How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Are you actually discussing this subject, or are you on auto-nay-say mode ?


By this point I'm getting the impression he's just trolling for argument's sake.

That last post about investing must have been intended as sarcasm.
 
By this point I'm getting the impression he's just trolling for argument's sake.

That last post about investing must have been intended as sarcasm.
Dump too much of anything on the market and the price will collapse long before the sell order is completed. What is sarcastic about that?
 
Of course, but so what? You're still making money and you're still crashing the market.
How are you making money if the price has collapsed? At best you are only going to fill a couple of buy orders at the original price. You won't get anything for the rest of the sale.
 
How are you making money if the price has collapsed? At best you are only going to fill a couple of buy orders at the original price. You won't get anything for the rest of the sale.

That's not how exchanges works. When you place a large enough sell order with a low enough minimum price you fill all the outstanding buy orders, each one at its previously set price point.

You basically vacuum up all the money backing the outstanding buy orders from the exchange and run, leaving behind you a dry carcass and a price that's collapsed to the lowest point you were willing to sell for -- in the case of Bitcoins, probably as close to 0 as make no difference.
 
How are you making money if the price has collapsed? At best you are only going to fill a couple of buy orders at the original price. You won't get anything for the rest of the sale.


When the price has collapsed, that's the time to start buying back in, not selling!

Geez, man, are you really that ignorant about this stuff?

Assuming one already possesses enough market share to effectively influence the entire market, I'd think the best way to maximize returns would be to wait for the price to reach a high water mark, start selling small with a relatively high minimum. Keep repeating with small amounts of shares for as long as you keep recovering the maximum share price, only gradually raising the volume until you find the "sweet spot," ie. the market's current appetite, at which you can hopefully continue to mete out your sales at a steady enough rate to continue to sell high for awhile without causing saturation.

Sooner or later though, the sheer amount of trade volume will cause the price to drop. At that point you can either stop selling and wait for it to rise again, or else dump a large share on the market to precipitate a crash. Once investors see the price beginning to drop, a panic will usually ensue as people try to cash in before the price falls too far. The price will plummet, then you can commence buying back into the market at a far lower price.

It's really not rocket science. The dynamics are simple, provided you have a big enough market share to sway the market.*

The small size of the Bitcoin market and the extreme wealth imbalance is especially problematic because the market is so extremely volatile and transfers are not instantaneous. It can take 10 minutes or more to execute a single transfer of bitcoins, and during that time frame your stock price can lose a significant amount of its value. The crazy dynamics represent a much worse drawback to Bitcoin's usage as a currency. Imagine being a merchant and selling something to a customer paying with bitcoins. The product is worth $100.00 USD, but after the sale goes through you see that the price of BTC has plummeted so much that the payment you just received only amounts to $6.50 USD. You just got reamed out of 93.5% of your sale price just because some douchebag decided to bugger the market for his own personal gain. So now your money is tied up in useless BTC for an indefinite amount of time until the market price creeps back up high enough for you to recover your $100.00 sale price.

Gaming the market like that effectively amounts to ripping people off big time. That's why it's so very illegal in most countries with modern economic systems and publicly traded securities.


*which is impossible for most traders of any real-world currencies and most real-world commodities
 
Last edited:
Dump too much of anything on the market and the price will collapse long before the sell order is completed. What is sarcastic about that?

The fact that I talked specifically about dropping a large enough amount to affect prices but not more. Even if they symply dumped the whole thing, they'd make a small fortune compared to what they invested (zero).
 
Do not edit quotes without making it very clear what you have changed.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Cuddles

I think you guys are naive if you think the market will let you get away with this strategy. Bitcoin buyers might be less savvy than the usual investor but generally, attempts to corner the market end disastrously (Silver Thursday).
 
Last edited by a moderator:
That's not how exchanges works. When you place a large enough sell order with a low enough minimum price you fill all the outstanding buy orders, each one at its previously set price point.

You basically vacuum up all the money backing the outstanding buy orders from the exchange and run, leaving behind you a dry carcass and a price that's collapsed to the lowest point you were willing to sell for -- in the case of Bitcoins, probably as close to 0 as make no difference.
At least you have an idea of the mechanics.

Assuming that the dump pans out as you say, would still get an average price for the sale of something like half of what it was before the dump (still a big profit if you got the bitcoins for nothing but a huge "paper loss").

If you then put in a huge market buy order you are going to hit some limit sell orders with quite a high price. I doubt that you would end up with a profit from this. In fact, I'm sure that a lot of bitcoin holders would make limit sell orders with an exorbitant price just to capitalize on people trying this strategy.

You could try to do this more gradually but I don't think it will have any more success. If you make orders big enough to affect the price of bitcoin then the market will notice and react with hostility. If you make the orders smaller than that then you are no longer "manipulating the price".
 
Last edited:
Otherwise, the GLBSE is closing down.
Apparently the "CEO" took user money to pay for a lawyer relating to an unspecified problem. And is now setting up a system where he will refund the users if they provide personal ID... like pirate, who ran the largest ponzi, did recently.

The bitcointalk forum administrator, "treasurer" of the GLBSE, has opened a thread about the "CEO" in the Scam Accusations section of his board... but said administrator himself is under scrutiny: he tried to dump all his GLBSE shares 10 days ago, and admitted that the pirate "investment" looked very dodgy but since he made money out of it (he entered the ponzi very soon), well, he didn't mind.

Coming up: Will Butterfly Labs -which one of the executive used to ran a mail fraud in the past-, manufacturer of mining rigs, actually deliver on its new ASIC products in time?
 
Hypothetically, if one wanted the price of bitcoins to drop... would it be possible for someone holding a large number of bitcoins to dump them on an exchange and then buy them straight back themselves? Wouldn't the only cost of doing this be the commission of the exchange? You could then hoover up any bitcoins people are foolish enough to panic and sell.

Would this work?
 
Reported.

You are truly desperate, now, if you think changing people's quotes constitutes an argument.

I don't think he intended that to be read as direct quotes, but him paraphrasing what (he thinks) we've said.
 
Isn't the problem with attempts to corner the market something along the lines of such interests not having the resources to maintain their position? In the case of the Silver thing, they'd borrowed heavily in their attempt to corner the silver market. If you could find a way to corner the market for next to nothing, what could stop you? Most of these examples seem to go wrong when somebody is forced to unwind their position and everybody knows they have to sell, so they unwind a huge position at a huge loss. If I had $5million in bitcoin, I don't see that much could happen in the bitcoin market to force me to sell it all, and presumably I'd need a lot less that $5million to be able to manipulate the price.
 
Last edited:
What has any of that got to do with Bitcoin?

The GLBSE is a stock exchange for bitcoin "companies". ASIC computer are destined to mining. The absolute trainwreck of the "community" of the bitcoin actors, as I said, may be the sign of a flaw in the concept itself. Or that it doesn't lend itself well to certain activities.
 
Hypothetically, if one wanted the price of bitcoins to drop... would it be possible for someone holding a large number of bitcoins to dump them on an exchange and then buy them straight back themselves?
I still think you would have the problem I referred to earlier. You don't know how many sell orders have limits of $100 or $1000 or more. The highest sell limit is what you will be paying for the remainder of your purchase.

Isn't the problem with attempts to corner the market something along the lines of such interests not having the resources to maintain their position?
You're right. I was looking for the history of commodities that were successfully cornered but data on that is thin on the ground. What happens after that would probably depend on the nature of the commodity and be not directly applicable to bitcoin.

Since tactics that are illegal in the stockmarket can still be used for bitcoin, I looked up a couple of stockmarket scams. However, it seems that you can't manipulate prices just by using buy and sell orders. Every scam invariably involves putting out false information about the company concerned. It is difficult to put out false information about something that has no utility.

I'm a bit of a noob when it comes to being a criminal myself but it seems to me that any marketing scam involving bitcoin would probably start with rumours of a big buy up or big sell off.
 
Isn't the problem with attempts to corner the market something along the lines of such interests not having the resources to maintain their position?


You're right. I was looking for the history of commodities that were successfully cornered but data on that is thin on the ground. What happens after that would probably depend on the nature of the commodity and be not directly applicable to bitcoin.


The difference is, Bitcoin was obviously designed to be cornered right from the get-go. A small group was allowed to accrue market share exponentially greater than anyone who would ever come after them, so the market was effectively cornered for over a year before the first Bitcoin exchange (Bitcoin Market) even opened.


I looked up a couple of stockmarket scams.


Some of the stories of those scams are really interesting. I remember back in the '90s there was a teenage kid who became a major influence in the AOL financial forums by running pump-and-dump scams. When he was eventually caught, the media described him as a "computer hacker."


However, it seems that you can't manipulate prices just by using buy and sell orders.


Bitcoin is a lot different than the stock market. Even "penny stocks" are largely capitalized by shareholders with a personal interest in the company (besides just the money) who are in for "the long haul." Those kinds of investors add stability. Stocks also have a fundamental value backing them that adds stability and tends to insulate them against sudden major swings. Also with stocks, one does not already possess a huge, dominant majority share from the start before the company ever goes capitalized, as happened for a small number of early adopters with Bitcoin.


Every scam invariably involves putting out false information about the company concerned. It is difficult to put out false information about something that has no utility.


The false information is the disingenuous marketing hype about its utility, about how widely it's accepted, about it being the "revolutionary money of the future," about it being useful for buying illegal contraband anonymously and evading taxes, etc.


I'm a bit of a noob when it comes to being a criminal myself but it seems to me that any marketing scam involving bitcoin would probably start with rumours of a big buy up or big sell off.


From what you posted here, you've already been involved in at least two popular investment scams (Airplane and Bitcoin). But what you seem so reluctant to even consider is how closely Bitcoin itself resembles a number of other historical scams.
 
Last edited:
Bitcoin without exchanges is nothing but a networking protocol. It would lose all value and disappear from the economic landscape overnight if there was suddenly no way to exchange BTC for real money.
Since there is no law requiring anybody to use bitcoin exchanges, I had a look to see if there were any other ways to acquire bitcoins.

Sure enough, you can buy them on ebay using paypal. The price is a lot higher than at Mt Gox and they are only available in small quantities but it is an alternative if you don't trust the exchanges.

From what you posted here, you've already been involved in at least two popular investment scams (Airplane and Bitcoin).
I'm tempted.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom