Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
That's easy...we wait to see what you think, that way, we will know the opposite to be the truth.

It's the only way to be sure.

Without source code, and based on the fact the source points MOVE, I'd have to assume it's based on MHD theory, leaving Clinger stuck in a vacuum without a plasma particle to his name. :)
 
It's physically WRONG however. Every line created by every pole is continuous, without beginning and without ending. No point is "special" or unique. Every POINT conforms to Gauss's law of magnetism that assures us no B lines begin or end! It really is that simple.
Yes, no point is special. The neutral point is simply a point that has no magnetic energy. So, we can say lines end and/or begin there. It has already been shown that this is consistent with ∇⋅ B = 0 -- everywhere -- including the neutral point.

Mathematically speaking, Clinger's example only applies in monopolism. Only if monopoles exist can B lines have "beginnings" and "endings". In our "real" universe, all the loops simply AVOID the actual X point. Nothing "begins" there, and nothing ends there. It's just another ordinary point in spacetime that conforms with Gauss's laws.

You keep saying that again and again but provide no evidence in the form of a mathematically based argument. Show why monopoles are required and how "all the loops simply AVOID the actual X point" with a real scientifically and mathematically based demonstration -- or stop saying it over and over like some religious chant.
 
Last edited:
Yes, no point is special. The neutral point is simply a point that has no magnetic energy. So, we can say lines end and/or begin there.

NO! You can only say that *NO* (as in zero) lines BEGIN *OR* END there, just as no lines begin or end anywhere else. In fact no lines even necessarily pass through there! That's your *CONCEPTUAL* problem in a nutshell.
 
Last edited:
W.D. Clinger is an Associate Professor in the College of Computer and Information Science at Northeastern University; his PhD (in computer science I presume) was earned at M.I.T.
My PhD is actually in mathematics. I was admitted to and completed my PhD in MIT's pure math program.

It would also be correct to say my PhD is in both mathematics and computer science, because my PhD dissertation was interdisciplinary. My dissertation advisor, Professor Carl Hewitt of MIT's EE&CS department, completed his own PhD through MIT's pure math program.

Anyone who cannot follow the jargon has no business making assertions about the meaning of the papers. This certainly includes Mozina but it also includes well educated scientists from some unrelated discipline; there is no reason to assume that someone with a PhD in pure mathematics, for instance, will immediately understand all of the jargon in a plasma physics paper, without making an effort to learn that jargon.
Although I had enough background in physics and applied math to be familiar with some of the jargon (such as "open" versus "closed" field lines), I still had to make an effort to understand the jargon of plasma physics, and I still don't understand very much of it.

In particular, it took some effort to understand the main results of Dungey's 1958 paper, partly because that paper contains some minor errors, partly because it's a response to a paper I haven't read, but mainly because it concerns the subject of plasma physics. On the other hand, the magnetic fields shown in figures 1 and 2 of Dungey's paper are the obvious keys to that paper. Because I took a good freshman-level course in electromagnetism (using Volume 2 of the Berkeley Physics Course, Purcell's Electricity and Magnetism), it was obvious to me that those magnetic fields can be reproduced in a vacuum, without plasma.

Michael Mozina is still in denial about that.
 
My PhD is actually in mathematics. I was admitted to and completed my PhD in MIT's pure math program.

The two of you need to stop erroneously using appeals to authority fallacies rather than real scientific arguments. I already provided you with a published work from MIT that REFUTES your claims! Since Tim's last paper is based on MHD theory, you're still stuck in a vacuum without a plasma particle to your name. If you don't have a published reference that claims reconnection occurs in the absence of plasma, when can I expect you to submit your UTTER NONSENSE for peer review?
 
Last edited:
Although I had enough background in physics and applied math to be familiar with some of the jargon (such as "open" versus "closed" field lines), I still had to make an effort to understand the jargon of plasma physics, and I still don't understand very much of it.

That much is very clear. When you finally understand that electrical discharges can and do occur in plasmas and solar flares, and the "reconnection" process is *NOT* "plasma optional", then you will finally "understand" the plasma physics term "reconnection".
 
The two of you need to stop erroneously using appeals to authority fallacies rather than real scientific arguments. I already provided you with a published work from MIT that REFUTES your claims!
Yet Michael Mozina wonders why his irony meters keep exploding.

Michael Mozina has cited course notes that repeat a white lie that's often told to freshmen.

Since Tim's last paper is based on MHD theory, you're still stuck in a vacuum without a plasma particle to your name. If you don't have a published reference that claims reconnection occurs in the absence of plasma, when can I expect you to submit your UTTER NONSENSE for peer review?
In reality, which Michael Mozina takes such great pains to avoid, Tim Thompson just posted several references that do exactly what Michael Mozina says we have not done. Those citations include
Michael Mozina is also ignoring Somov's section 4.4.2 on "Magnetic Reconnection in a Vacuum".
 
Michael Mozina has cited course notes that repeat a white lie that's often told to freshmen.

*IF* that were true (and it's not), then you should be able to show me some PUBLISHED references that explain the fact it's a 'little white lie'. You're just telling another WHOPPER of a lie, which is why you won't produce anything *PUBLISHED* to support that claim either.

I didn't TWIST YOUR ARM to make you LEAVE OUT PLASMA and cut yourself off from MHD theory in the process. You chose to do that all on your own. It was your fatal mistake.
 
In reality, which Michael Mozina takes such great pains to avoid, Tim Thompson just posted several references that do exactly what Michael Mozina says we have not done. Those citations include
Michael Mozina is also ignoring Somov's section 4.4.2 on "Magnetic Reconnection in a Vacuum".

In reality I have gone though each of those references and noted where they either USE CURRENT, or MHD theory, leaving you utterly stranded in a vacuum without a single reference, or legitimate scientific support for *YOUR PERSONAL* claims. Stop trying to ride everyone ELSE's PLASMA PHYSICS coattails. You specifically claimed you could create reconnection *WITHOUT* plasma.
 
Perpetual Student
Yes, no point is special. The neutral point is simply a point that has no magnetic energy. So, we can say lines end and/or begin there. It has already been shown that this is consistent with ∇⋅ B = 0 -- everywhere -- including the neutral point.



Originally Posted by Perpetual Student
Yes, no point is special. The neutral point is simply a point that has no magnetic energy. So, we can say lines end and/or begin there.


NO! You can only say that *NO* (as in zero) lines BEGIN *OR* END there, just as no lines begin or end anywhere else. In fact no lines even necessarily pass through there! That's your *CONCEPTUAL* problem in a nutshell.


Mozina, what do you think magnetic lines are? They are mathematical abstractions that successfully model the behavior of the real world. There are no "real lines"! Gauss, Faraday and Maxwell, etc. created a model that reliably reflects the behavior of electromagnetic phenomena. If the model shows that the lines begin and end, they do; that's how physics works! There is no other physics outside of the model.
 
Mozina, what do you think magnetic lines are? They are mathematical abstractions that successfully model the behavior of the real world. There are no "real lines"!

You're right of course, they are entire *FIELDS*.

Gauss, Faraday and Maxwell, etc. created a model that reliably reflects the behavior of electromagnetic phenomena.

Sure, but that is all done *WITHOUT* claiming that B lines begin and end in EM theory.

If the model shows that the lines begin and end, they do; that's how physics works! There is no other physics outside of the model.

The *MODEL* that Clinger describes is a MONOPOLE UNIVERSE MODEL, not the universe we live in. In *THIS* universe that we live in, B lines do not begin at *ANY* point, even though Gauss's laws are satisfied at *EVERY* point. In this universe no B lines begin ANYWHERE, even though Gauss's laws are satisfied *EVERYWHERE*.
 
Last edited:
You're right of course, they are entire *FIELDS*.
The concept of "field" is also a mathematical model.

Sure, but that is all done *WITHOUT* claiming that B lines begin and end in EM theory.
Show me how and where, using Maxwell's equations, the above is demonstrated

The *MODEL* that Clinger describes is a MONOPOLE UNIVERSE MODEL, not the universe we live in. In *THIS* universe that we live in, B lines do not begin at *ANY* point, even though Gauss's laws are satisfied at *EVERY* point. In this universe no B lines begin ANYWHERE, even though Gauss's laws are satisfied *EVERYWHERE*.
Perhaps you do not know what is meant by a mathematical model. Clinger is not describing a model. He is using a universally accepted model to demonstrate something that is true within that model.
 
The concept of "field" is also a mathematical model.

Ya, but it's a more "wholistic" concept that more correctly describes the continuity of the WHOLE CONTINUOUS THING.

Show me how and where ,using Maxwell's equations, the above is demonstrated

Pick up an freshman physics textbook that describes an ordinary quadrapole (electro)magnet experiment. Clinger already admitted his freshman textbook doesn't even once mention the term "reconnection" at all.

Perhaps you do not know what is meant by a mathematical model. Clinger is not describing a model. He is using a universally accepted model to demonstrate something that is true within that model.

I hate to burst your bubble, but not every mathematical abstraction is "true" any more than "epicycles" are true today.

His mathematical model is fine in monopoleverse. In this universe however, B lines have no source, no sink, no beginning and no end.
 
Last edited:
LOL!
...
I just LOVE how you DON'T CARE that Priests MONOPOLE DEVICE is a CURRENT. :) Wow!
LOL
I just LOVE how you DON'T CARE TO UNDERSTAND that Priests MONOPOLE DEVICE is a MATHEMATICAL TECHNIQUE. :) Wow

I just love how you persist with your delusions about the paper, e.g. that equation 17 is derived from equation 16 and that there are actual MONOPOLES in the paper when they explicitly say there are no actual MONOPOLES!

Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper V
 
MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting III

do I understand math *AND* physics, I pointed out YOUR error for you.
You are lying, MM.
You have not pointed out any error in W.D. Clinger's math from any of Michael Mozina claims to have "studied Calculus formally for years".

All you have been doing is screaming your ignorance of physics and the inability to learn:
MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point II

We have to wonder about what you think about the scentists who state the B lines break and reconnect (MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting II).
Are they all stupid MM? Maybe it is a great big conspiracy MM? Or something else, MM?

Michael Mozina
Why are these scientists who know more about the math and physics involved than you (and me!) all wrong when they state that B lines break and reconnect?

A hint - it would be stupid to cite undergraduate physics where 'lies to children' are stated about B lines never ending.
 
MM: Explain your "0+0=0 and NOTHING begins there" statement

Been there, done that for a year now. 0+0=0 and NOTHING begins there.


And for a year now you have been regurgitating this gibberish.
  • What is the first zero?
  • What is the second zero?
  • What is the operation of addition being used to add these 'zeros'?
  • What is the resulting third zero?
  • What is the NOTHING?
 
Those neutral points are pretty unusual, hence interesting. Their rarity is the reason the popular myth about magnetic field lines neither beginning nor ending is a reasonable white lie for professors to tell freshmen.
There are a few of these white lies (I prefer lies to children) that professors tell undergraduates.
The one I remember best is how physicists first get introduced to tensors. They start as neat ways to summarize systems of equations as matrices!
It is not until later you are introduced to their more fundemental nature, e.g. a way to express the laws of physics independently of coordinate transformations.

And one example from my previous area of expertise. To an undergraduate a crystal is a periodic, ordered structure. But later on you learn about quasicrystals which are ordered but not perioidic!
 
You keep handwaving about the fact that Guass's law is satisfied in the NULL. So what? That same law is satisfied EVERYWHERE, not just in the NULL. The same number of lines that enter ANY region, exit that same region. That is fundamental TRUTH of basic EM theory.
...snipped rant...
That is fundamental TRUTH of basic EM theory. The same number of lines that enter ANY region, exit that same region (Gauss's law of magnetism).
Thus a field line that crosses a null point obeys Gauss's law of magnetism.

What you have been ignoring is that the definition of a field line means that there can be no field line at the null point.
MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point II
The result is that the field line has to end before the null point and start after the null point. The line has broken.
 
You remain ignorant that you are the only one here claiming that monopoles are needed for magnetic reconnection. Citing the lies to children that professors tell undergraduates and are repeated on web sites it stupid.
You need to learn more advanced physics. If you are too lazy to do so or just cannot do so (or there is some reason you cannot understand this physics) then you need to trust people who are not lazy and have learned the phsyics, e.g. the scientists who work with magnetic reconnection.
MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting III

Or even the other people in this thread :eye-poppi !
 
Then the PRIMARY DIFFERENCE is Priest and Schriver must use PLASMA and MHD theory to get that movement, leaving Clinger still swinging in the breeze without a plasma particle to his name.
The primary difference is that you think that Priest and Schriver is the basis of W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.
It is not. They have a "toy model of vacuum reconnection". To anyone who can read English this is a toy model of magnetic reconnection in vacuum. The toy model is different from W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection.

W.D. Clinger's simple derivation of magnetic reconnection is undergraduate science. To understand it all you need is freshman math - something that you claim to know - and undergraduate physics (maybe 2nd year rather than freshman), which you are totally ignorant of given your rants about B field lines, e.g. MM: Explain your "0+0=0 and NOTHING begins there" statement and you bit about pressure somehow excluding magnetic field lines from a null point.

That MR happens in vacuum is supported by the scientific literature:


MM: 1000's of references for MR = field lines breaking and reconnecting II includes:
Then you have your delusions bout Somov:
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section VI
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom