David Rodale
Muse
- Joined
- Jun 29, 2006
- Messages
- 680
You're just making an idiot of yourself with arguments like that.
Please list in your best estimation what AGW does not explain with regard to climate.
You're just making an idiot of yourself with arguments like that.
and i didn't claim otherwise, AUP. i was pointing out that no one had lied regarding the implications of the alleged evidence in question. i was not claiming that anyone claims or expects models to be completely accurate. attempts to model the complex systems that we find on and in the earth are always going to be inherently innacurate to some degree, as it seems utterly impossible to account for every single possible variable. but these simplistic models can be amazingly valuable in both understanding and generalized prediction.
it is this understanding that drives my interest in the evidence in question. ASSUMING accuracy of the linked news article-- an assumption that i'm not willing to make, frankly-- the research may have some serious implications regarding some rather serious AGW predictions. i certainly see some real value in this article, because IF it is as was described, it may help the accuracy of our climate models, and it may lead to newer interpretations and predictions of AGW based climate change. again, IF.
given the time, i'll try to find this on friday. that's another IF...
It would be of great benefit to thoroughly research climate models.
If you already understand the basics of models in general, it shouldn't take long to reach a logical conclusion about the skillfulness of GCM's.
Originally Posted by David RodaleDo you think that doesn't already happen?![]()
It would be of great benefit to thoroughly research climate models.
Originally Posted by David RodaleGo on then. What is the logical conclusion?![]()
If you already understand the basics of models in general, it shouldn't take long to reach a logical conclusion about the skillfulness of GCM's.
And a general question, to keep things in the context of this thread, do you think we can get any useful information on climate from the climate models?
Read the article and draw your own conclusion then if you believe climate models are skillful predictive tools.Do you think that doesn't already happen?
Go on then. What is the logical conclusion?
And a general question, to keep things in the context of this thread, do you think we can get any useful information on climate from the climate models?
{snip}
Can you simply point me to where these exist for a particular run or several runs? I doubt it, but await a reply.
Maybe not.
Perhaps he sees farther by standing on the shoulders of dwarves.
The judicious application of krabapple's approach may also be contemplated, with reference to our friend UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon, speaking about climate at said conference -"I believe we are on the verge of a catastrophe if we do not act..... drought, severe weather, rising seas, dying species and other consequences".
I wouldn't want you to wait too long
No, I can't point to that. I'm not a climatologist, and I'm not familiar enough with this issue to find that information.
If you don't mind, I'll restate the question and ask you:
Do you think we should get our information on climate from climate models?
Don't confuse or obfuscate the issue by taking journalistic fluff pieces as representing the actual research done by climatologists, pretty much all of whom agree that AGW is a real and present danger!
I wouldn't want you to wait too long
No, I can't point to that. I'm not a climatologist, and I'm not familiar enough with this issue to find that information.
If you don't mind, I'll restate the question and ask you:
Do you think we should get our information on climate from climate models?
Vincent Gray, IPCC Reviewer, on climate models. Full story here
{snip}
it is this understanding that drives my interest in the evidence in question. ASSUMING accuracy of the linked news article-- an assumption that i'm not willing to make, frankly-- the research may have some serious implications regarding some rather serious AGW predictions. i certainly see some real value in this article, because IF it is as was described, it may help the accuracy of our climate models, and it may lead to newer interpretations and predictions of AGW based climate change. again, IF.
given the time, i'll try to find this on friday. that's another IF...
If I were a policymaker, how much weight should I rationally give to the opinions of this individual?
I'd like to actually be shown a climate model run that shows something.
This would imply a complete list of the input parameters, versions of databases used by the system, versions of all code used, and the full output. Then of course there would be interpretations and analysis of the output.
Vincent Gray, IPCC Reviewer, on climate models. Full story here
http://nzclimatescience.net/images/PDFs/gray2.ipcc spin.pdf
Perhaps I should explain what is meant by "validation".
Was all that an answer to my question: "Do you think we should get our information on climate from climate models?"
If I were a policymaker, how much weight should I rationally give to the opinions of this individual?
Mugs like you have fallen for the idea that the absence of all this crap might be in itself important. It's perfectly abnormal to publish code. You describe your methods, the data it's applied to, and the outcome. You leave it to others to reproduce - or not - your results. You'd no more provide your own code than any experimenter would provide their own apparatus.
[/b]
Hansen et al 1988 predicted a temperature increase of about 0.2C per decade up to now. That's what has occurred. It didn't show hurricane frequency, it didn't show ice extent, it just showed that the world would get warmer at about that rate.
It would imply nothing of the sort - unless you're going to credit the accuracy of the Hansen et al 1988 model prediction to luck. The other explanations - Solar Cycling, cycles in general, cosmic rays - have been summoned up after the event. Back in '88 it was all "it won't happen", now it's all "yes it's happened, but it stopped just now, and anyway it was because of something else, and anyway it might not have happened anyway what with them scientists who can't be trusted".
The model worked. The better models of today will work better. And the big bad analogue model will just keep rolling along as validation.
Mugs like you have fallen for the idea that the absence of all this crap might be in itself important. It's perfectly abnormal to publish code. You describe your methods, the data it's applied to, and the outcome. You leave it to others to reproduce - or not - your results. You'd no more provide your own code than any experimenter would provide their own apparatus.
What's important, twenty years along from Hansen et al 1988, is that it was predictively good. About 0.2C per decade, distributed very much as expected.




What is contemplated is trillions of dollars in taxes, fees, increased utility costs, gas price hikes, regulatory costs, and you advocate the righteousness of concealing the evidence on which public policy is predicated.
Some people might fall for that one.
By the way. How do you like that $10 USD/gallon gasoline price in England? Part of helping save the planet from global warming is letting the government take money out of your pocket a bit there, eh?