Terrible news from Afghanistan

...so you really really really are avoiding the topic of this thread.

I see you have a problem understanding complex thought. Reading lots of words is too difficult for you.

I'll make it simpler for you.

Do you think the Taliban are working in the best interest of the Afghan people?

Yes or no?
 
Last edited:
Do you really think that NEEDS TO BE SAID? it's not, you know, PATENTLY OBVIOUS?

I said what he did was right, silly green monkey?
Edited by LashL: 
To correct member's user name.


It is obvious what he did was terrible, but unlike the Islamist terrorists, he has been caught, and this type of tragedy will most likely not happen again.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Do you really think that NEEDS TO BE SAID? it's not, you know, PATENTLY OBVIOUS?

...well: considering that some people in this thread had posted several times and not addressed the topic at all and look all but apologists, yeah. From the posts that Pardalis has made in this thread it doesn't look like he has any sympathy at all for the victims and had done everything possible to make this thread about something else.
 
I see you have a problem understanding complex thought.

I'll make it simpler for you.

Do you think the Taliban are working in the best interest of the Afghan people?

Yes or no?

...no I don't.

A simple question for you: are the actions of the Taliban relevant at all to a thread about a US serviceman who allegedly murdered 16 people?
 
...well: considering that some people in this thread had posted several times and not addressed the topic at all and look all but apologists, yeah. From the posts that Pardalis has made in this thread it doesn't look like he has any sympathy at all for the victims and had done everything possible to make this thread about something else.

What's there to be said? He was caught and will face justice. I hope he gets life without parole.

And I have sympathy for the victims, and unlike some posters here, I also have sympathies for the growing list of Afghans and Pakistanis who keep being butchered by the Taliban.

The way I chose to be supportive of the Afghans is to support the efforts of our troops, because they are over there fighting the Taliban, they are not the ones who murder civilians as a policy and disrupting progress. They are actually helping the Afghans taking back their country from fascists and savages.

A simple question for you: are the actions of the Taliban relevant at all to a thread about a US serviceman who allegedly murdered 16 people?

It is relevant because Jihad Jane keeps apologizing for them and diminishing the problems they cause.

I hope I haven't used too many words this time. I wouldn't want to confuse you.
 
I said what he did was right, silly little green monkey?

It is obvious what he did was terrible, but unlike the Islamist terrorists, he has been caught, and this type of tragedy will most likely not happen again.
Edited by Tricky: 
Edited modded post.



Ummm, what Silly Green Monkey said actually supports you. I'd suggest not being so defensive.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Could you answer my question now?

I think it was fairly simple for you to comprehend.

...what part of "no I don't" is so hard for you to comprehend?

I'll make it easier for you and use less words: NO.

The way I chose to be supportive of the Afghans is to support the efforts of our troops, because they are over there fighting the Taliban, they are not the ones who murder civilians as a policy and disrupting progress. They are actually helping the Afghans taking back their country from fascists and savages.

...I support the mission of the troops as well. But you can't blindly look at the good things that are happening and ignore the bad. And this incident is very very bad and is more likely than anything else to disrupt the mission than anything else that has happened in the last few years. You can't just bury your head in the sand and pretend it didn't happen: and the tangent about the Taliban is not only irrelevant, but counterproductive to the discussion.

It is relevant because Jihad Jane keeps apologizing for them and diminishing the problems they cause.

So are the actions of the Taliban are relevant at all to a thread about a US serviceman who allegedly murdered 16 people because of the words written by an anonymous internet poster?
 
...I support the mission of the troops as well. But you can't blindly look at the good things that are happening and ignore the bad....
What's there to be said? He was caught and will face justice. I hope he gets life without parole.

It is obvious what he did was terrible, but unlike the Islamist terrorists, he has been caught, and this type of tragedy will most likely not happen again.
You are terrible at this, BB.

And this incident is very very bad and is more likely than anything else to disrupt the mission than anything else that has happened in the last few years. You can't just bury your head in the sand and pretend it didn't happen: and the tangent about the Taliban is not only irrelevant, but counterproductive to the discussion.
It's like you aren't actually reading what Para is saying.

So are the actions of the Taliban are relevant at all to a thread about a US serviceman who allegedly murdered 16 people because of the words written by an anonymous internet poster?
Yes. Because JJ has asserted that this soldier and the Coalition forces are bad because they kill innocent civilians. However, the Coalition does not make it a policy to target civvies, and it is a demonstrable fact that civilians are more likely to be killed by the Taliban, who deliberately target civilians. If the Coalition is bad because they kill civilians, then the Taliban is objectively much, much worse.

JJ's problem isn't with killing civilians, it's with the Coalition presence, period, no matter how much good they do. It is perfectly relevant to the thread to point out the logical inconsistencies in her position, as well as other causes of civilian casualties. Para has done so, and explicitly states that the soldier's actions were a very bad thing in the very post you are responding to, yet you say he's "ignoring the problem".
 
Pardalis is a franco-canadian
who desperately wants to be an American.
The second half of that sentence is untrue. I am not sure if the first half is or not, as I don't know how Pardalis chooses to classify himself. IIRC, he is Quebecois.

How is that "Franco Canadian."

I don't think the two terms are necessarily the same.

Back to the thread at hand:

for 3point14: as your initial attempt to mis-characterize my post was noted, I thank you for your honesty about your dishonesty.

Much appreciated. Most folks haven't got the integrity to do that.
 
Americans (plural) did not commit a terrible crime. It is neither fair, honest nor accurate to say that.

You should be careful where you out the letter "S". Just one of them could accidentally expose your personal prejudices.

Judging by the accounts of local witnesses it may be "multiple Americans" and we caught just one.
 
He won't be received kindly by his guards nor his fellow prisoners.


He probably won't be kept in solitary confinement for a year, stripped naked and chained to his bunk like his fellow inmate, Bradley Manning.
 


​
You are terrible at this, BB.

It's like you aren't actually reading what Para is saying.
...give me a break. How many posts did it take for Pardalis to actually comment on the soldier in question? By my count out of 31 posts in the thread only one of them address the soldier in question (apart from calling him a nutcase a couple of times) which is the one you quoted: and he only said that because I called him out about it.

Yes. Because JJ has asserted that this soldier and the Coalition forces are bad because they kill innocent civilians. However, the Coalition does not make it a policy to target civvies, and it is a demonstrable fact that civilians are more likely to be killed by the Taliban, who deliberately target civilians. If the Coalition is bad because they kill civilians, then the Taliban is objectively much, much worse.
Cite then? How many civilians have the Taliban killed since the occupation and how many have the Coalition forces? If your daughter has been killed by coalition troops, does it matter that it wasn't done on purpose?
JJ's problem isn't with killing civilians, it's with the Coalition presence, period, no matter how much good they do. It is perfectly relevant to the thread to point out the logical inconsistencies in her position, as well as other causes of civilian casualties. Para has done so, and explicitly states that the soldier's actions were a very bad thing in the very post you are responding to, yet you say he's "ignoring the problem".

As I've already stated: I was commenting on every other post that Pardalis had made in the thread up until that point. I was explaining why up until that point his posts were counter productive.

As Chaos said earlier in the thread:

I´ve got news for you: This is the "USA Politics" subforum. That sort of means that Americans are kind of the focus of what´s being discussed in this subforum. And there is no "obsession" to discussing crimes committed by Americans in a thread about a crime committed by one or more Americans in a subforum dedicated to the US.

You, on the other hand, seem obsessed to drag non-Americans and their perceived shortcomings into a discussion where this has no place. The Non-US Politics forum is further down that list.
 
...give me a break. How many posts did it take for Pardalis to actually comment on the soldier in question? By my count out of 31 posts in the thread only one of them address the soldier in question (apart from calling him a nutcase a couple of times) which is the one you quoted: and he only said that because I called him out about it.
So what? You accused him of paying attention to only the good effects of the Coalition occupation. JJ honestly thinks the insurgents are the good guys here.

Cite then? How many civilians have the Taliban killed since the occupation and how many have the Coalition forces? If your daughter has been killed by coalition troops, does it matter that it wasn't done on purpose?
I love the logical focus-pull you're trying here, going from general to specific as it pleases you.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8128878#post8128878
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8129890#post8129890
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8126232#post8126232
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8126237#post8126237
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8126203#post8126203
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8126189#post8126189
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8121676#post8121676
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8121616#post8121616
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8126222#post8126222

As I've already stated: I was commenting on every other post that Pardalis had made in the thread up until that point. I was explaining why up until that point his posts were counter productive.
Nope. You said he was, at the present, ignoring the bad and focusing on the good, and accused him of avoiding the topic of the thread when it was JJ who introduced the claim he rebutted, as he states in the very post you were responding to. As SGM pointed out, why would anyone need to explicitly say that killing civilians is bad? And when "pressed", Para said they should lock him up and throw away the key.

...
You know: providing a "laundry list" of incidents using google does not prove JihadJane's proposition incorrect. Were there more terrorist attacks on the citizens of Afghanistan before or after before or after the US invasion? There are many many other questions that you would have to ask before you could even come close to proving JihadJane wrong. The Taliban are not in power now: do you think providing a list of terror attacks that occured when the Taliban are not in power proves that the Taliaban aren't better at providing security? There is a certain logic failure there.
That's strange, you seemed perfectly willing to debate Para on the matter of whether JJ's claim was correct in post 295, the very same post you accused him of trying to change the subject. Asking him about the matter, then when he answers saying he's trying to avoid the main topic is the height of sophistry.

As Chaos said earlier in the thread:
But it is, apparently, off topic to discuss the actions of Americans by comparison to others, even when those actions specifically involve the US and the politics of such.

But feel free to help try to change the subject from Jane's logical inconsistency. She posted a quote that compared the Coalition to the Taliban, compared them herself, and you only started complaining when that claim was turned inside out. If you want to be logically consistent, you have to call her out on it as well.http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8120042#post8120042

Oh good, shall we start referring to the Taliban merely as "guys who went crazy", then, and drop all this "terrorist" nonsense?

;)
 
Last edited:
...so you really really really are avoiding the topic of this thread.
Woosh goes the point right over your head.

Killing civilians is not the policy of the US and ISAF. Bales wasn't shooting civilians on orders from anyone. The Taliban who send suicide bombers into markets, shoot teachers for educating girls, throw acid in the faces of girls who dare to go to school, forbid women from working, destroy ancient relics, etc etc do it intentonally.

Before the US was in Afghanistan the Taliban were brutally suppressing civilians, especially non-Pashtun and women. They executed and tortured people in front of cheering crowds in soccer stadiums. They shelled villages indiscriminately. It waqsn't lone Taliban who snapped and did these things, it's just what the Taliban do.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom