The first is true (and I thank you for bringing it up, as I'd forgotten that there's a strong correlation between GINI coefficient and gun deaths per capita), but I'd like to see some quantification of the others and how, for example, a "dysfunctional healthcare system" leads to gun violence.
At a minimum? People with mental illnesses are less likely to seek or recieve treatment. Some people with untreated mental illnesses are going to become violent. This doesn't mean every shooter is mentally ill, but some are. It also doesn't mean every mentaly ill person in a country with a functional healthcare system will be treated, but more will than in the US, leading to a drop in the number of mentally ill people going postal.
The other factor is costs. Healthcare in US can bankrupt you, but people in other developed countries know that if their health declines, they have options that will not leave them or their dependents destitute. This leads to reduced levels of stress overall - even among healthy people - and reduces the likelyhood of people breaking from overall stress from all factors.
The other two - schooling and social security - also work in a similar fashion. They're also two important reasons in why GINI index in US is so high. All six factors are interconnected and strengthen each other. By itself I doubt any of them would be particularily important, however when combined, they explain much of the violence prevalent in the US.
There is. Look at points 5, 6 & 8 in
this article. Point 5 - correlation between the percentage of people in a state who own guns and the number of gun deaths per capita. Point 6 - correlation between guns per capita and gun-related deaths per 100 capita. Point 8 - correlation between the strictness of gun control laws in various states and the number of gun-related fatalities.
New Zealand and Australia have about 1 gun per 5 inhabitants and has one of the lowest gun death rates on the list. Germany and Autria have 1 gun per 3 inhabitants and their gun death rates are just as low.
Belgium and Luxembourg have about 20% fewer guns per capita and have one of the higest gun death rates on the list.
Gun death rates from the article, gun ownership from wikipedia:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estimated_number_of_guns_per_capita_by_country
If you're going to make an argument about how gun ownership rates are supposed to correlate with gun deaths at least half of the cited list are outliers. Not merely "don't fall neatly with the theory", but outright outliers.
On the other hand if there are significant cultural or other aspects too you can also notice outliers come from countries that are similar to each other, they can be paired in a logical fashion: Belgium and Luxembourg; Austria and Germany; Australia and New Zealand. It's not Germany and Australia and Austria and New Zealand, I sincierly doubt this is a coincidence.
Point 6, I'd like to see the R
2 value of the correlation. Just because you can draw a line through a few points it doesn't mean there is a correlation, it looks more like fairly random noise to me. If you take USA out of equation and draw a straight line what do you get? If the correlation is causal you should get something similar, but given how the other points look I very much doubt that's the case.
Granted, IF gun ownership was the only significant difference between USA and other studied countries it would still be persuasive, but it isn't the sole factor.
The map on point 8 seems to indicate that there are more gun deaths in the US states that have less than 1 (i.e. 0) gun laws to protect children in place. They correlate the statistic with the number of deaths due to injury (presumably accidental) by firearm. At the very least they should tell us how many laws in question are in place in each state and how many of those injured are children. Presumably laws that protect children do little to protect adults.
Point 7 also seems relevant to the general thrust of your argument - the US does not have either more crime nor more violent crime than comparable nations. The UK has more of both. What the US has is more fatalities from violent crime, because it has more guns.
The statistic cited is inappropriate for the problem analyzed:
percent of population who are victims of crime at least once a year. For this statistic to work crime must be spread out equally in all observed countries. For example, none of the observed countries should have a marginalized minority that is more commonly a victim of a crime. Comparing USA and Japan or just about any other country on the list with this statistic is going to be problematic, to put it mildly.
McHrozni