WTC conspiracy theory giving me problems

I'm not a fan of your tone, but your response makes sense and pretty much settles it for me.

Cool :)

A five minute Google search would give you this and more, so you'll have to contend with the tone.

McHrozni
 
Well, no thermite should be found AT ALL. And none was found. Finding ANY thermite, no matter the amount in a particular sample (because that would be just 1 sample of TONS of dust), would destroy the official story (unless thermite was used at the towers in some way during construction or something).
Not really. Finding a few small flakes of so-called "thermitic material" far from the towers in a few plastic bags filled with dust is no threat to the official story. First you'd have to prove this material was somehow used to destroy the towers. And you'd have to prove it was even a viable instrument to destroy the towers or cut steel (which it's not), explain how it was used and also recreate the destruction (where all attempts have failed). But I totally agree what they found was NOT any form of Thermite, Thermate Or whatever you want to call it.
 
I have over the years made a hobby of debunking 9-11 conspiracy theories and I'm having major problems with this one:
Hi jamesraio,

How very interesting! Would you mind telling us how you have gone about debunking 9-11 conspiracy theories? Who were you trying to debunk? Which theories did you debunk? Did you engage in arguments with truthers? What methods did you use to debunk? Have you posted your results on any webpages other than JREF?

Welcome to the forums,
DAO
 
All you get are links to 911 blogger truther sites!

Googling "nano thermite paper debunked" yields [url="http://www.debunking911.com/thermite.htm]this[/url] as the 3rd hit. Learn to use Google property is all I can recommend.

McHrozni
 
Googling "nano thermite paper debunked" yields as the 3rd hit. Learn to use Google property is all I can recommend.

McHrozni
That wasn't a search field I used, but just so you know, I'm sure you'd be a happier person without being so negative. No one is very impressed, but I guess this is unsolicited advice.
 
Hi jamesraio,

How very interesting! Would you mind telling us how you have gone about debunking 9-11 conspiracy theories? Who were you trying to debunk? Which theories did you debunk? Did you engage in arguments with truthers? What methods did you use to debunk? Have you posted your results on any webpages other than JREF?

Welcome to the forums,
DAO
-Since 2005 when I watched an Alex Jones documentary for the first time
-Mike Riviero fans, nut jobs in nyc, I've called up alex jones and argued with him. I've also prAnked him and am proud to be the only guy who has done so successfully.
-Methods were simple. Most of their crap was patently unscientific or they would cite steven e jones, who want peer reviwed in the journal of marxist political science. Since trutherness has disippated I've stopped caring until I heard of this article.
-I'm by no means a thorough debunker. I just get intoi more arguments than i should.
 
-Since 2005 when I watched an Alex Jones documentary for the first time
-Mike Riviero fans, nut jobs in nyc, I've called up alex jones and argued with him. I've also prAnked him and am proud to be the only guy who has done so successfully.
I guess you've never heard of Unsecured Coins. ;)
 
That "article" was peer reviewed by scientists outside of the twoofer circle and the so-called nano thermite was found to be nothing but paint chips. Furthermore, the samples they used for testing had no chain of custody and we're turned in years after 9/11.

But one of the funniest parts about the Controlled Demo CT is that there are some seriously fundamental flaws in their logic.

First off, thermite would have been painfully obvious to anyone who watched the videos, in which you can clearly see the core clumns still standing for a few seconds after initial collapse...SUPRIZE!!! No glowing orange crap on the cores or on any other parts of the collapsed debris, other than a couple of isolated areas, which thermal imaging suggested was a result of the melted aluminum from the plane.

Secondly, the man power and expense of setting up such an operation would have been astronomical, which would quickly dismiss the likelyhood of these people having anything to gain from such an operation.

Third...You have a plethora of verifiable quotes from firefighters that confirm the inevitable collapse of all three buildings, due to fire alone...

Welcome to the forums!!! I'm a recovering Truther myself and glad to have joined the NWO.
 
The chief editor does not necessarily read every article, assistant editors often send out papers to be read to advisors and jr. editors. The fact the chief editor didn't claim that the article lacked any review whatsoever leads me to believe the paper was obviously reviewed by other legitimate editors, as would be standard practice.
.

Why then did she quit saying essentially the standards of the journal so that bad?
 
Last edited:
All you get are links to 911 blogger truther sites!

But you found JREF, so presumably you didnt try searching the forum or even searching google with the tag "jref". Your research skills are weak old man.
 
Well, no thermite should be found AT ALL. And none was found. Finding ANY thermite, no matter the amount in a particular sample (because that would be just 1 sample of TONS of dust), would destroy the official story (unless thermite was used at the towers in some way during construction or something).

Thermite is a mixture of ferric oxide (rust) and aluminum. Finding either or both of these materials in a steel-framed building that was hit by aluminum planes is hardly unexpected. Also, both aluminum powder and ferric oxide are commonly used in paint. So no, finding "thermite" does not "destroy the official story".
 
That wasn't a search field I used, but just so you know, I'm sure you'd be a happier person without being so negative. No one is very impressed, but I guess this is unsolicited advice.
Over the past 7 years, truthers by the legion have showed up on this board, claiming to be "debunkers" or "seekers of wisdom", and as soon as the "theory" they were claiming to try to debunk WAS shown to be false, they showed their true colors, and revealed the idiot inside. Some have returned many times as sock-puppets, and just as quickly are banned. Again.
So forgive us if we're skeptical about a "new" debunker.
 
Poster Sunstealer, who is a materials scientist, has links in his signature to posts he made which definitively prove that the material Jones was analyzing cannot be thermite and is either paint or primer. I highly recommend reading these.

Main one:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=4607894&postcount=1694

ETA - Another thread discussing this: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=140017

ETA II - Yet another thread: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=140426
 
Last edited:
Thermite is a mixture of ferric oxide (rust) and aluminum. Finding either or both of these materials in a steel-framed building that was hit by aluminum planes is hardly unexpected. Also, both aluminum powder and ferric oxide are commonly used in paint. So no, finding "thermite" does not "destroy the official story".
I thought that thermite had to be mixed a certain way. In other words, certain amounts of each of the materials mixed together.

Either way, thermite/thermate/nano-thermite/nano-thermate was NOT found.
 
Really, even that's beisde the fact. What's more compelling is the fact that even if it WAS thermite, it would be WAY to thin to do any adverse structural damage to the steel and would burn off with out doing much more then scorching the steel (if that). The Thermite theory was never logical.

Never logical especially since those who are claiming thermite are also claiming explosives in a controlled demo fashion. My question to them is which is it? Explosives or thermite? Maybe it's both? Then again, maybe it's what Jim Fetzer claimed as being a super sophisticated military weapon?

Google: "Hardfire Jim Fetzer"
 
Here's a series of links recording Ryan Mackey's adventure revealing Bentham Open Access's deficient editorial practices:
Here's a couple of external links from "Open Access News" complaining of Bentham's practices:
Poster Lenbrazil investigated the relative importance and citation rate of Bentham Open Access. In short, ignoring its deficient peer review and editorial practices, it's far from being prominent:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4691152#post4691152


My own summary of all of that:
Nice, Len! Very good work! This is excellent context on Bentham's relevance in the research world.
----

Now, to reiterate for others: I don't think anyone here is against the concept of Open Access journals in and of themselves. And to be honest, I don't think anyone would be against Bentham in particular if they would follow better, more responsible practices. The issue here, however, is not one of open access, nor is it one about the specific publishing "house". Rather, it is of the practices Bentham follows. Some irregularity is to be expected in a non-mainstream journal, but as Ryan Mackey discovered, their practices simply do not lend themselves to proper review of submitted material.

Bentham could be a respectable open access journal. But as of now, given their current practices, they are not.

One other thing: The other myth being slain is the truther chant of Bentham being a high-profile, respectable publication. As Lenbrazil has shown, they are far from the mainstream, and far from being well utilized in the scientific community. The value of a paper lies in how it influences other research, and that can be measured by how many other works reference it. That is the true measure of its utility. A publication that carries many oft-referenced works can be thought of as an "important" one. Len's work above clearly demonstrates that Bentham's publications are not.
 
Never logical especially since those who are claiming thermite are also claiming explosives in a controlled demo fashion. My question to them is which is it? Explosives or thermite? Maybe it's both? Then again, maybe it's what Jim Fetzer claimed as being a super sophisticated military weapon?

Google: "Hardfire Jim Fetzer"

In a conversation via email with real scientist Frank Greening, Steven Jones admitted that the thermite they found was likely used for fuses to ignite conventional explosives.

http://the911forum.freeforums.org/active-thermitic-material-in-wtc-dust-t150-30.html

Go to Dr.G. post #479

SO you see, their new hybrid (and bizarre) theory involves both...lol

TAM:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom