Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Thanks for quoting this GM; with MM on Ignore, I would not have seen it otherwise.

What forum (or fora) is MM referring to?

Here is a recent comment, by a mod on the Thunderdolts forum, on MM's website (the last four lines are links, in the original):

There's some pretty damning words in those four Teapots; for example "It is a pity that the “Iron Sun” researchers [that means you, MM, among others] are not conversant with plasma cosmology and the Electric Sun model." Ouch! :p


So who would've guessed iron Sun researchers are not conversant with plasma cosmology and the electric Sun model? Interesting, but certainly not surprising that even the fringe element, supporters of other crackpot conjectures, recognize the iron Sun notion as unsupportable, even further out past the edge than their own nutty ideas. Also interesting is that each of the four "Iron Sun Debate" links makes note of Oliver Manuel's wacky claims. It seems the electric Sun pushers want to distance themselves from Manuel, his associates, and the iron Sun conjecture in general. Who can blame them? Oliver Manuel has an unsupportable conjecture. But...

Oliver Manuel, in at least three of his papers, uses some radically misinterpreted satellite imagery to support his crackpot claims. These are just plain foolish bunny-in-the-cloud mistakes with absolutely no support aside from someone's say-so. They're backed with no expertise, no quantitative foundation, nothing. Tracing it back a few years it looks like one fellow put up a web site around 2005 with satellite pictures and running difference thermal graphs from the SOHO and TRACE programs, implying that somehow NASA has provided pictures that show a solid surface under the photosphere. And Oliver Manuel was exactly stupid enough to fall for that. It's all an attempt to defraud the scientific community, either intentionally or through sheer ignorance, and it's based in great part on some completely incorrect interpretation of those images.

On various forums for over five years I have made efforts to get any solid surface Sun proponents to quantitatively explain the details of any of that imagery. In my attempt to get an explanation, I have described to them how each pixel in each image comes to be the color that it is. I have quantitatively explained those satellite images, and I have asked how they could possibly show something beyond the optically opaque photosphere. But every effort I've made has been met with sheer ignorance. I've been insulted, badgered, and belittled for my expertise. And the best any electric/solid-surface Sun proponent has to offer is, "It looks like a solid surface so it is!" Well it's BS, nothing but a crazy hoax that started with an amateur level misunderstanding of a silly optical illusion. It grew to hook a handful of gullible rubes like Oliver Manuel who built even more mistakes on top of it.

And now all those crackpots are quoting each other about seeing something under the photosphere. They're radically misunderstanding how iron is involved in obtaining those EUV images. And it all started with one simple but obvious mistake. It's a circular argument passed around among a handful of believers, each using the other as their source, and none realizing just how completely empty their arguments are. So given the roots of the problem and the fact that the iron Sun nonsense appears to be wholly unsupportable, you can't hardly blame the electric Sun contingent from wanting to avoid association with the continued failure of the iron Sun proponents.
 
Good post GeeMack. Here we have a field within which thousands of highly trained specialists (many are quite brilliant) have used all the available tools and knowledge of science to construct a coherent theory of the sun.
But then, we have these other untrained people (like Mozina) who reject that theory and replace it with a bunch of homespun conjectures that can easily be shown to be inconsistent with the known laws of physics. It is an amazing thing and a sad commentary that there is no argument or demonstration that can show these people that their amateurish homespun musings are dead wrong -- even after it has been made apparent that their training is woefully inadequate to construct any viable conjecture about the topic.
 
Magnetic Reconnection In Vacuo IX

There is no other way to describe the behaviors of someone who IGNORES THE MATH AND PHYSICS provided by someone like Alfven or by Mann and Onel, and yet thinks "reconnection" happens in the *ABSENCE* of any plasma! It's like chatting with creationists. The data is irrelevant.


I have made several posts since last May that thoroughly demonstrate the serious fallacy of believing that magnetic reconnection does not happen in a vacuum. Here is the primary set of posts.


From post IV:
Also recall the abstract already referenced by Reality Check: Magnetic reconnection on the sun by E.R. Priest, from the book "Basic Plasma Processes on the Sun", Kluwer 1990, pages 271-288 (abstract truncated on ADS webpage - see paper for full abstract). Here we find the beginning of the 2nd paragraph of the introduction: In a vacuum, reconnection is a trivial process, but, in a plasma atmosphere such as the Sun's, normally the plasma is attached very effectively to the magnetic field.


Eric Priest says that "In a vacuum, reconnection is a trivial process". What makes you a more credible messenger than Priest?

From post II:
There is no arguing with the physics, that this definitely represents the breaking & reconnecting of magnetic field lines, no current of any kind involved. This is not found in textbooks & published papers for the simple reason that is is both obvious & trivial. Contrary to the ill-informed opinion of some, it is actually not true that literally everything is found within the covers of a book or on the pages of a scholarly paper. These are the same people who think that every question has an answer in the "solutions manual", if you can find it; thinking not required, just look it all up. It is just one more example of appeal too authority rather than an independent examination of the actual physics involved.


The statement I have highlighted here explains why there are few published references to magnetic reconnection in a vacuum. Contrary to your assertion, which has no basis in real physics by the way, magnetic reconnection is a real physical process involving the change in topology of the magnetic field (see Magnetic Reconnection Defined and Described). In the presence of a plasma the process results in very important, and potentially spectacular physics. In a vacuum the process results in nothing particularly interesting, hence the lack of published studies in a vacuum.

I stand behind my conclusion in post III:
Magnetic reconnection in a vacuum is a proven fact, whether you happen to like it or not.
 
They are two TWISTERS of flowing CURRENT including magnetic field energy PINCHING the filament into that THREAD. It's a lot more than SIMPLE MAGNETIC LINE. That's the point IMO. It's like equating a couple of tornadoes to "magnetic lines" and then calling it "magnetic reconnection".

Ah, so in your "opinion", as stated above, it is the "magnetic field energy PINCHING the filament into that THREAD". Yes it would be like " like equating a couple of tornadoes to "magnetic lines..." if said " tornadoes" were magnetically confined as 'in your opinion' these are.


The current flows along the loop and that is the "topology" of the current. If two current channels "reconnect" and there's a topology change in the CURRENT, it's still "current reconnection" every bit as much as it is "magnetic reconnection".

By all means please show us this ""topology" of the current" and how said currents "reconnect" without a reconnection of the magnetic fields that, well, were confining them in your 'opinion'?


The total MAXIMUM amount of energy that can be released in that short circuit process is directly related to the TOTAL CIRCUIT ENERGY of BOTH CIRCUITS?

What of that "magnetic field energy PINCHING the filament"? Are you just going to ignore it and your own stated 'opinion' again?
 
You underestimate both your relevance and the relevance of your inability to scratch chickens.

Let's look at just one small example. With my highlighting:


You posted that on 2 December 2011. I believe that was the start of your "0+0=0" meme.

You may have forgotten what you meant by "0+0=0", so I'll remind you. Your "0+0=0" is not a quotation. It is your own personal shorthand for your own personal incredulity that direct currents at some distance from the (arbitrary) origin of a Cartesian coordinate system could generate magnetic fields within a vacuum in the neighborhood of that origin. You think plasma is required.

Because your "0+0=0" argument is based on nothing more than your personal incredulity, your personal knowledge of the relevant physics became an essential foundation of your "0+0=0" argument. As is obvious from your ranting about the impossibility of magnetic fields sans plasma at some distance from any currents, you don't know what Ampère's law and the Kelvin-Stokes theorem mean.

Ampère's law and the Kelvin-Stokes theorem are essential parts of any decent freshman-level course on electromagnetism. Since you do not understand Ampère's law and the Kelvin-Stokes theorem, you do not understand freshman-level electromagnetism. Since freshman-level electromagnetism is prerequisite for plasma physics, and you do not understand freshman-level electromagnetism, you do not understand plasma physics, no matter how many books you claim to have read on that subject, and no matter how many times you claim to have understood those books.

Every time you repeat your "0+0=0" meme, you proclaim your near-total ignorance of basic electromagnetism (hence plasma physics).

You have reminded us often:






















You have found nothing wrong with the math and physics you've been ranting about. You invented your own strawman, put it in quotes so you could pretend someone else had said it, and repeated it often. That's how you argue.

There's a reason you argue like that: You don't understand the math or the physics. Your inability to scratch chickens or "bark math" is relevant because it's the reason you can't put together a reasoned scientific argument.

You are relevant, Michael Mozina. No other contributor to this forum has done so much to discredit Electric Sun and Electric Universe pseudoscience. Keep up the good work.


Yep and as I noted before Michael Mozina's mathematical ignorance is exemplified by his lack of understanding that -1+1 equals "0" as well. Though more specifically in this application the vector sum of equal opposing vectors at a given point results in no vector at that point (the conditions required for a null point).
 
Say it isn't so, RC, say it isn't so.

Did MM really, truly, write that? Is he truly so profoundly ignorant?

Let's see now ... the Gulf Stream is a several miles per hour stream of charged particles (sodium and chloride ions, among others). Per MM-logic, "AKA CURRENT" (as in, electrical current). I wonder how many million volts Jamaica is, with respect to Iceland and Ireland? And which is the cathode (or is it CATHODE)?

Yep, even more ignorant than that as he attempts to assert...

Well, put it this way: The sun acts as a CATHODE with respect to the heliosphere, and current flows between them. The particle flow is composed of both types of charged particles AS PREDICTED by Birkeland's cathode solar model as listed in my sig line.


"The sun acts as a CATHODE with respect to the heliosphere"!!!

As such cations should move towards it and anions away to whatever anode he imagines is out there. Resulting in a net difference in the heliosphere, the bubble created in the interstellar medium by the solar wind, "both types of charged particles".


We clearly see the disconnect here as he asserts "both types of charged particles AS PREDICTED by Birkeland's cathode solar model". As a cathode precludes the net emission of "both types of charged particles".
 
I do find it interesting that you honor his work in double layers and you fail to see how it's not related to ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES in plasmas and "reconnection" events in general.

That's because you don't understand plasma physics, quite simple.
 
Well, put it this way: The sun acts as a CATHODE with respect to the heliosphere, and current flows between them. The particle flow is composed of both types of charged particles AS PREDICTED by Birkeland's cathode solar model as listed in my sig line.

Please show some quantitative proof of this statement.
Yes, there is the heliospheric current sheet (which can have a inward component because of the bent field lines), but that is created through the dipolar magnetic field of the Sun.
So, now put some evidence and number to your cheap words.
 
That statement is false. It's called solar wind, AKA MILLION MILE PER HOUR moving charged particles, AKA CURRENT. The moment that current slams into a stationary magnetic field, like the Earth's magnetic field, that current is directed into the Earth!



It's "electrically neutral" like a lightening bolt is "electrically neutral". It's CURRENT CARRYING plasma.

Michael! when the frak are you actually gonna read the work by Alfvén for which he received a Nobel Prize, called MHD. There you will find how electric current is actually defined.

If equal amounts of opposite charge (FYI that is ions and electrons in a plasma) move at the same velocity like in the solar wind then the current is exactly ZERO.

How on Earth can you complain about people taking Alfvén not seriously, when you yourself cannot even seem to agree with Alfvén on what an electrical current is!
 
I have made several posts since last May that thoroughly demonstrate the serious fallacy of believing that magnetic reconnection does not happen in a vacuum. Here is the primary set of posts.


From post IV:



Eric Priest says that "In a vacuum, reconnection is a trivial process". What makes you a more credible messenger than Priest?

Oh, I agree with Priest that is a "trivial" process alright, so TRIVIAL that absolutely, positively NOTHING happens in the NULL. It couldn't. There's no energy at a ZERO point of one, or even an INFINITE number of 0 points of magnetic lines.

No particle kinetic energy in equation 16, no discrete magnet energy in 17. It's pretty TRIVIAL alright.

From post II:

The statement I have highlighted here explains why there are few published references to magnetic reconnection in a vacuum.

There aren't "few", there are NONE that DO NOT USE MHD THEORY. You guys give lips service to MHD theory, but fundamentally and foremost it is a theory about CHARGED PARTICLE PHYSICS. You can't DUMB IT DOWN, take out the CHARGED PARTICLES and then claim it's exactly the same thing. That's an equivocation fallacy of *EPIC* proportions Tim, and somewhere down inside you, you must know that! Let go of that equivocation fallacy right now.

Wow. This conversation is *EXACTLY* like having a conversation with creationist over the theory of evolution. There's no NEED to site PUBLISHED material to support the theory in question to a hater. Your behaviors are EXACTLY that of a creationist pointing to UNPUBLISHED works on the internet to support their case! Wow! Clinger's work is NOT published and it's MEANINGLESS in terms of releasing any energy. All magnetic lines are CONTINUOUS, without a beginning, without an ending and without the ability to disconnect from, nor reconnect to any other magnetic line.

Clinger first started out to prove that his ZERO point was SPECIAL somehow in terms of the LAWS OF PHYSICS. What he proved instead is that the laws of physics are satisfied EVERYWHERE, even at NULL points where ZERO energy might exist, as opposed to EVERY OTHER POINT that might experience field energy. So what? It's not a "unique" point in any way. His math proves nothing we didn't already know, it's not UNIQUE in any way!

I even showed you the EXACT EQUATIONS where Priest turned his electric water into magnetic wine Tim. What more can I do for you? If you honor mathematics, how can you ignore the implications of those two equations? No CURRENT (charged particle movements), no MAGNETIC WINE from the Z axis to the X,Y plane, and no ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE!

They are NOT THE SAME Tim.

Contrary to your assertion, which has no basis in real physics by the way, magnetic reconnection is a real physical process involving the change in topology of the magnetic field

Um Tim.....

I don't reject the B orientation of plasma physics. I don't accept your claim that plasma physics and magnetic fields in a vacuum are equal and the same.

I do not reject the math's associated with "reconnection" theory either Tim. I reject the STUPID NAME you folks assigned to the PLASMA PROCESS. You've confused yourself so badly with that name that you cannot even accept the E orientation of that EXACT SAME PROCESS in Alfven's double layer paper. It's not *ONLY* magnetic lines that "reconnect" Tim, it's the CHARGED PARTICLES THAT RECONNECT!

I have no problem with calling the PROCESS something like "current reconnection", or "circuit reconnection", or even something like "ELECTROmagnetic reconnection". What's in a name? Tons. You're so confused evidently that you refuse to even accept that the E orientation to that VERY same event is equally valid in terms of physics and science! That's what in a name Tim.

Your conclusions are not based on science and PUBLISHED works. There are no PUBLISHED WORKS that support RECONNECTION in the ABSENCE of PLASMA and MHD THEORY. You can't use MHD theory to support Clinger's nonsense because he doesn't have a plasma particle to his name, no electric current coming up the Z axis to turn into magnetic wine Tim! You're fundamentally up a creek without an energy paddle!
 
Last edited:
So who would've guessed iron Sun researchers are not conversant with plasma cosmology and the electric Sun model?

Huh? I support the "electric sun" model that Alfven supported, although it's not my 'favorite' one. I support the "electric sun" model that Birkeland promoted, and that happens to be my favorite. I do NOT personally promote a Jergen's solar model for the reasons that Zig cited. The silly part is you trying to claim what an "electric model" might be.

Interesting, but certainly not surprising that even the fringe element, supporters of other crackpot conjectures, recognize the iron Sun notion as unsupportable, even further out past the edge than their own nutty ideas.

I think everyone realizes (myself included) that a pure plasma model is more easily supported in terms of mathematics. Alfven's model is therefore pretty "attractive" to everyone in the EU community, myself included. I'm just not THAT attracted to it.

Also interesting is that each of the four "Iron Sun Debate" links makes note of Oliver Manuel's wacky claims. It seems the electric Sun pushers want to distance themselves from Manuel, his associates, and the iron Sun conjecture in general. Who can blame them? Oliver Manuel has an unsupportable conjecture. But...

Huh? If they wanted to "distance themselves", why promote and write about the idea and claim it supports their model too? I take it you never actually read those links, or you simply don't care about their content. I certainly wasn't offended by them in any way. It's rather nice of them to write about them in the first place IMO. I agree with them, that it does help support EU theory in general as well.

Oliver Manuel, in at least three of his papers, uses some radically misinterpreted satellite imagery to support his crackpot claims.

There's that ever present emotional crutch again. I don't think you can even post a post without resorting to personal insults and personal attacks.

You personally have NO RIGHT to even talk about anyone's "interpretation" of satellite images since you personally are CLUELESS about them. "Electrical discharges? What discharges?". You *STILL* think an iron line composite image leaves a colored ring around the sun due to some MISALIGNMENT of the RGB images! OMG! You have no right to speak for ANYONE on this topic, or claim ANY expertize on this topic.

These are just plain foolish bunny-in-the-cloud mistakes with absolutely no support aside from someone's say-so.

No, they are supported by YEARS of satellite imagery showing DISCHARGES in the solar atmosphere. They are supported by YEARS of images showing shock waves DEFLECT off solids during flare events. They are supported by RD images that show STRUCTURES that persist for hours, days and WEEKS, rather than 8 minutes or so that most STRUCTURES exist in the photosphere. They show an even rotation pattern from pole to equator to pole, unlike the rotation patterns seen in the photosphere that do not rotate evenly.

They're backed with no expertise, no quantitative foundation, nothing.

Oh BS! They are backed by DECADES of research into ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES and their fundamental effect on plasma. They are backed by YEARS of research in satellite images. They are backed by heliosiesmology data. They are backed by SDO images too. That 4800 figure from the first SDO composite images matches Kosovichev's "stratification subsurface' findings to within 32KM! That is *NOT* a coincidence.

I won't even bother counting how many times you had to resort to your emotion crutch using terms like "stupid", crackpot, nutty, yada, yada, yada. The mere fact you resort to such childish debate tactics is simply a result of your PURE DENIAL OF SCIENTIFIC FACT, including the fact that electrical discharges occur in CONDUCTORS, Plasmas and flares. The only crackpots around here are the ones that deny the fact that electrical discharges occur in conductors and plasmas and flares.
 
Last edited:
Yep and as I noted before Michael Mozina's mathematical ignorance

What "mathematical ignorance"? I went to all the trouble of speaking your language, citing the exact equations where Priest turns electric current into magnetic wine, thereby sinking Clinger's ship and all you ignored it! There's nothing wrong with my math skills. There's something wrong with the fact that none of you want to deal with the relevant math that sinks Clinger's ship. You all pretty much run like hell. Care to change course? How about dealing with those two equations I cited and explain to me how Clinger's model is going to work without current running up the Z axis?

is exemplified by his lack of understanding that -1+1 equals "0" as well.

Um.... While OTHER points will in fact experience such things where the field strength is NOT zero, the laws of physics are not different ANYWHERE in the experiment. Clinger shot himself in the foot in the final analysis. He started off trying to demonstrate that the zero point was unique in some way, but all he proved is that it is NOT unique in *ANY WAY*. It's not a special point.

Like I said, there's nothing wrong with my math skills. I pointed to the exact two equations where Priest turned his holy electric water into magnetic wine. It REQUIRES charged particles. It REQUIRES the flow of CHARGED PARTICLES up the Z axis. It REQUIRES plasma! Plasma is NOT OPTIONAL. No current up the Z axis, no DISCHARGE to the X,Y plane, no MAGNETIC WINE!
 
Nope. I've had lots of debates here (including with people I disagreed strongly with) whom I did not call crackpots. I call you a crackpot because I think you're a crackpot.

Ditto. Why should I care what you personally think of me? I've seen you sit back and DO NOTHING while GM and RC have made OUTRAGEOUSLY FALSE STATEMENTS in relationship to discharges, conductors, plasmas and flares. You're not interested in "truth" ben. Whatever your beef was with Manuel's model, I've made it clear to you that I personally prefer a relatively standard fusion model where fission MIGHT make a comeback if future neutrino research shows differences between the oscillation processes of neutrinos vs. anti-neutrinos. Alfven preferred a fusion model as well.

Like I said ben, I don't really care what you think of me because I've seen you make no effort to find "truth" during this conversation. It's just more of the "attack the individual' mentality that all "haters" tend to engage themselves in. By attacking other people it makes them feel better about themselves somehow. It's an ego gratification fix at another person's expense. The topic and "truth" ultimately don't matter to you personally as far as I can tell Ben. This whole thread (and the one it was spawned from) has been about SOLAR FLARES more than anything else and you've never said ANYTHING to set the record straight on that score ben. Furthermore, I know that you could if you wanted to.

Yes, I think Alfven (after a successful career in plasma theory) lost some his critical thinking skills in his old age, and became a crackpot. It's not uncommon---Brian Josephson did exactly the same thing.

But see what you did Ben? In your mind you RATIONALIZED, you didn't site a flaw in his theories about solar flares or his solar theories in general ben. He's not a "crackpot" on this topic until you can PROVE IT MATHEMATICALLY OR SCIENTIFICALLY in some way! Get over that hater mentality as it relates to this topic. Alfven isn't even personally responsible for MY BELIEFS ben!

But it's not a generic label for disagreement. Kary Mullis is wacky, but he's not a crackpot, I think. James Watson believes a number of things I disagree with (to put it mildly) but he's not a crackpot.

It's nothing more than an emotional crutch in the final analysis and it is devoid of any scientific meaning. It's just your ego needing to "put down" the opposition in a way that makes you look good and feel good. It has no relevance to this conversation on solar flares or Alfven's solar theories.

The need to interject those kinds of terms is typical of hater behavior. The topics change, but the behaviors are identical. Somehow by calling Alfven a "crackpot", in your mind you're absolved from finding any errors in his work on solar theory. How pitiful.

If you'd do that to Alfven ben, why should I care ONE IOTA what you think of me?
 
Last edited:
Michael! when the frak are you actually gonna read the work by Alfvén for which he received a Nobel Prize, called MHD.

I'll ask you that same question. You can't remove the CHARGED PARTICLES and claim that basic EM fields in a vacuum function the same and are *EXACTLY THE SAME* as MHD theory. When I see you set Clinger straight, or site a published work to support his case *WITHOUT* plasma, then you can lecture me about MHD theory, and not one moment sooner.
 
...
The mere fact you resort to such childish debate tactics is simply a result of your PURE DENIAL OF SCIENTIFIC FACT, including the fact that electrical discharges occur in CONDUCTORS, Plasmas and flares. The only crackpots around here are the ones that deny the fact that electrical discharges occur in conductors and plasmas and flares.

How can these comments about discharges in plasmas go on and on and on...?
It has already been acknowledged that the word "discharge" has more than one meaning. The folks here who say there can be no discharge in plasmas are referring to the kind of discharge that occurs when a dielectric medium breaks down. You cannot say they are wrong -- because by definition a plasma is a conducing material -- in this context there can be no discharge! End of discussion.
The term discharge is also commonly used in other ways, as when a battery discharges and capacitor discharges, etc. If I were to hold a charged capacitor in my hand and then connect the plates with a conductor, the capacitor will discharge through the conductor. So a discharge has occurred through a conductor. In that context, the word discharge has a different meaning. It is a rapid depletion of an electrical potential through the occurrence of a current in a conductor.
So, in solar plasmas, do such rapid discharges of electrical potential occur? I would imagine so, but they are not discharges in the context of the breakdown of a dielectric -- but are discharges in the other sense -- as when a capacitor discharges. So, they have no similarity to lightning on earth -- if that is a myth you still cling to. Discharges (the breakdown of a dielectric material) cannot happen in a plasma! Period!
Mozina, I have observed and been a victim of this kind of semantic slight of hand on your part. Do you really cling to these semantic tricks because you think they hold some substantive truth or is it just an endless game you delight in? This "discharge" debate is just plain rubbish!
 
How can these comments about discharges in plasmas go on and on and on...?
It has already been acknowledged that the word "discharge" has more than one meaning. The folks here who say there can be no discharge in plasmas are referring to the kind of discharge that occurs when a dielectric medium breaks down. You cannot say they are wrong -- because by definition a plasma is a conducing material -- in this context there can be no discharge! End of discussion.
The term discharge is also commonly used in other ways, as when a battery discharges and capacitor discharges, etc. If I were to hold a charged capacitor in my hand and then connect the plates with a conductor, the capacitor will discharge through the conductor. So a discharge has occurred through a conductor. In that context, the word discharge has a different meaning. It is a rapid depletion of an electrical potential through the occurrence of a current in a conductor.
So, in solar plasmas, do such rapid discharges of electrical potential occur? I would imagine so, but they are not discharges in the context of the breakdown of a dielectric -- but are discharges in the other sense -- as when a capacitor discharges. So, they have no similarity to lightning on earth -- if that is a myth you still cling to. Discharges (the breakdown of a dielectric material) cannot happen in a plasma! Period!
Mozina, I have observed and been a victim of this kind of semantic slight of hand on your part. Do you really cling to these semantic tricks because you think they hold some substantive truth or is it just an endless game you delight in? This "discharge" debate is just plain rubbish!

Talk about pure denial! It's not ME playing games with semantics, it's the fact RC and GM REFUSE TO EMBRACE REALITY and accept Dungey's use of the term in relationship to solar flares. "Electrical discharges" (of any type) can *ONLY* happen in a conductor. GM's claim is FALSE. When did you intend to correct it? The RUBBISH is the fact that you personally won't lift a finger to correct GM when he claimed that discharges could not occur in a conductor. There's only ONE TYPE of "electrical discharge" that even requires a dielectric breakdown, the one that RC and GM cling to.

The moment you folks accept that electrical discharges occur in plasmas and flares as Dungey claimed, you lose the debate. You folks can't handle the truth.
 
Last edited:
Huh? I support the "electric sun" model that Alfven supported, although it's not my 'favorite' one. I support the "electric sun" model that Birkeland promoted, and that happens to be my favorite. I do NOT personally promote a Jergen's solar model for the reasons that Zig cited. The silly part is you trying to claim what an "electric model" might be.

I think everyone realizes (myself included) that a pure plasma model is more easily supported in terms of mathematics. Alfven's model is therefore the pretty "attractive" to everyone, myself included. I'm just not THAT attracted to it.


According to the iron Sun supporters, Birkeland promoted a model that flings corpuscles off into space which eventually become planets, had an electromagnet inside connected to the outside by wires, and was made out of brass, a material which melts at less than 2000°F. Birkeland promoted a model of the Sun with prominences that worked the same way as Saturn's rings. Birkeland was wrong about what we now know of the Sun's workings far more often than he was right. But since these things have already been discussed a thousand times, pretending to not know that appears to be nothing more than a dishonest attempt to avoid discussing quantitative objective issues.

Huh? If they wanted to "distance themselves", why promote and write about the idea and claim it supports their model too? I take it you never actually read those links, or you simply don't care about their content. I certainly wasn't offended by them in any way. It's rather nice of them to write about them in the first place IMO. I agree with them, that it does help support EU theory in general as well.


Well they certainly got this part correct: "It is a pity that the 'Iron Sun' researchers are not conversant with plasma cosmology and the Electric Sun model." But one of the biggies they got wrong was believing Oliver Manuel had any idea what he was talking about. The fraud Manuel tries to push off on the scientific community by inferring satellite imagery actually shows what he claims only demonstrates that the electric Sun contingent are as quick to buy into lies and nonsense as Manuel was.

There's that ever present emotional crutch again. I don't think you can even post a post without resorting to personal insults and personal attacks.


Referring to Oliver Manuel as a crackpot is no more a personal attack than referring to Neil deGrasse Tyson as an astrophysicist. Manuel dug his own pit.

You personally have NO RIGHT to even talk about anyone's "interpretation" of satellite images since you personally are CLUELESS about them. "Electrical discharges? What discharges?". You *STILL* think an iron line composite image leaves a colored ring around the sun due to some MISALIGNMENT of the RGB images! OMG! You have no right to speak for ANYONE on this topic, or claim ANY expertize on this topic.


The continued uncivil barrage of badgering, insults, and complaints without so much as an attempt to quantitatively objectively demonstrate that I am wrong or that anyone else is correct is noted. Oh, and I do have a right. I even have a right to speak in my area of expertise on forums where iron Sun proponents have been banned for being unable to support their claims.

The quote above lends support to this, too...

On various forums for over five years I have made efforts to get any solid surface Sun proponents to quantitatively explain the details of any of that imagery. In my attempt to get an explanation, I have described to them how each pixel in each image comes to be the color that it is. I have quantitatively explained those satellite images, and I have asked how they could possibly show something beyond the optically opaque photosphere. But every effort I've made has been met with sheer ignorance. I've been insulted, badgered, and belittled for my expertise.

No quantitative objective explanation has ever been offered to support the claims that any solar imagery shows an iron surface, anything solid or rigid, and/or allows us to see beyond the point where the plasma becomes so dense that it's completely opaque.

No, they are supported by YEARS of satellite imagery showing DISCHARGES in the solar atmosphere. They are supported by YEARS of images showing shock waves DEFLECT off solids during flare events. They are supported by RD images that show STRUCTURES that persist for hours, days and WEEKS, rather than 8 minutes or so that most STRUCTURES exist in the photosphere. They show an even rotation pattern from pole to equator to pole, unlike the rotation patterns seen in the photosphere that do not rotate evenly.


The above quote simply bears out my previous comments. There are bare assertions and more looks-like-a-bunny arguments based on some ridiculous misunderstandings of satellite imagery. But given over a half a decade to come through with something quantitative, using actual numbers like real scientists would, to support all those silly arguments with something more than hollering, still not a damned thing. Not one single pixel in one single image has been objectively explained. The entire argument is, "It looks like it so it must be true."

Oh BS! They are backed by DECADES of research into ELECTRICAL DISCHARGES and their fundamental effect on plasma. They are backed by YEARS of research in satellite images. They are backed by heliosiesmology data. They are backed by SDO images too. That 4800 figure from the SDO composite image matches Kosovichev's "stratification subsurface' findings to withing 32KM! That is *NOT* a coincidence.


No, it's not a coincidence. It's a combination of falsehoods, ignorance of the beginner level physics people have been teaching in these discussions, and a gross misunderstanding of satellite images and helioseismology, all assembled into an argument that is so close to raw irrational it might just define the the phrase, "It's not even wrong."

I won't even both counting how many times you had to resort to your emotion crutch using terms like "stupid", crackpot, nutty, yada, yada, yada. The mere fact you resort to such childish debate tactics is simply a result of your PURE DENIAL OF SCIENTIFIC FACT, including the fact that electrical discharges occur in CONDUCTORS, Plasmas and flares. The only crackpots around here are the ones that deny the fact that electrical discharges occur in conductors and plasmas and flares.


Crackpot ideas earn their own descriptor. Stupid arguments are stupid arguments. Nutty conjectures are, well, nutty. But it is interesting, in a sort of ironic and humorous way, that I am personally the target of insults, accusations of denial, and childish debate tactics for pointing out the failures in the ideas, notions, conjectures, and arguments.

Any chance there is a quantitative, objective description forthcoming of any of the satellite images used as alleged support for the otherwise unsupported claim that they allow us to see solid structures on the Sun or let us see below the photosphere?
 
Last edited:
Talk about pure denial! It's not ME playing games with semantics, it's the fact RC and GM REFUSE TO EMBRACE REALITY and accept Dungey's use of the term in relationship to solar flares. "Electrical discharges" (of any type) can *ONLY* happen in a conductor. GM's claim is FALSE. When did you intend to correct it? The RUBBISH is the fact that you personally won't lift a finger to correct GM when he claimed that discharges could not occur in a conductor. There's only ONE TYPE of "electrical discharge" that even requires a dielectric breakdown, the one that RC and GM cling to.

The moment you folks accept that electrical discharges occur in plasmas and flares as Dungey claimed, you lose the debate. You folks can't handle the truth.

Did you so completely misunderstand my post or is this willful dissonance designed to continue some game?
Let's try this: Abandon the word discharge!
Do you agree that there is no dielectric material that breaks down in a plasma? If so, can we say that you are referring to a rapid depletion of an electrical potential by means of a current in a plasma? I doubt if anyone here would disagree that such rapid depletions of energy can occur. Someone can correct me if I am wrong.
The substance of the physics here does not depend on semantics; it is a function of reality and the mathematics that describes it. However we need to agree to how words are defined to have meaningful discussion about what the mathematics is describing.

Addendum: If you consider this wikipedia description LINK, you will see that most usages of the word discharge involve the breakdown of a dielectric. I do agree with you that GeeMack and others are not using good judgement in persisting in this semantic debate where it is clear you are not referring to the breakdown of a dielectric. More importantly, do you agree that lightning on earth does involve the breakdown of a dielectric (air) and consequently is not the same phenomenon as a rapid depletion of an electrical potential by means of a current in a plasma? That is the crux of the debate here; not the meaning of the word "discharge."
 
Last edited:
I'll ask you that same question. You can't remove the CHARGED PARTICLES and claim that basic EM fields in a vacuum function the same and are *EXACTLY THE SAME* as MHD theory. When I see you set Clinger straight, or site a published work to support his case *WITHOUT* plasma, then you can lecture me about MHD theory, and not one moment sooner.

Let's notice first that, as usual, you nicely forget about the rest I posted. Again, you will not go into your misconceptions about what constitutes a current, but hey what is new.

EM fields are EM fields and behave as Maxwell decrees. Now interestingly Maxwell's equations work wheter there are particles or not. If there are only fields, then j=0 and n=0 and you get rather simple versions of Maxwell's equations.

This does not mean that the presence of particles does not modify the behaviour of the fields, however, then you get into the discussion of what drives what, as I already said. To show that this is not trivial Vitenis Vasyliunas wrote a paper about magnetospheric physics where he shows that the magnetic field is driving everything and that the currents have to follow along. However, this still does not do away with the fact that the trivial vacuum reconnection model clearly shows what is going on with respect to the chaging topology of the magnetic field.

Naturally, all the early investigations of MRx started off with vacuum. To quote the excellent review paper on MRx by Yamada et al. (2010, pdf available):

Yamada et al. said:
In Sweet’s model for magnetic reconnection, he considered what would happen if two pairs of sunspots approached each other as in Fig. 14. Each pair has its own magnetic dipole field and as these sunspot pairs approach
each other their dipole fields frozen in the solar atmosphere would be crushed together forming a thin layer. He compared this to the case of a vacuum nonconducting solar atmosphere in which the magnetic field would simply add vectorially and the neutral (N) point of intersection would simply shift from line to line with the consequence that some lines originally connected to a single dipole would end up connecting one sunspot to the other.

And you can find Sweet's model in "Sweet, P., 1958, in Electromagnetic Phenomena in Cosmical Physics, edited by B. Lehnert Cambridge University Press, New York, p. 123." Which I unfortunately do not posess, but thank you ADS, section 2 of the paper first discusses a non-conducting atmosphere, which is the same for the fields as a vacuum.

Well, that is enough for now I think. I am sure you will not accept this anyway.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom