Faith leads to evil.

westprog

Philosopher
Joined
Dec 1, 2006
Messages
8,928
Faith leads to evil.

Again this is a spin off from the coddling religion thread. And again I'm seperating it because it's a seperate question which I want to deal with independently.

Let us assume, for the sake of argument, that faith - religious faith - is wrong. That a reasonable person must agree that Jesus, Buddha and Allah can all be classed with IPU and FSM as inherently absurd.

However, we are then left with a secondary contention as expressed by numerous posters on the coddling thread and elsewhere - that religious faith is not only false but evil. People with religious faith behave worse than other people who lack such beliefs, and are likely at any moment to do something truly evil because their beliefs will compel them to do it.

It's certainly true that most of human history consists of terrible things being done in the name of religion. Torture, murder, rape, indeed genocide. All done because someone claimed that it was because God wanted it.

And then we come to the twentieth century...

Around 1900, it was quite feasible to believe that if society could be established along the lines of materialistic humanism, then all that could be avoided. Well, we found out. A society based on an explicitly atheist ideology managed to do worse things in a shorter time than any of the horrors inspired by religion.

So what's the conclusion? Well, I certainly don't think that in a world where religious fanatics fly planes into buildings killing thousands of people, that religion is a panacea. But obviously, neither is atheism. But maybe, just maybe, tolerance is. Acceptance that while I like my beliefs, the other guy should be considered as if his beliefs were of equal value. Or at least of some value.
 
It's certainly true that most of human history consists of terrible things being done in the name of religion. Torture, murder, rape, indeed genocide. All done because someone claimed that it was because God wanted it.

I'm not quite sure it's exactly accurate to assume this about most of human history. I had a political science professor claim that most wars are about resources and land regardless of how they justify the actions they take to get those goals.

I've never come across a good comparative study of wars and reasons yet though to confirm that claim.
 
Last edited:
:"Let us assume, for the sake of argument, that faith - religious faith - is wrong. That a reasonable person must agree that Jesus, Buddha and Allah can all be classed with IPU and FSM as inherently absurd."
.
Faith all by itself has no substance, but many good people pattern their lives on what they have been taught, and act accordingly.
It gives them a set of rules, with a goal other than just blanking out forever.
Faith being an outgrowth of the ethical and moral rules any coherent group develops isn't always mentioned, the reverse idea that faith makes morals is what is preached.
"Atheists can't be good citizens!"
When enhanced with the carrot of eternal life, thinking about what society would be sans faith just never occurs.
It makes a handy cover-up for the actual reasons for aggression, which as noted are economic or political for the most part.
The spectacular brutalities and abject failures of the Crusades are more popular in the public mind than empire expansion for the sake of empire expansion, ala Alexander, or Attila...
Religion is merely about population pacification. A quiescent populace can be depended on to confirm what should be repugnant activities by the leaders, if the leaders can gloss over their criminal intent with pious reasons.
It helped get the current criminal adventure into Iraq going that Iraq was Islamic, for instance, bringing back memories of the Crusades' high-falutin' motives, while covering up the true intent of getting to all that oil.
 
I believe that the notion that it is important or good to have faith is what is evil. It just sets people up to believe anything, without evidence, and feel righteous about doing so.


A person with faith in heaven, for instance, is an easy sucker for any leader that wants people to kill and/or die for his cause. He doesn't have to convince anyone that his cause is worth dying for; only that it is "righteous".

A person with faith in a god is a sucker for any actor that can convince the believer that he's gotten a message direct from god.

A person who gets accustomed to just having faith that some things are true is less likely to look very hard at other unbelievable claims.

A person with faith that god has a plan for his life is more willing to just accept the crap he gets handed, rather than try to change the situation.

The opposite of faith is not atheism. The opposite of faith is critical thinking.

While one might be led to atheism by thinking critically, it is important to not confuse the two.
 
Faith leads to many things. Stupidity, blind assumptions, arrogance, etc.

Does stupidity lead to evil? Assuming we have a working definition of evil, no. Many stupid people are actually quite nice and kind, and many of the monsters of the 20th century were wildly intelligent.

Do blind assumptions lead to evil? Once again, no. We all have a set of assumptions we work with. They can lead to evil, but it's not necessarily the case.

How about arrogance? Sure. I think I'm better than you, therefore I can show you the error of your ways, or kill you to prevent you from spreading your error. Problem is, arrogance is equally apparent among atheists as among theists - there does not appear to be any particular correlation (see: Thaibox... I can't remember the rest without checking my blocked list).


Now lets consider if faith makes people easily lead into evil? An examination of all movements of the 20th century shows that every one of the monsters had their own particular belief system where the ends justified the means - Communism, National Socialism, Japan's imperial system, Pol Pot's Year Zero. In previous centuries that belief system was often religion, though not always. The French Revolution was not particularly religious, yet managed to earn its place on the list.

Any unquestioned belief system is dangerous. Why? It makes you easily led.

The people doing the leading are doing it for personal benefit. Oh, frequently it may have started making things better, but by the end they are in it for themselves. Any questioning of the belief system would quickly reveal glorious leader doesn't believe it.

Of course then the good ones have ways around that (see: Stalin) but it's still an ideology that drives the entire process.
 
Last edited:
I would say poverty makes people more easily led in the last century. It could be by religion, a wacky leader scapegoating another group, or people just wanting to take what does not belong to them, but it usually boils down to poverty or at least the need to have more.
 
What makes you think that, Tailgater?

Basic instinct. On average, most people are still animals. Even without religion, people need a leader or higher whatever. The people who are down need inspiration. Sometimes it is positive or negative. Negative more often because people are gravitated to what is easy. Positive things usually take more effort. That's the simple and easy answer. :D
 
I'm not quite sure it's exactly accurate to assume this about most of human history. I had a political science professor claim that most wars are about resources and land regardless of how they justify the actions they take to get those goals.

I've never come across a good comparative study of wars and reasons yet though to confirm that claim.

And I don't think that the excesses of atheistic regimes were necessarily down to their atheism either. However, in both cases the belief system was used to justify the atrocities, whether or not it was in fact the prime cause.
 
@ Taligater. I cannot agree with this for a number of reasons but it will take me a little time to sort them out I think. Off the top of my head I will say:

1. There are some people who would argue that religion and other ideological positions are largely developed and propagated by those with at least some power. For example, I Ratatant said, about 4 posts ago "Religion is merely about population pacification."

2. I have read that the main supporters of such movements as National Socialism were the middle classes: and this fits with what seems to be my own experience. There are many possible reasons for this but it does not suggest that the poor are the more easily led

3. I do not think that many wars or many revolutions are led by the truly poor. They don't have time.

4. I do not know what you mean when you say most people are still animals. In the trivial sense we are all animals: in the philsophical sense I do not agree and I wonder what you would bring forward in support of the statement.

5. Why do you think, if you do think, that only people who are down need inspiration? Is it only the poor who buy art or go to the opera? Or do you not think these things are inspirational?

6 Why do you think that world wars are easy?
 
Last edited:
I don't think faith necessarily leads to evil, though as you point out, it certainly can do.

And it is fair to point out that it can also lead to doing good.

The slave trade was carried out by Christians. Opposition to the slave trade was largely a Christian endeavour.
 
Again this is a spin off from the coddling religion thread. And again I'm seperating it because it's a seperate question which I want to deal with independently.

Let us assume, for the sake of argument, that faith - religious faith - is wrong. That a reasonable person must agree that Jesus, Buddha and Allah can all be classed with IPU and FSM as inherently absurd.

However, we are then left with a secondary contention as expressed by numerous posters on the coddling thread and elsewhere - that religious faith is not only false but evil. People with religious faith behave worse than other people who lack such beliefs, and are likely at any moment to do something truly evil because their beliefs will compel them to do it.

It's certainly true that most of human history consists of terrible things being done in the name of religion. Torture, murder, rape, indeed genocide. All done because someone claimed that it was because God wanted it.
Too general. Faith can lead to evil, but so can a lot of other things, even love in some instances.

And then we come to the twentieth century...

Around 1900, it was quite feasible to believe that if society could be established along the lines of materialistic humanism, then all that could be avoided. Well, we found out. A society based on an explicitly atheist ideology managed to do worse things in a shorter time than any of the horrors inspired by religion.

So what's the conclusion? Well, I certainly don't think that in a world where religious fanatics fly planes into buildings killing thousands of people, that religion is a panacea. But obviously, neither is atheism. But maybe, just maybe, tolerance is. Acceptance that while I like my beliefs, the other guy should be considered as if his beliefs were of equal value. Or at least of some value.
The societies that you are referring to were not based on atheist ideology. They were based on a specific type of Communist ideology. This ideology, for virtually all practical social purposes, simply established a religion of the State. Different name, same purpose and result. There are plenty of examples of highly secular nations that are quite peaceful in which the citizens are free and prosperous.
 
@ Taligater. I cannot agree with this for a number of reasons but it will take me a little time to sort them out I think. Off the top of my head I will say:

Ya, can of worms from hell it is.

1. There are some people who would argue that religion and other ideological positions are largely developed and propagated by those with at least some power. For example, I Ratatant said, about 4 posts ago "Religion is merely about population pacification."

True, but why do they have the power and what is the power they have over others? Is it based on material possessions? Food? The promise of a better life?

2. I have read that the main supporters of such movements as National Socialism were the middle classes: and this fits with what seems to be my own experience. There are many possible reasons for this but it does not suggest that the poor are the more easily led

Ah, but who judges who is in poverty? Have you ever met a person in your life that told you they have too much? I meet people all the time who make six figures and say they are broke. I'm so broke I just can't take that vacation to Cabo this year.:( Everyone above them is where they should be and they will listen to anyone who tells them they can be too. People in the US have it better than most of the world, even at the US poverty line. What do we hear at election time? We are all bad off and the politicians will make everyone better off by making things fair. Destroy the rich.

3. I do not think that many wars or many revolutions are led by the truly poor. They don't have time.

I don't understand what you mean here?

4. I do not know what you mean when you say most people are still animals. In the trivial sense we are all animals: in the philsophical sense I do not agree and I wonder what you would bring forward in support of the statement.

Ok, true. Some are just more domesticated?

5. Why do you think, if you do think, that only people who are down need inspiration? Is it only the poor who buy art or go to the opera? Or do you not think these things are inspirational?

Maybe I needed to be more clear. Not inspirational like art. Maybe hope is a better word, and yet not even hope. Some leaders control through poverty itself and not hope. From Hitlers Germany and Saddams Iraq there is scapegoating, hope, nationalistic inspiration, fear, etc, all negative and positive depending on where your standing and all come down to poverty, lack of education, communication, propoganda, envy, greed. Add that people need to rise up in position or status.

6 Why do you think that world wars are easy?

All of the above and more.:(
 
Last edited:
And it is fair to point out that it can also lead to doing good.

The slave trade was carried out by Christians. Opposition to the slave trade was largely a Christian endeavour.


They were christians, but was it their christianity that motivated them? I am unaware of any part of the Bible that condemns slavery.
 
Around 1900, it was quite feasible to believe that if society could be established along the lines of materialistic humanism, then all that could be avoided. Well, we found out. A society based on an explicitly atheist ideology managed to do worse things in a shorter time than any of the horrors inspired by religion.

Um, not really, because no society has been established along the lines of materialistic humanism. Unless you count the secular societies in the west that have developed in the last 50 years or so... which so far have done a better job avoiding evil than anything else in history...

To be fair, though, no society has been established along the lines of true theism, either.

In both cases, it is a mass of people that want to do good, or think they are doing good, who try to follow very lofty and admirable principles, but who are manipulated and mislead by their leaders.

Perhaps what we really need is an ideology that stresses individuality and individual thinking, rather than following leadership?
 
I don't feel that faith - in a religion, in your country, in authority, whatever - in and of itself is evil. The trouble is how easily it can be exploited by the unscrupulous.

GreyICE said it best:

GreyICE said:
Any unquestioned belief system is dangerous. Why? It makes you easily led.
 
The societies that you are referring to were not based on atheist ideology. They were based on a specific type of Communist ideology. This ideology, for virtually all practical social purposes, simply established a religion of the State. Different name, same purpose and result. There are plenty of examples of highly secular nations that are quite peaceful in which the citizens are free and prosperous.

Communist ideology is based very specifically on a philosophy of materialistic humanism. It's a specific Marxist version of humanism, but that's what it is.

I suppose that it's possible to claim that a different version of humanism would work differently. Well, that cuts both ways.

I'm not aware of other societies which are explicitly secular in the same way as in the communist bloc. I'd be interested to hear of the examples. However, my contention was never that atheism results in inevitable disaster.
 
Communist ideology is based very specifically on a philosophy of materialistic humanism. It's a specific Marxist version of humanism, but that's what it is.

I suppose that it's possible to claim that a different version of humanism would work differently. Well, that cuts both ways.

I'm not aware of other societies which are explicitly secular in the same way as in the communist bloc. I'd be interested to hear of the examples. However, my contention was never that atheism results in inevitable disaster.

You're committing a fallacy of composition regardless. Atheism is a minor component of communism, and of other belief systems such as materialistic humanism, Eastern philosophies such as Buddhism, and cults such as Raelism. You cannot equate atheism with the ideologies it is a part of. It's impossible to do anything "in the name of" atheism, or even to found a state "in the name of" atheism. Your argument makes as much sense as if you were to blame Hitler's mustache for the Holocaust.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom