Peer-reviewed paper shows Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies

Koch's dad founded Heritage Foundation to defend tobacco.
"To" is a statement of intention. Intentions are mental events. Either you (Ben) read minds of dead people or there's some text or recording somewhere in which the elder Koch makes this clear. Do you have any support for this assertion of intention?
 
No, but I think they should be held strictly liable for any damage caused by their product.

If you did this, no industry would exist.

People would have to grow their own.
Depending on the value that juries assigned to human life, they'd have to make their own cars also. They'd have to can their own vegetables. "No industry would exist" is about right.

Including the government industry, responsible for more death than any non-government organization.
 
The research paper, titled ‘To quarterback behind the scenes, third-party efforts’: the tobacco industry and the Tea Party, was published in the journal Tobacco Control, one of the many academic medical journals published by the British Medical Association's publishing group.

I can't access the full text, but color me unimpressed. If their point is simply that the tobacco industry backed small-government, low-tax advocacy groups, well, that's not really news, is it? If their point is that such groups (which have been around for quite a while) supported the tea party, why is that surprising? A group whose interests favor lower taxes and regulations is naturally going to align itself with any such movement. That is to be expected.

If, however, the claim is that the tea party started because of tobacco company support, well, I seriously doubt that, and I seriously doubt the paper has any evidence of that. Tobacco companies are far from the only people who want smaller government, less regulation, and lower taxes. I doubt they did anything more than jump on the bandwagon. And unless you think tobacco companies should have no freedom of speech (in which case, plenty of left-wing political campaigns are suspect too), why is that a problem?
 
I can't access the full text, but color me unimpressed.

So, you haven't even read the paper, but you just know it's wrong somehow?

If, however, the claim is that the tea party started because of tobacco company support, well, I seriously doubt that, and I seriously doubt the paper has any evidence of that. Tobacco companies are far from the only people who want smaller government, less regulation, and lower taxes. I doubt they did anything more than jump on the bandwagon. And unless you think tobacco companies should have no freedom of speech (in which case, plenty of left-wing political campaigns are suspect too), why is that a problem?

No, the conclusion of the paper is that the Tea Party movement isn't a grassroots organization that arose because Americans were unhappy with taxes and regulations and the size of government, but are a top-down astroturfing group sparked and primarily driven by tobacco industry and established right-wing political advocacy organizations.

And if you have problems with the paper's evidence, methodology, or conclusions, I suggest that you too detail your objections in a letter to the journal's editors. Or write your own peer-reviewed paper.
 
Last edited:
So, you haven't even read the paper, but you just know it's wrong somehow?

I am not able to access the full paper. I am therefore commenting on what I can access, namely the abstract. I am certainly not the only person unable to access the full paper (can you?). It is not reasonable for you to demand only criticism from the few who can. If you don't want people to comment who haven't read your sources, then only pick open sources.

No, the conclusion of the paper is that the Tea Party movement isn't a grassroots organization that arose because Americans were unhappy with taxes and regulations and the size of government, but are a top-down astroturfing group sparked and primarily driven by tobacco industry and established right-wing political advocacy organizations.

Nothing in the abstract leads me to believe they have any basis for that conclusion. Everything mentioned by the abstract cannot demonstrate more than a bandwagon effect.

And if you have problems with the paper's evidence, methodology, or conclusions, I suggest that you too detail your objections in a letter to the journal's editors. Or write your own peer-reviewed paper.

Your faith in the peer review process and the authority of a professional medical journal are cute. But they are misplaced, particularly on a topic for which the reviewers are not experts.
 
Last edited:
I am not able to access the full paper.

Sure you can. It's purchasable right at the link in my OP.

It is not reasonable for you to demand only criticism from the few who can. If you don't want people to comment who haven't read your sources, then only pick open sources.

Oh, you're more than welcome to comment all you like about something you haven't read. You just can't have those comments taken seriously, that's all.

Nothing in the abstract leads me to believe they have any basis for that conclusion. Everything mentioned by the abstract cannot demonstrate more than a bandwagon effect.

And yet, without having read the paper, you actually have no idea whatsoever.

Your faith in the peer review process and the authority of a professional medical journal are cute.

That's why I've been suggesting that people write to the editors of the journal with their criticisms. It'd help if you read the paper first, of course.

But they are misplaced, particularly on a topic for which the reviewers are not experts.

The journal Sokal submitted his paper to was not peer-reviewed.
 
Last edited:
No need to purchase it! Just go to your local college library and they will get the paper for you.

That too! That's my own main source, since my city is home to one of the leading biomedical universities in the US, and the research libraries here have copies of pretty much everything medicine-related.

I look forward to your detailed critique of this paper and its problems, Ziggurat.
 
Sure you can. It's purchasable right at the link in my OP.

Have you purchased it? Have you read the whole thing?

The journal Sokal submitted his paper to was not peer-reviewed.

What difference would that have made? Probably none, if the "peer" reviewers had been drawn from the same group as the editors were, as is often the case with professional journals. But what about this journal? It's ostensibly a medical journal, but it's publishing a paper about politics. Are the authors political scientists? No. Are the reviewers political scientists? God only knows.

Hell, the title of the journal itself should have set your skepticism alarm ringing. The journal itself is set up for advocacy of a particular political viewpoint, and explicitly so. So when a paper comes along that flatters that viewpoint, do you honestly think that it will receive the full scrutiny that the term "peer review" is supposed to imply? Don't kid yourself. I doubt this paper is a hoax, and I'm not accusing these people of deliberate fraud. But given the built-in bias that the journal is structurally pre-disposed towards, it's no stretch to suspect that they've over-reached in their interpretation.

But what has been your defense of this paper? An appeal to authority, nothing more. You presented a claim, but you aren't actually backing that claim up.
 
Have you purchased it? Have you read the whole thing?

Why, yes.

What difference would that have made? Probably none, if the "peer" reviewers had been drawn from the same group as the editors were, as is often the case with professional journals. But what about this journal? It's ostensibly a medical journal, but it's publishing a paper about politics. Are the authors political scientists? No. Are the reviewers political scientists? God only knows.

Tobacco Control regularly publishes both medical and social science papers.

Hell, the title of the journal itself should have set your skepticism alarm ringing. The journal itself is set up for advocacy of a particular political viewpoint, and explicitly so.

Doctors do tend to take a dim view of things that impact health, yes.

I hear they're also unreasonably biased against cancer.

I doubt this paper is a hoax, and I'm not accusing these people of deliberate fraud. But given the built-in bias that the journal is structurally pre-disposed towards, it's no stretch to suspect that they've over-reached in their interpretation.

But again, you don't know. All you have to make you doubt this peer-reviewed paper is that it contradicts your political biases.

You presented a claim, but you aren't actually backing that claim up.

The "claims" are in the paper, as is the supporting evidence. Please tell me, in specific detail, what is wrong with those claims.
 
The "claims" are in the paper, as is the supporting evidence.

That's a cop-out. You presented a claim, but you did not present evidence in a way that is accessible to me or most people on this board. You've presented a claim, and then demanded that I go elsewhere to find evidence in support of your claim. But it's your claim, the burden is on you to support it.

Please tell me, in specific detail, what is wrong with those claims.

I've already told you. The existence of financial support by tobacco companies for various advocacy groups is exactly what one would expect from an alternative scenario where tobacco follows existing or otherwise independent political currents. Nothing in the abstract even hints at evidence incompatible with this scenario, and you sure as hell have made no reference to any such evidence.
 
That's a cop-out. You presented a claim, but you did not present evidence in a way that is accessible to me or most people on this board. You've presented a claim, and then demanded that I go elsewhere to find evidence in support of your claim. But it's your claim, the burden is on you to support it.

My sole "claim" is exactly what's in the title of this thread, and it was backed up by providing a link directly to where you may obtain the paper for yourself.

You're certainly free to ignore the paper and never read it for yourself, if you like, but that just makes your attempts at criticism of it hollow and meaningless.

Nothing in the abstract even hints at evidence incompatible with this scenario, and you sure as hell have made no reference to any such evidence.

That would defeat the purpose of an abstract.
 
It would defeat the purpose of an abstract to summarize the best evidence for their conclusion? :confused:

Which it does.

Methods We used the Legacy Tobacco Documents
Library, the Wayback Machine, Google, LexisNexis, the
Center for Media and Democracy and the Center for
Responsive Politics (opensecrets.org) to examine the
tobacco companies’ connections to the Tea Party.

Results Starting in the 1980s, tobacco companies
worked to create the appearance of broad opposition to
tobacco control policies by attempting to create a
grassroots smokers’ rights movement. Simultaneously,
they funded and worked through third-party groups,
such as Citizens for a Sound Economy, the predecessor
of AFP and FreedomWorks, to accomplish their economic
and political agenda. There has been continuity of some
key players, strategies and messages from these groups
to Tea Party organisations. As of 2012, the Tea Party
was beginning to spread internationally.

EDIT: The Introduction to the paper lays out, with footnotes, the exact evidence summarized in the Abstract. Which you'd know if you read the paper.
 
Last edited:
No it doesn't. EVERYTHING in the abstract is consistent with the scenario I described.

No, not really.

The Tea Party, a loosely organised network of grassroots coalitions at local and state levels, is a complex social and political movement to the right of the traditional Republican Party that promotes less government regulation and lower taxes.1–4 It is often characterised as a grassroots movement that spontaneously arose in 2009.4–5 However, it has also been cited as an example of corporate ‘astroturfing,’ 5 defined as a movement that ‘appears to be grassroots, but is either funded, created or conceived by a corporation or industry trade association, political interest group or public relations firm.’6–8 National organisations funded by corporations, particularly Americans for Prosperity (AFP) and FreedomWorks, played an important role in structuring and supporting the Tea Party in the initial stages.5 They provided training, communication and materials for the earliest Tea Party activities, including the first ‘Tea Party’ on 27 February 2009.1 9 FreedomWorks organised the nationwide Tea Party tax protests in April 2009,10 the town hall protests about the proposed healthcare reform in August 20091 and the Taxpayers’ March on Washington the following September 2009.11 They continued to facilitate and support many of the local chapters and leaders that arose from the early events in 2009.5 AFP and FreedomWorks continued to facilitate local Tea Party activities by co-sponsoring rallies,1 12 13 creating talking points and organisational tips for supporters,14 15 supplying literature for local Tea Party groups16 and providing training sessions.1 3 17 FreedomWorks was a founding partner of the 2010 Contract from
America (recalling the Republican Party’s 1994 Contract with America).18
As of 2012, AFP and FreedomWorks were supporting the tobacco companies’ political agenda by mobilising local Tea Party opposition to tobacco taxes and smoke-free laws.19 20 This support for the tobacco companies’ agenda continues the tobacco industry use of AFP and FreedomWorks’ predecessor organisation, Citizens for a Sound Economy (CSE), as a third-party ally since at least 1991 (figure 1). Moreover, starting in the 1980s, major US tobacco companies attempted to manufacture an astroturf citizen ‘smokers’ rights movement’ to oppose local tobacco control policies. These smokers rights’ groups had grassroots membership in several localities, but were created, coordinated and funded by the cigarette companies.21
Although the Tea Party is widely considered to have started in 2009,9 this paper presents a historical study of some of the tobacco companies’ early activities and key players in the evolution of the Tea Party. Many people in the smokers’ rights effort or the tobacco companies went on to Tea Party organisations. Moreover, while the Tea Party started in the USA, it is beginning to spread internationally. 22–26 In 2012 FreedomWorks expanded the movement internationally, training activists in 30 countries, including Israel, Georgia, Japan, Nigeria and Serbia.22 This international expansion makes it likely that Tea Party organisations will be mounting opposition to tobacco control (and other health) policies as they have done in the USA.

I'd quote more, but Rule 4 and all that, you know.
 
No, not really.

So as evidence of what the abstract says, you post text not from the abstract? Yeah, um... that makes no sense. It doesn't support your claim about the abstract at all.

As for whether or not it supports the conclusion of the paper, it follows my suspicions rather closely. It presents evidence that tobacco companies supported advocacy groups which in turn supported the tea party. But the only evidence of the tea party being "astroturf" actually come from other sources (which I can't evaluate without knowing what those sources are). The only thing new this paper seems to contribute is the fact that tobacco was a contributor to these advocacy groups, but that's a big "so what?" Money always follows politics. If you have an influential political movement, then corporations which will benefit from your agenda will donate to you, even if they have nothing to do with the formation of your agenda. If someone has been pushing for small government, less regulation, and lower taxes for a long time, then it's no surprise that they could get support from people who want small government, less regulation, and lower taxes, or that they would join new movements that push for small government, less regulation, and lower taxes.
 
No need to purchase it! Just go to your local college library and they will get the paper for you.
(BenBurch): "Koch's dad founded Heritage Foundation to defend tobacco."
(Malcolm Kirkpatrick): "'To' is a statement of intention. Intentions are mental events. Either you (Ben) read minds of dead people or there's some text or recording somewhere in which the elder Koch makes this clear. Do you have any support for this assertion of intention?"
C'mon. Cite =___?
 
Last edited:
So as evidence of what the abstract says, you post text not from the abstract? Yeah, um... that makes no sense. It doesn't support your claim about the abstract at all.

Except that pretty much everything that was in that text was summarized in the "Results" part of the abstract. Which is the purpose of an abstract.

As for whether or not it supports the conclusion of the paper, it follows my suspicions rather closely.

Yes, we've already established that you've entirely made up your mind about what this paper says without bothering to actually read it.

But the only evidence of the tea party being "astroturf" actually come from other sources (which I can't evaluate without knowing what those sources are).

Thus highlighting the rather large, glaring flaw in your "criticism" of the paper.

If you have an influential political movement, then corporations which will benefit from your agenda will donate to you, even if they have nothing to do with the formation of your agenda. If someone has been pushing for small government, less regulation, and lower taxes for a long time, then it's no surprise that they could get support from people who want small government, less regulation, and lower taxes, or that they would join new movements that push for small government, less regulation, and lower taxes.

So, please, explain how the documents and other sources cited in the paper are just as consistent with your theory there as they are with the paper's conclusions, like you asserted they were.
 
Last edited:
1. What facts have I invented?
2. That depends on the time interval under consideration. According to the British Meterological Office, as I understand the current state of expert opinion, there has been no overall warming in the last fifteen years. It's been up and down since the end of the Younger Dryas. Interglacials vary in duration, around 15 to 30 thousand years. The current one is about 15 thousand years old.
3. Actually, lots of people have called for the end of private property. Read Igor Shafareyevitch, The Socialist Phenomenon, and Norman Cohn, The Pursuit of the Millennium. Additionally, more people apparently envision an end to private property but are reserved about expressing their position.
4. Abstractions don't call for anything. Quite often, advocates for regulation make their case as though there were only benefits and as though disinterested regulators may simply be assumed.

The first question is rather disingenious, since you invented the whole thing.
The second question is purely dodging the entire issue, and denying basic physics. As such, denying basic physics and attempting a diversion is an attack on science and the scientific method, is scientific misconduct, and since the USA was founded on the Enlightenment Movement, an attack on the USA itself.
Inferring that communists are socialists is a very strange thing to do, and attempting to pass off the idea that social supports are eliminating private property is even nuttier. And, of course, denying that there is private property is communism, not socialism. I guess you fell for that one.
Finally, your article forces a false conclusion, so you are absoutely calling for something.

In other words, nice try, no cigar.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom