How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
OK then. Explain how a virtual commodity is a pyramid scheme.


I didn't say "a virtual commodity" is a pyramid scheme, I said this particular virtual commodity is a pyramid scheme.

Bitcoin is most definitely a pyramid scheme because it was engineered to create a pyramidal hierarchy for the specific purpose of allowing the earliest adopters to easily hoard the false "commodity," and then generate false scarcity so they can cash in when the system gains popular traction.

A very important question: Is it a commodity or is it a currency?

Its creators purport it to be a currency, but it lacks fluidity, stability and other factors necessary for a useful currency, and consequently lacks general acceptance as a currency. Therefore it's only marginally useful as a currency.

Because it has little or no legitimate value as a currency, that lack of real value negates its legitimacy as a commodity. So it's really neither a currency nor a commodity, because it has little to no use as a currency and no value as a commodity.

Whether or not its creators originally intended it as such, for all intents and purposes it's just a scam.
 
Last edited:
I didn't say "a virtual commodity" is a pyramid scheme, I said this particular virtual commodity is a pyramid scheme.
Do you have an example of a virtual commodity that isn't a pyramid scheme? Is there another virtual commodity at all?

Bitcoin is most definitely a pyramid scheme because it was engineered to create a pyramidal hierarchy for the specific purpose of allowing the earliest adopters to easily hoard the false "commodity," and then generate false scarcity so they can cash in when the system gains popular traction.
There are rumours that the founder of bitcoin (whoever he is) is sitting on a large hoard of bitcoins. That is hardly a pyramid and is no different to any other commodity that can be cornered.

A very important question: Is it a commodity or is it a currency?

Its creators purport it to be a currency, but it lacks fluidity, stability and other factors necessary for a useful currency, and consequently lacks general acceptance as a currency. Therefore it's only marginally useful as a currency.
A trivial question really. Bitcoin can be used as a currency but its fixed supply makes it no more useful as a national currency than gold.

Because it has little or no legitimate value as a currency, that lack of real value negates its legitimacy as a commodity. So it's really neither a currency nor a commodity, because it has little to no use as a currency and no value as a commodity.
By your logic, commodities (like gold) are not useful as a currency so commodities have no value as a commodity.

Bitcoin is fungible, easily transported and there is demand for it in the market place. That's the definition of a tradeable commodity.

Whether or not its creators originally intended it as such, for all intents and purposes it's just a scam.
Even the Mt Gox fiasco failed to knock bitcoin out. Naysayers keep saying that bitcoin won't last. I suspect that I can keep posting bitcoin prices long after the last naysayer has given up saying that.
 
After all the discussion,I'm still convinced that the primary purpose is not to create a currency that will be useful or stable in the long term, but to profit from the belief that it might.
 
Do you have an example of a virtual commodity that isn't a pyramid scheme? Is there another virtual commodity at all?


Whether or not something's virtual has no bearing on whether it's a pyramid scheme. I didn't say Bitcoin was a pyramid scheme because it was a virtual commodity. That's a strawman you created yourself.

World of Warcraft gold, magical weapons and other in-game assets are virtual commodities, as are virtual "real estate properties" in Second Life. All those things are "virtual commodities" because they have value and function and can be traded, but none of those things are "pyramid schemes" in and of themselves.

Bitcoin is a pyramid scheme not because it's virtual; it's a pyramid scheme because it was designed and implemented to operate as one.


There are rumours that the founder of bitcoin (whoever he is) is sitting on a large hoard of bitcoins. That is hardly a pyramid and is no different to any other commodity that can be cornered.


Wrong.

Whomever the founder of Bitcoin is, he's sitting on a large hoard of bitcoins because he himself designed and built the system to award himself a large hoard of bitcoins. In other words, he founded a pyramid scheme:

  • The system is designed to award the early adopters a disproportionately huge financial interest in the system without any outlay of cash.
  • The creators of Bitcoin promote it in an idealistic way, so as to appeal to unsophisticated investors and individualistic ideologues. This is very similar to how many other MLMs are marketed.
  • The Bitcoin software is designed to systematically reduce the availability of "coins" over time, in order to make sure the supply can never quite keep up with even moderate rates of demand. By deliberately creating artificial scarcity, the system "pumps" up the perceived valuation of those virtual assets in order to draw money into the system from investors.
  • The early adopters (who paid nothing initially) then reap the benefits of money paid in by successive waves of latecomers.
Bitcoin is a complicated scheme to funnel in money from the new investors at the bottom up to the originators at the top. That's a pyramid scheme.


A very important question: Is it a commodity or is it a currency?

Its creators purport it to be a currency, but it lacks fluidity, stability and other factors necessary for a useful currency, and consequently lacks general acceptance as a currency. Therefore it's only marginally useful as a currency.


A trivial question really. Bitcoin can be used as a currency but its fixed supply makes it no more useful as a national currency than gold.


It's not a trivial question at all. It's an entirely relevant question that directly addresses the fraudulent nature of Bitcoin.

I never argued that Bitcoin is "more useful as a national currency than gold." I've been arguing that it's practically useless as a currency, or for anything else besides fleecing a bunch of suckers.

The supply of bitcoins is not "fixed." Its supply is programmed to maintain a state of artificial scarcity, and therefore a constant state of overvaluation. That is a very bad state for a currency to be in, because a currency in a state of deflation discourages people from actually using it to buy things. Bitcoin is actually far less stable than gold. It has no physical properties either, so unlike gold (or a national currency like the USD) there's absolutely no recourse if it's lost or stolen. It's also extremely unstable and unpredictable, which also makes it practically useless as a real currency.


By your logic, commodities (like gold) are not useful as a currency so commodities have no value as a commodity.


"By my logic"? No.

That's not my "logic" you're invoking. That faulty "logic" is another strawman of your own creation.

Gold is a commodity because it has uses. Gold is used in a number of industries, and is also prized as a precious metal for decorative purposes and the art of jewelry-making. All real commodities have some value based on intrinsic usefulness. Even World of Warcraft gold can be used to gain advantages in the online game.

Bitcoin, on the other hand, is a fake currency with extremely limited acceptance primarily among criminals. Its main purpose is idle gambling by foolish speculators.


Bitcoin is fungible, easily transported and there is demand for it in the market place. That's the definition of a tradeable commodity.


Bitcoin is only "fungible" for extremely limited goods and services online. I'm pretty sure the average person can't even think of a single retailer who accepts Bitcoins as payment. I only know one person who's ever bought anything with them, and even that person admits to being far more interested in them as a theory and an investment opportunity than actually buying anything with them.

The whole idea of an "alternative currency" is completely unnecessary and useless. It's not useful for buying stuff. It has no intrinsic value, so it's not really a commodity. It's unstable and unregulated, and therefore a magnet for unscrupulous con-men and criminals. The level of risk is outrageous, therefore it's a very bad investment product. Just about the only real purpose it serves is a pretense to get people to invest real money so the creators and early adopters can profit.


into it,Even the Mt Gox fiasco failed to knock bitcoin out. Naysayers keep saying that bitcoin won't last. I suspect that I can keep posting bitcoin prices long after the last naysayer has given up saying that.


Yeah, there are still suckers out there buying Liberty Dollars and Phoenix Dollars too. Never underestimate the gullibility of the public.
 
Last edited:
The supply of bitcoins is not "fixed." Its supply is programmed to maintain a state of artificial scarcity, and therefore a constant state of overvaluation.

You made so many false statements in your post but I though I would just point this one out. You clearly do not understand how bitcoins are created.
 
...once they get the interweb, that is.

Read the article, they already have the interweb and they are already using other electronic currencies because transporting loads of cash creates it's own problems. One of the e-currencies they use had their servers crash and no one could make transactions for some time. Bitcoin is decentralized and would not have such a problem.

I don't see why people are whinging about bitcoin being a pyramid. It doesn't matter if someone has hoarded lots of bitcoins as long as I can convert them to cash.
 
I don't see why people are whinging about bitcoin being a pyramid. It doesn't matter if someone has hoarded lots of bitcoins as long as I can convert them to cash.

It matters because hoarders and early adopters have disproportionate control of the market, and therefore control the price.
 
Read the article, they already have the interweb and they are already using other electronic currencies because transporting loads of cash creates it's own problems. One of the e-currencies they use had their servers crash and no one could make transactions for some time. Bitcoin is decentralized and would not have such a problem.

I don't see why people are whinging about bitcoin being a pyramid. It doesn't matter if someone has hoarded lots of bitcoins as long as I can convert them to cash.
Oh you mean like when MtGox and other Bitcoin exchanges crashed/got hacked and 'lost' half of their bitcoin funds?
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitcoin

Read the part of "difficulty".

John Albert is spot on.
No mention of "pyramids" in that wiki. However the "ponzi" aspect is discussed:
Some criticize Bitcoin for being a Ponzi scheme in that it rewards early adopters. While early Bitcoin miners may benefit more than later ones, the returns on their investments do not come at the expense of others participating in the Bitcoin economy.​
Doesn't help John Albert's case at all.
 
Last edited:
No mention of "pyramids" in that wiki. However the "ponzi" aspect is discussed:
Some criticize Bitcoin for being a Ponzi scheme in that it rewards early adopters. While early Bitcoin miners may benefit more than later ones, the returns on their investments do not come at the expense of others participating in the Bitcoin economy.​
Doesn't help John Albert's case at all.


That statement is just plain wrong. (you do realize that anyone can edit Wikipedia, so it's not a reliable source for information on contentious issues.

The simple fact is that the bitcoin miners paid nothing for their bitcoins, and those bitcoins would be worth nothing if it weren't for the people who came later and invested real cash into the system. So the people who paid money are the only ones who directly contributed to the wealth of the early adopters. That's a pyramid scheme.
 
That statement is just plain wrong. (you do realize that anyone can edit Wikipedia, so it's not a reliable source for information on contentious issues.
You are only drawing attention to the reliability of wikipedia because it doesn't support your claim that it is a pyramid as mentioned in post # 750 .

The simple fact is that the bitcoin miners paid nothing for their bitcoins, and those bitcoins would be worth nothing if it weren't for the people who came later and invested real cash into the system. So the people who paid money are the only ones who directly contributed to the wealth of the early adopters. That's a pyramid scheme.
There is no "system" for anybody to put money into. It's just people buying and selling a commodity.
 
You are only drawing attention to the reliability of wikipedia because it doesn't support your claim that it is a pyramid as mentioned in post # 750 .


The fact that the Wikipedia article says it's not a Ponzi scheme and does not use the word "pyramid" proves nothing. It may not be a "Ponzi" scheme, but Bitcoin is most definitely a pyramid scheme.


There is no "system" for anybody to put money into. It's just people buying and selling a commodity.


That's a lie. There is no commodity. Bitcoin is not a resource with intrinsic value, nor is it a company with financial profits. There's no tangible, physical, real-world thing of any value behind Bitcoin, nor is its value recognized, supported, or enforced by any legal authority. It is in fact completely imaginary, built entirely on spurious promises of benefits that have never been realized. The breakdown of its market value amounts to 100% perceived value and 0% intrinsic value.

Bitcoin is in fact a distributed computing system designed to create a fictional commodity. The system is engineered to award the earliest adopters the lion's share of units of that fictional commodity, then exponentially ramp up the difficulty of obtaining new shares to create engineered scarcity.

Extending that system is a loose network of "exchanges" that allows people to "purchase shares" in that fake commodity, thereby generating any and all real-world monetary value that Bitcoins may represent. If it weren't for the latecomers contributing actual money into the system, the entire thing would operate in an economic vacuum and bitcoins would have no market value whatsoever.

Bitcoin is engineered to be a pyramid scheme, and the fact that people have paid actual money into the system makes it a scam. The creators set themselves up as lords of an imaginary empire, with with the early adopters as their vassals. This small pool of (largely anonymous) early "miners" have held vast majority stakes in Bitcoin from the very beginning, and therefore wield complete control over its economy. The pretense of an "alternative currency" is just the come-on that entices people to hand over their real money to buy into shares of that empire.

"Investors" buying in at the bottom are the only factor that contributes all monetary value that the creators and early adopters can take to the bank. There's no real commodity or profitable enterprise at all behind this scheme; everyone with a stake in Bitcoin benefits solely from the influx of in new investors at the bottom. As long as new people keep buying in, those new investors will keep on losing out on "market fluctuations" while the creators and early adopters continually cash in at the top. As long as BTCs are worth anything at all, the early adopters will continue to profit because they paid nothing for their shares in the first place.

No two ways about it, that is a pyramid scheme.

Just because it's being conducted anonymously on a global scale using a distributed computing system on the Internet (and its mechanics are more elaborate than something like the "Airplane Game") that does not diminish the fact that its economic structure is essentially the same as any other pyramid scam. It's a pyramidic economy with its creators (who paid nothing to participate) at the top, enjoying wealth that's being supplied from an ever-changing population of suckers (who contributed all the money) at the bottom.
 
Last edited:
The fact that the Wikipedia article says it's not a Ponzi scheme and does not use the word "pyramid" proves nothing.
I didn't quote the WIKI. If you don't like the WIKI then complain to the person who put up the link.

It may not be a "Ponzi" scheme, but Bitcoin is most definitely a pyramid scheme.
'tisn't! :D

A peerless transfer mechanism doesn't make for a pyramid (or any other "scheme"). There is no pyramid because nobody is being recruited to sell bitcoins. If you sell me some bitcoins then the only person who makes money out of the transaction is you. None of the other bitcoin holders benefit from the transaction.

Bitcoin miners can make a profit purely from the mining activity but this is true of any commodity that is being mined.

That's a lie. There is no commodity. ... <made up nonsense> ...
It might not be a physical commodity but it is definitely real.
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitcoin

Read the part of "difficulty".

John Albert is spot on.

No, he is not. It costs more and more computing power to create bitcoins when there is more computing power attempting to create bitcoins. That doesn't make it a pyramid scheme and that doesn't create "artificial scarcity." Bitcoin is not about being able to mine for bitcoins, it's about anonymous digital transactions. The entire reason for awarding bitcoins to "miners" is to reward them for doing the calculations necessary to process bitcoin transactions. You don't buy bitcoins to make money, you buy them to use in transactions.
 
What is a Pyramid Scheme?

The illegal drug market could properly be described as a pyramid. Those at the top sell large quantities of relatively pure version of the drug to their preferred buyers. These people in turn will subdivide their purchase (and probably cut it with impurities) and on sell these subdivisions to their own buyers at a profit. This process will continue along the pyramid until you find those at the bottom who pay high prices for a small quantity of a largely impure product.

MLMs are a largely codified version of this process. Probably the main difference is that rather than buying/splitting/selling the product, the intermediaries take orders from their customers and collect the product from their suppliers (who also pay the markup) for distribution.

Then there are the pure "ponzi" pyramids where there is no product at all. People buy into these schemes in the hopes that they will eventually move to the head of the pyramid and collect money from the new entrants to the scheme.

If bitcoin were a pyramid then I (as a bottom level entrant) would pay a high premium for the few bitcoins that I purchased. Even then, I would get few bitcoins for my purchase. Mostly what I would be getting from my supplier was IOUs designated in bitcoins.

The fact is that anybody can buy any quantity of bitcoins at the market rate from a bitcoin exchange. Brokerage might make it less profitable to buy smaller quantities of bitcoins but that is not the same as a broker on-selling bitcoins at a profit.
 
Bitcoin is a pyramid scheme not because it's virtual; it's a pyramid scheme because it was designed and implemented to operate as one.
No it isn't. It lacks the "middle levels" of the hierarchy, and the money flow (while strongly favoring early adoptors) isn't hierarchical either. That's very necessary; it's what puts the pyramid in the pyramid scheme.

If anything, bitcoin was designed and implemented as a pump and dump stock scheme. And operated as one, repeatedly.

  • The system is designed to award the early adopters a disproportionately huge financial interest in the system without any outlay of cash.
  • The creators of Bitcoin promote it in an idealistic way, so as to appeal to unsophisticated investors and individualistic ideologues. This is very similar to how many other MLMs are marketed.
  • The Bitcoin software is designed to systematically reduce the availability of "coins" over time, in order to make sure the supply can never quite keep up with even moderate rates of demand. By deliberately creating artificial scarcity, the system "pumps" up the perceived valuation of those virtual assets in order to draw money into the system from investors.
  • The early adopters (who paid nothing initially) then reap the benefits of money paid in by successive waves of latecomers.
The thing I'm noticing is, while all of these criticisms are quite well deserved, none of them are inherent to the tech of crypto currency, just bitcoin's particular implementation of it. Since bitcoin's open source, I'd be curious to hear what you'd think of an alternate currency/virtual-commodity/what-the-hell-ever with the serial numbers filed off and the terrible economics replaced with something more sensible.

To wit:
  • Pick an inflation rate generally considered healthy for economies - 5%, say?
  • Choose a difficulty function that follows Moore's Law so as to constrain mining operations to that rate. It would still be exponentially increasing, but instead of crapping out at 21 million coins or whatever, computers should just barely be able to keep up.
  • Set the initial difficulty rate high, so that early adoptors are essentially just mining the inflation on a larger nonexistent economy. This means real inflation will start out high (though not Zimbabwe high) and asymptotically approach the ideal over time as compound inflation begins to dominate.
  • Call the result tibcoins, or <3coins, or sharecoins or something. It's not bitcoins, just operates on similar platforms.

I think that should address your concerns - there's no initial gold rush of easily hoarded wealth, nor built-in deflation to increase market leverage. Any surge or run of participants only has the effect of shifting the inflation rate relative to Moore's Law, which being exponential, isn't going to move that much. [ETA] Anyone coming late to the game isn't going to be making anyone else richer; whether they buy <3 directly or the equipment to mine their own should make little difference overall.

Thoughts?
 
Last edited:
I'd be curious to hear what you'd think of an alternate currency/virtual-commodity/what-the-hell-ever with the serial numbers filed off and the terrible economics replaced with something more sensible.
The main reason why bitcoin is not suitable as a currency is that there will never be any more than 21 million of them. Instead of the generation rate tapering off like it does, it should have been held constant for 40 years and thereafter, the generation rate should increase so that there is a constant inflation rate of 2.5%.

The other problem with bitcoin is the unfair way it rewards miners who have the most powerful computers. A more equitable system would allocate new currency packages to users at random. (For example, every time somebody spent some of these coins, he could be eligible to receive a currency package).

If a bit currency was ever invented along these lines (and adopted by a country) then it could render checkable bank deposits obsolete so expect the banks to have something to say about that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom