Terrible news from Afghanistan

I suppose it is possible that some of those people simply don't think there is any moral issue with invading a country that never attacked you and killing thousands of people.
So you're a 9/11 truther too?
 
Jane, I believe my interpretation of your post and posts is a reasonable one.

Without substantiation, 063, what you believe is irrelevant, doubly so now that you are trying to justify your beliefs by inventing quotations.

If someone says "they have to resist the big meanie invaders with suicide bombings, they have no choice!"

Who said that?

that looks almost exactly like they're going "it's okay to suicide bomb to resist the invaders".

Yes, reality is great when one can just make it up as one goes along.

Here, out of context, is what I actually said (in another thread):

Suicide bombing didn't exist in Afghanistan before the invasion.

The "suicide bombers" in Afghanistan are frequently motivated by very personal experiences of the occupiers' violence, such as the death and abuse of family members.

They are, indeed, consciously resisting an unjust occupation and with the most effective means available to them.

As readers will note, it is a factual statement and it contains no reference to "big meanie invaders" or any other infantile, schoolyard turns of phrase.


I refuse to withdraw my claim until you categorically deny my allegations,...

Traditionally, on this forum, it is up to the person who makes a claim to justify it.

... which you seem to be going through a lot of effort to not do.

Your apparently intense need to smear people (see Rule 12) is your problem, not mine. Not playing along with your crude, intellectually dishonest game is no effort at all.

You have done so in the past, with regards to the Bali Nightclub bombing.

Done what?

It is also the height of hypocrisy to snark at me for allegedly not knowing your position, yet refuse to state what that position is, even when I ask you to say so. If you won't correct me, if you keep with your mealy mouthed nonsense about how it's "unsubstantiated", you don't get to complain about the interpretation I have.

There is no "allegedly" about it. If you knew my position, you wouldn't be so aggressively trying to get me to tell you what it is!

You made claim. It's up to you to justify it.

And you did, in fact, start the "sidetrack" by comparing the US forces in general to the Taliban.

The comment you link to was a sarcastic response to another poster's response to an article by Robert Fisk in which he compared the narratives of "defence experts and the think-tank boys and girls" vis-à-vis Taliban and US atrocities. Fisk isn't discussing who is better or worse. He's discussing presentation (i.e. propaganda).

Remember Pat Tillman?

Fisk's comment is very relevant to the side-tracking antics happening in this thread. I recommend that you read his article in full.


This comment was a response to a poster's claim that "a prolonged American presence and war is far better than letting the Taliban regain power."

...including the laughable and objectively wrong claim that Afghanistan was more secure under the Taliban compared to the "tooled-up night raiders".

One of people's main grievances against the occupying force is their use of night raids on their homes.

I said that the Taliban had shown themselves better at providing everyday security, a point backed up by analysis from the Council on Foreign Relations think tank and by a British General, who admitted that, when the Taliban were in power, it was possible for a young women to travel safely by bus between towns. Now it isn't.

Simples!

But sure, keep linking to the post where BB proved he wasn't actually reading any of the links he scoffed at by asking me for information that was in one of the links. That'll help your case.

What case?

I linked to BB's post because it contains the words you failed to quote while casting your smear with them.

The one where he quotes your claim about suicide bombing not existing in Afghanistan before the invasion, which is objectively wrong.

The Taliban didn't use suicide bombing as a tactic in Afghanistan before the US invasion and occupation.


I also like how you refuse to say whether the Taliban is or was worse than the Coalition, and can only scoff at the claims to that effect. We can all tell why you're not addressing the points in any substance and avoiding direct questions about your position, Jane. Mocking something is not the same as denying it.

And now, following on from invented quotes, you present a psychic reading as evidence.

063, I have no interest in discussing with you whether the Taliban is worse than the "Coalition", or pursuing your simplistic Good Guys/Bad Guys narrative. It is irrelevant to the topic of the thread, which is, in case you've forgotten, the massacre and burning of mostly women and children by an, allegedly, lone, allegedly deranged and/or drunk/drugged, foreign soldier of occupation.

EDIT: I just noticed you cut out part of the final post you responded to.

Doesn't gel with your image of the US as jackbooted thugs, does it, Jane?

That's your image, not mine, 063.

I notice that your response cuts out my post entirely.

Mine was an unintentional omission, though, now you have reproduced it, I see it is, characteristically, completely irrelevant to the thread topic or anything I have written. What could possibly be motivating so many people to focus so intensely and exclusively on how bad the Taliban are in a thread about an horrific, US-perpetrated war atrocity? ;)



That, and the fact that she could easily prove me wrong by saying "I think the Taliban are the bad guys" if she thought the Taliban are the bad guys. It's like how on TV the perp goes "you can't prove any of that!" after the cops corner them, right at around the 51-minute mark. Then when the cops show they can prove it, they either blurt out a confession or ask for their lawyer.

But that's enough of a sidetrack about Jane's beliefs. She won't deny it, I won't retract it, let's move on.

How long have you been using the Cowboys and Indians, Good Guys/Bad Guys meme as a guide to understanding complex international conflicts?

How useful would this analytical technique be if we there weren't actually any "Good Guys"?








Btw? so-called JihadJane is expressing a pretty moderate center-right position here so you probably ought to quit acting like she's some sort of communist. I am a communist. And on the whole I actually do believe the sort of stuff you're falsely saying she believes, but when I actually say it? Crickets. Alright. I just think that's all kinda funny.

Cartoons are what many people best respond to round these parts. To get a response, just change your name to JihadDavid. :)

Thanks for your incisive, well-informed analyses.
 
Last edited:
How long have you been using the Cowboys and Indians, Good Guys/Bad Guys meme as a guide to understanding complex international conflicts?

How useful would this analytical technique be if we there weren't actually any "Good Guys"?

See signature. The more someone proclaims their nuanced thinking, the more ideologically blinkered and dogmatic they actually are.

Who would you rather live under:

a) NATO
b) The Taliban and Al-Qaeda.

Pick one.
 
Last edited:
...Which had allowed the organization responsible for the 9/11 attacks to train there, to use its territory as a safe house and refused to hand over the criminals responsible for trial....
They also called for Afghanistan to do the same back in 1998. As a reasonable consequence of not doing so, the Taliban should've reasonably known Al Qaeda would continue to attack the Great Satan, possibly pissing it off and causing a serious response.

Oh, look, that's exactly what happened.

I love this responsibility chain stuff. It's self-debunking.
 
...So your axiom is really about who spends most gas mileage?
Oh, I get it. The US are the bad guys because they spent more gas. Why couldn't they be more eco-friendly?

So ridiculous. The US flew across the world to fight a war. The AQ terrorists deliberately killed thousands of civilians to start one. And they did. I like how the US is solely responsible for the Afghan War, but AQ isn't responsible for starting that war.
 
I said that the Taliban had shown themselves better at providing everyday security, a point backed up by analysis from the Council on Foreign Relations think tank and by a British General, who admitted that, when the Taliban were in power, it was possible for a young women to travel safely by bus between towns. Now it isn't.

Except that she won't be able to figure out which bus is which since the Taliban won't allow her to learn to read.
 
You know you're not making any sense.
I don't think he does. This seems like someone prone to self-reflection to you?

If you want to argue that 9/11 wasn't caused by AQ you should talk about it here, that subforum is dedicated to that sort of stuff, you'll have a fun time.
Funny. JJ used to hang out there. She stopped after people kept asking her for her opinion on things.

...
The problem is I'm not American.

Montréal is in Canada.
Dave's research skills strike again!

...He doesn't strike me as British....
I currently live in England, and have a British passport, of sorts(as I have admitted on JREF before), but grew up elsewhere, and don't consider myself British. That "elsewhere" was not the United States, or Canada. I don't consider myself "American" either.
 
See signature. The more someone proclaims their nuanced thinking, the more ideologically blinkered and dogmatic they actually are.

Who would you rather live under:

a) NATO
b) The Taliban and Al-Qaeda.

Pick one.

The ironic thing is that Dave is using the same simplification, and she sees no problem with it. Off of BB's post defending her, no less.


In what possible world are the "insurgents" not the good guys? USA invaded yet another country and bombed and murdered hundreds of thousands of people which is on-going. It's a black and white case of unprovoked aggression, the use of force, a breach of the peace, a war crime under the Nuremburg principles and a violation of the UN charter.
Still hilarious how he was crying about the UN Charter, but ignored the fact that the Taliban repeatedly ignored the UN telling them to turn AQ over and stop supporting them, well before 9/11.
 
Funny. JJ used to hang out there. She stopped after people kept asking her for her opinion on things.

Cute smear, but wrong.

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

'Afghan Massacre Sheds Light on Culture of Mania and Aggression in U.S. Troops in Afghanistan'

""""We speak with journalist Neil Shea, who has reported on Afghanistan and Iraq since 2006 for Stars and Stripes and other publications. Shea discusses his experiences witnessing disturbing behavior during his travels with U.S. troops in Afghanistan and offers insight into understanding the massacre of 16 Afghan civilians.

"I found that during one of my last trips to Afghanistan, I met up with a group of soldiers who were the first I had ever come across who made me feel pretty nervous about what I was going to see while I was with them. And I spent a few days with them and came to just really understand that they had gotten to the edge of violence, as we understand it, in Afghanistan, and they seemed ready and capable of doing some pretty bad things. I didn’t actually witness them do anything too terrible, but the way that they talked and the way that they acted toward Afghan civilians and animals and property in the country was sort of stunning to me. And that’s what I describe in the article. It’s talking about these—this group of soldiers and sort of their mental state during a multi-day mission in a central part of Afghanistan that was supposed to be a Taliban stronghold. Many of these guys seemed like they had reached the end of their rope in terms of stability and controlling their aggression.
" """"
 
Last edited:
Just to be clear, Jane, I actually am ignoring you, not the content of #444, which I have only read enough of to know you were responding to me. That is, "the poster, not the post". I decided I didn't want to try and debate something with someone who argues tricking an 8-year old girl into delivering a bomb to a police station is self-defense or "the most effective means available to them" to resist "an unjust invasion". It's taken Dave, what, two pages to even admit that they do harm civilians, and he didn't even admit it was on purpose.

Regarding of the Ride the Bus Safely claim, I'm assuming you're ignoring post 345, and haven't read this well-sourced Wikipedia article.
 
Last edited:
Dave's research skills strike again!

It's like that guy doesn't realise it says Montreal underneath his name on every post.
I currently live in England, and have a British passport, of sorts(as I have admitted on JREF before), but grew up elsewhere, and don't consider myself British. That "elsewhere" was not the United States, or Canada. I don't consider myself "American" either.

So I got that right at least.
 
Last edited:
It's like that guy doesn't realise it says Montreal underneath his name on every post.
Yet you still specifically called him an American.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=8140233#post8140233
Sorry that sounds awfully patronising but it's true. I guess everyone has their issues where they cannot see anything but their own prejudices and Americans are essentially brainwashed from birth with this American cult of the state, or nationalism. You are trained as children to salute the flag and sing praises to the state and all that Nazi-like stuff. Really creepy but it's not your fault.
Are you even capable of recognizing your failures? Because this is becoming more of a farce every time you post. You. Were. Wrong. If you can't even admit it on a minor fact, how do you expect to hold any credibility about a war.

So I got that right at least.
You assumed I was British. I'm not. Para said I didn't seem British. He was right. You. Were. Wrong.

That's right isn't it? That other guy sounds British and they don't get all that nationalistic crap the same way. I mean he's biased and been subjected to a lot of propaganda but he's not utterly unreachable. He tries to make sense. He makes arguments based on what he sees as facts and logic. You don't. And I only mean on this topic I am sure you are fine on anything which isn't undermining your patriotism.
I make arguments based on facts and logic, but you still disagree with me and refuse to even admit to the possibility the war was justified. Yet you accused me of being so biased that I wasn't able to say the war might not have been justified. And I did. By your own petard, you're biased.
 
So basically this "debate" is currently being held down on one side by a group of people who can't debate, at least not on this topic.

They claim the UN somehow "blessed" the war but when questioned they can't say what they mean by it, but nevertheless remain dogmatic that it happened, and offended when it is pointed out that it didn't happen.

They claim the US invasion of Afghanistan was wonderful, but cannot answer a simple question about whether it would be wonderful if their own country was invaded, instead claiming such a question is "loaded".

They have no conception about elementary axioms of ethics, simply denying them, even as they of course use them the same as anyone else.

It's funny that they are now accusing me of being a 9-11 truther because truthers at least have confidence in their own thinking and use the form of debate and argument and facts to present their case. They don't just call people names and keep saying "that's a lie" or "it's just a fact" or some other ridiculous irrational slogan like this one:

Who would you rather live under:
a) NATO
b) The Taliban and Al-Qaeda.

All this statement does is display an inability to think straight. NATO has killed millions of people in Iraq and Afghanistan. Maybe that has something to do with the fact that the people who actually do have this sort of choice don't want to be ruled by a gang of mass murderers?

I will re-write the question and see who can answer it for me shall I?

Who would you rather live under:
a) a group that has murdered millions of people that look like you
b) Anybody else

This whole conversation should be really good for a skeptics board because I think it perfectly demonstrates that so-called skeptics can speak utterly irrationally and dogmatically hold to ideologically informed opinions on things without showing even the slightest hint that they have any self awareness they are doing it.

* When you cannot answer your opponents arguments
* When you cannot form any arguments of your own
* When you must resort to making up stuff
* When you must resort to insulting your opponents
* When you strongly believe things you have no idea how to demonstrate

well you might just be a dogmatic ideologue that believes rubbish.

What does it say that all (I think all? is it all?) of the people taking the pro-invasion side here seem to endorse the obviously nonsense idea that a UN security council resolution made after the invasion, gave permission for the invasion to begin?

I believe the debate has now moved from being about Afghanistan and that war, to a debate about the credulity and brainwashed nature of the proponents of the view that the war was justified. At least until an actual skeptic turns up to take that other side (perhaps as a devil's advocate?)

Still hilarious how he was crying about the UN Charter, but ignored the fact that the Taliban repeatedly ignored the UN telling them to turn AQ over and stop supporting them, well before 9/11.

That never happened even once but you claim it happened repeatedly. How do you debate someone who is delusional? Are you going to say this demand was made in another resolution that they had to sent back in a time ship to before the war started? UN resolutions are not good things to make up stuff about because they are all on-line and they are numbered so it's pretty hard to just lie about them like that, but I guess it's easier if you don't feel any need to respond when people call you out on your delusions and ask you WHICH resolution, huh? Excuse me resolutions plural as you said "repeatedly".

The AQ terrorists deliberately killed thousands of civilians

I asked you to substantiate your claim which seems obviously false for the reasons I gave before. No response from you but to repeat the same ludicrous and unsubstantiated claim.

Would you say that your pattern of behaviour is demonstrating skepticism or ideological blindness?

I am trying to look for what might be your best "arguments" and apparently the above is it. Two statements that have already been disputed, and you simply repeat them.
 
Last edited:
I make arguments based on facts and logic, but you still disagree with me and refuse to even admit to the possibility the war was justified.

You don't "use facts and logic" at all. 90% of the post you just made appeared to be arguing that because I guessed someone was American that somehow means I am wrong about Afghanistan. Can you not see how irrational that was ???????

Furthermore what the heck do you mean by "but you still disagree with me"? It's as if you're thinking that I should grade you on the curve or something. I am supposed to give you a pass and pretend your nonsense makes sense because? What? You're trying? I am not sure you even are trying to make sense. I guess you're doing better than anyone else on your side but that's still just awful.

And what is that weird stuff about "refuse to even admit to the possibility", what is that about?

If I am debating creationism should I start off saying "Oh I believe that creationism might be true. It's a possibility"? Sorry. if you want to be told you're right then think right and use logic and argument.

Yet you accused me of being so biased that I wasn't able to say the war might not have been justified. And I did. By your own petard, you're biased.

I don't CARE if you say the war "might not be" justified. I didn't ask you to say that. I don't care if you did or not, although as it happens I don't recall you ever saying it anyway so I am thinking you are actually lying even when you make that claim (no I really don't care).

Freakish behaviour.

If you want to impress me, which for whatever reason you seem to, then stick to the debate and try and articulate the reasons you have for the beliefs you hold.

You can start by getting back to me on why you think the UN had a resolution saying it was OK to invade Afghanistan.
 
They claim the US invasion of Afghanistan was wonderful,
And you think it was illegal, because 9/11 was an inside jobby-job, or perpetrated by the Jews/Mossad/NWO or some group other than al Qaeda operating from Afghanistan, is this correct?
 
Is this supposed to be an argument?

Incidentally, here's an article mentioning the 9-year old girl who was kidnapped and had a bomb strapped to her by the Taliban, in addition to the 8-year old accidental bomb mule earlier. It apparently isn't uncommon for them to use prepubescent kids as suicide bombers.

I didn't realise it might be because it's so dumb, but I guess you've said it before so maybe you think it is. That's like if we had a debate about what is the tallest building in the world and you just keep pointing at random buildings saying, "Wow that looks big I bet that's the tallest building in the world."

What's the thinking here?

You point out what appears on it's surface to be a "bad" event that on it's surface you can blame on the Taliban. And that's the whole argument? That's it? You must know that I could point out very easily many events directly committed by the US forces that are far worse, right? if I wanted to. I mean this entire thread started with one such example where many children were killed. Not one. Many.

And I already showed that any such examples you make of the Taliban doing stuff in response to the invasion is morally the fault of US invasion forces because if the US had not invaded then none of this stuff would have happened. JihadJane hinted at such an argument when she said "suicide bombing never happened in Afghanistan before the invasion" but I said it explicitly. Your response was to deny the moral axiom. You said that nobody blames criminals for bad things that happens as a result of their crimes. I linked to a statement about common law saying that you were wrong and you made no reply.

So what the heck is your thinking here? You're just irrationally repeating this statement as if the force of the emotions will make the argument that you cannot. is that how you think? Should I post pictures of dead Afghan children? Would that count as an argument in your mind?

Do you understand that what I am saying here is that you are being irrational? An argument is not simply the act of throwing out unproven statements at random or repeating the same ones again and again.

For example it doesn't matter how many times you post that statement about suicide bombers it will never make any difference to whether the UN formally approved an invasion of Afghanistan or not. Do you understand that?

I've seen you on other topics and you're not stupid. You do know how to marshal an argument and put out relevant facts. Why can't you do it on this topic? And "because I am wrong" isn't a good enough answer either.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom