Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
I love how you folks are allowed to get away with the personal attacks on a daily basis, but if I put a toe over the line, 10 of my posts disappear. :(



The fields pull apart and their topology changes over time, but unlike you, I do care about the *PROPER USE* of "scientific terminology". In terms of PHYSICS, "magnetic attraction" isn't "reconnection".
If their topology changes, how can it do so without magnetic lines breaking and reconnecting? Two bar magnets spatially separated are trivially not topologically equivalent to two magnets touching, as the animation shows. Do you know what topological equivalence means? For something to change topologically, something must break and/or connect.

TOPOLOGICAL EQUIVALENCE

Try to learn something for a change before the usual knee jerk dismissal.
 
http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/physics/...-maxwells-equations/MIT8_02SC_notes26to30.pdf
Gauss's laws are satisfied *EVERYWHERE*, but nowhere is the "beginning" of a B line.
Once again we have the lies to children that professors tell undergraduates.

Gauss's laws are satisfied *EVERYWHERE*, even when a B line has a begiining or ending at a null point.
MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point II
W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection
MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting III

And from the same MIT course:
Eventually those field lines "break" and snap back toward the earth on the nightside. It is this process transferring solar wind energy into magnetic energy and thence into energy flowing into the earth's atmosphere as the magnetic field lines "snap" that drives the aurora. The aurora occur at the feet of the "last closed field line", which defines the auroral oval.
 
Last edited:
Michael Mozina's delusion that an argument from authority is valid

Hannes Alfven on the topic of magnetic reconnection/merging:
You are persisting with your delusion that an argument from authority is not a logical fallacy.

It is even worse when you lie about what the authority you quote (with random highlighting :(!) is talking about: Alfvén strongly stresses the danger of using the frozen-in concept (not MR).

It is even worse when you cite a speech (Alfvén's personal opinion) from 1986.

And he was wrong, just read any modern textbook on magnetic reconnection or someof MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting III
 
Michael Mozina's delusion that Gauss's law is only satisfied at a point in MR

Then provide a PUBLISHED reference, EXTERNAL TO CLINGER, that demonstrates this statement is false:

http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/physics/...-maxwells-equations/MIT8_02SC_notes26to30.pdf
MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting III

Gauss's law is satisfied *EVERYWHERE*, not just at a SINGLE point!
And you have brought up this fantasy enough to make it into a new delusion: W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection does not violate Gauss's law for magnetism anywhere for the simple reason that every field line that enters a surface is matched by a field line that exits the surface.

MR in vacuum or plasma does not violate Gauss's law for magnetism anywhere for the simple reason that every field line that enters a surface is matched by a field line that exits the surface.

The fact that there are no sources or sinks in W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection or MR shows that Gauss's law for magnetism is satisfied.
 
Last edited:
They just do. Shouldn't it be your job to demonstrate *YOUR* claims? What published work claims it's an example of "reconnection"?

Is that really the best response you have?
This is just logic; here is my demonstration:

In order for O → 0 0, the lines must break and reconnect. No stretching and twisting can accomplish that transformation. Similarly, the topology of the field of a single bar magnet (which is equivalent to two magnets in series) cannot be stretched and twisted to become the topology of the fields of two bar magnets.
QED
 
1000's of references on reconnection theory that are based on MHD theory and plasma don't help Clinger one iota.
MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting III
that includes:
MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting II
that includes REAL PUBLISHED REFERENCES to MR in vacuum (where field lines also break and reconnect):
do support W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.

Anyone with a basic knowledge of science (not you MM!) can understand W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection and see that MR happens in a vacuum and that B lines break and reconnect (as in the other MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting III).

On the other hand we have your inability to even understand the word vacuum and throwing arbitrary plasma into it (why not wires, electrons, protons or even charged pink unicorns :jaw-dropp!):
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VI

P.S.
MM: Explain your "0+0=0 and NOTHING begins there" statement
First asked 5th December 2011 (3 days ago and counting)
 
Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo VI: Mozina's links (3)

The fields pull apart and their topology changes over time, but unlike you, I do care about the *PROPER USE* of "scientific terminology". In terms of PHYSICS, "magnetic attraction" isn't "reconnection".

If their topology changes, how can it do so without magnetic lines breaking and reconnecting? Two bar magnets spatially separated are trivially not topologically equivalent to two magnets touching, as the animation shows. Do you know what topological equivalence means? For something to change topologically, something must break and/or connect.

TOPOLOGICAL EQUIVALENCE

If their topology changes, how can it do so without magnetic lines breaking and reconnecting?
They just do. Shouldn't it be your job to demonstrate *YOUR* claims? What published work claims it's an example of "reconnection"?


"They just do"? Don't you mean "It just does" (as in their topology changes but the lines don't reconnect)? "They just do" is plural so it can only refer to the only plural in the sentence, namely field lines, and the only thing they will "do" in this context is break & reconnect. Or is this perhaps your frank admission that field lines "just do" break & reconnect?

Here is a published work which specifies the equivalence between magnetic reconnection and changing topology.

Reference: Magnetic Reconnection; Masaaki Yamada, Russell Kulsrud & Hantao Ji (Center for Magnetic Self-Organization in Laboratory and Astrophysical Plasmas, Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory, Princeton University); Reviews of Modern Physics 82(1): 603-664, January-March 2010.

Yamada said:
Magnetic fields are observed at all scales in the Universe, in the Earth's dipole field, in the magnetosphere, in the solar corona, and on larger scale from the interstellar medium to galaxy clusters. How are magnetic fields generated in the Universe? How are they involved in determining the characteristics of plasmas? Understanding magnetic reconnection, a topological rearrangement of magnetic field lines, provides a key to these questions. In magnetized astrophysical and laboratory plasmas, magnetic reconnection rearranges the magnetic field-line configurations restructuring macroscopic quantities of plasmas such as flow and thermal energy.


This should not have been necessary. If you really understood the math & physics, as you claim you do, then you would realize, as I have pointed out before, that a change in the topology of the field requires the breaking and reconnection of field lines in an absolute & logically necessary sense.

You admit above in your own words, "The fields pull apart and their topology changes over time". Unlike you, I actually do care about the proper use of scientific terminology, which I also happen to know far better than you do. The change in topology of the magnetic field lines, which you describe, is the direct manifestation of magnetic reconnection. So you have boxed yourself into a neat corner. How will you get out? Either you have to reject your own observation that the topology changes, or you have to admit that magnetic reconnection really does happen, or you are going to have to convince everyone that you know more about electromagnetism and plasma physics, all by yourself, than do Masaaki, Kulsrud, Ji and the reviewers for Reviews of Modern Physics (you can always make the claim but don't hold your breath waiting for lots of agreement).
 
You don't understand the basic physics and math, and your interpretation is wrong.

The first part is a lie that MANY folks around here keep repeating over and over again. The second part, assuming it's true, *SHOULD BE* very easy to demonstrate. All you need are *external* references to support such claims.
 
Is that really the best response you have?

Sure. I'm not obligated to DISPROVE your handwave claims. You need to provide *EXTERNAL* evidence that ordinary attraction/flux change is a form of 'magnetic reconnection' in the absence of all plasma.

This is just logic; here is my demonstration:

Logically speaking stretching and twisting, and the proper selection of WHICH lines to draw would explain the phenomenon WITHOUT claiming any B lines begin, end or 'reconnect'. In an Occum's razor argument, you lose BIG TIME!

I'm really tired of you folks provide NO EXTERNAL REFERENCES TO SUPPORT YOUR CLAIMS. When can I expect to see actual "evidence' from some *EXTERNAL* source?
 
If you really understood the math & physics, as you claim you do, then you would realize, as I have pointed out before, that a change in the topology of the field requires the breaking and reconnection of field lines in an absolute & logically necessary sense.

No it DOES NOT! Magnetic flux changes can occur *WITHOUT* any sort of "reconnection" process taking place Tim. The LINES CAN SIMPLY MOVE as FULL UNITS, and CHANGE as full units in terms of their shape and strengths. They don't have to 'make or break' to MOVE or to INDUCE CURRENTS in plasma.

I ask you again for *EXTERNAL REFERENCES* that do *NOT* (NOT!) involve *PLASMAS*. I have no doubt CURRENTS can 'reconnect' in a plasma. I have no doubt that B field lines CANNOT begin or end or have a source or a sink without monopoles.

The references you keep citing all involved PLASMA!
 
Last edited:
In order for O → 0 0, the lines must break and reconnect. No stretching and twisting can accomplish that transformation. Similarly, the topology of the field of a single bar magnet (which is equivalent to two magnets in series) cannot be stretched and twisted to become the topology of the fields of two bar magnets.
QED
Sure. I'm not obligated to DISPROVE your handwave claims. You need to provide *EXTERNAL* evidence that ordinary attraction/flux change is a form of 'magnetic reconnection' in the absence of all plasma.



Logically speaking stretching and twisting, and the proper selection of WHICH lines to draw would explain the phenomenon WITHOUT claiming any B lines begin, end or 'reconnect'. In an Occum's razor argument, you lose BIG TIME!

I'm really tired of you folks provide NO EXTERNAL REFERENCES TO SUPPORT YOUR CLAIMS. When can I expect to see actual "evidence' from some *EXTERNAL* source?
No external evidence is required. There is no hand waving here; I have provided you with a straightforward topological argument. Either accept that magnetic lines break and reconnect or show us all how
O → 00
without lines breaking and reconnecting. Feel free to use Maxwell's equations or Occam's razor. :rolleyes:
It's that simple -- show us with whatever topological, other mathematical or logical argument you have -- or admit that you are wrong.
 
IMO it's "dishonest" of you to turn a scientific discussion into a PERSONAL attack. I've been VERY upfront about the fact that I personally believe that *CLINGER'S* (not my) claim that all lines CROSS in the middle is BS. I think it's MORE LIKELY NONE of the B lines actually get there, or "cross" there. It's a NULL *BECAUSE* no lines go through it. The process is most likely an INTERFERENCE issue that begins along the outer ring "brighter ring", and few and few loops go through any area as we move closer the X. By the time we get to X, NOTHING is crossing!

"I personally believe"? You assert that then you proclaim some dishonesty in addressing how you go about asserting not only what you just "personally believe" but the strawman claims you simply want to ascribe to others? Talk about dishonesty. Please show where anyone but you has claimed "lines CROSS" anywhere or stop trying to ascribe your own nonsense claims to others.

"MORE LIKELY NONE of the B lines actually get there"? So your previous claim of " They simply pass through the NULL with a zero field strength." is now " MORE LIKELY" false or is it that you just don't know what you want to claim to perpetuate what you "personally believe"?

"INTERFERENCE" is the wrong word as it specifically relates to waves. Cancelation would be more appropriate and yes opposing vectors do cancel at the null which is why there is no resulting field vector at that point (so much for your 0 + 0 = 0) and thus no field line to represent that lack of a magnetic field vector. Again you seem to be getting closer but still have some serious disconnect simply because of what you " personally believe".

You folks are the ones *INSISTING* that every freshman physics textbook on the planet is *WRONG*, not me. How HONEST is that behavior considering the fact that NONE of you have produced a PUBLISHED, PEER REVIEWED WORK to support any of your *MANY* fallacious claims?

From a *PURELY MATHEMATICAL* perspective, yes, you might *THINK* of a bunch of lines crossing at ZERO, but even in basic EM theory, they make it clear the NO B LINES CROSS! Clinger has made ONE FRESHMAN MISTAKE AFTER ANOTHER AFTER ANOTHER.

Again evidently just "you might *THINK* of a bunch of lines crossing at ZERO" stop trying to ascribe your nonsense claims to others. By all means, please, show from " a *PURELY MATHEMATICAL* perspective how one might "*THINK* of a bunch of lines crossing at ZERO" or stop pretending your nonsense claim is any kind of "*PURELY MATHEMATICAL* perspective".
 
Once again, as I never claimed it was "just in the NULL", the "handwaving" and obviously futile strawman are still simply just yours (maybe you should have had a different entrée as the dinner doesn't seem to have helped you much).

Though as noted by Tim Thompson before, you agree, and explicitly state above, that "Guass's law is satisfied in the NULL".

So what? Gauss's law is satisfied *EVERYWHERE*, not ONLY in NULLS! What a LAME argument!

Again read the post you just quoted, as the purported "LAME argument" was simply yours both it and the continuing, obviously dishonest and futile strawman tactic remain simply just yours.
 
Excuse me? It's *DISHONEST AS HELL* of you to try to claim that B lines can "begin" in the absence of a monopole. It is dishonest to argue with nothing more than HANDWAVES rather than published works. It's DISHONEST to claim that it's "super-significant' that Gauss's laws are satisfied in ONE point when they are in fact satisfied *EVERYWHERE*! This whole conversation is dishonest because your side has presented no science. It simply attacks the individual repetitiously and loudly and tosses in PERSONAL HANDWAVES by the bucket load. Those are purely dishonest debate tactics from start to end. Do not even *THINK* about lecturing me about "honesty".


I might be inclined to excuse you if there was any indication that your repeated misrepresentations were based on some simple misunderstanding that you were honestly trying to correct, but they are evidently simply deliberate. "It's DISHONEST to claim that it's "super-significant' that Gauss's laws are satisfied in ONE point..."? Well since you're the only one to make such a ""super-significant'" claim you're obviously aware of your own deliberate dishonesty. Rest assured that the lectures on honesty will continue as long as your deliberate dishonesty does.
 
I already gave you a "science" based response. You FALLACIOUSLY believe that all errors/truths are MATHEMATICAL in nature. That's ridiculous. In this case his error isn't MATHEMATICAL at all. It's CONCEPTUAL in nature. CONCEPTUALLY, B lines *DO NOT* begin, end, have a source or a sink. That is a CONCEPTUAL understanding of how our universe functions that *MUST* be applied to all discussions related to particle and plasma physics.

So long as you VIOLATE that basic CONCEPTUAL understanding of the PHYSICAL NATURE of B lines, what else can I say? You're in pure denial of how THIS PHYSICAL UNIVERSE OPERATES at a FUNDAMENTAL level, rather than the function of some mythical monopole universe. At a fundamental level, B lines *DO NOT* begin, end, have a source or a sink. Only E fields can do that. All B lines are a result of the MOVEMENT OF CURRENT, and they from as continuous loops as that A diagram I posted earlier demonstrates.

Gauss's laws isn't *ONLY* preserved in Origin the Dud, it's preserved *EVERYWHERE IN THE EXPERIMENT* PS! Origin isn't unique. Get off your knees already.

You are confusing (perhaps deliberately) a concept with dogma. Expecting, and even asserting as you do, that " THIS PHYSICAL UNIVERSE OPERATES at a FUNDAMENTAL level" by some dogmatic concept of yours, your the only one on their knees.

So let me get this right you claim a null point "isn't unique" because it has no magnetic field vector like most other points in the field? You might want to get off your knees so that you would have a leg to stand on.
 
What LINES OF FORCE? You don't even have any evidence that any actual *LINES OF FORCE* go through X in the first place!

Well you're the only one that claimed...

They simply pass through the NULL with a zero field strength.

So you're now asserting that "You don't even have any evidence" for that claim. Hey you might just be starting to get the hang of this honesty thing after all.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom