Cont: The One Covid-19 Science and Medicine Thread Part 5

From Eric Topol's substack:

Shane Crotty: A Landmark Study on Upper Airway Mucosal Immunity
https://erictopol.substack.com/p/shane-crotty-a-landmark-study-on

This is the first time a Ground Truths podcast is being posted simultaneous with a new publication, this one in Nature, by Professor Shane Crotty and his colleagues at La Jolla Institute for Immunology.
....
Today’s paper in Nature is indeed a landmark contribution doing something that hasn’t been done before—to understand the underpinnings of mucosal immunity of the upper airway. 100 participants had monthly nasal and nasopharyngeal swabs throughout the pandemic. With a median of >100,000 cells per swab recovered , they undertook single-cell sequencing and full characterization of the cells (B, T, C4+, CD8+, tissue-resident cells, follicular T helper cells, germinal centers, etc) to determine optimal immune protection of the upper airway, the effect of infections by different variants, breakthrough infections, vaccination, and age.
 
Long Covid

This new review on #LongCovid @TheLancet is outstanding
https://thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(24)01136-X/fulltext
by @trishgreenhalgh @sivanmanoj @DrAPerlowski and Janko Nikolich
Eric Topol (X, Aug 1, 2024)

Post-COVID-19 condition (also known as long COVID) is generally defined as symptoms persisting for 3 months or more after acute COVID-19. Long COVID can affect multiple organ systems and lead to severe and protracted impairment of function as a result of organ damage. (...) Although current approaches to long COVID care are largely symptomatic and supportive, recent advances in clinical phenotyping, deep molecular profiling, and biomarker identification might herald a more mechanism-informed and personally tailored approach to clinical care.
Long COVID: a clinical update (TheLancet/ScienceDirect, July 31, 2024)


As for Long Covid prevention:
Long COVID currently has no definitive cure, so prevention is of the utmost importance. The best way to prevent long COVID is to prevent COVID-19 through well established public health measures such as paying attention to indoor air quality (eg. ventilation or filtration); wearing well fitting, high-filtration masks or respirators when appropriate; and supporting infectious individuals to quarantine. People with acute COVID-19 should ensure they rest.
Vaccination is also crucial.


Ensuring they rest is the exact opposite of what is currently expected of top athletes with COVID-19, be it at Tour de France or at the Olympics.
 
Eric Topol on the current wave and details of how it differs from the early Omicron.

The Indomitable Covid Virus
https://erictopol.substack.com/p/the-indomitable-covid-virus

Fortunately, the rise in levels of the virus, still going up in all 4 major US regions (most recent CDC data below) has not been linked with as much severe Covid (absolute increase) as was seen in prior waves, but compared to last week there was a relative increase of 25% of deaths and 12% increase in emergency room visits due to Covid.
...
The antigenic distance map below reflects that evolution. JN.1 is further way from the infamous Omicron BA.1 than BA.1 is from the major variants of 2020 and 2021 (Wuhan-ancestral, D614G, Alpha, Delta, Beta). KP.3 and KP.3.1.1. is to the right of JN.1 (not shown), even further away. The virus will not stop here, despite our desire to will it way. It will continue to find new ways to infect and reinfect us, under selection pressure from our prior immunity (be it infections, vaccinations, or combinations).
...
Added to problem of the virus‘s evolution and, as a result, is the blunting of our immune response, the big issue of waning immunity. The vaccine boosters only last 4-6 months for protection from severe Covid, do little after early weeks for any protection from infections or spread. The same goes for infections. Neutralizing antibody levels go down. Our interferon first line of defense gets blocked (Shane Crotty called this the “superpower of SARS-CoV-2” in our podcast this week).
 
Interpretation
Psychiatric and cognitive symptoms appear to increase over the first 2–3 years post-hospitalisation due to both worsening of symptoms already present at 6 months and emergence of new symptoms. New symptoms occur mostly in people with other symptoms already present at 6 months. Early identification and management of symptoms might therefore be an effective strategy to prevent later onset of a complex syndrome. Occupation change is common and associated mainly with objective and subjective cognitive deficits. Interventions to promote cognitive recovery or to prevent cognitive decline are therefore needed to limit the functional and economic impacts of COVID-19.
Cognitive and psychiatric symptom trajectories 2–3 years after hospital admission for COVID-19: a longitudinal, prospective cohort study in the UK (TheLancet, July 31, 2024)


What's the use of that old brain anyway, right?!
 
If you're not familiar with Susan Oliver (and Cindy), you should give her (them) a chance in spite of the immediate impression you may get the first time you click on one of her YouTube videos.
The first time I heard her intro, i.e. "Hello, and welcome to Back to the Science. I'm Dr. Susan Oliver and I'm a scientist, and this is Cindy Oliver, and she's a dog," I thought, No, you're not. I don't have to listen to this crap. It didn't make it any better that she asks people to "Buy me a coffee (or Cindy a treat) https://buymeacoffee.com/susanandjulie". I'm not sure if Julie died and was replaced or if she just changed her name.
I only gave Back to the Science another chance when I saw one of the guys at Science-Based Medicine recommend one of her analyses.

The results of a recent study looking at cardiovascular safety following vaccination are devastating for antivaxxers who like to scare people by falsely claiming vaccines are causing increases in cardiovascular events. The study clearly shows that the lies they have been grifting off are bollocks.
Cardiovascular events after COVID vaccine. The SHOCKING truth! (Back to the Science on YouTube, Aug 7, 2024 - 12:07 min.

That she is also antivaxxer John Campbell's Nemesis contributes to my admiration for her.
He is so full of it!

Dr. Susan Oliver (PhD) is also on X.
 
Last edited:
If you're not familiar...

:dl:

Who's the "you" you're referring to?

Nobody's taking any notice of you, as evinced by the zero responses you get, and visitors are barred from the site.

You're talking to an empty room.

But do carry on.
 
Who's the "you" you're referring to?

Nobody's taking any notice of you, as evinced by the zero responses you get, and visitors are barred from the site.

You're talking to an empty room.

But do carry on.
Well, I do take notice, I just don’t have anything new to say.
 
Ditto. To both threads.

Not taking sides. I find dann's factual posting persuasive. But then so are the other side's posts, oftentimes, including The Atheist's as well. And in any case, regardless of which side scores, the ongoing discussion on these two threads means I generally stay abreast of what's up, at a time when generally I don't much check the news for this.

Like I said, not taking sides. Just, I dislike rhetorical tricks like these on general principles, this using of ridicule and (incorrect, inaccurate) accusations of irrelevance, to shut down an opponent, particularly given how sincerely and painstakingly and consistently they present their facts. So I thought to post this. I take notice, as well, for what that is worth.
 
So I thought to post this. I take notice, as well, for what that is worth.

Fair enough.

Given the hours of work, I'd be looking for a much bigger audience than half a dozen, but people have weird hobbies, I guess.
 
Yes, some people have the hobby of spreading disinformation on a skeptics' forum.
How weird is that?!
I notice that the audience just grew from nobody to half a dozen.
Great!
:)

ETA: Is it a coincidence that yet another Trumpian debate tactic has come into play, pooh poohing the opponent's crowd size?
And in the Science, Mathematics, Medicine, and Technology subforum, of all places!
 
Last edited:
ZDoggMD finally gets Covid after 4.5 years.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0t3CqFYeaVo

I like this video because it gives the doctor's perspective on the symptoms and how it differs from other illnesses. Interesting fellow because he is friends with both Dr. Paul Offit and Dr. Vinay Prasad. Very reasonable doc though I'm not into the mediation stuff that seems to fascinate him.

His daughter got Covid at camp a few days earlier, came home, then he got it. She tested positive with a rapid test. Initial rapid test for ZDoggMD was totally negative even though he had strong symptoms then strong positive the next day. Has some distortion in sense of smell/taste. Typical range of symptoms. Is recovering. Says he will report on any long term issues.

His wife hasn't gotten Covid and still is negative. She also had current boosters. ZDoggMD has not had recent boosters.


No, he is not a "Very reasonable doc." ZDoggMD is a numbskull! He is an MD, he has a condition, two genes that predispose him for blood clots, and yet he hasn't had a booster shot since 2021!
Maybe he shouldn't listen to Vinay Prasad and other minimizers, antivaxxers and antimaskers.
The day my COVID got worse…
(ZDoggMD on YouTube, Aug 8, 2024 - 25:52 min.)

As for not being "into the mediation stuff that seems to fascinate him," this guy is a ******* new age guru!
16:45-19:38: ... so that's the emptiness thread. You askyou ask the question, 'What still feels real? What still feels solid. What still feels here and present, can that be deconstructed?' And let go.
For the love thread, you could ask the question, 'What's here in my experience now that makes
things feel separate or seems in opposition to unconditional love for everything?' And you can look go, 'Oh man, I'm really mad at this guy!' Okay, let'sfeel into that. So what is it the sense that I'm apart from them? The sense that we're in conflict in some way. And that thread can continue to refine and deepen.
For the energy thread you could ask the question, 'What is it here that still feels solid,
that doesn't feel Dynamic and in motion constantly in flux?' So you can feel like, 'Oh, the body
feels like energy, but this table feels solid, feels static.' Ah, so you know as that thread evolves that that table is going to start to look like it does in the Matrix, just vibrating, oscillating condensed energy.
In the unconscious thread, you could ask the question, 'What is it here that hasn't been allowed, that hasn't been felt in Consciousness fully, that hasn't been liberated? What inner trauma, what inner child, what inner ancestor, what inner experience hasn't been allowed into the light of
awareness? Hasn't integrated into the one soul?'
And you could ask that question, and you know at some point it's going to come. [Giggles!]
And so, you can attune in a way.
So in a sense, it's a beautiful model that validates the experience you're having. By the way, those four threads are only the most common. So, it, there's probably an infinite number of threads.
So whatever you're experiencing is right! It is right!. [Creepy guru laugh!]
What a relief! That's the good news! There are so many people who are banging their head against the wall going, 'I'm not having stage three Awakening! I haven't had non-dual perception! I haven't experienced emptiness! I haven't had a mindblowing Kundalini experience! I don't feel like everything is love!'
That's fine. It's okay. You're perfect.
This goes as it goes for you, and just knowing this can - I know it did for me, and I know it did for the friend who turned me on to this - it can create an opening, it can dissolve a resistance
pattern to what's actually happening for you. And then, then you start to go back and realize, 'Oh, oh', because it's often seen in retrospect this has been happening the
whole time.
Your awakening will never fit THEIR mold, here's why. (ZDoggMD on YouTube, May 27, 2024 - 28:30 min.)
The creepy laugh is at 18:45, if anybody feels like cringing. The rest is as boring as it is moronic.

This isn't meditation. This is full-blown new age nonsense.
It also isn't somehow exterior to his attitude to the pandemic and to the worst of the very worst COVID-19 minimizers. It is no coincidence that ZDoggMD can nod and smile when he lets Vinay Prasad spread pandemic disinformation:
Whatever you're experiencing is right! It is right!
This, by the way, is Vinay Prasad: The Epidemic of #DiedSuddenly (TheFreePress, Jan 25, 2023).

It is also no coincidence that one of the comments to his latest video has to remind him of the pandemic facts:
You're describing the second week cytokine storm that occurs with covid, often mistakenly called "Paxlovid rebound" even though it also happens for people who don't take Paxlovid. This Week in Virology's weekly Clinical update with Dr. Daniel Griffin discusses the different phases of the covid infection, and advises doctors on treatment recommendations for each phase.
To ZDoggMD, even his bout with Covid is all about the experience. It is the experience of somebody who knows about medicine, but still. What a stupid *******!
 
Last edited:
PEM

While watching ZDoggMD's YouTube video (the new one), I was reminded of a problem with SARS-CoV-2 infections and exercise, post-exertional malaise (PEM), but forgot about it again.
He started exercising while he was still testing positive.

Post-exertional malaise (PEM) is fatigue and worsening of symptoms following even minor physical or mental exertion. It is commonly reported by people with post COVID-19 condition, and can impair their ability to exercise, work or go about daily activities. In this webinar, you will hear how to identify post-exertional malaise, and interventions to support patients and aid recovery.
Post-Exertional Malaise (PEM) and Long Covid (WHO)


I tried to continue my exercise routine through my first SARS2 infection and haven’t recovered in four years. I cannot safely do anything that elevates my heart rate without lots of medication(anti-seizure, vasoconstrictors, etc…) and days of bedrest. Tens of millions like me.

I was asymptomatic and unaware of the dangers of exercise during an acute viral infection.

Meds: multiple anti-seizure, multiple migraine, multiple wakefulness, multiple blood pressure all of which stop working if I do too much all because I use to be exceptionally active. Long Covid gets everyone.
Dr. Michael (X, Aug 9, 2024)
 
In 2023, covid dropped to 10th on the cause of death in USA.

And will continue falling.

https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/73/wr/mm7331a1.htm

Despite all your shrieking about the new variants, the damage done by covid continues to fall everywhere on the planet. It's now just a cold and far less damaging than influenza, except for those with toe-tags printed, in which case it's a very good thing.

OMG, some people are dying weeks early from covid!
 
The Atheist is making wild predictions, "And will continue falling," based on absolutely nothing, as usual.
And as usual, he mixes it with outright lies, "OMG, some people are dying weeks early from covid!," his tired old 'toe-tag' fairy tale. It was never true, and it still isn't.
It is his false argument for not caring about people (of all ages) dying from this disease, and since it seems to be his one and only concern, he will probably never give up on the lie.

He may not have noticed, but the excess mortality has increased considerably since the pandemic began - and not by weeks.
Excess mortality: Cumulative deaths from all causes compared to projection based on previous years (Nordics, Australia)
Australia is as high as it is because its population is more than twice that of Sweden.

What is interesting is the difference between when the great dying started in countries that had almost no restrictions at the early stage of the pandemic and in countries where it didn't start until they claimed that all precautions other than vaccinations were unnecessary because 'hybrid immunity', i.e. the post-vax version of herd immunity by infection, was 'super immunity'.
Excess mortality: Cumulative deaths from all causes compared to projection based on previous years (DK, NZ)
Cumulative confirmed COVID-19 deaths per million people (DK, NZ, AUS)

However, it is apparent that the excess mortality has dropped considerably, that the 'curve' has been 'flattened', mainly due to the decrease in C19 deaths:
"The COVID-19 death rate decreased from 2022 to 2023 for all age groups." (CDC)
Excess mortality: Cumulative deaths from all causes compared to projection based on previous years (USA)
Cumulative confirmed COVID-19 deaths per million people

On X, Eric Topol has copied graphics from a JAMA article:
Look how the leading causes of death in the US have changed over the past 4 years
@JAMA_current
Leading Causes of Death in the US, 2019-2023 (JAMA)
Eric Topol (X, Aug 8, 2024)
(See graphics in tweet)
Still ~50,000 Covid deaths in 2023
Compared with pre-pandemic
Heart disease and stroke are not declining
Small reduction in cancer deaths
Eric Topol (X, Aug 8, 2024)

It is really no surprise that heart disease and stroke are not declining since COVID-19 infections contribute to both. In fact, the ranking of stroke, Alzheimer, diabetes and kidney disease as causes of death all rose from 2022 to 2023, and we know that COVID-19 leads to an increase of all four diseases and deaths from those diseases as well as of heart disease.
Of the 10 leading causes of death, C19 is the only infectious disease.


ETA:
* Report finds 5% more deaths in Australia in 2023 than expected
* Covid’s after-effects are resetting baseline of illness, death

Australians are still dying at higher rates than before the pandemic, reflecting how Covid-19’s lingering effects may be driving a sustained increase in death and disease around the globe.
Excess mortality – the increase above the expected toll had the pandemic not occurred – was 5% for Australia in 2023, the Sydney-based Actuaries Institute said in a report Monday, significantly higher than the 1-2% excess seen in years of crushing seasonal influenza epidemics.
Excess Deaths in Australia Reveal Covid’s Long, Lethal Tail (Bloomberg, July 28, 2024)
 
Last edited:
HIV and Long Covid - viral persistence

In a considerable number of Long Covid patients, the virus persists, so it makes sense to test if drugs against HIV may help them fight their persistent SARS-CoV-2:
In a study released in mid-July, scientists at the Wistar Institute in Philadelphia showed how microbial changes in the intestines of some people living with HIV increased their risk for developing long Covid after a SARS-CoV-2 infection. At the University of California, San Francisco, infectious diseases doctors have applied their expertise looking for HIV reservoirs in the body to track vestiges of the coronavirus in ‘long haulers.’
Now, researchers are looking at whether medications used to treat or prevent HIV may also alleviate long Covid symptoms.
Treatments For Long Covid Draw on Decades-Long HIV Research (Bloomberg, July 29, 2024)
 
C19 death toll 2023

In post 537, I quoted Eric Topol talking about "~50,000 Covid deaths in 2023" in the USA.
It appears to be 50% more than that, according to this CIDRAP article:
Provisional data from the National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS) on the top causes of deaths in the United States in 2023 shows COVID-19 dropped to the tenth leading cause of death. In 2022, it was the fourth leading cause of death, meaning deaths from COVID dropped by 68.9% in 1 year.
There were 76,446 deaths from COVID-19 in 2023, and 245,614 in 2022. In 2023, the leading causes of death in the United States were heart disease (680,909 deaths), cancer (613,331), and unintentional injury (222,518).
COVID drops to 10th leading cause of death in US (CIDRAP, Aug 8, 2024)

I got the number 75,663 when I looked at the CDC page earlier today.
When I look at the 2024 numbers from Dec 30, 2023, to July 13, 2024, I get 26,751 C19 deaths.

A reply to Topol's tweet says:
It’s strange that their total for deaths involving covid doesn’t jibe with the official (@cdcgov) total over the same period.
Their number (1,004,204) is 14% lower than the official one (1,171,237).
Model-based estimates suggest the official count is a ~50% undercount, iirc.
Arijit Chakravarty (X, Aug 8, 2024)
It mentions the number 76,024 for 2023 and 27,863 for 2024, so far.
 
Last edited:
Multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children after COVID-19

Scientists now have an answer to a mysterious severe illness that put many children on the verge of dying after COVID complications. https://abc7ne.ws/3YKybRv
San Francisco scientists crack case of severe illness in kids after COVID (ABC7 News Bay Area on YouTube, Aug 10, 2024)

It was 2020, Dr. Aaron Bodansky kept seeing a high number of children coming into the ICU with a mysterious inflammatory disease.
"They had severe inflammation of all their bodies but in particular their lungs and really their hearts."
It turns out this was happening to children across the world, and no one knew why. The illness came to be known as multi system inflammatory syndrome in children or MIS-C.
"The only thing we knew was that they had previously had a SARS-CoV-2 infection."
As cases intensified, doctors suspected that the severe inflammation was connected to the immune system. To keep children alive, medical personnel acted on that hunch.
"We used medicines to suppress and calm their immune system, which thankfully worked extremely well to save their lives."
Dr. Bodansky remembers reaching a breaking point after seeing one of his patients.
"We had to put a breathing tube in and put on medicines to essentially induce a coma. It was really hard to look the parents in the eyes and just tell them that we had no idea what was happening, and I didn't want to have to keep doing that."
After this, he contacted some of the top infectious diseases experts and scientists in the area, the pivotal figure Dr. Joe DeRisi. Together they collaborated with the CDC and hospitals across the country to collect nearly 200 blood samples.
"This has been a puzzle that researchers and clinicians across the country, and in fact across the world, have tried to figure out. And yet it has eluded almost everyone until now."
After years in this lab, they cracked the case.
"So the moment was realizing that that unusual reaction to COViD matched something in our own immune system, so it acquired a target against COVID that matched us. So it was attacking both at the same time."
Now they're hoping to use their findings to advance science.
"Knowing that a virus can provoke an autoimmune reaction later on and having this proof allows us to potentially develop therapeutics and diagnostics for anything like this that might occur in the future."
Now these scientists are hopeful this finding will help understand other diseases, including type 1 diabetes or MS.


SF scientists crack case of severe illness that put children 'on death's door' after COVID (ABC7 News, Aug 10, 2024)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom