For TokenConservative - Where should we get our information on climate from?

and i didn't claim otherwise, AUP. i was pointing out that no one had lied regarding the implications of the alleged evidence in question. i was not claiming that anyone claims or expects models to be completely accurate. attempts to model the complex systems that we find on and in the earth are always going to be inherently innacurate to some degree, as it seems utterly impossible to account for every single possible variable. but these simplistic models can be amazingly valuable in both understanding and generalized prediction.

it is this understanding that drives my interest in the evidence in question. ASSUMING accuracy of the linked news article-- an assumption that i'm not willing to make, frankly-- the research may have some serious implications regarding some rather serious AGW predictions. i certainly see some real value in this article, because IF it is as was described, it may help the accuracy of our climate models, and it may lead to newer interpretations and predictions of AGW based climate change. again, IF.

given the time, i'll try to find this on friday. that's another IF...

It would be of great benefit to thoroughly research climate models. If you already understand the basics of models in general, it shouldn't take long to reach a logical conclusion about the skillfulness of GCM's.

Maybe begin with this:
http://irina.eas.gatech.edu/EAS_spring2006/Stephens2005.pdf

An insignificant variable in climate?
 
It would be of great benefit to thoroughly research climate models.

Do you think that doesn't already happen?

If you already understand the basics of models in general, it shouldn't take long to reach a logical conclusion about the skillfulness of GCM's.

Go on then. What is the logical conclusion?

And a general question, to keep things in the context of this thread, do you think we can get any useful information on climate from the climate models?
 
Originally Posted by David Rodale
It would be of great benefit to thoroughly research climate models.
​
Do you think that doesn't already happen?
Originally Posted by David Rodale
If you already understand the basics of models in general, it shouldn't take long to reach a logical conclusion about the skillfulness of GCM's.
​
Go on then. What is the logical conclusion?

And a general question, to keep things in the context of this thread, do you think we can get any useful information on climate from the climate models?

I'd like to actually be shown a climate model run that shows something.

This would imply a complete list of the input parameters, versions of databases used by the system, versions of all code used, and the full output. Then of course there would be interpretations and analysis of the output.

However, I have never seen such a thing. Rather we hear all this chatter about "the models show this" or the "models are dead on". It certainly would seem that with the value of gigabytes being measured in (almost) pennies, that this could and should be made available.

What I have asked for here is what is expected in medicine, engineering, criminology/forensics, and many other fields where the results of action or inaction have serious consequences. The work is verifiable by independent outsiders. However, I have never seen such a thing with a climate model.

Have you?

On the contrary what we all have seen is smearing of the likes of Steve McIntyre, true believers scoffing at anyone who would be so rude as to wish to audit scientific work.

So...consider that the above definition is what I consider a climate model. Inputs, outputs, versions, databases. Can you simply point me to where these exist for a particular run or several runs? I doubt it, but await a reply.
 
Do you think that doesn't already happen?



Go on then. What is the logical conclusion?

And a general question, to keep things in the context of this thread, do you think we can get any useful information on climate from the climate models?
Read the article and draw your own conclusion then if you believe climate models are skillful predictive tools.

Yes, there is useful information gained from climate models.
 
{snip}
Can you simply point me to where these exist for a particular run or several runs? I doubt it, but await a reply.


I wouldn't want you to wait too long :)

No, I can't point to that. I'm not a climatologist, and I'm not familiar enough with this issue to find that information.

If you don't mind, I'll restate the question and ask you:

Do you think we should get our information on climate from climate models?
 
Originally Posted by David Rodale
Surely you've seen the AGW formula:
AGW causes x
x = anything.



You're just making an idiot of yourself with arguments like that.
Maybe not.

Perhaps he sees farther by standing on the shoulders of dwarves.

The judicious application of krabapple's approach may also be contemplated, with reference to our friend UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon, speaking about climate at said conference -
"I believe we are on the verge of a catastrophe if we do not act..... drought, severe weather, rising seas, dying species and other consequences".
​

I must confess my AGW model is not perfect. Hemorrhoids are not listed, but I heard there are government funds available for research.
http://www.numberwatch.co.uk/warmlist.htm

Agricultural land increase, Africa devastated, African aid threatened, Africa hit hardest, air pressure changes, Alaska reshaped, allergies increase, Alps melting, Amazon a desert, American dream end, amphibians breeding earlier (or not), ancient forests dramatically changed, animals head for the hills, Antarctic grass flourishes, anxiety, algal blooms, archaeological sites threatened, Arctic bogs melt, Arctic in bloom, Arctic lakes disappear, asthma, Atlantic less salty, Atlantic more salty, atmospheric defiance, atmospheric circulation modified, attack of the killer jellyfish, avalanches reduced, avalanches increased, bananas destroyed, bananas grow, beetle infestation, bet for $10,000, better beer, big melt faster, billion dollar research projects, billions of deaths, bird distributions change, bird visitors drop, birds return early, blackbirds stop singing, blizzards, blue mussels return, bluetongue, boredom, bridge collapse (Minneapolis), Britain Siberian, British gardens change, brothels struggle, bubonic plague, budget increases, Buddhist temple threatened, building collapse, building season extension, bushfires, business opportunities, business risks, butterflies move north, cancer deaths in England, cardiac arrest, caterpillar biomass shift, challenges and opportunities, childhood insomnia, Cholera, circumcision in decline, cirrus disappearance, civil unrest, cloud increase, cloud stripping, cockroach migration, cod go south, cold climate creatures survive, cold spells (Australia), computer models, conferences, coral bleaching, coral reefs dying, coral reefs grow, coral reefs shrink , cold spells, cost of trillions, cougar attacks, cremation to end, crime increase, crocodile sex, crumbling roads, buildings and sewage systems, cyclones (Australia), damages equivalent to $200 billion, Darfur, Dartford Warbler plague, death rate increase (US), Dengue hemorrhagic fever, dermatitis, desert advance, desert life threatened, desert retreat, destruction of the environment, diarrhoea, disappearance of coastal cities, diseases move north, Dolomites collapse, drought, drowning people, ducks and geese decline, dust bowl in the corn belt, early marriages, early spring, earlier pollen season, Earth biodiversity crisis, Earth dying, Earth even hotter, Earth light dimming, Earth lopsided, Earth melting, Earth morbid fever, Earth on fast track, Earth past point of no return, Earth slowing down, Earth spinning out of control, Earth spins faster, Earth to explode, earth upside down, Earth wobbling, earthquakes, El Niño intensification, erosion, emerging infections, encephalitis, equality threatened, Europe simultaneously baking and freezing, evolution accelerating, expansion of university climate groups, extinctions (human, civilisation, logic, Inuit, smallest butterfly, cod, ladybirds, bats, pandas, pikas, polar bears, pigmy possums, gorillas, koalas, walrus, whales, frogs, toads, turtles, orang-utan, elephants, tigers, plants, salmon, trout, wild flowers, woodlice, penguins, a million species, half of all animal and plant species, not polar bears, barrier reef, leaches), experts muzzled, extreme changes to California, fading fall foliage, famine, farmers go under, fashion disaster, fever,figurehead sacked, fir cone bonanza, fish catches drop, fish catches rise, fish stocks at risk, fish stocks decline, five million illnesses, flesh eating disease, flood patterns change, floods, floods of beaches and cities, Florida economic decline, food poisoning, food prices rise, food security threat (SA), footpath erosion, forest decline, forest expansion, frostbite, frosts, fungi fruitful, fungi invasion, games change, Garden of Eden wilts, genetic diversity decline, gene pools slashed, gingerbread houses collapse, glacial earthquakes, glacial retreat, glacial growth, glacier wrapped, global cooling, global dimming, glowing clouds, god melts, golf Masters wrecked, Gore omnipresence, grandstanding, grasslands wetter, Great Barrier Reef 95% dead, Great Lakes drop, greening of the North, Grey whales lose weight, Gulf Stream failure, habitat loss, Hantavirus pulmonary syndrome, harvest increase, harvest shrinkage, hay fever epidemic, hazardous waste sites breached, health of children harmed,heart disease,heart attacks and strokes (Australia),heat waves, hibernation ends too soon, hibernation ends too late, homeless 50 million, hornets, high court debates, human development faces unprecedented reversal, human fertility reduced, human health improvement, human health risk, hurricanes, hurricane reduction, hydropower problems, hyperthermia deaths, ice sheet growth, ice sheet shrinkage, illness and death, inclement weather, infrastructure failure (Canada), Inuit displacement, Inuit poisoned, Inuit suing, industry threatened, infectious diseases, inflation in China, insurance premium rises, invasion of cats, invasion of herons, invasion of midges, island disappears, islands sinking, itchier poison ivy, jellyfish explosion, Kew Gardens taxed, kitten boom, krill decline, lake and stream productivity decline, lake shrinking and growing, landslides, landslides of ice at 140 mph, lawsuits increase, lawsuit successful, lawyers' income increased (surprise surprise!), lightning related insurance claims, little response in the atmosphere, lush growth in rain forests, Lyme disease, Malaria, malnutrition, mammoth dung melt, Maple syrup shortage, marine diseases, marine food chain decimated, marine dead zone, Meaching (end of the world), megacryometeors, Melanoma, methane emissions from plants, methane burps, melting permafrost, Middle Kingdom convulses, migration, migration difficult (birds), microbes to decompose soil carbon more rapidly, monkeys on the move, Mont Blanc grows,monuments imperiled, more bad air days, more research needed, mountain (Everest) shrinking, mountains break up, mountains taller, mortality lower, mudslides, National security implications, new islands, next ice age, Nile delta damaged, no effect in India, Northwest Passage opened, nuclear plants bloom, oaks move north, ocean acidification, ocean waves speed up, opera house to be destroyed, outdoor hockey threatened, oyster diseases, ozone loss, ozone repair slowed, ozone rise, Pacific dead zone, personal carbon rationing, pest outbreaks, pests increase, phenology shifts, plankton blooms, plankton destabilised, plankton loss, plant viruses, plants march north, polar bears aggressive, polar bears cannibalistic, polar bears drowning, polar bears starve, polar tours scrapped, porpoise astray, profits collapse, psychosocial disturbances, puffin decline, railroad tracks deformed, rainfall increase, rainfall reduction, rape wave, refugees, reindeer larger, release of ancient frozen viruses, resorts disappear, rice threatened, rice yields crash, riches, rift on Capitol Hill, rioting and nuclear war, rivers dry up, river flow impacted, rivers raised, roads wear out, rockfalls, rocky peaks crack apart, roof of the world a desert, Ross river disease, ruins ruined, salinity reduction, salinity increase, Salmonella, salmon stronger, satellites accelerate, school closures, sea level rise, sea level rise faster, seals mating more, sewer bills rise, sex change, sharks booming, sharks moving north, sheep shrink, shop closures, shrinking ponds, shrinking shrine, ski resorts threatened, slow death, smaller brains, smog, snowfall increase, snowfall heavy, snowfall reduction, societal collapse, songbirds change eating habits, sour grapes, space problem, spiders invade Scotland, squid population explosion, squirrels reproduce earlier, spectacular orchids, stormwater drains stressed, street crime to increase, suicide, taxes, tectonic plate movement, teenage drinking, terrorism, threat to peace, ticks move northward (Sweden), tides rise, tourism increase, trade barriers, trade winds weakened, tree beetle attacks, tree foliage increase (UK), tree growth slowed, trees could return to Antarctic, trees in trouble, trees less colourful, trees more colourful, trees lush, tropics expansion, tropopause raised, tsunamis, turtles crash, turtles lay earlier, UK Katrina, Vampire moths, Venice flooded, volcanic eruptions, walrus displaced, walrus pups orphaned, war, wars over water, wars threaten billions, water bills double, water supply unreliability, water scarcity (20% of increase), water stress, weather out of its mind, weather patterns awry, weeds, Western aid cancelled out, West Nile fever, whales move north, wheat yields crushed in Australia, white Christmas dream ends, wildfires, wind shift, wind reduced, wine - harm to Australian industry, wine industry damage (California), wine industry disaster (US), wine - more English, wine -German boon, wine - no more French , winters in Britain colder, wolves eat more moose, wolves eat less, workers laid off, World bankruptcy, World in crisis, World in flames, Yellow fever.


and all on 0.006 deg C per year!



 
Last edited:
Just from doing a bit of hovering, it seems that most (all?) of your links are to places like Fox News and other media outlets...

If you have a case to make that the media distorts climate science, then make it. Don't confuse or obfuscate the issue by taking journalistic fluff pieces as representing the actual research done by climatologists, pretty much all of whom agree that AGW is a real and present danger!
 
I wouldn't want you to wait too long :)

No, I can't point to that. I'm not a climatologist, and I'm not familiar enough with this issue to find that information.

If you don't mind, I'll restate the question and ask you:

Do you think we should get our information on climate from climate models?

No way.

Do we invest based on stock market models?
 
Don't confuse or obfuscate the issue by taking journalistic fluff pieces as representing the actual research done by climatologists, pretty much all of whom agree that AGW is a real and present danger!

They do?
 
I wouldn't want you to wait too long :)

No, I can't point to that. I'm not a climatologist, and I'm not familiar enough with this issue to find that information.

If you don't mind, I'll restate the question and ask you:

Do you think we should get our information on climate from climate models?

Vincent Gray, IPCC Reviewer, on climate models. Full story here

http://nzclimatescience.net/images/PDFs/gray2.ipcc spin.pdf

Perhaps I should explain what is meant by "validation". It is a term used by computer engineers to describe the rigorous testing process that is necessary before a computer-based model can be put to use. It must include successful prediction over the entire range of circumstances for which it is required. Without this process it is impossible to find out whether the model is suitable for use or what levels of accuracy can be expected from it.

The IPCC has never even attempted this process, and they do not even discuss ways in which it may be carried out. As a result the models are worthless, and their possible inaccuracy is completely unknown.The IPCC has developed an elaborate procedure for covering up this deficiency which is well described in the IPCC document on "Guidance Notes for Lead Authors on Addressing Uncertainties". It includes attempts to "simulate" those past climate sequences where suitable adjustment of the uncertain parameters and equations in their models can be made to give an approximate “fit”, but they rely largely on the elaborate procedure for mobilizing the opinions of those who originate the models. Most of them depend financially on acceptance of the models, so their opinions are handicapped by their conflict of interest..

The outcomes of the models are classified in the following levels of confidence;

Very High Confidence; At least 9 out of 10 chance of being correct
High confidence. About 8 out of 10 chance
Medium confidence About 5 out of 10 chance
Low confidence About 2 out of 10 chance
Very low confidence. Less tha 1 out of 10 chance

These figures do not possess statistical significance as they are pure guesswork. As might be expected.

Low confidence and Very low confidence are extremely rare.

In addition there are levels of Likelihood which take the place of predictions.

Virtually certain >99% probability of occurrence
Very likely >90% probability
Likely > 66% probability
About as likely as not 33 to 66% probability
Unlikely <33% probability
Very Unlikely <10% probability
Exceptionally Unlikely <1% probability

As before, you search very hard to find anything at all that is below “Likely”; and as before, the probability figures are pure guesswork and have no relationship to mathematical statistics.

These procedures are merely an orchestrated litany of guesswork.

From the 1995 Report on, the IPCC always makes "projections”, never "predictions". They thus admit that their models are not suitable for "prediction" at all.

Also as everything is "evaluated" but not "validated". There can never be never preferred models or scenarios, as they have no way of choosing between them.

Almost all the “opinions” expressed are based on assuming that a correlation implies a cause and effect relationship. This defies a fundamental logical principle, but it is evaded by calling the process
“attribution”. They agree that this is unfair, but cover it up as follows....

“unequivocal attribution would require controlled experimentation with the climate system. Since that is not possible, in practice attribution of anthropogenic climate change is understood to mean demonstration that a detected change is ‘consistent with the estimated responses to the given combination of anthropogenic and natural forcing’ and ‘not consistent with alternative, physically plausible explanations of recent climate change that exclude important elements of the given combination of forcings”. ed experimentation with the climate system. Since that is not possible, in practice attribution of anthropogenic climate change is understood to mean demonstration that a detected change is ‘consistent with the estimated responses to the given combination of anthropogenic and natural forcing’ and ‘not consistent with alternative, physically plausible explanations of recent climate change that exclude important elements of the given combination of forcings”.

Since the alternative explanations are always marginalized or distorted, “attribution” to “anthropogenic change” always wins. It is strange, though, that Very little credence is given to “anthropogenic” changes that do not involve greenhouse gas emissions, such as land use and urban changes.
 
Vincent Gray, IPCC Reviewer, on climate models. Full story here
{snip}


Was all that an answer to my question: "Do you think we should get our information on climate from climate models?" What was the point of posting it exactly?

In a thread asking where we should get our information on climate, you link to a long screed by a contrarian retired coal researcher named Vincent Gray, who has never published on climate science in the peer reviewed climate journals.

Should one get information on climate science from him? Was that your point?

Do you think his opinion outweighs that of all the climate scientists that actually use models, that put together the IPCC reports, that publish in the peer reviewed climate science literature?

If I were a policymaker, how much weight should I rationally give to the opinions of this individual?
 
it is this understanding that drives my interest in the evidence in question. ASSUMING accuracy of the linked news article-- an assumption that i'm not willing to make, frankly-- the research may have some serious implications regarding some rather serious AGW predictions. i certainly see some real value in this article, because IF it is as was described, it may help the accuracy of our climate models, and it may lead to newer interpretations and predictions of AGW based climate change. again, IF.

given the time, i'll try to find this on friday. that's another IF...

I applaud your approach.

I'm pretty fed-up with the focus on models, which is a contrarian hangover from the days when significant AGW was still arguably a prediction. It's been happening for twenty years but that same 80's mantra - "It's based on models and they're no good" - keeps humming along. While the big bad analogue model out there only throws up surprises that suggest our expectations were conservative.

Long story short, I won't be chasing it up. Too jaded, I guess :). I've seen too much "what about this, eh?" to do more than ask "well, what about it?" and deal with any response there might be.
 
If I were a policymaker, how much weight should I rationally give to the opinions of this individual?

We'll get evidence for how much weight is given to the makers of mhaze's opinion from the Bali Conference, which kicks off in a week or two. My prediction is that it won't be much.

Unlike mhaze, decision-makers have to take account of the inexorable intrusion of AGW into the world they govern. Like mhaze they'd (mostly) rather it weren't so, but there it is. Their scientific advisors say it is, so does everybody else's via the IPCC, scientific institutions say it is, the "more research that [was] needed" confirms it, observation by the Mk1 Eyeball confirm it, let alone satellites.

On the other hand, Bali might see McIntyre's breakthrough. Maybe Bali will be when the scales fall from the eyes of the great and good, the epiphany. McIntyre, Gray, Singer, Bellamy, Chrichton, Monckton, the Copenhagen Solar Cycling Team - they were right all along, but their message was stifled! We've been making a fuss about nothing!

Can't see it myself. I can see Canada and Russia revealinging a "meh?" aittude. For them, the downside is not obvious, while the upside is.
 
I'd like to actually be shown a climate model run that shows something.


Hansen et al 1988 predicted a temperature increase of about 0.2C per decade up to now. That's what has occurred. It didn't show hurricane frequency, it didn't show ice extent, it just showed that the world would get warmer at about that rate.

This would imply a complete list of the input parameters, versions of databases used by the system, versions of all code used, and the full output. Then of course there would be interpretations and analysis of the output.

It would imply nothing of the sort - unless you're going to credit the accuracy of the Hansen et al 1988 model prediction to luck. The other explanations - Solar Cycling, cycles in general, cosmic rays - have been summoned up after the event. Back in '88 it was all "it won't happen", now it's all "yes it's happened, but it stopped just now, and anyway it was because of something else, and anyway it might not have happened anyway what with them scientists who can't be trusted".

The model worked. The better models of today will work better. And the big bad analogue model will just keep rolling along as validation.

