Split Thread USA Gun control/regulation

The US could never do things half-way: one day, when there is an actual will to reduce the number of gun deaths, the US will have to implement much harsher gun restrictions than most European countries currently have to achieve the same effect.

If you kept the current US society and just took the guns away you'd likely end up with a society with many more stabbings, vehicular attacks, improvised weapons attacks and such. It would be a step up from the gun violence - it's easier to kill people with a gun than with a hammer - but the situation would still be quite bad. Furthermore achieving this is next to impossible, given that the country is awash with guns.

The proper way to address the issue is to examine the causes why the US culture is so violent. I don't know what causes it, gun ownership may well contribute to it, but it's clear that it's not the only, or even main cause. Figuring out what the other causes are and addressing them should come before gun control.

Why? Gun control is next to impossible to achieve in USA and given the current availability of guns and is unlikely to improve the situation in anytihng less than a generation ... a generation during which the legislation could well change, with the somewhat valid reason "see, your way didn't fix anything". It's a high hanging fruit that isn't even particularily sweet to begin with. It's best to start elsewhere and revisit the issue when you addressed the parts of the problem that don't need the political capital of several generations to fix.

McHrozni
 
If you kept the current US society and just took the guns away you'd likely end up with a society with many more stabbings, vehicular attacks, improvised weapons attacks and such.

I'm not sure that's true. I've not got time to look now, but I've seen multiple sources that lay out various factors that people say are likely causes of the much larger gun violence in the US than in other first world nations - from the reasonable-sounding such as economic factors, to the silly such as prevalence of computer games - and the only factor in which the US stands out is number of guns per capita.

From the data I've seen, the US is not a more violent nation than other first world nations, it's just that more people have access to more guns so that when people do turn violent it's more likely to be fatal, and to affect more people.
 
If you kept the current US society and just took the guns away you'd likely end up with a society with many more stabbings, vehicular attacks, improvised weapons attacks and such. It would be a step up from the gun violence - it's easier to kill people with a gun than with a hammer - but the situation would still be quite bad.

That is very probably wrong.
For starters, chance of survival from a stab-wound is way, way higher than from gunshots. With no guarantee that your victim dies, violence brings extra risk. And bloodstains are noncontroversial evidence.
Secondly, it is way harder, psychologically, to get that close to a person to kill them: TV violence makes guns look nice and clinically clean, stabbing or smashing someone is messy.
But most importantly, the police would have the edge of firepower again, making it much less likely that they would be killed or that officers would feel so threaten that they would shoot people who are most likely not armed.
 
I'm not sure that's true. I've not got time to look now, but I've seen multiple sources that lay out various factors that people say are likely causes of the much larger gun violence in the US than in other first world nations - from the reasonable-sounding such as economic factors, to the silly such as prevalence of computer games - and the only factor in which the US stands out is number of guns per capita.

My only response to this is to find better sources.

US stands out of developed nations for:

- unusually high GINI index
- dysfunctional heathcare system
- unusually expensive schooling system
- weak social security system
- much more heavily polarized society (though some places are coming close)
- racial nonhomogenity

And these are just the ones I can name off the top of my head, mind you. At least the first four of those above are fixable with known solutions existing and only one is unsolvable (the last one, obviously). These four should be targeted first, I think.

From the data I've seen, the US is not a more violent nation than other first world nations, it's just that more people have access to more guns so that when people do turn violent it's more likely to be fatal, and to affect more people.

This explains a part of the difference, yes.

And yet, gun ownership stands out in Canada, Switzerland, Serbia and Czech republic too, yet none of those come close to USA and don't stand out with their gun deaths from their peer groups. If this was all to it you'd expect a clear correlation between the number of deaths and how widespread gun ownership is.

Don't get me wrong, USA is an outlier in gun ownership and that is a part of the problem. However it's only a part of the problem and, in all likelyhood, the part which is by far the most difficult to solve. Even if it's the largest single contributor it still makes good sense to pick the lower hanging fruit first.

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
My only response to this is to find better sources.

US stands out of developed nations for:

- unusually high GINI index
- dysfunctional heathcare system
- unusually expensive schooling system
- weak social security system
- much more heavily polarized society (some places are coming close)
- racial nonhomogenity

The first is true (and I thank you for bringing it up, as I'd forgotten that there's a strong correlation between GINI coefficient and gun deaths per capita), but I'd like to see some quantification of the others and how, for example, a "dysfunctional healthcare system" leads to gun violence.

If this was all to it you'd expect a clear correlation between the number of deaths and how widespread gun ownership is.

There is. Look at points 5, 6 & 8 in this article. Point 5 - correlation between the percentage of people in a state who own guns and the number of gun deaths per capita. Point 6 - correlation between guns per capita and gun-related deaths per 100 capita. Point 8 - correlation between the strictness of gun control laws in various states and the number of gun-related fatalities.

Point 7 also seems relevant to the general thrust of your argument - the US does not have either more crime nor more violent crime than comparable nations. The UK has more of both. What the US has is more fatalities from violent crime, because it has more guns.
 
The first is true (and I thank you for bringing it up, as I'd forgotten that there's a strong correlation between GINI coefficient and gun deaths per capita), but I'd like to see some quantification of the others and how, for example, a "dysfunctional healthcare system" leads to gun violence.

At a minimum? People with mental illnesses are less likely to seek or recieve treatment. Some people with untreated mental illnesses are going to become violent. This doesn't mean every shooter is mentally ill, but some are. It also doesn't mean every mentaly ill person in a country with a functional healthcare system will be treated, but more will than in the US, leading to a drop in the number of mentally ill people going postal.

The other factor is costs. Healthcare in US can bankrupt you, but people in other developed countries know that if their health declines, they have options that will not leave them or their dependents destitute. This leads to reduced levels of stress overall - even among healthy people - and reduces the likelyhood of people breaking from overall stress from all factors.

The other two - schooling and social security - also work in a similar fashion. They're also two important reasons in why GINI index in US is so high. All six factors are interconnected and strengthen each other. By itself I doubt any of them would be particularily important, however when combined, they explain much of the violence prevalent in the US.

There is. Look at points 5, 6 & 8 in this article. Point 5 - correlation between the percentage of people in a state who own guns and the number of gun deaths per capita. Point 6 - correlation between guns per capita and gun-related deaths per 100 capita. Point 8 - correlation between the strictness of gun control laws in various states and the number of gun-related fatalities.

New Zealand and Australia have about 1 gun per 5 inhabitants and has one of the lowest gun death rates on the list. Germany and Autria have 1 gun per 3 inhabitants and their gun death rates are just as low.

Belgium and Luxembourg have about 20% fewer guns per capita and have one of the higest gun death rates on the list.

Gun death rates from the article, gun ownership from wikipedia:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estimated_number_of_guns_per_capita_by_country

If you're going to make an argument about how gun ownership rates are supposed to correlate with gun deaths at least half of the cited list are outliers. Not merely "don't fall neatly with the theory", but outright outliers.
On the other hand if there are significant cultural or other aspects too you can also notice outliers come from countries that are similar to each other, they can be paired in a logical fashion: Belgium and Luxembourg; Austria and Germany; Australia and New Zealand. It's not Germany and Australia and Austria and New Zealand, I sincierly doubt this is a coincidence.

Point 6, I'd like to see the R2 value of the correlation. Just because you can draw a line through a few points it doesn't mean there is a correlation, it looks more like fairly random noise to me. If you take USA out of equation and draw a straight line what do you get? If the correlation is causal you should get something similar, but given how the other points look I very much doubt that's the case.

Granted, IF gun ownership was the only significant difference between USA and other studied countries it would still be persuasive, but it isn't the sole factor.

The map on point 8 seems to indicate that there are more gun deaths in the US states that have less than 1 (i.e. 0) gun laws to protect children in place. They correlate the statistic with the number of deaths due to injury (presumably accidental) by firearm. At the very least they should tell us how many laws in question are in place in each state and how many of those injured are children. Presumably laws that protect children do little to protect adults.

Point 7 also seems relevant to the general thrust of your argument - the US does not have either more crime nor more violent crime than comparable nations. The UK has more of both. What the US has is more fatalities from violent crime, because it has more guns.

The statistic cited is inappropriate for the problem analyzed: percent of population who are victims of crime at least once a year. For this statistic to work crime must be spread out equally in all observed countries. For example, none of the observed countries should have a marginalized minority that is more commonly a victim of a crime. Comparing USA and Japan or just about any other country on the list with this statistic is going to be problematic, to put it mildly.

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
The statistic cited is inappropriate for the problem analyzed: percent of population who are victims of crime at least once a year. For this statistic to work crime must be spread out equally in all observed countries. For example, none of the observed countries should have a marginalized minority that is more commonly a victim of a crime. Comparing USA and Japan or just about any other country on the list with this statistic is going to be problematic, to put it mildly.
I don't think this means what you think it means. The survey question would be, "Have you been a victim of crime at least once in the past year?" Yes/No.

You're saying the question would be, "Are you a victim of crime at least once per year?" Yes/No. Or, "How many times each year are you victimized by crimes?"

The title at the top is "12-month prevalence rates for 11 index-crimes"
The vertical axis is labeled "Percent victims of crime at least once in year"

Are marginalized minorities disproportionately saying they've been a victim of crime in the past year? Probably, but that just gets folded into the overall national statistic. Overall, Australians are more likely to report being victimized in the past year than Americans are. I see this as apples-to-apples, without introducing a category of people who are chronically victimized once a year or more.

Those stats are from 2000, a little dated anyway.

Wow. The U.S. Department of Justice reports that about 60 percent of all adult firearm deaths are suicides. I had no idea it was that high.
 
I don't think this means what you think it means. The survey question would be, "Have you been a victim of crime at least once in the past year?" Yes/No.

You're saying the question would be, "Are you a victim of crime at least once per year?" Yes/No. Or, "How many times each year are you victimized by crimes?"

The title at the top is "12-month prevalence rates for 11 index-crimes"
The vertical axis is labeled "Percent victims of crime at least once in year"

The proper statistic to cite in this case would be number of violent crimes per X number of people per year. USA doesn't do too poorly there, but it's not something to be proud of.

This is what I could find, rapes per million of people:

http://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/stats/Crime/Violent-crime/Rapes-per-million-people#-amount

Australia is worse, New Zealand comparible, France and Germany significantly better, Canada is way down on the list.

There are clearly factors other than gun ownership that shape a countries' crime profile.

Are marginalized minorities disproportionately saying they've been a victim of crime in the past year?

No, a marginalized minority is disproportionally a victim of a crime several times per year. In the cited statistic it doesn't matter if you got mugged once in the past year or once a week in the past year. You can compare Japan and Poland in this way I suppose, as neither has a large, disfrenchised ethnic or economic minority that would be a victim of several crimes per year more often than the general population, but USA does and the statistic itself is a poor choice.

Those stats are from 2000, a little dated anyway.

It's notable that the murder rate collapsed, halved since 1993 without an appreciatable drop in gun ownership rates. Lead exposure is a decent explanation, there is a causal mechanism which could explain it (lead lowers intellect and leads higher rates of violence) and the drop correlates with the drop in lead exposure quite well. However this, if true, also shows how factors other than gun control could also be highly relevant and should not be ignored.

Wow. The U.S. Department of Justice reports that about 60 percent of all adult firearm deaths are suicides. I had no idea it was that high.

There are good, sound reasons for implementing gun control in the US. There are also even better reasons to focus on other aspects of the problem for the time being.

You see, the argument "if you make guns illegal only the bad guys will have guns" is not outright wrong. Any gun control will by definition make a change with law-abiding citizens first, it will take time for the law enforcement to chase down the (tens of) millions of guns that are used in crimes or will be stowed away to be used for future crimes. I estimate it would take at least five years to make a significant dent in illegal guns and change the patterns of crimes, ten to make the country an unequivocally better place. It's a worthwhile invesment, but consider that there are at least two elections during the first five years, one of which will be presidential. Consider also that the impressions during those first five years would last far into the period where the state is genuinely better off.

If gun control is to be useful it must be maintained. Yet if you were to shove it down the US throats you'd let the crazies have an easy win in under two years simply by promising to do away with "taking guns away from law-abiding citizens and giving it to criminals". Yes, I know it's a lie, do you think they'd mind?

The time is not right, it's nowhere near right. US culture must change first, gun control will have to follow. You don't have to like it, it's still a fact. Picking a fight you lose even when you win is not the way you can do anything useful.

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
You see, the argument "if you make guns illegal only the bad guys will have guns" is not outright wrong.

Increase in gun regulation leads to decrease in gun-related deaths.

I estimate it would take at least five years to make a significant dent in illegal guns and change the patterns of crimes, ten to make the country an unequivocally better place.

How long do you estimate it will take to get rid of economic inequality?

The time is not right, it's nowhere near right. US culture must change first, gun control will have to follow.

As per a poll conducted in February, 70% of US adults back stricter gun control. How high does that figure need to be before the time is right?
 
Increase in gun regulation leads to decrease in gun-related deaths.

Yes, yes ... not what I was talking about though.

How long do you estimate it will take to get rid of economic inequality?

Get rid of it? Until the end of time.

A more realistic and useful goal would be to get GINI to around 35 (currently it's about 42), which can be done in under a decade, but if you take two that's still fine. EU has GINI in the 25-30 range, with some dipping below to 22, USA had GINI of 35 in 1979 so it's an achievable goal.

As per a poll conducted in February, 70% of US adults back stricter gun control. How high does that figure need to be before the time is right?

First of all, any poll on the matter in the wake of a shooting is going to be slanted in a way you don't want it to slant.

Second of all, how many of those who back "stricter gun control" back "a complete ban on all firearms"? Because >90% of gun crimes aren't by assault rifles or derivates but by handguns who don't even register on the gun control radar. Doing a half-assed job on gun control is even worse than not doing it at all, if it's controversial and won't do anything the first effect will be a t-rex sized bite in your backside come next election cycle or two and second, it won't even do anything to begin with.

Note, I'm not saying a complete ban on all firearms would be a bad thing per se, I'm saying it's about as realistic as solving gun violence through teaching everyone to be nice to each other. Worse probably, because a partial success on the latter still improves society, a partial success on gun control can be worse than useless.

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
Yes, yes ... not what I was talking about though.

It's what's relevant though, right?

As for the rest of it, surely you can see that you're not treating things equally if you're arguing on the one hand for a slight reduction in economic inequality as being a great step forwards, while on the other hand claiming that only a complete ban on all guns is good enough and that nothing should be done to gun laws until that's feasible?
 
Will any of you please self-report and have this derail removed to an appropriate thread? Thanks.
 
It's what's relevant though, right?

It's one of the things that are relevant, sure. It's hardly the only factor.

As for the rest of it, surely you can see that you're not treating things equally if you're arguing on the one hand for a slight reduction in economic inequality as being a great step forwards, while on the other hand claiming that only a complete ban on all guns is good enough and that nothing should be done to gun laws until that's feasible?

7 point drop in GINI is not "slight", it's a significant change.

Furthermore, if you want to make a dent in gun deaths you absolutely must ban those guns that cause the overwhelming majority of gun deaths. Or at least you should explain how would a ban on assault rifle derivates reduce the number of deaths by handgun.

In 2016 for each homicide by rifle or shotgun combined there were ten deaths by a handgun. So yeah, if you want to significantly reduce gun violence controling rifles, shotguns, assault rifle derivates and 40 mm Bofors are going to be background noise.

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipe...yweapon.svg/846px-Ushomicidesbyweapon.svg.png

Even a marginal reduction of income inequality could concievably do more even in the homicide department than gun legislation that doesn't significantly curb handguns.

McHrozni
 
Will any of you please self-report and have this derail removed to an appropriate thread? Thanks.

I think it's quite relevant, actually. Win the Congress and the Presidency, enact strict gun regulation and you have three terms of Trump-like clowns in the White House.

McHrozni
 
I think it's quite relevant, actually. Win the Congress and the Presidency, enact strict gun regulation and you have three terms of Trump-like clowns in the White House.

McHrozni

I don't think so, provided the Democrats manage to halt GOP voter surpression efforts and fix the unequal electoral college. Let's face it, the only way the GOP can win is if they fix the vote and rely on an outdated and deeply unfair system.
Remove those, and the GOP is left with two efforts; move away from extremism or perish.

And anyone who votes on gun issues vote GOP anyway.
 
Last edited:
I would say that reducing deaths is the only thing that matters WRT guns.

If you think this is a witty - or even relevant - reply I would say you need to read and re-read my argument over and over again until you understand the point I was making.

McHrozni
 
If you think this is a witty - or even relevant - reply I would say you need to read and re-read my argument over and over again until you understand the point I was making.

It's not witty, and nor is it trying to be, but it is relevant.

But, yes, I think the two of us have been talking past each other for a while.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom