Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo XVIII
If I move a bar magnet at 1 meter/second, then the magnetic field of that bar magnet must also move through space at 1 meter/second. Is that not fairly obvious? Now, if I move a bar magnet at 1 meter/second, the change in magnetic field, as a result of the motion of the magnet, will propagate away from the magnet at the speed of light. So, if I move the magnet say 1 millimeter to the left, a measurement device located 10 meters away, will see the magnetic field change at its location {10 meters / speed of light} seconds later. So there are two different velocities for the magnetic field, one being the bulk motion of the field and the other being the change in the field.
You lost me. The two velocities (if I'm following you correctly) relate to the speed of light and the speed of the movement of the physical object in question, in this case the magnetic (or plasma particles in plasma).
Simple. Place a measuring device at some distance "d" from the bar magnet. Move the bar magnet at 1 meter/second. Measure the speed with which the magnetic field is moving with the measuring device. It will measure 1 meter/second, the same speed as the magnetic. Since the magnetic field is rigidly connected to the magnet, how can it be possible for the magnetic field to move with any velocity other than that of the magnet?
Now consider a similar experiment, except that instead of measuring the speed of the magnetic field, we will measure the strength of the magnetic field, and instead of moving the magnet at a constant velocity, we will move (or displace) the magnet over a relatively small, fixed distance (say 1 centimeter). Since the magnetic field has a shape unique to the magnet (but generally a dipole shape), any displacement of the magnet from its original position will cause the magnetic field strength at the measuring device to change. The change in the magnetic field will propagate through the magnetic field at the speed of light. So at a time x/c after the magnet moves, the measuring device will record the change in the magnetic field.
The field itself cannot move at any speed other than the speed of the magnet. But a change in the magnetic field propagates as a wave along the magnetic field lines, at the speed of light.
So let's go back to the paragraph you try so hard to ignore ...
One need only look at either of the images provided by
phunk (
post 6553, 29 Feb 2012) or myself (
Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo, 20 May 2011) and see that when the opposite polarity ends of a bar magnet face each other, then the magnetic field lines from either magnet are
fully connected to those of the other, while in the case of same polarity ends the magnetic field lines of either magnet are
fully disconnected from those of the other.
Simply rotating one magnet with respect to the other creates a transition from a fully connected to a fully disconnected state, or vice-versa. That is all you need to see & know, to know that the field lines of the two magnets have to change their connectivity, or in other words, the field lines must
reconnect. Now, if we want to talk about the process in some more detail, then all of the technical details you talk about must come into play. However, simply to establish the minimal condition that some form of reconnection takes place does not require anything beyond a visual inspection of the field line images.
No. No B lines never "disconnect", or "reconnect". They don't have a beginning or an end. Monopoles do not exist. Magnetic fields have no source and no sink. They are CREATED by the movement of charged particles. Even the concept of a LINE is a GROSS OVERSIMPLIFICATION of two FIELDS interacting.
Whether or not the magnetic field lines end is quite irrelevant since there is no need for the lines to end in order to reconnect. They simply reconnect at the crossing points necessarily created by the motion of the magnets. Like I said,
One need only look at either of the images to see that "no" is a logically impossible answer. The magnetic field lines are absolutely required to reconnect, by obvious and simple visual logic. If you don't think so, then why don't you explain how lines that are fully connected can become lines that are fully disconnecte, without ever actually disconnecting?
And no, the concept of a line is by no means a "gross oversimplification". Just look at the image of the iron filings. Don't you find it the slightest bit interesting that the physical iron filings align in the magnetic field in
exact conformity with the concept of field lines? You can literally see the field lines, with your own eyes, made of iron filings.
The velocity of the magnetic field is the velocity of motion of the bar magnets.
No. The velocity of the magnetic field is the speed of light and the velocity of the magnet is the velocity of the magnet. They aren't the same. More equivocation fallacies in play I see.
No "equivocation fallacy" here. There is no logic that allows for the velocity of the magnetic field to be anything other than the velocity of the magnetic.
As I said before, the ratio of incoming & outgoing velocities is necessarily 1 and therefore the reconnection rate do defined must always be exactly 1 in a vacuum.
Nonsense. It's exactly ZERO in a vacuum because ZERO velocity changes have been achieved as a result of moving anything. You don't lose any energy from the movement of your magnet just by moving it. If you move it around in a conductor like a plasma you might transfer some energy to particle kinetic energy, but unless you transfer energy, no 'Reconnection" could ever occur in a 'vacuum" devoid of all charged particles.
Hah! Nonsense yourself, you're quite full of it today. Must be feeling your oats, as they say. So, you think if I move a bar magnet its magnetic field does not move at all? Remember, we are not talking about one magnet, we are talking about two magnets, as illustrated in the figures attached to my post
Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo. Transitioning from one state to the other must reconnect the magnetic field lines, and whether or not any charged particles are directly affected by the change in the magnetic field is also seriously irrelevant, since no charged particles of any kind are ever required to be at or near the locus of points where the topological rearrangement of magnetic field lines takes place.
Nonsense. The reconnection rate is defined as a ratio of velocities, which means it is a unitless number (i.e., it has no units of measure, certainly not acceleration of anything).
Incredible. You can't even come up with a formula to describe the rate of "reconnection" without describing charged particle velocity changes. If you disagree, show otherwise.
I disagree, and evidently you can't read (like that's news).
The magnetic reconnection rate is set by the velocity of the magnetic field, not by the velocity of the plasma. The reason the velocity of the plasma is used is that outside the separatrix area where reconnection actually happens, the magnetic field is frozen to the plasma, so that the two velocities are the same (see, e.g, "Magnetic Reconnection: MHD Theory and Applications", Priest & Forbes, Cambridge University Press 2000, page 36). Magnetic reconnection in a vacuum is both trivial and unavoidable, happening very easily. However, as a general rule, magnetic reconnection is much harder to achieve in an astrophysical plasma because the fields are usually frozen to the plasma in astrophysical applications; e.g., magnetic reconnection is impossible in non-resistive, "ideal", MHD, which is the form originally invented by Alfven. Only in the presence of resistive plasma where the magnetic field can diffuse through the plasma can magnetic reconnection in a plasma actually take place.
In this case the rate of reconnection is the ratio of the velocity of the "incoming" magnetic field to the "outgoing" magnetic field, which is necessarily 1 in all cases, since there is only one relative velocity between the two magnets.
You knew very well that I was talking about the velocity of the magnetic field, not the plasma, but you deliberately chose to claim I was talking about a plasma velocity anyway. That is not an honest thing to do.