Beelzebuddy
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Jun 10, 2010
- Messages
- 11,009
If it does, a blow will have been struck for chart analysis not being woo.
I want to clarify this a bit. Being correct, or incorrect, after the fact has no bearing on whether a technique is woo. What matters is the methodology used to get the predictions, tempered somewhat by its predictive power. If your methodology has a reasonable basis but it's only right once in a great while, it isn't necessarily woo (though it could be regarded as such if you stubbornly cling to it). Conversely, if you're always eventually proven right but you claim it's because Bigfoot whispers the answers into your ear, well, that's still woo, but it does bear further investigation - maybe he is after all.
Wrs has made a ton of charty predictions in this thread, most of which have been discarded when they failed to come about, but more importantly, in his methodology cause and effect have been switched - he claims it is the market which brings about the changes of the world, not the other way around. But that's an argument for another thread.
To keep this on bitcoin predictions, just for curiosity's sake, I dug up wrs's original prediction to see the state of the charts that led him to it:
Just watching the Mt. Gox ticker I see that bitcoin doesn't sustain very high transaction volume without significant price swings. It's pretty clear to me that each time the price falls, it's driven back up again with incremental buying. This all looks like speculation and to me, that always ends with a collapse of some kind and $150 is just a guess, it may only be $500.
I don't see any chart woo going on here at all, merely a statement of volatility (which we've all been making), a prediction of market collapse and a "guess" at value (with a range approximately equal to anything anyone might claim would be a collapse).
Sure are a lot of charts lines now though.
Finally, just to keep this in perspective, the predictions of psion01 are also correct at this point in time.