Terrible news from Afghanistan

But your analogy is wrong. They didn't just protest the q'ran burning as you know.

I don't have to construe anything, an Afghan Mullah said the same thing.

If you don't want to take Wildcat's word for it, take his.

We were talking about human life, and its value. You are the one who kept bringing up "devaluation" and misinterpreting Wildcat's poisition. Go ahead and read again our exchange if you don't believe me. Now you're trying to change the conversation.

Insist all you want, I still think Afghans think this life is less important than the other one, and that is why they feel more compelled to express outrage at a Q'ran burning than the killing of innocent villagers. It's the same reason why Muslims don't drink, they can't enjoy this life because they have to "prepare" for the other one.

And an Afghan atheists facebook page? Please... :rolleyes:

Afghanis have computers. They are probably quite vocal on many issues in countries such as the UK, France, and so on where life is less difficult.
 
Woosh goes the point right over your head.

Killing civilians is not the policy of the US and ISAF. Bales wasn't shooting civilians on orders from anyone. The Taliban who send suicide bombers into markets, shoot teachers for educating girls, throw acid in the faces of girls who dare to go to school, forbid women from working, destroy ancient relics, etc etc do it intentonally.

Before the US was in Afghanistan the Taliban were brutally suppressing civilians, especially non-Pashtun and women. They executed and tortured people in front of cheering crowds in soccer stadiums. They shelled villages indiscriminately. It waqsn't lone Taliban who snapped and did these things, it's just what the Taliban do.
But...but...it's off topic (except for Jane)!
 
Karzhai did raise an interesting question the other day. He mentions that all the dead were gathered in one place to be burned. They were killed in different houses. Seems a little strange that one drunk person with a part of his foot blown off in an earlier fight would go to this trouble.

There havebeen conflicting reports as to how many shooters there were. It is concieveable that only one man did the shooting and others helped gather the bodies.

Bear in mind that the shooter is from a unit which, in the past had a case of several soldiers going on a rampage as a group.

Possibility exists that the shooter is covering for the clean-up detail.

Then it is time to chat up an uncovering me thinks if so.
 
I'm not sure anyone is claiming there is a cover-up. There is definitely a problem in the struggle to win the hearts and minds of the people of Afghanistan with whisking him out of country quickly and not even allowing Afghan authorities to conduct any independent investigation.

U.S. authorities aren't even claiming to have any evidence of what happened other than the statement of the "CRAZY! NUTS Whacko!" guy, and the video of his return to the base. The fact that Afghanistan has found evidence (witness testimony and apparently some physical evidence--Karzai says the people were killed in 4 different rooms, then all the bodies moved to one room where they were set afire) that conflicts with the theory of the case that the U.S. has is a pretty big deal.

Even without surrendering the guy for prosecution by Afghanistan, the US could have been a lot more cooperative.

If this is still an investigation stage case with multiple killers sitting quiet, it may not be best to have leader killer in the same base with said killers. Leader back in USA makes it easier for Afghanistan/investigation to catch the others.
 
So what? You accused him of paying attention to only the good effects of the Coalition occupation. JJ honestly thinks the insurgents are the good guys here.

...wow. JJ doesn't say what you claim she says remotely in the post you linked to. She said:

Suicide bombing didn't exist in Afghanistan before the invasion.

The "suicide bombers" in Afghanistan are frequently motivated by very personal experiences of the occupiers' violence, such as the death and abuse of family members.

They are, indeed, consciously resisting an unjust occupation and with the most effective means available to them.

I see no claim that the insurgents are the good guys: You've made that claim up. Did you think I wasn't going to click on the link?

Nice laundry list of randomly googled events. However you made this claim:

demonstrable fact that civilians are more likely to be killed by the Taliban,

It is only demonstrable if you can prove that civilians are more likely to be killed by the Taliban, not that the Taliban have killed civilians. How many civilians have the US killed since the invasion? How many have the Taliban? If you can't back up your assertion you should withdraw it.

Nope. You said he was, at the present, ignoring the bad and focusing on the good, and accused him of avoiding the topic of the thread when it was JJ who introduced the claim he rebutted, as he states in the very post you were responding to. As SGM pointed out, why would anyone need to explicitly say that killing civilians is bad? And when "pressed", Para said they should lock him up and throw away the key.

​


Oh come on. Pardalis has been avoiding the topic of the thread since his very first post where he talked about the "heroic actions of the coalition." That was well before he even started interacting with JJ.

Here are a sample of the posts in the thread where Pardalis avoids the topic:

url]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8128878#post8128878[/url]
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8129890#post8129890
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8126232#post8126232
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8126237#post8126237
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8126203#post8126203
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8126189#post8126189
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8121676#post8121676
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8121616#post8121616
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8126222#post8126222

For the rest of the posts where he avoided the topic, refer to any of his posts with the exception of the ones where he responded to me.


​
That's strange, you seemed perfectly willing to debate Para on the matter of whether JJ's claim was correct in post 295, the very same post you accused him of trying to change the subject. Asking him about the matter, then when he answers saying he's trying to avoid the main topic is the height of sophistry.
Somebody asked me a question: I responded. It was the polite thing to do.
But it is, apparently, off topic to discuss the actions of Americans by comparison to others, even when those actions specifically involve the US and the politics of such.
Well, yeah, if the sole point of the comparisons is to diminish the actions of this US soldier.
But feel free to help try to change the subject from Jane's logical inconsistency. She posted a quote that compared the Coalition to the Taliban, compared them herself, and you only started complaining when that claim was turned inside out. If you want to be logically consistent, you have to call her out on it as well.http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8120042#post8120042

When did the topic of this thread become about Jane's logical inconsistency?

And your gonna have to help me out here. What is the problem you have with the posts you linked to? One of them was obvious sarcasm, indicated by the sarcasm smile, and the other one was a quote from Robert Fisk who made a specific rhetorical point that coincidentally, is actually related to the thread.
 
Last edited:

A seven year old spy for :rule10 and spews. What can a seven year old spy on or if he or she did make sense of?
 
The "local civilians":

Nine of the 16 victims were children.

'No One Asked Their Names'

Photograph of distressed adult with small, dead children:
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/263894f692dbd630ba.jpg[/qimg]

The dead:

That's a photograph of two adults and some dead kids. Adult number two is behind adult one and looking at the kids. Adult one is facing the camera with tears in his eyes.</nitpick>
 
...If the Taliban and the insurgency weren't there to create chaos, the work of the Coalition would be easier ...

Didn't we go in there to beat the Taliban? We'll never know what we could have done had we stayed on-task instead of starting an optional war 18 months later. Driving the Taliban out of the cities wasn't enough.

Militarily or in nation-building terms, how much opportunity to secure Afghanistan did we forgo in order to invade Iraq?

All our resources and the resources of the Afghan government are diverted towards the fight against terrorism ...

"All" our resources? In January 2009 there were 144K troops in Iraq and 33K in Afghanistan. Why did we take our eye off the ball to begin with? Is it possible forgoing the optional war would have left the military fitter and individual soldiers less prone to battle fatigue or whatever makes a soldier snap?
 
...
It is only demonstrable if you can prove that civilians are more likely to be killed by the Taliban, not that the Taliban have killed civilians. How many civilians have the US killed since the invasion? How many have the Taliban? If you can't back up your assertion you should withdraw it....

The Taliban say they want to avenge the death of civilians, what about the civilian deaths they cause?

The Taliban caused 77% of civilian casualties in 2011.

Article title: "Most Afghan civilian deaths 'caused by Taliban attacks, not US forces'"

The annual United Nations report on civilian casualties shows that more than two-thirds of the 2,777 civilians killed last year were the victims of insurgents – a 28% increase on 2009. By contrast Nato and Afghan government forces were responsible for killing 440, a 25% decrease.

So, you've made it clear you didn't actually check those links in Para's posts, or you wouldn't be asking me to back up my claims, because I already linked them. In fact, given that he clearly described the first one, you probably never made it that far down the list.


...Well, yeah, if the sole point of the comparisons is to diminish the actions of this US soldier....
As I have already pointed out, it was to refute Jane. Not talking about the soldier does not mean that one is attempting to diminish the crime he seems to have committed, and when you pressed him, Para said clearly and unambiguously that he thinks they should lock him up and throw away the key, a sentiment I honestly share. What, does he need keep saying it in every post for you to be convinced he's not trying to diminish the attacks? And why is Jane so reluctant to respond to these herself in any depth?

Before you tu quoque, Para's already responded to you in depth. Note that he actually linked to the fact that the Taliban kills more people in Iraq than the Coalition. Even a year by year account. I'm not sure why you asked me about it. I'm only arguing because I think you're wrong. Well, I was arguing.

Pleasure doing business with ya.
 
Last edited:
Which is factually incorrect.

Do you know how Ahmad Shah Massoud was assasinated? And when?
If ergo was here, he'd hastily amend his claim to "bombing of innocents" or "bombing of coalition forces" or something, the first of which is wrong, and the second of which is self-evident. Then he'd run away and come back later acting like he won.

It's nice to debate someone who is willing to stand their ground, even if said ground is quicksand.
 
I'm glad Jihad Jane mentioned Amnesty International

Amnesty International.



Amnesty International: Taliban Leaders Should be Prosecuted for War Crimes.


The "court" that ordered the punishment, found Sanam Gul, also known as Bibi Sanubar, guilty of having an illicit affair, proof of which was her pregnancy. She was sentenced to 200 lashes and then executed. The punishment was carried out by Mohammad Yousuf, the area Taliban commander amid a crowd of onlookers.


Sanam Gul's death comes soon after the chilling Aug 7 executions of ten medical aid workers who had been returning from a trip to provide free medical care to remote regions of Afghanistan.


These barbaric theatrics meant to intimidate and terrify local populations are not novel tactics for the Taliban. In the time that they controlled Afghanistan, from 1998-2001, such public floggings and executions were frequent occurrences in towns controlled by the group. In addition to such tactics of terror which misuse concepts of Islamic law to instate a reign of terror, the Taliban are also guilty of increasingly bloodthirsty killing campaigns that kill hundreds of Afghan civilians.
A U.N report released on August 10 revealed that civilian casualties caused by the Taliban have increased nearly 31% in the first six months of 2010. This means that over 3,000 Afghan civilians have died in the shootings, killings, suicide bombings that the Taliban carry out with impunity in areas which they control.
 
Last edited:
No source, I note.


No response to this, I note:

...wow. JJ doesn't say what you claim she says remotely in the post you linked to. She said:

Suicide bombing didn't exist in Afghanistan before the invasion.

The "suicide bombers" in Afghanistan are frequently motivated by very personal experiences of the occupiers' violence, such as the death and abuse of family members.

They are, indeed, consciously resisting an unjust occupation and with the most effective means available to them.


I see no claim that the insurgents are the good guys: You've made that claim up. Did you think I wasn't going to click on the link?


~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~


Roads were safer in Afghanistan under the Taliban, British general admits

***A senior British general heaped further pressure on Gordon Brown's strategy in Afghanistan today after be admitted the country's roads were safer under the Taliban.

Major-General Nick Carter, who leads Nato forces in the south of the troubled country, said that, before the 2001 invasion, young women could travel alone between major cities without risk of harm.

He said: "The difference, I think we need to be clear, is that when the Taliban were here they did ensure security on the main highways and they did it very effectively.

"You could put your daughter on a bus in Kabul sure in the knowledge that she would get in one piece to Kandahar.

"That is not the case at the moment, and we need to change that," he told the BBC.
***

[/derail]
 
Last edited:
The roads were safer when the Taliban wanted to keep them open. The roads are no longer safe because the Taliban doesn't want them to be safe.
 
No response to this, I note:

...
I stopped responding to BB because he's not being intellectually honest, barring my one last Parthian shot where I showed he wasn't actually reading the links he scoffed at. Which makes it ironic when he says I was bluffing. Speaking of which, let's clear something up; when you said

[Suicide bombers] are, indeed, consciously resisting an unjust occupation and with the most effective means available to them.
were you saying suicide bombing in Afghanistan is justifiable? How does that gel with them going after civilian targets as well?

The Taliban kills more civilians than all the Coalition forces in Afghanistan, combined, and deliberately. If the US is bad for killing civvies, then the Taliban, logically, is worse because it kills more civilians, and on purpose. These pieces of human scum used an 8-year old girl as bombers. Even Amnesty Intl doesn't support them. Even your claim that "Suicide bombing didn't exist in Afghanistan before the invasion.", as Noah pointed out, is factually incorrect. In fact, it was pointed out back when you made the initial claim, so you hurriedly claimed they were "imported from Tunisia" and moved the goalposts.

But hey, keep trying to distract us from your lack of sources, and not directly claiming that the Taliban are, in fact, bad guys, and that you're ignoring posts that prove you wrong.

It's interesting how you continuously seem happy to disagree with the poistions of others while being so strangely reticent to comment on your own.

I guess we'll leave it that I personally find all suicide bombing abhorrent and unjustifiable and you... appear to enjoy arguing for its own sake.
 
The roads were safer when the Taliban wanted to keep them open. The roads are no longer safe because the Taliban doesn't want them to be safe.

The Coalition are the ones building roads the Taliban destroyed.

Hey Jihad, THE ROADS ARE UNSAFE BECAUSE OF THE TALIBAN
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom