Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
No. Tim provided a paper that is based upon mathematics that is directly related to MHD theory, and the flow of charged particle mass.


There is no disagreement on the issue of failure to support an electric/iron Sun conjecture. Continuing to complain about that failure is not going to result in success.

You're the liar.


The persistent incivility, unsupported assertions, and lack of willingness to offer quantitative objective support is noted.
 
He's "correct", but only because he understands that charged particles must be present in the vacuum for "reconnection" to occur. That's LIGHT YEARS ahead of Clinger.

I lost count of how many times I've said reconnection can happen in a vacuum without charged particles. I'm flabbergasted that you can say that I believe the opposite.
 
OMG. Somov takes two CURRENTS composed of moving charged particles, merges them into a single "field line" that encloses BOTH streams of moving charged particles and you're STILL claiming that no charged particles are involved in the process! Like I said, I've seen denial in my day, but EU haters are in a class by themselves.
OMG. Somov takes two CURRENTS. They never merge. They never become a single "field line".
The IDEALIZED CURRENTS I generate magnetic fields. These magnetic fields are visualized by the use of magnetic field lines in his diagrams.
MR then happens in a vacuum as Tim Thompson best stated:
I would like to point out that it is critical to look at figure 1.3, on page 103. The currents that generate the magnetic fields flow in a line perpendicular to the page in two marked spots (little circles with an x in them). Everywhere else is a vacuum with no current flow, in particular the null point marked "X". This null point, where the magnetic fields actually do their reconnecting, are completely embedded in a vacuum, there are no particles and there is no current flow at or near that point. This is a direct illustration of the reconnection of magnetic field lines in a vacuum.

I would also like to point out out that it is critical to look at figure 1.3, on page 103. The currents go through points. A point has an infinestimal size. Nothing physical can pass through that point, i.e. no charged particles exist in the diagram. It is a vacuum :eye-poppi!
One cavet though: electrons are thought to be point particles. So I guess Michael Mozina will go on a rant about the CURRENTS being streams of electrons.

I would also like to point out out that it is critical to think about the real physics that Michael Mozina's delusion raises, e.g. what keeps the charged particles going through those two points?

Like everyone can see, they have seen ignorance in their days, but science haters are in a class by themselves.

Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section IX!
 
Michael Mozina: where do you think MR in a vacuum happens

You're now attempting to CHANGE Somov's VACUUM+CURRENT to INCLUDE something he did NOT include, namely a SOLID wire. Sorry, no such fallacies allowed.
You're have been constantly attempting to CHANGE Somov's VACUUM+CURRENT to INCLUDE something he did NOT include, namely PLASMA. Sorry, no such fallacies allowed.

Somov's VACUUM+CURRENT is vacuum + current :jaw-dropp!
The current is an idealized current with no physical representation.

The MR does not happen at the currents. It happens at the neutral point. None of the magnetic field lines includes the currents.
Thus even if you do go to a physical representation by replacing the currents with a wire, MR still happens in vacuum.

A simple question for you, MM: where do you think MR in a vacuum containing 2 idealized currents happens?
Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov, section 4.4.2 Reconnection in Vacuum, figure 4.17.
 
I love Somov's work, but that sentence is, well, not precise.
That sentence is very precise.
His figure 4.17 has 2 currents I in them. These generate an enclosing magnetic field. When you draw magnetic fields lines to represent the magnetic field these lines can enclose either one current or both currents.

Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov
Chapter 4. Motion of a Particle in a Field
4.4.2 Reconnection in a Vacuum.
This process is realized as follows: Two field lines approach the X-point, merge there, forming a separatrix, and then they reconnect forming a field line which encloses both currents. Such a process us termed reconnection of field lines or magnetic reconenction. A2 is that last reconnect field line.
 
The really ridiculous part of this conversation is the fact that Somov is ultimately just describing the "magnetic attraction" that occurs between two current carrying filaments, ...usual rant snipped...
The really ridiculous part of this conversation is your inability to understand what Somove wrote.
There is no mention of the sign of the currents, thus no "magnetic attraction" that occurs between two currents (it could just as easily be repulsion).

What Somov does is describe what happens if the currents move a small distance (dl) closer. This causes MR.

Of course none of it works without current! If there was no current then there would be no magnetic field. Duh :eye-poppi!
 
I'm *STILL WAITING* for you folks to explain the RATE OF RECONNECTION in the absence of mass flow. Everyone must notice by now that you're all avoiding that question like the plague.
The question that you are trying to write was answered:
A definition of reconnection rate is a ratio between plasma flow velocities. It does not exist in vacuum.
Everyone must notice by now that you are avoiding the answer to that question like the plague.

The answer to your new mangled question is that it is a dumb question.
We are not talking about mass flows, e.g. avalanches.
 
There's a CAUSE/EFFECT part of his explanation you seem to have missed. The currents have to MOVE toward each other, or none of this occurs.
That is correct:
If the currents are displaced in the direction of each other, then the following redistribution of a magnetic flux will take place.
And thus MR in vacuum.
This contradicts your assertion that the currents "ultimately" merge.

This displacement only happens once. Somov does not repeat the displacement. The currents never merge.

Displace means to go from one place to another place. Displace does not mean constant motion as you seem to imply.
 
Then you should be able to mathematically quantify the rate of reconnection in some other way that isn't dependent upon the flow of matter. I've yet to see your side produce such a thing. Tick.tick.tick...
How idiotic, it is defined in terms of the velocity of plasma:
Posted on 15th March 2012, 03:47 PM
The Sweet-Parker model has a reconnection rate of
9567473f430340803975053589c8908e.png

where the dimensionless Lundquist number
5dbc98dcc983a70728bd082d1a47546e.png
is given by
c4bca0477871854bef9cbd717c20999f.png
[/
quote]

Unless this is the even more idiotic demand for a reconnection rate without plasma.
 
MM: What is reconnection rate of the plasma inside a rock containing no plasma

Wow. I don't think ANY of you will EVER explain the rate of reconnection, mathematically or otherwise in the absence of matter. This has to be the saddest, most denial oriented cult on the planet. EU haters RUN LIKE HELL from every tough question put before them.
Wow. I don't think you could get any more ignorant than to ask for an explantion of the reconnection rate in the absence of matter when it is only defined for plasma (matter).

That has to be the saddest, most delusion oriented crank statement on the planet. Sceince haters RUN LIKE HELL from every easy question put before them.

Simple question, MM: I have a lump of rock containing no plasma. What is reconnection rate of the plasma inside that rock?
 
PEER REVIEWED material that states plasma is OPTIONAL in MR

This is weird. I asked you for two simple things;

I asked you folks for PEER REVIEWED material to support your claims that plasma is OPTIONAL in the reconnection process. That's never happened. I also asked you for a mathematical description of the rate of reconnection without PLASMA. That has never happened either. Don't you think others are noticing that not one of you can even define the RATE of reconnection in the absence of plasma? Doesn't that bother you?
That is insane. We gave you two simple things
  • PEER REVIEWED material to support your claims that plasma is OPTIONAL in the reconnection process.
  • The fact that reconnection rate is defined for plasma. The rate of flow for plasma should have been a clue!
And now you lie again about the first and still cannot understand the insanity of asking for a reconneciton rate for non-plasma! That is like asking for the speed of light for a bowling ball!
Doesn't that bother you, Michael Mozina?

MR in a vacuum is mentioned in the scientific literature:
W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection starts with no plasma and shows that MR happens. Also see Cosmic plasma physics By Boris V. Somov, section 4.2.2 Reconnection in vacuum.
 
Last edited:
In my simplistic understanding of the text, the currents, wires or whatever, where outside the vacuum region while the fields reconnected in the vacuum region,

Can one of the sane posters confirm or correct me on this?
The currents are idealized currents. This is the same as the current J in Maxwell's equations. Somov thus describes reconnection in vacuum because there is nothing physical there.

The magnetic field lines reconnect at the null (or neutral) point which is distant from the currents. So even if someone assumes that the currents are actual wires or magically constrained plasma or magically constrained charged particles, the MR still happens in vacuum.
 
I'm really the only one here that notices that none of you can even define a rate of reconnection in the absence of matter? WOW!
Everyone else can read and understand the insanity of trying to define a reconnection rate ("rate of reconnection" does not exist) in the absence of matter?
You need matter in order to have an inward flose velocity and outward flow velocity. You need plasma to have a reconnection rate.

Reconnection rates are important for MR in plasma.
Reconnection rates do not exist for MR in vacuum.

MM: What is reconnection rate of the plasma inside a rock containing no plasma?
 
Still waiting for that mathematical expression of a rate of reconnection in the absence of plasma. You can't even come up with it. Who do you think you're fooling anyway?
MM: What is reconnection rate of the plasma inside a rock containing no plasma?

No one with two brain cells would claim that anyone can come up with "mathematical expression of a rate of reconnection in the absence of plasma" because "rate of reconnection" does not exist (you mean reconnection rate).
And reconnection rate is defined for plasma. Magnetic reconnection (in plasma)

We could derail this thread and look at defining a "reconnection rate" for solids or liquids or gases :rolleyes:.
 
What are you talking about? Every single paper that uses MHD theory to describe "reconnection" demonstrates that plasma is REQUIRED in the process called "reconnection".
What are you talking about? Every single paper that uses MHD theory to describe magnetic reconnection assumes that plasma is PRESENT in the magnetic reconnection that the paper describes :jaw-dropp!

It would be insane for someone using MHD to state that there is no plama.
It is delustional for someone to think that these papers using MHD theory mean that plasma is always requred especially when the btextbooks say otherwise, published papers themseves say otherwise and it is simple to show that MR in without plasma happens.

If you feel otherwise you need to provide a formula for the rate of reconnection that is NOT based upon the flow of charged particles.
And this inane demand again:MM: What is reconnection rate of the plasma inside a rock containing no plasma?
Talk about hilite]*DISHONEST* [/hilite] and crackpot ignorance.
 
He's "correct", but only because he understands that charged particles must be present in the vacuum for "reconnection" to occur. That's LIGHT YEARS ahead of Clinger.

Except that in that very post dasmiller linked to phunk states:
phunk said:
Reconnection rate is a term used in plasma physics. It does not apply in a vacuum. That doesn't mean reconnection doesn't happen, it means there's no matter entrained in the fields that are reconnecting.

Could this be any more clear?
Actually, yes it could...
phunk said:
Reconnection rate is a term used in plasma physics. It does not apply in a vacuum. That doesn't mean reconnection doesn't happen, it means there's no matter entrained in the fields that are reconnecting.

To claim that phunk disagrees with Clinger and disagrees with you is astonishing. Especially given that anybody able to use a computer can check exactly what phunk said. It is utterly staggering that you would even try and claim phunk agreed with you that charged particles had to be present.
 
To claim that phunk disagrees with Clinger and disagrees with you is astonishing. Especially given that anybody able to use a computer can check exactly what phunk said. It is utterly staggering that you would even try and claim phunk agreed with you that charged particles had to be present.

Actually, given that MM interprets Somov's "Reconnection in vacuum is a real physical process" to mean that reconnection in a vacuum cannot happen, we shouldn't be too surprised that he interprets phunk's "That doesn't mean reconnection doesn't happen" to mean that reconnection doesn't happen.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom