Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
The Coulomb force is not replacing gravity ya burke! It's lessening it's apparent force!

That might be the case but it's thrown a spanner in your mass estimates and ultimately the density calculation for 67P! :D

No one cares it's out by a few meters when your measuring the mass from mm differences from radio wave propagation...well YOU HAVE A PROBLEM
Good to see a demonstration that, despite what you've posted earlier, you Sol88 are more than capable of doing the calculations required to show how the relevant data is consistent with an estimated density of 67P being ~that of "rock".

Or do you lack the cojones to do such a calculation, for fear it'll blast your beloved ELECTRIC COMET model into dust? :confused:
 
The Coulomb force is not replacing gravity ya burke! It's lessening it's apparent force!

That might be the case but it's thrown a spanner in your mass estimates and ultimately the density calculation for 67P! :D

No one cares it's out by a few meters when your measuring the mass from mm differences from radio wave propagation...well YOU HAVE A PROBLEM

Personally I think this just shows how little Sol understands about what he is suggesting. He doesn't seem to understand the problem.
Here is a breakdown of the problem that he needs to calculate;

Forget about RSI. Regardless of what this invisible plasma woo is doing to the signal, it doesn't affect the gravity (and therefore the calculated density) of the comet. That is measured by the effect it has on the orbiting spacecraft. If the gravity were greater than that which is measured, the spacecraft would crash. It didn't.
Suppose we wish to orbit a satellite around Earth, at a certain altitude; how do we go about doing that? Well, we need to know the gravity exerted on it by the planet. To cut a long story short, we can then calculate an orbital speed that will keep it in that orbit. If we get the speed wrong, then it'll either head back towards Earth, or head outwards into a more distant orbit.
If the spacecraft behaves as expected, then we know that we have measured Earth's gravity correctly.
The same applies at 67P. If the density were 4 x greater than measured, then the orbital speed used by the mission controllers would not be sufficient to keep it in orbit, and it would crash.
So, Sol needs to explain how it was able to maintain this orbit, at a speed insufficient to keep it from crashing, if the density were as he suggests. That is where we are now. He suggests electrostatic repulsion. Harvey and Tom Bridgman have already shown him how to do that calculation. The results show the suggestion of electrostatic repulsion to be idiotic.
It is now up to Sol to show why it isn't idiotic. Firstly, give us the equation. Secondly, give us the figures to plug into it.
Hint: this has already been done.
 
Last edited:
Ok, I'll simplify it for you then me 'ol chugger tusenfem!

your original assertion HERE



Does a point charge have an electric field?

:rolleyes:

i know what i wrote, and it is true.
however what you wrote

like the electric field of off the charged nucleus?

That doesn't need charge separation of the solar wind!

of off??
the second line is your claim
whatever
 
Personally I think this just shows how little Sol understands about what he is suggesting. He doesn't seem to understand the problem.
Here is a breakdown of the problem that he needs to calculate;

Forget about RSI. Regardless of what this invisible plasma woo is doing to the signal, it doesn't affect the gravity (and therefore the calculated density) of the comet. That is measured by the effect it has on the orbiting spacecraft. If the gravity were greater than that which is measured, the spacecraft would crash. It didn't.
Suppose we wish to orbit a satellite around Earth, at a certain altitude; how do we go about doing that? Well, we need to know the gravity exerted on it by the planet. To cut a long story short, we can then calculate an orbital speed that will keep it in that orbit. If we get the speed wrong, then it'll either head back towards Earth, or head outwards into a more distant orbit.
If the spacecraft behaves as expected, then we know that we have measured Earth's gravity correctly.
The same applies at 67P. If the density were 4 x greater than measured, then the orbital speed used by the mission controllers would not be sufficient to keep it in orbit, and it would crash.
So, Sol needs to explain how it was able to maintain this orbit, at a speed insufficient to keep it from crashing, if the density were as he suggests. That is where we are now. He suggests electrostatic repulsion. Harvey and Tom Bridgman have already shown him how to do that calculation. The results show the suggestion of electrostatic repulsion to be idiotic.
It is now up to Sol to show why it isn't idiotic. Firstly, give us the equation. Secondly, give us the figures to plug into it.
Hint: this has already been done.

Righto, back from out back and need to set a few boundaries so we all read from the same book.

Official 67P Stats

Mass= 9.98e12 kg
Volume = 187000 m3
GM = 662.2m3-m2
Density = 533 kg/m3


g = 6.8e-4 m-s-2 30 years of the Vega mission: Comparison of some properties of the 1P/Halley and 67P/ChuryumovëGerasimenko comets


That's pretty much the mainstream understanding?
 
Those numbers are WIKI's understanding, I assume you are going to complain about slightly different numbers in the Ksanfomati paper?
For those interested the DOI is 10.3367/UFNe.2016.07.037867

At the moment, just a consensus on the generally accepted figures for 67P.

So wiki or not, can I use them in a few calcs?
 
At the moment, just a consensus on the generally accepted figures for 67P.

So wiki or not, can I use them in a few calcs?
Please don't. Your "Volume" is wrong by five decimal orders of magnitude.

The Wiki article you were citing gives the volume as 18.7 km3. That's 18700000000 cubic meters, not 187000.
 
Please don't. Your "Volume" is wrong by five decimal orders of magnitude.

The Wiki article you were citing gives the volume as 18.7 km3. That's 18700000000 cubic meters, not 187000.

Roger 18700000000 or 1.87e10. Ok

We should add

Rosetta mass 1250 kg

Orbit distance 10km

For the calcs :thumbsup:
 
Idiocy of discussing comets are rocks insanity starting with 67P is not a rock

So wiki or not, can I use them in a few calcs?
10 August 2018: Idiocy of discussing his "comets are rocks, etc." insanity starting with the measurement that Comet 67P is not a rock!

Add a "few calcs" delusion when he has a track record of 9 years of the inability to do basic physics or even click on links.

This may be doing a calculation from the density of an ices and dust comet, coming up with a fantasy that the mainstream is wrong and then the stupidity that we have seen before that his "comets are rocks, etc." insanity must be right. Charitably this is the fallacy of false dichotomy.

Maybe the idiocy of doing the same calculations that have been done before which are a small bit of evidence debunks his comet insanity: Electric Comets III: Mass vs. Charge

Nothing to do with
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic. Stupidly thinks that a ambipolar electric field is a double layer.
 
Last edited:
Focus rc, focus.

Gunna give this math turn out a crack. Tom simplistic calculations will very much be a part of this whole shebang.

Just need to establish a baseline on “known” comet properties so as to leave no wiggle room. For you and me both.

Keen to play?
 
Do you agree to use the measured density of Comet 67P (less than rock)

Keen to play?
Of course I am keen to expose even more parroting of the delusion that you can do physics when you have denied physics calculation for over 9 years :p.

We will start with where you started, "Official 67P Stats". This is Comet 67P
Volume 18.7 km3 (4.5 cu mi)[3]
Mass (9.982±0.003)×1012 kg[3]
Mean density 0.533 ± 0.006 g/cm
10 August 2018 Sol88: Do you agree to use the measured density of Comet 67P (about 6 times less than that of rock)?

N.B. This is what the orbital parameters gives us. The RSI measurement also gives us a similar mass. It is this mass that the electric comet insanity says is wrong.
 
Focus rc, focus.

Gunna give this math turn out a crack. Tom simplistic calculations will very much be a part of this whole shebang.

Just need to establish a baseline on “known” comet properties so as to leave no wiggle room. For you and me both.

Keen to play?
 
Orbit distance 10km

For the calcs :thumbsup:

Irrelevant; Rosetta orbited at distances from 1500 km to 0 km. The equations for the force laws involved both decrease as the inverse square of the distance, which means that they cancel out.
 
Well the flight team for Rosetta needed something so they could ORBIT the nucleus, like you said Jd116 and with fuel to spare!!

Focus jd116, focus

Cometary nuclei consist mostly of dust and water ice1. Previous observations have found nuclei to be low-density and highly porous bodies2,3,4, but have only moderately constrained the range of allowed densities because of the measurement uncertainties. Here we report the precise mass, bulk density, porosity and internal structure of the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko on the basis of its gravity field. The mass and gravity field are derived from measured spacecraft velocity perturbations at fly-by distances between 10 and 100 kilometres. The gravitational point mass is GM = 666.2 ± 0.2 cubic metres per second squared, giving a mass M = (9,982 ± 3) × 109 kilograms. Together with the current estimate of the volume of the nucleus5, the average bulk density of the nucleus is 533 ± 6 kilograms per cubic metre. The nucleus appears to be a low-density, highly porous (72–74 per cent) dusty body, similar to that of comet 9P/Tempel 12,3. The most likely composition mix has approximately four times more dust than ice by mass and two times more dust than ice by volume. We conclude that the interior of the nucleus is homogeneous and constant in density on a global scale without large voids. The high porosity seems to be an inherent property of the nucleus material.
LINK

So, tusenfem is wiki on the money here sport?

Which one would you like to use? the 10 or 100km jd116?
 
Last edited:
Of course I am keen to expose even more parroting of the delusion that you can do physics when you have denied physics calculation for over 9 years :p.

We will start with where you started, "Official 67P Stats". This is Comet 67P

10 August 2018 Sol88: Do you agree to use the measured density of Comet 67P (about 6 times less than that of rock)?

N.B. This is what the orbital parameters gives us. The RSI measurement also gives us a similar mass. It is this mass that the electric comet insanity says is wrong.


So which mass do i use rc?

Wiki's 9.98e12 kg or M. Pätzold's 9.982e9 kg?
 
Well the flight team for Rosetta needed something so they could ORBIT the nucleus, like you said Jd116 and with fuel to spare!!

Focus jd116, focus

No, you focus. What is Coulomb's law? What is the gravitational law? Both of them have r2 as the denominator. Ergo, they cancel out.
This has nothing to do with the flight team. They measured the mass, and therefore the gravity, using Doppler effects on the RSI. That tells them at what velocity to orbit the spacecraft in bound orbits. At 5 km the velocity required will be higher than at 20 km. If they had got it wrong, the spacecraft would either crash or fly off to who knows where. They didn't get it wrong, did they? So, what is causing Rosetta to orbit in bound orbits (i.e. not using propulsion, merely gravity) when you think the damn thing is 5 x heavier than measured? Let me spell this out again; It. would. crash.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom