Terrible news from Afghanistan

Just to preserve this gem of what passes for "debate" by the pro-invasion side.

Originally Posted by DavidByron View Post
They claim the US invasion of Afghanistan was wonderful,

And you think it was illegal, because 9/11 was an inside jobby-job, or perpetrated by the Jews/Mossad/NWO or some group other than al Qaeda operating from Afghanistan, is this correct?
 
You can't answer this simple question?

I prefer to use it as a demonstration of your frame of mind.

I've never said anything about what I think happened on 9-11. I've never mentioned "Mossad" or "Jews" in this thread (or any other in the case of Mosad... don't know about the word "Jew"). I've never ... I am not even sure what "NWO" means. Is that "New World Order"? I've never said that on any thread either.

So basically what we have here is that you are ascribing to me a view entirely without any basis whatsoever, just so you can attack me for having that view. And it appears to be a racist view too, which is probably a breach of the rules of this board, although I certainly do not want your words censored.

So no I am not going to answer this "simple question" any more than when you asked if I had quit beating my wife.

No doubt you will now consider yourself very clever over this and yet I feel other people will take a different view, so we are both very happy I hope, with this exchange so far?
 
Oh, good, we've reached the point where someone soliloquizes to no one about straw men he attributes to his opponents because he can't debate them directly.

So basically this "debate" is currently being held down on one side by a group of people who can't debate, at least not on this topic.

They claim the UN somehow "blessed" the war but when questioned they can't say what they mean by it, but nevertheless remain dogmatic that it happened, and offended when it is pointed out that it didn't happen.
Nope. Para has explicitly claimed and shown that the UN condoned the use of force in stopping Al Qaeda.

They claim the US invasion of Afghanistan was wonderful,
Straw man. Justified is not the same as "wonderful".

but cannot answer a simple question about whether it would be wonderful if their own country was invaded, instead claiming such a question is "loaded".
Because it's based on a straw man.

They have no conception about elementary axioms of ethics, simply denying them, even as they of course use them the same as anyone else.
Projecting much? If Coalition killing civilians = wrong, then Taliban killing civilians = wrong.

It's funny that they are now accusing me of being a 9-11 truther because truthers at least have confidence in their own thinking and use the form of debate and argument and facts to present their case. They don't just call people names and keep saying "that's a lie" or "it's just a fact" or some other ridiculous irrational slogan like this one:
Actually, they do. All the time. You're either with them, one of the sheep, or a shill. Christopher7, for example, has repeatedly claimed the NIST is lying about something he thinks is incorrect, yet he has presented no evidence to prove that it wasn't a simple mistake. When questioned, he just keeps saying it's "obvious" and repeating the assertion.


All this statement does is display an inability to think straight. NATO has killed millions of people in Iraq and Afghanistan.
Citation needed.
Maybe that has something to do with the fact that the people who actually do have this sort of choice don't want to be ruled by a gang of mass murderers?
Mass murderers like the Taliban, who we've already shown murdered lots of people and continue to do so? Also, citation needed.

You still aren't answering the question, I note. If NATO is so bad, it should be easy for you to respond, right?

I will re-write the question and see who can answer it for me shall I?
So you can't even answer your own strawman question.

This whole conversation should be really good for a skeptics board because I think it perfectly demonstrates that so-called skeptics can speak utterly irrationally and dogmatically hold to ideologically informed opinions on things without showing even the slightest hint that they have any self awareness they are doing it....
Said the man who cut out the part of my post informing him he was wrong when he responded.
 
Last edited:
If Saddam Husein had conducted a poll or had one done in Iraq that came out saying everyone was really happy with his rule would you consider that it might be biased? In general do you think any polling done under a military occupation which has been killing people left and right, might be suspicious and prone to bias favouring the occupation?

...
Also, you're dismissing a study that disagrees with you on the grounds it might be biased. Not trying to find out whether it is biased, you're just assuming it is. Look, there's me considering that it might be biased. The study we are discussing might be biased.

Turnabout is fair play; can you consider that it might not be? Can you say "The study might not be biased?"....

...
I don't see that such a statement serves any purpose except possibly to make you feel happier which is not something I am really into sorry. Think about what you are saying. It's like you're saying we should give SOME weight to evidence that could be wholly manipulated and fabricated because... oh well it's 50-50, right? So where would that get us? Every UFO report we'd have to say it was 50-50 chance of being right. Since there's hundreds of them then the odds they are ALL wrong is 2 to the power of hundreds right? Which is billions to one. That's the sort of flawed logic that people use all the time but skeptics are supposed to refute.

Yes the study might not be biased but we can't give that any weight. If we did then every dictator and occupier would be pumping out such polls and saying "My poll deserves to be taken seriously". After all it might not be biased....

Well, looks like I was wrong. You did say it might be biased. After spending an entire paragraph waffling how it's pointless to say so, then you say it might not be biased and then tried to discredit it based on your personal incredulity ("it could be made up!"), instead of any actual facts. Compare that to my declaration, which had much less qualifiers and excuses.

Incidentally, here's a thread from a Truther who uses exactly the same argument. It is essentially his only argument, as the only way he can explain away the masses of evidence for the official story is by saying that it might be made up, therefore it's unreliable. He can't understand why people take offense to him literally ignoring every single piece of evidence they present. Similarly, you just keep doing the same with the evidence we present. It took you how many pages to acknowledge the Taliban was killing civilians?

I mean, you literally said we shouldn't give any consideration to the possibility that the study wasn't biased. That means we can only consider the possibility it was biased. Conveniently, that's your view.
 
Last edited:
I prefer to use it as a demonstration of your frame of mind.
I'm asking you because you said Afghanistan never attacked us, which means you think someone other than al Qaeda, operating from Afghanistan and protected by the Taliban, perpetrated the 9/11 attacks.

Can you answer the question?
 
I'm asking you because you said Afghanistan never attacked us, which means you think someone other than al Qaeda, operating from Afghanistan and protected by the Taliban, perpetrated the 9/11 attacks.

Ooooh.
Tell me more of what I must think.

ETA: that was a sarcastic way of pointing out that your syllogism was faulty in case you didn't get that.
 
Last edited:
Ooooh.
Tell me more of what I must think.

ETA: that was a sarcastic way of pointing out that your syllogism was faulty in case you didn't get that.
Why did you say Afghanistan didn't attack us on 9/11?

Who did David?

Why can't you answer simple questions?
 
when the Taliban were in power, it was possible for a young women to travel safely by bus between towns. Now it isn't.

And why isn't it secure anymore? Because the Taliban are attacking roadways with roadside bombs, suicide attacks and landmines.

You're stuck in a catch-22.
 
Also, Jihad, were roads safe for the Hazara minority under the Taliban rule?

http://www.hazara.net/persecution/mazar.html

This report documents the massacre of civilians and other serious breaches of international humanitarian law committed by the Taliban in Afghanistan in August, 1998. The incident, which occurred in Mazar-i Sharif, a city in northern Afghanistan, represents one of the single worst examples of civilian killings in Afghanistan's twenty-year war where at least 8000 Hazaras were singled out and massacred by the Taliban regime.


And the women Hazaras, were they safe?

Human Rights Watch has also received persistent reports that women and girls, particularly in certain Hazara neighborhoods of Mazar-i Sharif, including Saidabad, Karte Ariana, and Ali Chopan were raped and abducted during the Taliban takeover of the city and that their whereabouts remain unknown.


Is that your idea of security?
 
The topic that began this thread had to do with a soldier going well past three sigmas of abberant behavior and
1) leaving base alone
2) committing murder

The "why we are there" isn't the topic of the thread.

Recent stories in the news indicate that this soldier had a load of issues, none of which IMO excuse murder while assigned to that unit. So, how about some of you fine folks stop with the asinine pissing contest and either return to the topic, or find another thread.

A few points.

I find it singularly odd that at a remote base any soldier leaves the wire alone in a combat environment, or even in quasi-combat environments like the COIN sort of op that is being undertaken in Afghanistan.

A few of the news reports indicate that he left once, killed a few, came back, left base alone again, killed a few more. Or maybe he did it all in one sortie. Not sure I understand the reports.

When President Obama states in all candor that he finds the murder of Afghans to be as serious as the murder of Americans, I find his remarks perfectly in context and perfectly rational. If this guy had been assigned to Fort Hood, had snuck off base alone one night, went into Kileen or Austin, and then killed up to 17 people, is there any question what the general response would have been?

That attitude will likely be taken by the military prosecutor, since what Sergeant Bales did (which he apparently confessed/reported upon his return???) was NOT in the line of duty, nor in accordance with the RoE, nor in compliance with any number of a long litany of standing orders, nor fragmentary orders.

None of that has to do with "should we be there or not," since we are there.
Most (99% I'd say, or more) of the soldiers of any number of NATO nations that are there DON'T pull crap like that.

So, to be clear: this has nothing to do with policy (policy is why we are there) and everything to do with what I see as three basic elements:

1. Someone is either seriously malicious or losing his noggin, and so went on a killing spree
2. A command and control failure (how did a lone soldier leave base in such an environment? Even in peacetime, standard SOP in foreign countries is Buddy System).
3. Chain of command failure: how well do you know your people, and how do you lead them, how disciplined a unit do you run?

Address those, if you can, but leave the "why are we there" crap for another thread.
It's irrelevant to this case, unless we find Sgt Bales defense team raising "he did this to protest us being there" or some such tripe.

Cheers.
 
Last edited:
:blush:

Can I marry you?

There has been no indication of such. She gives every indication of honestly believing what she's saying. Which is somewhat terrifying.

If JihadJane contains her belief system to internet forums things are well enough. That is same with everyone else. Lobbing ideas isn't quite the same as throwing something else.
 
If JihadJane contains her belief system to internet forums things are well enough. That is same with everyone else. Lobbing ideas isn't quite the same as throwing something else.

A rigid, extremist, cartoon reality doesn't contain enough dimensions to allow an accurate assessment of someone else's belief system.

As DavidByron pointed out earlier, my comments re the invasion and occupation of Afghanistan have been moderate. It is not controversial to point out that, for fighters without an air force, suicide bombing is equivalent to firing missiles at, for example, weddings, funerals and emergency responders, from remote-controlled drones.

Noisily focussing, in this thread, on the violence of the Taliban (not to mention name-calling and attempted character assassination of individual posters) is a transparent distraction from looking at the what and why of Robert Bales' alleged violence and what is says about the US "mission" and, on a broader level, about warfare itself as a political instrument and what the US permanent warfare strategy does to its troops.
 
Last edited:
1. The Taliban started it.
2. The NATO response is a legitimate military operation.
3. When NATO forces act badly it's an aberration, not standard practice.
4. The overwhelming majority of casualties are caused by the terrorists and their drug-gang allies.
5. Afghans are better off now than they were under the Taliban and Al-Qaeda.

You don't and can't acknowledge any of those facts because you need to make the Evil Western Empire, a figment of your leftist indoctrinated imagination, look bad.
 
Last edited:
So, to be clear: this has nothing to do with policy (policy is why we are there) and everything to do with what I see as three basic elements:

1. Someone is either seriously malicious or losing his noggin, and so went on a killing spree
2. A command and control failure (how did a lone soldier leave base in such an environment? Even in peacetime, standard SOP in foreign countries is Buddy System).
3. Chain of command failure: how well do you know your people, and how do you lead them, how disciplined a unit do you run?

DR,

Based on the various comments his lawyer has made in the last week or so, I expect that we will never know the truth as to 1.

Regarding 2: Bergdahl walked off his post in 2009. Yes, you will not be able to walk off post in the big-box FOBs, but the smaller ones it is definitely possible. (To my mind, it does demonstrate some premeditation as well.) This was a small camp doing village security operations (SOF types) that SSG Bales was probably attached to. Perimeter security noticed him leaving, but perimeter security was not US or coalition (common at a lot of bases and outposts).

Regarding 3: I am certain that SSG Bales chain of command and NCO chain are under the microscope right now. I don't know how large a slice SSG Bales was a part of. Onesie twosies and detachments are very common in Afghanistan. The SOF he was supporting would not know him that well (although I'm also betting they are being grilled right now too). His chain of command kept in touch, but face-to-faces are difficult due to transportation challenges. Were there indicators or signs, or was this fairly well concealed? I would not be surprised to find out that there were no signs of this, and he was picked for this type of position because he was thought to be experienced and mature. If the allegations about alcohol prove to be true, either his command or the SOF will get smacked for that lax command discipline.
 
None of that has to do with "should we be there or not," since we are there.
Most (99% I'd say, or more) of the soldiers of any number of NATO nations that are there DON'T pull crap like that.

So, to be clear: this has nothing to do with policy (policy is why we are there) and everything to do with what I see as three basic elements:

1. Someone is either seriously malicious or losing his noggin, and so went on a killing spree
2. A command and control failure (how did a lone soldier leave base in such an environment? Even in peacetime, standard SOP in foreign countries is Buddy System).
3. Chain of command failure: how well do you know your people, and how do you lead them, how disciplined a unit do you run?

Address those, if you can, but leave the "why are we there" crap for another thread.
It's irrelevant to this case, unless we find Sgt Bales defense team raising "he did this to protest us being there" or some such tripe.

Cheers.



The journalist, Neil Shea, in the interview I linked to, above, ('Afghan Massacre Sheds Light on Culture of Mania and Aggression in U.S. Troops in Afghanistan') contradicts your assertions and crude expletives.

His observations lead him to state that policy and "why we are there" are very relevant to the extremely strung-out state of foreign troops in Afghanistan after multiple tours and shifting justifications for their presence there. He has observed (since 2006) a build-up of aggression amongst troops:

"Many of these guys seemed like they had reached the end of their rope in terms of stability and controlling their aggression.

...

...I’ve seen soldiers and marines sort of build up through these cycles of aggression, to the point where they start doing—they begin with small things. They’ll insult Iraqis or Afghans behind their backs, and that’s sort of the very mild beginning of it. And then they sort of move up the chain, if we can call it that, into more serious acts of aggression, where they’ll kill animals or they’ll beat somebody or treat them roughly, and it sort of builds up from there.

What I saw with these guys in Afghanistan when I was with them was that several of them had already been through multiple tours in Iraq and Afghanistan, and they had reached a point where they hated Afghans, they hated the country, and they were really not interested in doing any of the hearts and minds stuff anymore that’s a crucial part of the mission. So by the time I reached these guys, they had already been sort of—they had been building up anger and aggression in strange ways for a number of years.

And when I saw them, they had just shot a dog that had been a pet in an Afghan home that they had confiscated during the mission, and they treated Afghan civilians fairly roughly, and they took a few prisoners and treated them very roughly, as well. Nothing that would rise to necessarily the—sort of a crime at that time, but the way that they talked about things and the way that they sort of handled themselves was really aggressive. And it was only—it seemed to me only to be barely kept in check.

So it’s just this small—when we cycle our soldiers and marines through these wars that don’t really have a clear purpose over years and years, I write in the article that we begin—we expect light-switch control over their aggression. We expect to be able to turn them into killers and then turn them back into winners of hearts and minds. And when you do that to a man or a woman over many years, that light-switch control begins to fray. And that’s what I believe I was seeing with these guys in Afghanistan.
"

The whole article is worth reading.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom