Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
"I personally believe"? You assert that then you proclaim some dishonesty in addressing how you go about asserting not only what you just "personally believe" but the strawman claims you simply want to ascribe to others? Talk about dishonesty. Please show where anyone but you has claimed "lines CROSS" anywhere or stop trying to ascribe your own nonsense claims to others.

OMG! This has been *CLINGER'S* handwavy claim for OVER A YEAR NOW! He is the one that drew several lines going INTO and OUT OF ONE SINGLE POINT, not me. Stop blaming me for being confused over HIS HANDWAVES since NONE of them have been published, and I got them in INSTALLMENTS!

I'm bored silly of this conversation now. Not one of you have provided an *EXTERNAL* reference that states that B lines "BEGIN" in a NULL! It's just one constant PERSONAL HANDWAVE AFTER ANOTHER around here, combined with a HEALTHY DOSE OF PERSONAL ATTACKS in every post.

You for instance REFUSE to keep the conversation focused in any way, instead you go for the "dishonesty" BS. Never once have you noted or accepted the fact that NONE OF YOU have provided ANY PUBLISHED REFERENCES to support CLINGER'S claim that B lines "begin" somewhere! Oy Vey. Talk about DISHONEST DEBATE! This has been the handwave from hell!

"MORE LIKELY NONE of the B lines actually get there"? So your previous claim of " They simply pass through the NULL with a zero field strength." is now " MORE LIKELY" false or is it that you just don't know what you want to claim to perpetuate what you "personally believe"?

I've explained this over and over again. I don't have any reason to believe ANYTHING reaches, begins, ends, is a source or a sink at ORIGIN the DUD!

Clinger's use of vector calculus at *ONE* POINT was bogus from the start. No lines "begin" there. No lines "end" there. No lines have a "source' there. No lines have a 'sink" there. No lines even necessarily *GO THERE IN THE FIRST PLACE*! It's not "special" in terms of satisfying Gauss's law. It's just ANOTHER BORING POINT where no lines begin or end.

Either produce a valid published reference that claims B lines "begin" at various/special "points" without plasma, or admit it's nothing but a KLUDGED claim.
 
Last edited:
Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo VI: Mozina's links (4)

This should not have been necessary. If you really understood the math & physics, as you claim you do, then you would realize, as I have pointed out before, that a change in the topology of the field requires the breaking and reconnection of field lines in an absolute & logically necessary sense.
No it DOES NOT!
YES IT DOES.


I ask you again for *EXTERNAL REFERENCES* that do *NOT* (NOT!) involve *PLASMAS*. ,,, The references you keep citing all involved PLASMA!


I already have. The references I have given you do not involve plasma and neither does this one. Stop demanding that I give you more sources that do not deal with plasma and deal with the real physics for a change. You are the one who admitted in your own words that that the field line topology changes and that is essentially the definition of magnetic reconnection. So, like I said ...

You admit above in your own words, "The fields pull apart and their topology changes over time". Unlike you, I actually do care about the proper use of scientific terminology, which I also happen to know far better than you do. The change in topology of the magnetic field lines, which you describe, is the direct manifestation of magnetic reconnection. So you have boxed yourself into a neat corner. How will you get out? Either you have to reject your own observation that the topology changes, or you have to admit that magnetic reconnection really does happen, or you are going to have to convince everyone that you know more about electromagnetism and plasma physics, all by yourself, than do Masaaki, Kulsrud, Ji and the reviewers for Reviews of Modern Physics (you can always make the claim but don't hold your breath waiting for lots of agreement).


Face the physics. It will do you good.
 
YES IT DOES.

No, it doesn't.

I already have. The references I have given you do not involve plasma

WHICH ONE?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?


You are the one who admitted in your own words that that the field line topology changes and that is essentially the definition of magnetic reconnection. So, like I said ...

No. No lines need to DISCONNECT in order for FLUX CHANGE to occur Tim.
 
You are confusing (perhaps deliberately) a concept with dogma. Expecting, and even asserting as you do, that " THIS PHYSICAL UNIVERSE OPERATES at a FUNDAMENTAL level" by some dogmatic concept of yours, your the only one on their knees.

So let me get this right you claim a null point "isn't unique" because it has no magnetic field vector like most other points in the field? You might want to get off your knees so that you would have a leg to stand on.

This physical universe has no monopoles, and B lines have no source or sink, making it *IMPOSSIBLE* for B lines to "begin" anywhere. Deal with it.
 
Tim, that last reference by Priest was ALL ABOUT THE PHOTOSPHERE AND CORONA. They didn't even draw full loops ANYWHERE, and the whole thing is based on plasma movements in the photosphere! Whatever code they use *MUST* involve MHD theory.
 
I've seen denial play out in threads before, but this particular thread is AMAZING.

Do any of you even accept that electrical discharges occur in plasmas and flares yet?

WOW!
 
Face the physics. It will do you good.

Speaking of facing facts, when did you intend to face that fact that without a MONOPOLE, it's impossible for B *LINES* to have beginnings and endings? When did you intend to face the fact that plasma and current are not OPTIONAL in the 'reconnection' process Tim?
 
OMG! This has been *CLINGER'S* handwavy claim for OVER A YEAR NOW! He is the one that drew several lines going INTO and OUT OF ONE SINGLE POINT, not me.


That isn't what W.D.Clinger actually presented.

Stop blaming me for being confused over HIS HANDWAVES since NONE of them have been published, and I got them in INSTALLMENTS!

I'm bored silly of this conversation now. Not one of you have provided an *EXTERNAL* reference that states that B lines "BEGIN" in a NULL!


Misrepresenting the explanations or claiming they have not been provided would be dishonest. Claiming the explanations are wrong because of misunderstanding them would be an argument from ignorance.

It's just one constant PERSONAL HANDWAVE AFTER ANOTHER around here, combined with a HEALTHY DOSE OF PERSONAL ATTACKS in every post.


Pointing out the ridiculousness of the criticisms of magnetic reconnection should not be mistaken for personal attacks. The criticisms merit the ridicule they are receiving.

You for instance REFUSE to keep the conversation focused in any way, instead you go for the "dishonesty" BS. Never once have you noted or accepted the fact that NONE OF YOU have provided ANY PUBLISHED REFERENCES to support CLINGER'S claim that B lines "begin" somewhere! Oy Vey. Talk about DISHONEST DEBATE! This has been the handwave from hell!


This is demonstrably untrue. But my previous comment also applies here: Misrepresenting the explanations or claiming they have not been provided would be dishonest. Claiming the explanations are wrong because of misunderstanding them would be an argument from ignorance.

I've explained this over and over again. I don't have any reason to believe ANYTHING reaches, begins, ends, is a source or a sink at ORIGIN the DUD!


This is an argument from incredulity and a straw man, a dishonest caricature of the explanations provided.

Clinger's use of vector calculus at *ONE* POINT was bogus from the start. No lines "begin" there. No lines "end" there. No lines have a "source' there. No lines have a 'sink" there. No lines even necessarily *GO THERE IN THE FIRST PLACE*! It's not "special" in terms of satisfying Gauss's law. It's just ANOTHER BORING POINT where no lines begin or end.


And again: Misrepresenting the explanations would be dishonest. Claiming the explanations are wrong because of misunderstanding them would be an argument from ignorance.

Either produce a valid published reference that claims B lines "begin" at various/special "points" without plasma, or admit it's nothing but a KLUDGED claim.


Several valid published references have been provided. Claiming they have not been would be dishonest. Claiming the references don't contain the requested explanations because of misunderstanding or ignoring them would be an argument from ignorance.
 
Last edited:
OMG! This has been *CLINGER'S* handwavy claim for OVER A YEAR NOW! He is the one that drew several lines going INTO and OUT OF ONE SINGLE POINT, not me. Stop blaming me for being confused over HIS HANDWAVES since NONE of them have been published, and I got them in INSTALLMENTS!

So you can't show where he claimed the lines cross. I, however can show you where he specifically refutes the claim you have dishonestly tried to attribute to him.


All of the dishonesty quoted below comes from yesterday's posts by Michael Mozina.


It was Michael Mozina who claimed (on 14 November 2011) that magnetic field lines cross at the X.

Magnetic field lines cannot cross. I have corrected Michael Mozina on this point several times. When Michael Mozina pretends his mistake was mine, he is being dishonest.


I'm bored silly of this conversation now. Not one of you have provided an *EXTERNAL* reference that states that B lines "BEGIN" in a NULL! It's just one constant PERSONAL HANDWAVE AFTER ANOTHER around here, combined with a HEALTHY DOSE OF PERSONAL ATTACKS in every post.


Again I'd recommend you take more honest approach to this conversation if you are " bored silly" by your current antics.

You for instance REFUSE to keep the conversation focused in any way, instead you go for the "dishonesty" BS. Never once have you noted or accepted the fact that NONE OF YOU have provided ANY PUBLISHED REFERENCES to support CLINGER'S claim that B lines "begin" somewhere! Oy Vey. Talk about DISHONEST DEBATE! This has been the handwave from hell!

Your dishonesty is the only consistent aspect of your part of this conversation. If you want that focus to change than just stop your obviously dishonest BS.




I've explained this over and over again. I don't have any reason to believe ANYTHING reaches, begins, ends, is a source or a sink at ORIGIN the DUD!

There's that dishonesty again, you've already asserted that Gauss's law holds at the null point and everywhere else. So unless your claiming a null region around that null point (is that what your claiming?) then the point is surrounded by field vectors that can be represented by field lines that terminate at that null point. Again there just needs to be as many beginning there as end there to have Gauss's law hold at that point.

Perhaps you just wanted to say that you have personal reasons you don't want "to believe ANYTHING reaches, begins, ends, is a source or a sink at ORIGIN the DUD!"?

We've explained this over and over again to you, with no magnetic field vector at the null point the magnetic field line end as well as start at that point.



Clinger's use of vector calculus at *ONE* POINT was bogus from the start. No lines "begin" there. No lines "end" there. No lines have a "source' there. No lines have a 'sink" there. No lines even necessarily *GO THERE IN THE FIRST PLACE*! It's not "special" in terms of satisfying Gauss's law. It's just ANOTHER BORING POINT where no lines begin or end.

Your claim that it was "vector calculus at *ONE* POINT" as well as your claim that it is "special" in terms of satisfying Gauss's law" were both "bogus from the start". "No lines even necessarily *GO THERE IN THE FIRST PLACE*!" So your claim is that a null point is surrounded by a null area or volume? If not then the null point is surrounded by points with field vectors that can be represented by field lines approaching and end or beginning an leaving that null point (otherwise it would not be null point and satisfy Gauss's law)


Either produce a valid published reference that claims B lines "begin" at various/special "points" without plasma, or admit it's nothing but a KLUDGED claim.

"a valid published reference"? Just what in your mind would constitute such 'validity'?

Are you still claiming...

They simply pass through the NULL with a zero field strength.

Or are you sticking with...


.. NO lines reach X to begin with, the PRESSURE keeps them from actually crossing.



Either produce a valid published reference that claims "NO lines reach X to begin with, the PRESSURE keeps them from actually crossing" or that "They simply pass through the NULL with a zero field strength." (with or without plasma), or admit it is just your understanding of magnetic fields (and vector fields in general) that is simply, well, "KLUDGED".
 
I have provided you with a straightforward topological argument. Either accept that magnetic lines break and reconnect or show us all how
O → 00
without lines breaking and reconnecting. Feel free to use Maxwell's equations or Occam's razor.
It's that simple -- show us with whatever topological, other mathematical or logical argument you have -- or admit that you are wrong.
:popcorn1
 
So you can't show where he claimed the lines cross. I, however can show you where he specifically refutes the claim you have dishonestly tried to attribute to him.

Huh? HE DREW THE LINES COMING TO A POINT, NOT ME! He also claimed that lines BEGIN there, not me!

Again I'd recommend you take more honest approach to this conversation if you are " bored silly" by your current antics.

I'd recommend you quit DISHONESTLY trying to shift the burden of proof. I'm not leaning on him to prove lines CROSS, I'm leaning on him to prove lines *BEGIN*. That was the CLAIM that I balked at!

Where's the PUBLISHED EVIDENCE? QUIT DISHONESTLY dodging THE ISSUE! I didn't ask him to prove ANYTHING about them CROSSING. I asked him to demonstrate they have a BEGINNING!
 
Last edited:

What are you waiting for anyway? All one would have to do is draw TWO LOOPS in the second image, one that CHANGES TOPOLOGY (doesn't disconnect, just shrinks/stretches) and a NEW ONE on the second magnet that weaker and wasn't shown in the first image. It's simply gotten STRONGER since the first image, so it's shown in the second image! Holy cow. You people are AMAZING!
 
Last edited:
This whole conversation is surreal. None of you have provided PUBLISHED references to support ANYTHING related to B lines having a "beginning"! It's just waves of handwaves and personal attacks, one wave after another, after another. Don't you folks even UNDERSTAND HOW SCIENCE DEBATE WORKS? OMG. Do any of you understand what an external published work is?

PLASMA PHYSICS can't save Clinger. Clinger made a DIFFERENT claim than any paper based on MHD theory. Clinger claimed reconnection as described by Dungey did NOT require a plasma. He claims B lines "begin" too. I've yet to see ANYTHING PUBLISHED to substantiate that claim!
 
Clinger's KLUDGED concept of physics began here:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7739880&postcount=4661

Myth 3: Magnetic field lines can neither begin nor end
In my two colored graphs of the magnetic field around four conducting rods, there are two magnetic field lines that begin at the neutral point and two other magnetic field lines that end at the neutral point......

The idea that Gauss's law prevents magnetic field lines from beginning or ending is a fairy tale. Gauss's law doesn't really talk about magnetic field lines at all. Gauss's law is really about certain integrals and limits.

......

Gauss's law for magnetism says the magnetic flux through any smooth closed surface is zero. That's true at the neutral point: Intuitively speaking, the two lines that end there are offset by the two lines that begin there.

This was the claim by CLINGER that is utterly BOGUS and that has NEVER been supported with *EXTERNAL* (to CLINGER) published references of any form.

I've provided over a dozen curriculum publications from various college and universities that all explained that B lines *DO NOT* "begin". They do NOT end. They do NOT have a source. They do NOT have a sink. They do NOT begin, because there are no MONOPOLES in *THIS UNIVERSE*.
 
Last edited:
I don't care ONE IOTA about any *OTHER* issues or any other claims related to those lines. Clinger's claim that B lines "begin" and "end" at *ANY* point, including Origin the DUD, is pure BS. It's pure PERSONAL HANDWAVE. No supporting evidence *EXTERNAL TO CLINGER* has been provided to support that claim! Gauss's laws are satisfied *EVERYWHERE*, but no lines begin *ANYWHERE*.
 
Last edited:
http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/physics/...-maxwells-equations/MIT8_02SC_notes26to30.pdf

This implies that the number of magnetic field lines entering a closed surface is equal to the number of field lines leaving the surface. That is, there is no source or sink. In addition, the lines must be continuous with no starting or end points. In fact, as shown in Figure 13.2.1(b) for a bar magnet, the field lines that emanate from the north pole to the south pole outside the magnet return within the magnet and form a closed loop.
 
What are you waiting for anyway? All one would have to do is draw TWO LOOPS in the second image, one that CHANGES TOPOLOGY (doesn't disconnect, just shrinks/stretches) and a NEW ONE on the second magnet that weaker and wasn't shown in the first image. It's simply gotten STRONGER since the first image, so it's shown in the second image! Holy cow. You people are AMAZING!


That's not how topology works. It's pretty simple math stuff. But just taking wild uninformed guesses is likely to result in an incorrect answer. As it has above. In spades.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom