Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
what current??????..

the imf changes direction and usually there are like 4 sectors in tne imf, pointing outward and inward alternatingly, driven by the large scale magnetic field topology of tne sun

this has nothing to do with non-classical draping, which is caused by cometary ion pick up, acceleration by the solar wind convective electric field and solar wind deflection by momentum conservation and the solar wind magnetic field following the deflected ions (see koenders et al, 2016)


Lately, in the era of Rosetta [Glassmeier et al., 2007a] at comet 67PCG, currents are playing an important role in new observations.
Current sheets in comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko's coma m.volwerk
 
Current sheets in comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko's coma m.volwerk

and what are we supposed to deduce from this, other than your ignorance of what you read?

so once more, what current is supposed to have "changed direction" ?
 
http://www.safirefilm.com/ewExternalFiles/SAFIRE-Project-Report.pdf



Seems they are leaving the mainstream theoretical models for dust!

Empirical science at its best!
My bold.

Clearly, you are either a) reading a totally different document, or b) have a profound misunderstanding of said mtms (possibly both).

A ~logical equivalent might be something like “seems they are leaving Sol88’s hotdog eating record for dust!”

But perhaps it is I who misunderstand; would you care write, in detail, what led you to your apparent “seems”?
 
of course the most obvious flaw in the experiment (and in the es model drawn on page 14) that the sun is an anode, and there is only charge going in (electrons) and out through the cord in the hollow anode. naturally that cannot happen in the sun, even juergens was at least smart enough to have a complete circuit, going out at he poles.
 
http://www.safirefilm.com/ewExternalFiles/SAFIRE-Project-Report.pdf



Seems they are leaving the mainstream theoretical models for dust!

Empirical science at its best!

"The SAFIRE PROJECT generates the same energy densities as the sun’s photosphere and nuclear bombs. . ."​

Bwahahahahahahahaha!
No.

The authors don't seem to understand that the energy densities of the sun are actually fairly low, orders of magnitude lower than an atomic bomb.

"The model is not without precedent. Some of the most illustrious explorers in the history of the sciences have long proposed that electricity plays a much more important role in the heavens than has been acknowledged – Benjamin Franklin, Michael Faraday, James Clerk Maxwell, Sir William Crookes, Kristian Birkeland, Nicola Tesla, Irving Langmuir, Hannes Alfvén, to name only a few. "​

Nuclear fusion was first proposed as a possible power source for the sun in 1920. Franklin, Faraday, Maxwell, Crookes, and Birkeland all died before 1920, so their lack of knowledge of fusion is neither a strike against them nor against a fusion model of the sun.

Tesla could be a crank. I've seen no evidence that Langmuir thought the sun was powered by anything other than fusion. And Alfven explicitly stated that the sun is powered by fusion.

This attempt to appeal to authority is pathetic.
 
The one proposed in the paper were we forget about the ice and model it on silicates and sulfides?

More lying. That is not what the paper says. Have you ever tried to make an honest argument in your life? Why is it that EU proponents always seem to need to either lie, obfuscate, or show complete ignorance, whenever they discuss science? Is it a prerequisite of cult membership, or do you all pick it up from Thornhill, like some sort of contagious meme?
 
So, I haven't read the paper, but they've managed to make an electric orb glow like the sun using the current going trough the universe and NOT by plugging it into a mains?
 
A SAFIRE project lie (a pathetic attempt to model an electric Sun)

the SAFIRE team ...
12 April 2018: A SAFIRE project lie (a pathetic attempt to model an electric Sun, not his comet delusions).

12 April 2018: Mindlessly parrots a SAFIRE project web site DL lie.

The deluded Thunderbolts cult has many "we see bunnies in the clouds" delusions, e.g. Birkeland currents in physically impossible places (not around planets in a solar wind :eye-poppi!).

The project web site uses that delusion by labeling images of varying levels of light from plasma as "double layers". A paper the researchers published back in 2015 makes this into a lie.
Study of striations in a spherically symmetric hydrogen discharge does not mention double layers, even mentions that the striations are not new (first found in 1997) and explains the striations as "instabilities arising from copious formation of negative ions that modify the radial space charge and electric field distributions".
 
Last edited:
Lies about a mainstream comet paper yet again

Unexpected and significant findings in comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an interdisciplinary view
13 April 2018: Lies about a mainstream "Unexpected and significant findings" comet paper yet again.
This is the measurement of ices and dust in comets :jaw-dropp! The paper is not his "serious doubts" lie. The paper suggests spending more time modeling comets like 67P, i.e. 6 times as much dust as ices.

13 April 2018: The repeated insanity that scientific models do not change and descriptions are a scientific model.
Whipple 1950 described comets as "dirty ice balls" because the knowledge at the time was of an outer solar system producing objects that were lots of ice and some dust. Thus a typical comet would be mostly ices with some "dirt". Of course comet ice and dust ratios will vary. Short period comets like the ones we have visited lose ices when they sublimate close to the Sun and may not have time to replace the ices during the outer part f their orbit.
Thus in hindsight it is not really a surprise that we measure some short period comets having more dust than ices.

The real insanity is that if we replaced a Whipple 1950 model of comets with more ice than dust with a modern astronomers 2018 model of comets with more dust than ice, comets would still be made of ices and dust. Sol88 would still be totally deluded about comets being made of rock, etc. :jaw-dropp!
 
Last edited:
826 items of ignorance, idiocy, delusions and lies, 29 August 2016 - 13 April 2018

803 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 22 March 2018 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)
  1. 28 March 2018: Repeats a lie of DL's, etc. in cometary papers.
  2. 28 March 2018: Cites Wal Thornhill who has been lying abut comets for 13 years !
  3. 28 March 2018: Cites insane "comets from Mars" delusions from Wal Thornhill.
  4. 28 March 2018: Usual lies about DLs, Birkeland currents in comet papers to derail from his many comet delusions.
  5. 28 March 2018: The usual lie of ice and dust papers supporting his many comet delusions
  6. 28 March 2018: Links to a repeated lie of DLs found around comets in a Laako paper
  7. 11 April 2018: A lie that we are arguing about the role electricity plays in the Universe
  8. 11 April 2018: A lie by citing Electric Currents in Geospace and Beyond which is a standard astrophysics book.
  9. 11 April 2018: A lie that Alfven said MHD is wrong from another lying, deluded Thunderbolts video.
  10. 11 April 2018: An inane "MHD should have died with Alfven" delusion.
  11. 11 April 2018: A lie that we argued that there can be no charge separation in space plasmas.
  12. 11 April 2018: Idiocy and a lie not related to his insane video.
  13. 11 April 2018: Lies by quote mining H. Madanian et.al.
  14. 11 April 2018: Lies about tunsenfem's joke in a tweet.
  15. 11 April 2018: Lies of "double layers and Birkeland currents (FAC's, flux ropes, flux tubes, stringy things.....)" around comets.
  16. 12 April 2018: A deluded DL question was ignored but since he insists on his delusions being recorded forever we have a size of DL delusion.
  17. 12 April 2018: Usual DLs at comets idiocy and electric field stupidity.
  18. 12 April 2018: Lies about Ziggurat's post, MHD and plasma
  19. 12 April 2018: Lies about jonesdave116's post where he understands Thornhill's loopy, unscientific woo (electric comet, etc.).
  20. 12 April 2018: A SAFIRE project lie (a pathetic attempt to model an electric Sun, not his comet delusions).
  21. 12 April 2018: Mindlessly parrots a SAFIRE project web site DL lie.
  22. 13 April 2018: Lies about a mainstream "Unexpected and significant findings" comet paper yet again.
  23. 13 April 2018: The repeated insanity that scientific models do not change and descriptions are a scientific model.
 
Last edited:
So, I haven't read the paper, but they've managed to make an electric orb glow like the sun using the current going trough the universe and NOT by plugging it into a mains?
It is not a paper - it is a deluded and lying PDF on their web site, e.g. that "generates the same energy densities as the sun's photosphere and nuclear bombs..." fantasy. It gives the insane background of the SAFIRE project.

The SAFIRE web site lies producing images looking like the Sun, e.g. the Sun is not covered in uniformly distributed tufts!

We have the engineer Montgomery Childs imagining defects with the "standard model of solar physics" and falling for the electric sun insanity which at best predicts that the Sun is a white dwarf (imaginary fusion in the photosphere from Scott).

There is the stupidity that "in industry, something as statistically stable as the stars suggest a relatively simple process". Followed by exploring the word of William Crooke - a experiment where he saw rubies glowing in a discharge. That leads to the insanity of no fusion at all - an electric sun that is close to a light bulb :eek:!

Ziggurat notes pathetic and wrong appeals to outdated authority as if Benjamin Franklin knew what we know about the Sun and space today!
 
Last edited:
and what are we supposed to deduce from this, other than your ignorance of what you read?

so once more, what current is supposed to have "changed direction" ?

There are no electric currents at and around comets, move along nothing to see here!

Gunna be good if they ever publish your paper, tusenfem. :D

There a definitely NO electric currents in the tail of a comet and most definitely nothing like this
The angle of pitch of the helix varies smoothly and continuously with increasing radial distance, r, from the central axis of the current out as far as the plasma's current-carrying charge density extends. This causes cyclical reversals of direction (counter flows) in both the axial and azimuthal magnetic field and its collinear current density.
as detailed first by Don Scott.

So Whipples model still holds, sublimating ice being blown back by the wind.
 
A "no electric currents" lie about tusenfem's post.

There are no electric currents at and around comets, move along nothing to see here!
13 April 2018: A "no electric currents" lie about tusenfem's post.
tusenfem's post is asking Sol88 for Sol88's electric current at and around comets that Sol688 asserted to have changed direction.

ETA
13 April 2018: A lie that Don Scott detailed anything at all (let alone first!) about comets or their tails

13 April 2018: A lie that a Don Scott quote is about comets or their tails
That quote is from Scott's deluded Birkeland current paper.
Figure 9 on the same page as the quote illustrates the obvious deluded nature of the paper. This is an image of the North Pole of Saturn, i.e. the storms inside Saturn's not-a-plasma atmosphere :eek:!

Followed by his "The M2-9 Hourglass planetary nebula in Figure 10" is an z-pinch delusion. Known Unknowns
But this is one of those cases where there is a clear prediction from the EU model. That is, the flow of plasma is through the pinch. This means if you look at the Doppler shift of light coming from the nebula you should clearly see that the material flows in on one side and out on the other. The standard red giant model makes a very different prediction. It says the Doppler measurements should show material flowing out from the center on both sides. It turns out we’ve made Doppler observations of M2-9, and sure enough it agrees with the standard red giant model.


Figure 7 is the hexagonal storm inside the atmosphere at Saturn's north pole insanely compared to a cross-section of supposedly a "dense plasma focus Birkeland Current" from a crank paper (A.L.Peratt, from Characteristics of a High-Current, Z-Pinch Aurora As Recorded in Antiquity, Part II Directionality and Source by Peratt, Directionality and Source. IEEE Transactions on Plasma Sci., August 2007).
I have emphasized the insanity.

Donald Scott lies about the Peratt paper. That image is "Fig. 59. Penumbra of a DPF from a discharge current of 174 kA. The rotational structure has a periodicity of 56 as shown by the 56-dot overlay pattern." as described in the Dense Plasma Focus section which does not mention any Birkeland currents!
 
Last edited:
Ziggurat notes pathetic and wrong appeals to outdated authority as if Benjamin Franklin knew what we know about the Sun and space today!

Hell, Ben Franklin didn't even know that much about electricity. Not that his contemporaries did either, so no blame there, but still.
 
Oh yes, I personally don't buy any of the electric universe stuff either, as it requires reality to be different than observed, but the EU crowd could at the same time prove everyone wrong AND solve the worlds energy crisis is they can tap the massive electrical fields they claim exist.

So, Sol88, does the Safire project require man-made electricity or not? Because if it does, it's just a glorified glow bulb.
 
Other interesting observations concern electrically charged nanograins in the inner coma, indicating a possible connection between dust at the surface of the nucleus and the comet’s plasma environment [53].

Reckon he'd be on the money, they are part of the current system that operates at a comet, including interacting with the cometary double layers!
 
Last edited:
Reckon he'd be on the money, they are part of the current system that operates at a comet.

a) there was no DL at Halley, and b) who is 'he'? The quote is unattributed, and could have been said by your next door neighbour, for all I know.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom