terms that the notion of vicarious liability hanging him out to dry, and forcing him to defend himself personally, simply didn't exist.
In fact, we were promised that was just crazy talk....
By whom, I wonder. I never actually disputed that, AFAIK. My issue was with the claims you were making to support your conclusion, not so much the conclusion itself. I stated as much.

...Except that is not what you "simply pointed out". You said that the Chancellor claimed something that she did not, in support of your VF conclusion. If the claim is false, it is useless as support for your argument. That is why it is being discussed....

...
The statement is ambiguous (such as whether the Chancellor issued the orders or just relayed them), and there is the legal question of how much discretion cops and these cops in particular have when they are put in a situation that threatens both themselves and their prisoners, through no fault of their own, which their orders do not cover. I'm not sure the Chancellor has direct operational control over the police any more than a mayor does over his city's police force.
I thought I was making it pretty clear that I wanted to discuss how much legal responsibility the cops had in that situation.

And of course, naming the Chancellor specifically in the suit does not mean she will be found legally responsible.
 
I understand that.
Which is why I've pointed out more than once that my interest was in the real world legal aspects, and not in armchair quarterbacking the specific techniques used.
Well, then, congratulations are in order. You've successfully argued that someone can sue someone else. Would you prefer pie or cake?
 
This certainly satisfies my interest in the matter.



http://edca.typepad.com/files/baker-v.-katehi-12-cv-450-jam.pdf

Now that the filing is available and instead of arguing that the complaint against the police officer should proceed in the face of the immunity of his official capacity, it names him individually. Katehi is named in her official and individual capacity.

WHAAAT???? :eek:

Buuuhh...buuuhh...buuuh.....buuuhhtt... How could that ever possibly be???

We've been assured that there would be no way that the officer could be separated from the immunity against being sued for the performance of lawful official duties.
We were told in no uncertain terms that the notion of vicarious liability hanging him out to dry, and forcing him to defend himself personally, simply didn't exist.
In fact, we were promised that was just crazy talk.

Oh well, maybe declaring that those claims were never posted, or that this simply isn't true, or that it means the exact opposite of what it says, and then demanding proof of a negative (as was done with previous links to articles and such) will work its magic...
You can sue anyone for anything, the fact that a suit exists doesn't mean it has any merit.
 
You can sue anyone for anything, the fact that a suit exists doesn't mean it has any merit.
The fact that someone who understands the law (and who stands to make a nice chunk of change if the case goes forward) chose the specifics of how to word the filing is the point, not folksy homilies.

No prediction as to the final outcome has been made, merely the observation that it would involve an element of vicarious liability in the face of repeated claims that the actions were lawfully authorized by the university.

There is a valid strategic legal reason for going after the Lt. as an individual, and it has to do with ways to get around the presumption that police officers performing authorized actions have a form of immunity.

From the academy on out, officers are taught this. Lawyers are too, this isn't some deep dark secret, or some unheard of controversial theory, this is Crim Law 101 stuff.
 
Well, then, congratulations are in order. You've successfully argued that someone can sue someone else. Would you prefer pie or cake?
So how is it that so many of the legal 'experts' here had no clue that this would be the way it was filed, and in fact argued that it couldn't be?
 
By whom, I wonder. I never actually disputed that, AFAIK. My issue was with the claims you were making to support your conclusion, not so much the conclusion itself. I stated as much.

​

​
I thought I was making it pretty clear that I wanted to discuss how much legal responsibility the cops had in that situation.

And of course, naming the Chancellor specifically in the suit does not mean she will be found legally responsible.
'As far as you know' hasn't been too compelling so far, and it isn't working now either.

As far as I know, you repeatedly told me that I was full of it for stating a very obvious and fundamental legal fact about suing the police and vicarious liability.

But, if you need selective amnesia FTW, go for it.

I'll settle for the consolation of dealing in facts, instead of arguing against them.
 
So how is it that so many of the legal 'experts' here had no clue that this would be the way it was filed, and in fact argued that it couldn't be?

Hold on a moment. I thought you said you weren't even interested in this aspect of the discussion, that you preferred to be talking about something else entirely?

So here you are, having succesfully made a point you weren't even interested in making, and instead of promptly dropping it faster than you picked it up, and going straight back the stuff that actually interests you, you're still arguing a point that you supposedly don't even care about? How does that work?

I mean, a reasonable person might wonder why you even got involved in this side-track in the first place, if it doesn't interest you. A reasonable person, seeing how enthusiastic you are about winning this argument, might question your sincerity when you claim that this argument doesn't really interest you.
 
Hold on a moment. I thought you said you weren't even interested in this aspect of the discussion, that you preferred to be talking about something else entirely?

So here you are, having succesfully made a point you weren't even interested in making, and instead of promptly dropping it faster than you picked it up, and going straight back the stuff that actually interests you, you're still arguing a point that you supposedly don't even care about? How does that work?

I mean, a reasonable person might wonder why you even got involved in this side-track in the first place, if it doesn't interest you. A reasonable person, seeing how enthusiastic you are about winning this argument, might question your sincerity when you claim that this argument doesn't really interest you.
How did my claiming I was interested in the legal aspects throughout this whole thread lead you to the conclusion that I claimed I was not interested in the legal aspects?

What something else entirely did I say I was interested in talking about instead of the legalities?
 
Last edited:
The fact that someone who understands the law (and who stands to make a nice chunk of change if the case goes forward) chose the specifics of how to word the filing is the point, not folksy homilies.
It's still not evidence that Pike can be held liable, or he acted outside the scope of his employment.

Once again, anyone can be sued for anything.
 
It's still not evidence that Pike can be held liable, or he acted outside the scope of his employment.

Once again, anyone can be sued for anything.
As I've already pointed out, I never said anything about Pike winning or losing in court or being held liable. but don't let that inconvenient bit of reality keep you from enjoying those strawmen.
(You did bother to find out that vicarious liability doesn't automatically mean 'a finding of liable by a court' before you chimed in, didn't you?)

As far as evidence of vicarious liability being a factor in the lawsuit, according to the legal system, not charging him in his official capacity is evidence... according to you it isn't...

Who to believe, who to believe?
 
I don't recall any legal experts here arguing that.


So the selective amnesia is contagious?

In any case. I will certainly be happy to see someone post something about this topic that is correct and useful.
 
Last edited:
As I've already pointed out, I never said anything about Pike winning or losing in court or being held liable. but don't let that inconvenient bit of reality keep you from enjoying those strawmen.
(You did bother to find out that vicarious liability doesn't automatically mean 'a finding of liable by a court' before you chimed in, didn't you?)

As far as evidence of vicarious liability being a factor in the lawsuit, according to the legal system, not charging him in his official capacity is evidence... according to you it isn't...

Who to believe, who to believe?
This is a lawsuit, not criminal charges.

And anyone can bring a lawsuit.
 
This is a lawsuit, not criminal charges.

And anyone can bring a lawsuit.
Asked and answered. You rebleating it won't make it either correct, or useful.

Again, be sure let me know if you ever decide to bring anything either correct or useful to a topic, I'm sure it will be refreshing change to actually have a discussion, instead of this same old, same old.
 
Last edited:
I don't recall any legal experts here arguing that.

So the selective amnesia is contagious?
In any case. I will certainly be happy to see someone post something about this topic that is correct and useful.

As I've already pointed out, I never said anything about Pike winning or losing in court or being held liable. but don't let that inconvenient bit of reality keep you from enjoying those strawmen.
(You did bother to find out that vicarious liability doesn't automatically mean 'a finding of liable by a court' before you chimed in, didn't you?)

As far as evidence of vicarious liability being a factor in the lawsuit, according to the legal system, not charging him in his official capacity is evidence... according to you it isn't...

Who to believe, who to believe?

Asked and answered. You rebleating it won't make it either correct, or useful.

Again, be sure let me know if you ever decide to bring anything either correct or useful to a topic, I'm sure it will be refreshing change to actually have a discussion, instead of this same old, same old.
I'm noticing several claims and not much links to evidence here, much like your claims about my alleged strawmen, or your post mentioning pepper spray standards. (The differences between the two situations have been explained.)

I've shown your logic and understanding of others' positions is sometimes...flawed, let's say, already. And no, saying "all of my posts in the thread" is not specific evidence, nor is claiming your opponents don't know what they're talking about. There's a 9/11 Truther called ergo who makes very similar claims, all the time, but he's been proven objectively wrong on many occasions. Doesn't seem to bother him; he either ignores it or responds with personal attacks.

Don't you find it a tad bit odd how many sophists you seem to encounter, everywhere you go, especially among people who disagree with you? Everywhere you look, everywhere you look (NSFW)...

...
That would be for the courts to decide if that decision applies in this particular situation. I tend to agree other with the other police policy and tactics experts who say it does not. What they did was done according to policy in other departments, but you wouldn't know about this since you are uniformed on this topic. You really think that other departments would allow this if in fact the court decision prevents it?...
 
Last edited:
I'm noticing several claims and not much links to evidence here, much like your claims about my alleged strawmen, or your post mentioning pepper spray standards. (The differences between the two situations have been explained.)

I've shown your logic and understanding of others' positions is sometimes...flawed, let's say, already. And no, saying "all of my posts in the thread" is not specific evidence, nor is claiming your opponents don't know what they're talking about. There's a 9/11 Truther called ergo who makes very similar claims, all the time, but he's been proven objectively wrong on many occasions. Doesn't seem to bother him; he either ignores it or responds with personal attacks.

Don't you find it a tad bit odd how many sophists you seem to encounter, everywhere you go, especially among people who disagree with you? Everywhere you look, everywhere you look (NSFW)...

​
Ahh, back to recycling the appeal to popularity fallacies again?

As far as your opinion goes, anyone who wants to believe that the Chancellor never said what was in the articles that I linked to, or that I never linked to any evidence, or that I said Humboldt would mean a win, or any of the other things you've fabricated, is welcome to do so. Not my job to stop them from falling for specious argument.

I've done what I wanted, which was to point out an obvious factor, and provide links to factual sources so that people could make up their own minds.
That's the difference between rational discourse in a skeptic's forum, and endless debates in an online RPG or chat room debate.

Since you've assured us that you aren't going to provide any proof on your part, and you've assured us that you are done with this, I'll be happy to take you at your word on both of those, and quit waiting for you to contribute anything either correct, or useful.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom