How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
If it does, a blow will have been struck for chart analysis not being woo.

I want to clarify this a bit. Being correct, or incorrect, after the fact has no bearing on whether a technique is woo. What matters is the methodology used to get the predictions, tempered somewhat by its predictive power. If your methodology has a reasonable basis but it's only right once in a great while, it isn't necessarily woo (though it could be regarded as such if you stubbornly cling to it). Conversely, if you're always eventually proven right but you claim it's because Bigfoot whispers the answers into your ear, well, that's still woo, but it does bear further investigation - maybe he is after all.

Wrs has made a ton of charty predictions in this thread, most of which have been discarded when they failed to come about, but more importantly, in his methodology cause and effect have been switched - he claims it is the market which brings about the changes of the world, not the other way around. But that's an argument for another thread.

To keep this on bitcoin predictions, just for curiosity's sake, I dug up wrs's original prediction to see the state of the charts that led him to it:

Just watching the Mt. Gox ticker I see that bitcoin doesn't sustain very high transaction volume without significant price swings. It's pretty clear to me that each time the price falls, it's driven back up again with incremental buying. This all looks like speculation and to me, that always ends with a collapse of some kind and $150 is just a guess, it may only be $500.

I don't see any chart woo going on here at all, merely a statement of volatility (which we've all been making), a prediction of market collapse and a "guess" at value (with a range approximately equal to anything anyone might claim would be a collapse).

Sure are a lot of charts lines now though.

Finally, just to keep this in perspective, the predictions of psion01 are also correct at this point in time.
 
Someone(s) put a huge pile of money back in between 6 and 7am EST -- 6000+ coins' worth of artificial price increases dragging it back up from $382 to $550, which is where it's piddling around now. I strongly suspect this is from people with a bunch of Bitprofit already made trying to predict the bottom and make a quick buck on the bounce, but it's hard to say. I would be near certain almost none of that money that went 'in' was from fresh depositors though, only from people who've already been playing in Bitcoin.

It would almost have to be; China's not allowing new money and only fools would go through Mt. Gox at this point.
 
I want to clarify this a bit. Being correct, or incorrect, after the fact has no bearing on whether a technique is woo. What matters is the methodology used to get the predictions, tempered somewhat by its predictive power. If your methodology has a reasonable basis but it's only right once in a great while, it isn't necessarily woo (though it could be regarded as such if you stubbornly cling to it). Conversely, if you're always eventually proven right but you claim it's because Bigfoot whispers the answers into your ear, well, that's still woo, but it does bear further investigation - maybe he is after all.

Wrs has made a ton of charty predictions in this thread, most of which have been discarded when they failed to come about, but more importantly, in his methodology cause and effect have been switched - he claims it is the market which brings about the changes of the world, not the other way around. But that's an argument for another thread.

To keep this on bitcoin predictions, just for curiosity's sake, I dug up wrs's original prediction to see the state of the charts that led him to it:



I don't see any chart woo going on here at all, merely a statement of volatility (which we've all been making), a prediction of market collapse and a "guess" at value (with a range approximately equal to anything anyone might claim would be a collapse).

Sure are a lot of charts lines now though.

Finally, just to keep this in perspective, the predictions of psion01 are also correct at this point in time.

This prediction was made a couple of posts later. Was there anything wrong with it?

I would also ask you to provide the basis for what I have highlighted in your statement.
 
Last edited:
By the way, are we counting anything much over $100 as being part of the exponential growth? I had a look at the charts and from what I can see, if the "true" value is based on long term exponential growth, surely we are still way over priced?
I count the last 2 years as part of the exponential growth. When the chart is viewed on a logarithmic scale and the Cyprus bubble and the current bubble are discounted, the price follows pretty much a straight line.

http://bitcoincharts.com/charts/mtgoxUSD#rg730ztgSzm1g10zm2g25zvzl

ETA as for how long the exponential growth can go, that's anybody's guess. So far, bitcoin has been pretty resilient to bitcoin exchange shenanigans but the war by the banks is starting in earnest now. Of course, the exchanges only account for a fraction of the total bitcoins mined and decentralized exchanges will change the picture again.
 
Last edited:
I count the last 2 years as part of the exponential growth. When the chart is viewed on a logarithmic scale and the Cyprus bubble and the current bubble are discounted, the price follows pretty much a straight line.

http://bitcoincharts.com/charts/mtgoxUSD#rg730ztgSzm1g10zm2g25zvzl

ETA as for how long the exponential growth can go, that's anybody's guess. So far, bitcoin has been pretty resilient to bitcoin exchange shenanigans but the war by the banks is starting in earnest now. Of course, the exchanges only account for a fraction of the total bitcoins mined and decentralized exchanges will change the picture again.

Just drawing some lines on that chart shows that the rate of exponential growth in bitcoin price has been increasing. There are several declines that can occur from here that still maintain an exponential rate of increase much lower than the current.

Just curious here, which line do you think makes the most sense?
 

Attachments

  • btclog.jpg
    btclog.jpg
    23.1 KB · Views: 14
Last edited:
I count the last 2 years as part of the exponential growth. When the chart is viewed on a logarithmic scale and the Cyprus bubble and the current bubble are discounted, the price follows pretty much a straight line.
I was going on the past 2 years as well, although I wasn't trying that hard to be precise.

I agree that there are aspects of the past price history of bitcoins that look exponential, but we all know that when the dust has settled the overall shape of the graph won't be exponential. When it will collapse to nothing, stabilize at some non-zero value or something else the arguably exponential past of the graph can't tell you.
 
Surely if the "exponential growth rate is increasing", then it isn't exponential growth?
 
I agree that there are aspects of the past price history of bitcoins that look exponential, but we all know that when the dust has settled the overall shape of the graph won't be exponential. When it will collapse to nothing, stabilize at some non-zero value or something else the arguably exponential past of the graph can't tell you.

When you start the value at "worthless" any increase looks exponential, because any value at all is de facto better than zero. Bitbugs still count the time when a single Bitcoin was worth pennies and draw their trend lines accordingly, because it matches their beliefs; it just doesn't have any practical connection to reality.
 
When you start the value at "worthless" any increase looks exponential, because any value at all is de facto better than zero. Bitbugs still count the time when a single Bitcoin was worth pennies and draw their trend lines accordingly, because it matches their beliefs; it just doesn't have any practical connection to reality.
My plot started at $5/BTC, but basically I agree with you.
 
Wasn't it around $1k when he made the prediction? You would've accepted the statement "Bitcoin will lose half its value by the end of the month" then

Yes, because 500 and 150 are very different.

Here, I predict that BTC will be between 0 and 2000 USD by the end of the day.

The JREF's MDC doesn't try to force applicants to perform beyond what they believe their own abilities are, and yet you're doing so here

What ?
 
Yes, because 500 and 150 are very different.

Here, I predict that BTC will be between 0 and 2000 USD by the end of the day.



What ?

Yes but that isn't a prediction, it's a statement of the obvious. There is no uncertainty and in my prediction, as remirol points out, there was plenty of uncertainty as to the direction and duration of any subsequent move in price.
 
Just curious here, which line do you think makes the most sense?
The top line suggests that the exponential rate of growth increased in January this year but that is probably a distortion caused by the large bubbles we have had this year.

Way back (in October) my post included this chart:
33f6gid.jpg


BTW in spite of what the non-mathematicians will say, exponential growth is significant throughout the 2 years that I am referring to because it is an indication of the percentage gain of your investment/gamble. (If you spent the same amount of money 2 years ago you would simply have bought more bitcoins than you would today).

As to my opinion on how long the exponential growth rate can last, see above.
 
Yes, because 500 and 150 are very different.

Here, I predict that BTC will be between 0 and 2000 USD by the end of the day.

His prediction range can be considered to be "the broad side of a barn". Yours would be comparable to "landing anywhere within sight of the barn". Regardless, it's the prediction you've made, and if BTC happens to end up at 1900 by the end of the day, it's inappropriate for me to say "Yeah, but I was only counting if it was close to 0, those high numbers weren't real."

The MDC does not require claimants to demonstrate abilities they don't claim; if someone claims to be able to project words into others' heads, asking them to send a picture is not a fair test of their claim.

When pressed, he made a formal prediction that covered a wide (but not horribly unreasonable given short-term history) range. You don't get to only pick part of that range and claim that it's only a hit if it matches that part. To be fair, you have to either accept the entire range or ask him to narrow it to a more specific value. He wouldn't narrow it, so that's the prediction we have: between $150 and $500 by the end of the month.

You cannot unilaterally change the criteria for a "hit" just because you don't like the probability of him achieving it. You can consider that particular "hit" to not be sufficiently representative of any particular predictive ability (as I noted above, all he'll have shown is that he can hit the barn IMO; next time you and he can decide on a much smaller range if you'd like), but like your anywhere-within-sight prediction above, it's still a hit; it just isn't a hit that means much.

Reiterating: if anyone had said "BTC will lose half its value by the end of the month", you'd have accepted that as a valid prediction. It's the same prediction as "BTC will be worth $500 or less by the end of the month" -- why do you want to penalize wrs now for shrinking that range to $150-$500?
 
As to my opinion on how long the exponential growth rate can last, see above.
Your graph ends in the past. Are you saying you have no idea whether bitcoin will keep rising, or crash to the floor and stay there before the end of the week?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom