Alright, I understand this. What I was getting at is how energy/performance intensive this secure transaction is? In 2008, Finland had a population of 5.3 million, and roughly two million credit card transactions daily (the per capita ratio is probably higher in USA). If bitcoin is to be thought as an alternative for national currencies, could it handle these transaction rates, and at what cost? Has this been calculated somewhere on the net?
That's an excellent question, that raises some other very important questions.
Considering the following questions might shed even more light on the bigger question of whether Bitcoin was truly engineered to function as a useful currency, or to simply masquerade as one while actually serving as an easily-monopolized bubble economy...
If the plan is for this thing to grow into a useful currency that supports a flourishing economy, then the securing of the transactions ought to be the top priority, correct?
In the Bitcoin model, the main purpose of rewarding "mining" with profits is to provide an incentive for users to voluntarily accept the computational burden of securing the transactions.
In a best-case scenario, Bitcoin's popularity grows, and many millions (or tens, or hundreds of millions) of users start adopting Bitcoin as a currency. With each user making multiple transactions per day, the transaction load will increase exponentially. So in that scenario, one would expect the system to provide greater and greater incentives for more miners to come online and handle the task of processing transactions, right?
But that's not how it works at all. In fact, it works the
exact opposite way. Instead of lowering the "mining difficulty factor" to adjust for increased workload, and to balance the competition among the influx of new miners coming online, the Bitcoin system inexplicably
ramps up the difficulty over time. As time goes on and the thing grows in popularity, while it ought to be making transaction processing easier and easier for miners, it instead burdens the individuals processing transactions with this useless, ever increasing resource drain of solving arbitrary, excessively difficult mathematical problems of no real benefit to the system.
So while the Bitcoin economy should be growing its infrastructure, it instead removes incentives to participate in the infrastructure, and wastes exponentially more and more computational resources of the remaining miners that would be better applied toward processing monetary transactions.
Wouldn't it make more sense to provide
greater incentives for mining as more and more people start trading Bitcoin as a currency? One would certainly think so, if the genuine intention of the creators was to provide a useful currency. Instead, it makes "mining" less and less profitable over time, thus disincentivizing the all-important work of transaction processing when it should be rewarding it.
It's basically engineered to doom itself to failure as a useful currency, by taxing the miners out of existence.
So if the processing of transactions is so unimportant that it can just be pissed away in favor of ever-increasing "mining difficulty", then what's the purpose of "mining difficulty" in the first place?
Obviously, the mining difficulty factor exists for the sole purpose of engineering scarcity, thereby artificially inflating the value of this intrinsically valueless product that doesn't even serve the ostensible purpose for which it was created. Calling Bitcoin a "currency" appears to be a false pretense merely intended to lure investors to it in the first place.
That's why I say it appears to be engineered to operate as an investment bubble, and to be easily manipulated by the anonymous creators and early adopters who awarded themselves controlling shares right from the outset. An ingenious scam. Can you think of any better reason for it to have been set up to function in this way?