Mugs like you have fallen for the idea that the absence of all this crap might be in itself important. It's perfectly abnormal to publish code. You describe your methods, the data it's applied to, and the outcome. You leave it to others to reproduce - or not - your results. You'd no more provide your own code than any experimenter would provide their own apparatus.

What's important, twenty years along from Hansen et al 1988, is that it was predictively good. About 0.2C per decade, distributed very much as expected.
 
Was all that an answer to my question: "Do you think we should get our information on climate from climate models?"

If I were a policymaker, how much weight should I rationally give to the opinions of this individual?

As much weigh as his argument deserves on its merits, no more or less.

Do you have a problem with his analysis?

Oh-by the way. I now see that although you are enamored by the IPCC process, some of its own reviewers seem to not meet your standards.

How can that be?
 
Mugs like you have fallen for the idea that the absence of all this crap might be in itself important. It's perfectly abnormal to publish code. You describe your methods, the data it's applied to, and the outcome. You leave it to others to reproduce - or not - your results. You'd no more provide your own code than any experimenter would provide their own apparatus.

What is contemplated is trillions of dollars in taxes, fees, increased utility costs, gas price hikes, regulatory costs, and you advocate the righteousness of concealing the evidence on which public policy is predicated.

Some people might fall for that one.

By the way. How do you like that $10 USD/gallon gasoline price in England? Part of helping save the planet from global warming is letting the government take money out of your pocket a bit there, eh?
 
[/b]

Hansen et al 1988 predicted a temperature increase of about 0.2C per decade up to now. That's what has occurred. It didn't show hurricane frequency, it didn't show ice extent, it just showed that the world would get warmer at about that rate.



It would imply nothing of the sort - unless you're going to credit the accuracy of the Hansen et al 1988 model prediction to luck. The other explanations - Solar Cycling, cycles in general, cosmic rays - have been summoned up after the event. Back in '88 it was all "it won't happen", now it's all "yes it's happened, but it stopped just now, and anyway it was because of something else, and anyway it might not have happened anyway what with them scientists who can't be trusted".

The model worked. The better models of today will work better. And the big bad analogue model will just keep rolling along as validation.

Mugs like you have fallen for the idea that the absence of all this crap might be in itself important. It's perfectly abnormal to publish code. You describe your methods, the data it's applied to, and the outcome. You leave it to others to reproduce - or not - your results. You'd no more provide your own code than any experimenter would provide their own apparatus.

What's important, twenty years along from Hansen et al 1988, is that it was predictively good. About 0.2C per decade, distributed very much as expected.

How many times are you going to dig up a dead horse?

It was nothing more than a carnival guess based on an already established decadal trend. Only in gullible warmers minds can it be considered novel. Hansen didn't include any other factors, so how can you attribute it to anything but an educated guess? How many cycles in the last 100 years only lasted 10 years? Cite the sources who in 1988 said temps wouldn't rise.

Don't you admire how Hansen started his zero points for temps (red) higher than the start points for his scenarios? Why are HadCRUT temps different?




Then there's that pesky satellite data. Damn, temps are going down and no higher now than 1988. The data must be flawed.


Please point out the AGW signal in the tropics. It would 10 km up at Eq.


Where's all that AGW hurricane activity?


And all that is validation in your world?

Ah, that's right. You said we have to wait 5-8 years. Or was it 3-5? What was it again?
 
What is contemplated is trillions of dollars in taxes, fees, increased utility costs, gas price hikes, regulatory costs, and you advocate the righteousness of concealing the evidence on which public policy is predicated.

Some people might fall for that one.

By the way. How do you like that $10 USD/gallon gasoline price in England? Part of helping save the planet from global warming is letting the government take money out of your pocket a bit there, eh?

Trillions of dollars? Spread over how many years, over how many people? What is the payback of renewable energy when you won't have to blow trillions of overseas wars?

Meanwhile in Australia

Power rise to jump due to climate change.

http://www.news.com.au/heraldsun/story/0,21985,22847360-661,00.html

Trains to suffer extensive and expensive disruption due to summer heat.

http://www.news.com.au/heraldsun/story/0,21985,22847360-661,00.html

We will be paying either way. The do nothing option doesn't exist.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom