Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
The idiocy of "looks like rock so must be rock" pops up yet again

22 June 2018: The idiocy of "looks like rock so must be rock" pops up yet again?
Or actual insanity that a bright patch is an electrical discharge?

That is an image of Comet 67P which has been measured to be made of ices and dust.
There is a bright patch. It is at a low point on 67P (a small part of the electrical discharge insanity).
 
An insane EDM lie.

Yup, EDM ...
22 June 2018: An insane EDM lie.
This is Electrical Discharge Machining
Electrical discharge machining (EDM), also known as spark machining, spark eroding, burning, die sinking, wire burning or wire erosion, is a manufacturing process whereby a desired shape is obtained by using electrical discharges (sparks).[1] Material is removed from the work piece by a series of rapidly recurring current discharges between two electrodes, separated by a dielectric liquid and subject to an electric voltage.
No dielectric liquids on comets :eye-poppi!
Comet coma are conducting plasma.
His delusion of electrical discharges on comets still has no evidence.
 
Tell us Sol - from your extensive knowledge of electric woo, what signature would be seen of this discharge by an instrument looking directly at it in FUV? Should it resemble the spectrum of reflected sunlight from dust?

ALICE was never designed to search for these signatures ALICE—THE ULTRAVIOLET IMAGING SPECTROMETER ABOARD THE ROSETTA ORBITER D. C. Slater1, J. Scherrer1, J. Stone1, M. F. A’Hearn2, J. L. Bertaux3, P. D. Feldman4, and M. C. Festou5, and S. A.Stern5[/I] but it did find this "surprising" finding...

This comparison showed that simulations performed using nanograins entering the slit would created similar shapes as seen on February 19th, evidence that the most common appearance of the AF is caused by dust. For future UVS missions to unique and extreme environments in terms of dust, ions, and electrons, more research into this AF will determine if there are possible instrument enhancements that could mitigate the intensity or even appearance of the AF, an ion repeller grid for example.

The effects of dust outbursts on the anomalistic features observed by Rosetta Alice around 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko John Noonana, Eric Schindhelma, Joel Wm. Parkera, Andrew Steffla, Michael Davisb, S. Alan Sterna, Zuni Levinc, Sascha Kempfc, and Mihaly Horanyic

And mainstream find it's a problem and need to mitigate it's intensity!! :boggled:

Kinetic plasma effects. Charge separation in action!

Now where did that dust from my breakfast end up one wonders?
 
What EDM (lol)? Please show us the signature in the data that was collected over 2+ years from 0m to 1500 km.
What 'electrochemistry? How are you doing this woo?



What double layer? Please show its signature in the data collected over 2+ years.

Honestly, talk about deranged!

Like tusenfem said, boring terminator orbits did not lend themselves well to observing this layer with high resolution.

but

At Halley

Vega flew thru this

5wku1x.jpg


Electric Fields and Cold Electrons at Comet Halley H.Laakso
 
Last edited:
22 June 2018: An insane EDM lie.
This is Electrical Discharge Machining

No dielectric liquids on comets :eye-poppi!
Comet coma are conducting plasma.
His delusion of electrical discharges on comets still has no evidence.

None needed <snip>

Electrostatic disruption of a charged conducting spheroid Jay Roderick Hill and , D. A. Mendis

Abstract

Electrostatic disruption of elongated or chain-like parent grains following sudden charging to high electrostatic potentials was recently offered as a specific mechanism for a certain cometary phenomenon, namely the appearance of the so-called striae or pseudosynchronic bands observed in several comets.

What is NEEDED are intense applied electric fields!!! These will be found on the terminator between shadowed and sunlit areas!

And kinetic plasma effects make this more than a mere possibility!

The ELECTRIC COMET!!


Edited by Loss Leader: 
Edited for Rules 0/12. Insults clothed in sophistry are still insults.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
ALICE was never designed to search for these signatures ALICE—THE ULTRAVIOLET IMAGING SPECTROMETER ABOARD THE ROSETTA ORBITER D. C. Slater1, J. Scherrer1, J. Stone1, M. F. A’Hearn2, J. L. Bertaux3, P. D. Feldman4, and M. C. Festou5, and S. A.Stern5[/I] but it did find this "surprising" finding...



The effects of dust outbursts on the anomalistic features observed by Rosetta Alice around 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko John Noonana, Eric Schindhelma, Joel Wm. Parkera, Andrew Steffla, Michael Davisb, S. Alan Sterna, Zuni Levinc, Sascha Kempfc, and Mihaly Horanyic

And mainstream find it's a problem and need to mitigate it's intensity!! :boggled:

Kinetic plasma effects. Charge separation in action!

Now where did that dust from my breakfast end up one wonders?


Total and utter irrelevance, and an inability to understand what the instrument does! Lol. If there was any sort of discharge woo, it would have been noticed by a number of instruments, including ALICE. It didn't seem to have any problem detecting the sunlight reflected from the dust! Sorry, there was no electric woo. It would be bleeding obvious. And wouldn't create ice grains! Deary me.
 
Last edited:
Like tusenfem said, boring terminator orbits did not lend themselves well to observing this layer with high resolution.

but

At Halley

Vega flew thru this

[qimg]http://i68.tinypic.com/5wku1x.jpg[/qimg]

Electric Fields and Cold Electrons at Comet Halley H.Laakso

Which wasn't a DL, and even if it were in some strange fantasy world, what did it do?
 
Electrostatic disruption of a charged conducting spheroid Jay Roderick Hill and , D. A. Mendis



What is NEEDED are intense applied electric fields!!! These will be found on the terminator between shadowed and sunlit areas!

And kinetic plasma effects make this more than a mere possibility!

The ELECTRIC COMET!!

CRAP!!!! And why is this not happening to asteroids? Or the Moon? Stop making stuff up. You have no scientifically valid mechanism for this scientifically illiterate woo, and zero evidence. Give it up. You're probably the only person on the planet who still believes in this idiocy.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
CRAP!!!! And why is this not happening to asteroids? Or the Moon? Stop making stuff up. You have no scientifically valid mechanism for this scientifically illiterate woo, and zero evidence. Give it up. You're probably the only person on the planet who still believes in this idiocy.


4. Conclusion

In summary, the population of small bodies in our solar system today, including both minor planets and classical comets, is far less well-delineated into distinct groups of objects than the classical paradigm might have led one to believe in the past. These objects instead appear to occupy a continuum spanning the full range of observational, physical and dynamical properties classically attributed solely either to asteroids or comets. We now know of currently actively sublimating main-belt objects that could have originated either in the asteroid belt or in the outer solar system, and objects displaying comet-like activity that may have no volatile ice content whatsoever.
Asteroid–comet continuum objects in the solar system Henry H. Hsieh
 
CRAP!!!! And why is this not happening to asteroids? Or the Moon? Stop making stuff up. You have no scientifically valid mechanism for this scientifically illiterate woo, and zero evidence. Give it up. You're probably the only person on the planet who still believes in this idiocy.


Answer me this if you can, why is this not a scientifically valid mechanism?

or

Just answer yes/no to the following simple question

Is there charge separation in the plasma's on/around a comet?
 


Aaaaannnnddd? How many objects in the asteroid belt? How many behave like comets? What were the densities of the two asteroids visited by Rosetta? How is an asteroid behaving like a comet in the asteroid belt? I thought it was all to do with some fictitious voltage drop woo, due to an elliptical orbit? Well, not much ellipticity in the main belt, is there? You can't even manage to keep your fairy tale straight for more than a few posts in a row.
 
Answer me this if you can, why is this not a scientifically valid mechanism?

or

Just answer yes/no to the following simple question

Is there charge separation in the plasma's on/around a comet?

Why don't you use the search function? Tusenfem has already told you this. You just keep repeating the same inane crap, over and over. Sorry, but scientifically impossible woo is not suddenly going to become possible just because you want it to.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom