Last edited:
Haig and his Sun caused earthquakes
- Thread starter aleCcowaN
- Start date
A team of four researchers from several universities in the U.S. has given a presentation at this year's American Physical Society meeting, outlining a theory they are developing to help explain a phenomenon known as earthquake lightning..
The lightning rate increase is corroborated by an increase in the total number of thunder days observed by UK Met stations, again persisting for around 40 d after the arrival of a high speed solar wind stream
The lightning rate increase is corroborated by an increase in the total number of thunder days observed by UK Met stations, again persisting for around 40 d after the arrival of a high speed solar wind stream
BazBear
Possible Suspect
Unfortunately Haig, neither of those citations support your hypothesis.
Trakar
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Oct 20, 2007
- Messages
- 12,637
Demonstrate the evidence compellingly linking solar wind to earthquakes.
Jrrarglblarg
Unregistered
- Joined
- Nov 15, 2010
- Messages
- 12,673
Haig, all kind of different objects, phenomena and substances can create electrical discharge. "Lighting" is just an electrical potential difference between two somethings discharging through an atmosphere. But that doesn't mean all electrical discharges have the same source. If I rub my shoes across the rug and go touch Mrs J on the earlobe the visible static elecric spark has absolutely nothing to do with solar anything or the Electromawhachamcalit theory. It's just electrons scrubbed off my shoes into the carpet or vice versa creating a potential difference between me and all the other Ugly Bags Of Mostly Water in the room.
ferd burfle
Graduate Poster
Truer words were never spoken. So why do you feel qualified to gainsay real scientists? Oh, that's right, you're a no-claimer who doesn't stand behind the links you post.
Well the facts speak for themselves so it doesn't really matter that it's a numpty posting it but actually, when you think about it, it's hilarious
Earthspots News, Space Weather Report | S0 News May 24, 2015
Reality Check
Penultimate Amazing
There is a lie, HaigAnd here is the start of the up-tick
4 May 2015 Haig: The scientific evidence is that there is no connection between solar activity and earthquakes.
13 May 2015 Haig: The fantasies of Suspicious0bservers are not scientific evidence!
Reality Check
Penultimate Amazing
Wrong, Haig, the obsession with a deluded YouTube channel is your problem along with several others:That's a problem for you not me
- 4 May 2015 Haig: The scientific evidence is that there is no connection between solar activity and earthquakes.
- 13 May 2015 Haig: The fantasies of Suspicious0bservers are not scientific evidence!
- 14th May 2015 Haig: Given no citation to the research by Dr. Holloman, it is possible that this press release by Ben Davidson is lying about the research being connected to earthquakes !
- 15th May 2015Haig: Ignorance about the effects of a new Maunder Minimum has persisted for almost 3 years !
- 18th May 2015 Haig: Currently Piers Corbyn is lying about "excellent results" in order to sell his scam to people.
- 21st May 2015 Haig: A lie about "The science is there if you follow the scientific method / empirical science" (you are not following the empirical evidence just blindly believing in the delusions of cranks).
- More of that obsession with cranks:
7th November 2010 Haig: Support for electric comet delusion that comets are rocks despite the empirical science that they are less dense then water!
Reality Check
Penultimate Amazing
Oh dear, Haig - now you do not know what volcanoes are (they are not the Sun or earthquakes
)!Followed by a couple of more irrelevant posts about volcanoes and lightning.
Last edited:
Reality Check
Penultimate Amazing
Well, Haig, the ignorance, lies and delusions of a crank video have been speaking for themselves for several weeks now - why have you not been listening?
We can guess - what we see is that you are gullible enough to fall for obviously crank ideas that are floating around the internet and not willing to escape their clammy clutches: 7th November 2010 Haig: Support for electric comet delusion that comets are rocks despite the empirical science that they are less dense then water!
If you cannot understand the fact that 0.6 g/cc (measured density of comets) is less than 3.0 g/cc (measured density of asteroids) then you certainly will never understand the simple science that
* that correlation is not causation
* cheery picked examples in crank videos are not even correlation!
BazBear
Possible Suspect
They sure do Haig; but, unsurprisingly, they're not saying what you keep insisting they're saying.Well the facts speak for themselves so it doesn't really matter that it's a numpty posting it but actually, when you think about it, it's hilarious
Earthspots News, Space Weather Report | S0 News May 24, 2015
ETA-Unsupported assertions made in crank YT videos are not facts.
Last edited:
catsmate
No longer the 1
- Joined
- Apr 9, 2007
- Messages
- 37,282
None of which has anything to do with your claims that solar activity and earthquakes are linked. Stop trying to divert attention form your failure and provide evidence.
ferd burfle
Graduate Poster
But Haig, you've just admitted you're a non-scientist and therefore incapable of separating fact from baloney.
...but actually, when you think about it, it's hilarious
Ah, thanks for flying your true colors; they tell me all I need to know about your sincerity.
Well, I'm gioing to take off; I just wish I could nuke this thread from orbit.
Belz...
Fiend God
Since by your own admission you know pretty much nothing about science, what makes you think you have the necessary knowledge to both spot and interpret said facts ?
Simples, I can look at the facts and make my own mind up.
Do you think taxpayers only have to pay for publicly funded science and not have an opinion ?
Facts in support of solar events triggering of earthquakes, volcanoes, major storms etc
The Calm. Planets Lining Up Again | S0 News May 26, 2015
Can we probe the conductivity of the lithosphere and upper mantle using satellite tidal magnetic signals?: Satellite tidal magnetic signals
Reality Check
Penultimate Amazing
Haig: Can you understand that Schnepf et. al is not about the Sun or earthquakes
You have not looked at the facts about the Sun and earthquakes as noted over 3 weeks ago or even the facts about any of the crank ideas you have fallen for:
27 May 2015 Haig: Can you understand that Schnepf et. al is not about the Sun or earthquakes?
Can we probe the conductivity of the lithosphere and upper mantle using satellite tidal magnetic signals?: Satellite tidal magnetic signals[/QUOTE] which is not about the Sun or earthquakes!
Anyone can have an opinion, Haig. But when that opinion is based on an obsession with a crank YouTube channel run by the rather obviously deluded Ben Davidson then we will all have a good laugh at that opinion. When that opinion is based on denial of even reading comprehension then it deserves a
That is wrong, Haig.Simples, I can look at the facts and make my own mind up.
You have not looked at the facts about the Sun and earthquakes as noted over 3 weeks ago or even the facts about any of the crank ideas you have fallen for:
- 4 May 2015 Haig: The scientific evidence is that there is no connection between solar activity and earthquakes.
- 13 May 2015 Haig: The fantasies of Suspicious0bservers are not scientific evidence!
- 14th May 2015 Haig: Given no citation to the research by Dr. Holloman, it is possible that this press release by Ben Davidson is lying about the research being connected to earthquakes !
- 15th May 2015Haig: Ignorance about the effects of a new Maunder Minimum has persisted for almost 3 years !
- 18th May 2015 Haig: Currently Piers Corbyn is lying about "excellent results" in order to sell his scam to people.
- 21st May 2015 Haig: A lie about "The science is there if you follow the scientific method / empirical science" (you are not following the empirical evidence just blindly believing in the delusions of cranks).
- More of that obsession with cranks:
7th November 2010 Haig: Support for electric comet delusion that comets are rocks despite the empirical science that they are less dense then water!
27 May 2015 Haig: Can you understand that Schnepf et. al is not about the Sun or earthquakes?
Can we probe the conductivity of the lithosphere and upper mantle using satellite tidal magnetic signals?: Satellite tidal magnetic signals[/QUOTE] which is not about the Sun or earthquakes!
Anyone can have an opinion, Haig. But when that opinion is based on an obsession with a crank YouTube channel run by the rather obviously deluded Ben Davidson then we will all have a good laugh at that opinion. When that opinion is based on denial of even reading comprehension then it deserves a
Last edited:
Reality Check
Penultimate Amazing
No, Haig, I am not stupid enough to look at any of Ben Davidson's delusions.
Are you smart enough to actually read a paper's abstract and see that it is not about the Sun or earthquakes, Haig?
27 May 2015 Haig: Can you understand that Schnepf et. al is not about the Sun or earthquakes (no matter what delusions Ben Davidson may have about it!) ?
If that YouTube vid has anything to do with increased tectonic activity because the planets have lined up then the guy is deluded, and quite incapable of doing the maths to figure out any increased stress caused by the planetary alignment, ie bugger all.
As for the second link, I'll echo RC, it has nothing whatsoever to do with sun caused earthquakes. Do you just do a random search on "magnetism", "earth" and "electric" and assume any paper you come up with is proof? Because that's exactly what it seems like to me.
As for the second link, I'll echo RC, it has nothing whatsoever to do with sun caused earthquakes. Do you just do a random search on "magnetism", "earth" and "electric" and assume any paper you come up with is proof? Because that's exactly what it seems like to me.