North Pole is melting faster than predicted

Unlike other people, Megalodon actually has a real life, and his PhD will not write itself.

I dedicate the time I find adequate to snipe at the idiocy I see posted in this forum. No more, no less.

But thank you for missing me, it's heart-warming :)

Adding to list also at your unspoken request

argumento sniper de idiocracy:D
 
So...

Whether or not there is a relation between a given quantity of CO2 in the atmosphere, and a given temperature, further, whether a causal relation can be established between CO2 and temperature, based on the historical variations in CO2 and temperature since 1850.

The causal relationship can be established from the science. What can't be established so well is the scale, given that we've no experience to go on. All those feedbacks (let alone other forcings such as aerosols) make things very complicated. Ball-park estimates can be made, and have been in the past. Recent observations - over the last few decades - bear them out.

Regarding your conclusive opinion supported by facts with sources, or in the alternative, an unsubstantiated opinion based on belief.

That's all?

I can call on retreating glaciers, vanishing sea-ice, melting permafrost, treelines and species heading northwards and upwards, changing growing-seasons, the fact that it's warmer now than ten years ago, and was warmer then than twenty years ago ... and so on, as backup. If need be.

That's what my conclusion is based on. Like almost everybody thirty years ago, I was unconvinced of any significant impact from anthropogenic CO2; we were raised in the anti-catastrophist, get-over-yourselves scientific atmosphere that's been established over the last few centuries. Events have made me shed that attitude. AGW is no longer a prediction, it's a process we're well into.

In 1850, this was not the case. Fossil-fueled industrialisation had made a miniscule difference to CO2-load. It had only been embraced in Western Europe, where the wood had run out. In the US and Eastern Europe they still had forests; in the US they even ran trains on wood decades later. Thermodynamically absurd, but cost-effective when there are still trees near the lines. Branch-lines were even built to bring wood to main-lines.

Forget 1850. There's no refuge there. The last fifty years (where that exponential CO2-load line starts to take-off) is the relevant period. The last thirty years even more so, the last ten yet more, and the next ten more again. That's how it is with exponentials. They lie low for ages, then suddenly spring out at you.



No comfort blankets of facts and science for the rest of us?

No comfort blankets. Not in the past, not in Antarctica, not in "global warming on Mars", not in "it might not" (it has), not in the lack of exactitude, not in demonisation, not in anything. We are screwed.


Just the arguments ad absurdo sidesteperado ...

That pretty much sums up England's performance against the 'Boks this evening.

... ad argumentado obscurado ...

That'll be the long words and my allusive style. I can't control that.

... and ad argumento minutae?

Ask me again about the charts from the 1850's onwards that are apparently so important to you. Should they be adjusted to take account of volcanoes? Other aerosols? Solar activity? Site-history? Urban Heat Island Effect? Any and/or all? How calculated? By whom? What's their voting history?

I need a more precise specification than "show me charts" from someone as picky as you.
 
So, I bring a World Bank publication of 2007 to the table, and you dismiss it because of perceived left-wing issues... The World Bank...

Paranoia, thy name is hazy...

They squeezed Wolfie out pretty damn' quick. Before he could twig what was really going on. Yes, the World Bank has surely fallen to the Enemies of Goodness and Sense.

I remember the good old days, when "green" was a slang term for money, and society was properly ordered. Before "World This" and "United That" and "International Other Thing" provided totalitarian vehicles for the Enemies of Goodness and Sense to ride into power on.

I saw it all coming, of course, and sensibly signed up with the Enemies. I get a taste from the hedge-fund evil. Before that, from the dot.con evil and the junk-bond evil. And now, of course, from the Climate Alarmism evil.

You should try it. The hours are good - easily fitted in around a thesis - and it's well-rewarded. It's easy, and it's fun.
 
pssst...pssst your 2007 report has 2003 data on it.

Many a report will use data of previous years because it takes so much time to gather, collate and analyse. D'oh. What doesn't change is that the report was published in 2007.

And since you're the poster who thought Russia was still communist, which it hasn't been for over 10 years, and you showed similar ignorance about the rest of Europe, maybe you should simply STFU. Unless you really like being the object of entertainment.
 
Or you could have used Wikipedia :covereyes

It seems that you have failed Irony 101...:deadhorse

Don't worry, try again, it's free.
:tr:

Many a report will use data of previous years because it takes so much time to gather, collate and analyse. D'oh. What doesn't change is that the report was published in 2007.

And since you're the poster who thought Russia was still communist, which it hasn't been for over 10 years, and you showed similar ignorance about the rest of Europe, maybe you should simply STFU. Unless you really like being the object of entertainment.
 
And since you're the poster who thought Russia was still communist, which it hasn't been for over 10 years ...

You fell for that misdirection? The USSR was never communist, it simply suited the Enemies of Goodness and Sense to present them that way. These guys were already well-embedded by 1850. Before the Civil War. See how it all falls into place?

... and you showed similar ignorance about the rest of Europe, maybe you should simply STFU. Unless you really like being the object of entertainment.

Hush up. I like entertainment.
 
Russia was part of a Socialist Dictatorship. It was never communist.

Russia was the sandbox for 19thCE German social theorising, but has always been Russia. A late starter with serious inertia - Czarism was moulded on Louis XIV - but always destined to be a player. Even without global warming, which is bad for them how much? Not much, that's for sure. On balance, very likely a good thing.

Putin is the current face of Russia, and it's so familiar ... Putin is how Russia does things. And it's come a long way since Peter the Great.
 
Originally Posted by Megalodon
Unlike other people, Megalodon actually has a real life, and his PhD will not write itself.

I dedicate the time I find adequate to snipe at the idiocy I see posted in this forum. No more, no less.
​
But thank you for missing me, it's heart-warming

Adding to list also at your unspoken request

argumento sniper de idiocracy:D

Of course this argument reference to the movie "Idiocracy" .

In that dystopia, you pickup your Phd at Costco.

Irony 304 ;)
 
The causal relationship can be established from the science. What can't be established so well is the scale, given that we've no experience to go on. All those feedbacks (let alone other forcings such as aerosols) make things very complicated. Ball-park estimates can be made, and have been in the past. Recent observations - over the last few decades - bear them out.

I need a more precise specification than "show me charts" from someone as picky as you.
Forget 1850. There's no refuge there. The last fifty years (where that exponential CO2-load line starts to take-off) is the relevant period. The last thirty years even more so, the last ten yet more, and the next ten more again. That's how it is with exponentials. They lie low for ages, then suddenly spring out at you.​


​
Well, how about some actual demonstration of this exponential trend in the last 50 years? A relation between CO2 and temperatures of that sort.

Can you show that?

That would be what, an exponential temperature increase? I know quite well you can say it exists. I'm asking if you can objectively demonstrate it.
 
Argument ad IPCCobotomy, invalid and specious.

The IPCC report is the result of serious research by qualified scientists following the scientific process. Earnest amateurs can always come up with any amount of hand waving and and a jolly good time, but it's still not science.

Which part of the IPCC report did you not like?
 
[/indent]Well, how about some actual demonstration of this exponential trend in the last 50 years? A relation between CO2 and temperatures of that sort.

Can you show that?

That would be what, an exponential temperature increase? I know quite well you can say it exists. I'm asking if you can objectively demonstrate it.

http://ipcc-wg1.ucar.edu/wg1/Report/suppl/docs/AR4WG1_Pub_Ch09-SM.pdf

I have a friend who is a researcher in climate change. When I ask him questions, he says look at the IPCC report. Any references to people like Chrichton, he just laughs, and can't understand why anyone would waste their time listening to a novelist about the topic.
 
http://ipcc-wg1.ucar.edu/wg1/Report/suppl/docs/AR4WG1_Pub_Ch09-SM.pdf

I have a friend who is a researcher in climate change. When I ask him questions, he says look at the IPCC report. Any references to people like Chrichton, he just laughs, and can't understand why anyone would waste their time listening to a novelist about the topic.

Originally Posted by mhaze
​
Well, how about some actual demonstration of this exponential trend in the last 50 years? A relation between CO2 and temperatures of that sort.

Can you show that?

That would be what, an exponential temperature increase? I know quite well you can say it exists. I'm asking if you can objectively demonstrate it.



[/INDENT]You often use the phrase "accelerating rate of change" with reference to temperature and CP alleges "exponential". So my question seem very straightforward - I'm just asking what is that relationship, as you believe it to exist.

Is it Temp = (Atm concentration of CO2) cubed, maybe?

Or what?



​
 
Well, how about some actual demonstration of this exponential trend in the last 50 years? A relation between CO2 and temperatures of that sort.

Can you show that?

That would be what, an exponential temperature increase? I know quite well you can say it exists. I'm asking if you can objectively demonstrate it.



[/indent]You often use the phrase "accelerating rate of change" with reference to temperature and CP alleges "exponential". So my question seem very straightforward - I'm just asking what is that relationship, as you believe it to exist.

Is it Temp = (Atm concentration of CO2) cubed, maybe?

Or what?

I don't recall using exponential, IIRC, I use accelerating. It has to flatten off somewhere, obviously, but at the moment, in geological terms, it's extremely rapid compared to the usual changes. Extremely rapid changes in the past have usually brought about mass extinctions.

Where will it end? That answer can only be attempted by models, because we have no other way of knowing. If you want a simple formula, you won't get it. Knowing that it will warm is a trivial case to answer, knowing exactly how much and when is very complex.

The link I provide gives the process used to estimate that, did you read it? The answer can only be arrived at using the process described. You will often read people describing the pure CO2 forcing, (and apparently getting that wrong more often than not). Since feedback and other complex factors are involved the IPCC uses the process described, with the answers given.
 
I don't recall using exponential, IIRC, I use accelerating. It has to flatten off somewhere, obviously, but at the moment, in geological terms, it's extremely rapid compared to the usual changes. Extremely rapid changes in the past have usually brought about mass extinctions.

Where will it end? That answer can only be attempted by models, because we have no other way of knowing. If you want a simple formula, you won't get it. Knowing that it will warm is a trivial case to answer, knowing exactly how much and when is very complex.

The link I provide gives the process used to estimate that, did you read it? The answer can only be arrived at using the process described. You will often read people describing the pure CO2 forcing, (and apparently getting that wrong more often than not). Since feedback and other complex factors are involved the IPCC uses the process described, with the answers given.

But I want your take on it. Or are you just saying that you are going to strictly go by the IPCC Book whatever it may say?

If to then you lose all those "tipping points":)
 
Because less fiction from novelist than from that hockey stick Team - Hansen, Mann and Jones?:rolleyes:
  • IPCC temperature rise of 1C in last century based largely on Jones et al.
  • Jones refuses to release his data and methods.
  • Jones has been formally charged with scientific fraud separately.
Do you refute any of this?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom