Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
No
Edited by Agatha: 
Removed moderated content
if you would actually read and understand what I am writing is that the dirty snowball was invented in the 1950s when we had NO close up views whatsoever of comets. As soon as the flybys by Halley happened in the 1980s it became clear that the nucleus looked different from what was thought in the simple model dubbed "dirty snowball" (i.e. volatile ices such as H2O and CO2, bound in a solid rocky body of meteoritic material) needed to be revised, and so it moved on and on with more observations of more comets more information about the structure is found and thereby the dirty snowball model is adapted. THIS IS JUST THE BASIC SCIENTIFIC PROCESS, YOU START FROM A SIMPLE EXPLANATION AND THEN MOVE ON FROM THERE IF YOU GET MORE OBSERVATIONS, AMEND THE MODEL.

I guess you think that Einstein should have thrown away Newton's work, and have started from scratch to explain gravity.

Easy champ :eye-poppi


Please tell me the lurkers, in fact the WHOLE scientific community which model we are using?




Asteroid–comet continuum objects in the solar system


4. Conclusion In summary, the population of small bodies in our solar system today, including both minor planets and classical comets, is far less well-delineated into distinct groups of objects than the classical paradigm might have led one to believe in the past. These objects instead appear to occupy a continuum spanning the full range of observational, physical and dynamical properties classically attributed solely either to asteroids or comets. We now know of currently actively sublimating main-belt objects that could have originated either in the asteroid belt or in the outer solar system, and objects displaying comet-like activity that may have no volatile ice content whatsoever. We have found objects composed of inner-asteroid-belt-like material on long-period comet-like orbits, and active objects on comet-like orbits that may in fact originate from the asteroid belt. We also now recognize that dormant comets may be found in both comet-like and un-comet-like orbits. The population of continuum objects is extraordinarily diverse, with each type of object holding the potential for revealing exciting new insights about our solar system due to their unique sets of overlapping comet- and asteroid-like properties. Given this complexity and the growing interest in addressing the many questions that it has raised thus far, it is likely that many more interesting findings await us in this rapidly developing field in the coming years.

So what is a comet, Tusenfem?

in fact
JUST THE BASIC SCIENTIFIC PROCESS, YOU START FROM A SIMPLE EXPLANATION AND THEN MOVE ON FROM THERE IF YOU GET MORE OBSERVATIONS, AMEND THE MODEL.
how far do you "amend" the model before the model is falsified?

it was falsified when the Halley fleet flew by in 1986!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Most likely part of the dust is charged, that's what happens with dust in a plasma, so what?

So what? what is, is everything we are now observing and measuring is ALL complex plasma related.

and the sooner the mainstream accept that the quicker science can move on.

Go read up on complex plasmas wsx.lanl.gov/RSX/PPSS_2006/lectures/Goree_LANL_PPSS07.pdf

Comets are charged rock immersed in a plasma flow. This is what we see, smell, feel and touch using the various instrument on the probes we've sent to visit.

What there NOT is dirtysnowballs, icydustballs, deep fried ice cream, loose rubble piles, sand piles or any of the other "models" mainstream have come up with!
 
Last edited:
Most likely part of the dust is charged, that's what happens with dust in a plasma, so what?

Part of the dust?

Care to give an estimate on the percentage of dust that is charged?

The fact it's charged all the way down on the nucleus should be a hint along with the absolute menagerie of "stuff" we see on and around the nucleus?

It CAN NOT be all incorporated in the "ices"!

Case in hand molecular oxygen! :jaw-dropp

that's got ya mob completely stumped! :blush:
 
Is the dust CHARGED?


i don't recall the dust being charged as a specific element in the referenced papers. While I don't see why the dust couldn't carry some charge, however carrying such charges, of the same polarity, would reduce the cohesive forces that are referred to in the papers. Opposing charges between particles would increase cohesion but would make the overall charge tend to neutral.
 
What there NOT is dirtysnowballs, icydustballs, deep fried ice cream, loose rubble piles, sand piles or any of the other "models" mainstream have come up with!

Sure, whatever you say, I iwll wait for your paper explaining it all.
 
Sol88: idiocy of a list of ignorance, delusions and lies is a list of questions

Look if you want me to answer any of those questions you'll have to supply me with a complete list :)
5 October 2017 Sol88: The idiocy that a list of 298 items of ignorance, delusions and lies from him is a list of questions.

5 October 2017 Sol88: A lie that there is no list of questions when it is on the now previous page.
 
Sol88: Irrelevant question to derail from his ignorant comet delusions

Please tell me the lurkers, in fact the WHOLE scientific community which model we are using?
If this was not yet another post of idiocy and lies I would give fuller responses but ...
5 October 2017 Sol88: Irrelevant and stupid question to derail from his ignorant comet delusions.

5 October 2017 Sol88: Insults tusenfem by implying that a researcher on comets does not know what a comet is :jaw-dropp!

5 October 2017 Sol88: The idiocy that amended models become falsified.
Models are amended to better fit data and so are less false than they were before.

5 October 2017 Sol88: A lie that the Halley's Comet flybys falsified the ices and dust comet model.
 
Sol88: A lie that everything we are observing is plasmas related

So what? ...
So:
5 October 2017 Sol88: A lie that everything we are observing [about comets] is plasma related.
Comet nuclei are solid, not plasma. The measurements of nuclei density, porosity and composition have nothing to do with plasma.

Even his comet delusions have nothing to do with plasma :jaw-dropp!

5 October 2017 Sol88: A lie that mainstream do not accept that plasma related things are plasma related!

5 October 2017 Sol88: The idiocy of an irrelevant to his comet delusions paper about complex plasma.

5 October 2017 Sol88: Lies about comets being rocks and charged.

5 October 2017 Sol88: Repeats his delusion that comet descriptions are models.

5 October 2017 Sol88: Lies about the mainstream comet model not using the various instrument on the probes we've sent to visit comets.

5 October 2017 Sol88: Lies about the comet descriptions which do not include "loose rubble piles, sand piles".
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Care to give an estimate on the percentage of dust that is charged

Care to give an estimate on the percentage of dust that is charged?
Usual derail from his comet delusions so:
Questions with deafening silence emphasizing the complete uselessness of the comets are rocks delusion.
  1. 14 August 2017 Sol88: Comets are rocks so where did that rock come from?
  2. 18 August 2017 Sol88: What is your predicted composition of comets from their origins?
  3. 18 August 2017 Sol88: What is your predicted density of comets?
  4. 18 August 2017 Sol88: What is the measured density of comets?
  5. 18 August 2017 Sol88: State the physics that explains any density difference showing that the measurements are matched.
  6. 22 August 2017 Sol88: Why are all main-belt asteroids not comets according to your comet delusions?
  7. 22 August 2017 Sol88: Why are all asteroids with cometary obits not comets as in your comet delusions?
  8. 23 August 2017 Sol88: Why does comet dust not match planetary rock or asteroid composition?
  9. 23 August 2017 Sol88: What is your evidence that comets were blasted from planets such as the Earth?
  10. 28 August 2017 Sol88: What is your prediction for the "water produced per surface area of nucleus" on Hartley 2?
  11. 14 September 2017 Sol88: Cite the observations from comet jets of narrow band x-rays bursts that electrical discharges emit.
  12. 3 October 2017 Sol88: Give the electric comet calculation of the distance(s) that comet coma form.
  13. 4 October 2017 Sol88: Cite the electric comet modeling of the lifting of dust from comet nuclei.
No honesty yet:
4 September 2017 Sol88: Are you not honest enough to acknowledge the Thunderbolts comet origins?

5 October 2017 Sol88: Care to give an estimate on the percentage of dust that is charged?
 
But tasty and useful spam!
A post of ignorance, delusions and lies tells anyone who reads the thread that the electric comet is so obviously ignorant and deluded that supporters have to ignore it and derail into lies about mainstream science.
 
i don't recall the dust being charged as a specific element in the referenced papers. While I don't see why the dust couldn't carry some charge, however carrying such charges, of the same polarity, would reduce the cohesive forces that are referred to in the papers. Opposing charges between particles would increase cohesion but would make the overall charge tend to neutral.

reckon your onto it cobb!

Dust charging and transport on airless planetary bodies
X. Wang1,2, J. Schwan1,2, H.-W. Hsu1,2, E. Grün1,2, and M. Horányi1,2

AbstractWe report on laboratory experiments to shed light on dust charging and transport that have been suggested to explain a variety of unusual phenomena on the surfaces of airless planetary bodies. We have recorded micron-sized insulating dust particles jumping to several centimeters high with an initial speed of ~0.6 m/s under ultraviolet illumination or exposure to plasmas, resulting in an equivalent height of ~0.11mon the lunar surface that is comparable to the height of the so-called lunar horizon glow. Lofted large aggregates and surface mobilization are related to many space observations. We experimentally show that the emission and re-absorption of photoelectron and/or secondary electron at the walls of microcavities formed between neighboring dust particles below the surface are responsible for generating unexpectedly large negative charges and intense particle-particle repulsive forces to mobilize and lift off dust particles

question is then, is the dust on comet 67P charged or not? :confused:

GIADA: shining a light on the monitoring of the comet dust production from the nucleus of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
V. Della Corte1, A. Rotundi1;2, M. Fulle3, E. Gruen4, P. Weissman5, R. Sordini1, M. Ferrari1, S. Ivanovski1,
F. Lucarelli2, M. Accolla6, V. Zakharov7, E. Mazzotta Epifani8;9, J. J. Lopez-Moreno10, J. Rodriguez10, L. Colangeli11,
P. Palumbo2;1, E. Bussoletti2, J. F. Crifo12, F. Esposito8, S. F. Green13, P. L. Lamy14, J. A. M. McDonnell13;15;16,
V. Mennella8, A. Molina17, R. Morales10, F. Moreno10, J. L. Ortiz10, E. Palomba1, J. M. Perrin12;18,
F. J. M. Rietmeijer19, R. Rodrigo20;21, J. C. Zarnecki21, M. Cosi22, F. Giovane23, B. Gustafson24,


4. Discussion Fluffy particles are porous aggregates of submicron grains produced from the nucleus. They range in size from 0.2 to 2.5 mm and their equivalent bulk density is up to 1 kg m^3. They are charged, fragmented, and decelerated by the spacecraft negative potential and enter GIADA in showers of fragments at speeds < 1 ms1 (Fulle et al., 2015a)

also

SIMULATION OF THE ELECTROSTATIC CHARGING OF PHILAE ON 67P/CHURYUMOV-GERASIMENKO AND OF ITS INTERACTION WITH THE DUSTS.
S. L. G. Hess1, P. Sarrailh1, J.-C. Mateo-Velez1, J. Forest2, B. Jeanty-Ruard2 and F. Cipriani3

4 Conclusions We performed simple simulation of Philae on 67P/Churyumov Gerasimenko using generic parameters for the comet composition that would have to be re.ned using the results of the ongoing experiments to accurately model the environment of Philae. Nonetheless, our purpose was to investigate the effect of the electrostatic charging of the dust grains on their interaction with Philae. We showed that even if the dominant dust production mechanism is the ejection of neutral dust caused by the sublimation of volatile material in the soil, the subsequent charging of the dust increased the dust collection by about an order of magnitude. This is an important effect that should be taken into account to interpret Philae's dust measurements.

along with my old favourite

Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity


Observation of charged nanograins at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
J. L. Burch1, T. I. Gombosi2, G. Clark3, P. Mokashi1, and R. Goldstein1

5. Discussion and Conclusions The Rosetta IES data presented in this study represent the first measurements of energetic charged submicron-sized dust or ice grains (nanograins) in a cometary environment. Previous measurements of charged nanograins at Enceladus [Hill et al., 2012] and at comet Halley [Sagdeev et al., 1989] were of generally stationary particles whose energies in the measurement frame resulted from high spacecraft velocities. For Rosetta the very low velocities with respect to the comet (a few m/s) along triangular trajectories 50–60 km from the comet in the sunward direction provided a unique opportunity to observe charged nanograins ejected from the comet as well as their predicted reflection by solar radiation pressure and solar wind electric fields [Mendis and Horányi, 2013; Mann et al., 2014]. As comet 67P and Rosetta complete their journey around the Sun and again move to larger distances, we anticipate more instances of the favorable triangular trajectories upstream of the comet, which again will provide optimal viewing of nanograins as they leave and return to comet 67P. During these future studies we expect to search for collective plasma effects produced by the dust, perhaps including the dust acoustic waves predicted by Rao et al. [1990], through their effects on electron densities. Another future task we are considering is quantitative modeling of the solar wind pickup process using observed IMFs and solar wind velocities to test the plausibility of this mechanism for producing the accelerated and reflected grains. These future observations may also provide opportunities to investigate possible effects of the nanograins on ambient electron densities as suggested by Vigren et al. [2015] and on the effects of nucleus charging on nanograin acceleration as proposed by Szego et al. [2014]. These further measurements should also provide the opportunity to search for interplanetary dust blown outward from the Sun as described by Mann et al. [2014]. These particles have not been noticed as yet, possibly because their flux levels are below the IES threshold or their energies are above the IES energy range.

Negatively charged nano-grains at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
T. I. Gombosi1, J. L. Burch2, andM. Horányi3

ABSTRACT Shortly after the Rosetta mission’s rendezvous with 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko the RPC/IES instrument intermittently detected negative particles that were identified as singly charged nano-dust grains. These grains were recorded as a nearly mono-energetic beam of particles in the 200-500 eV range arriving from the direction of the comet. Occasionally, another population of particles in the energy range of 1-20 keV were also noticed arriving from the approximate direction of the Sun. In this paper we review the processes that can explain the energization and the directionality of the observed nano-dust populations.We show that the observations are consistent with gas-drag acceleration of the outflowing particles with radii of 3-4 nm, and with the returning fragments of bigger particles accelerated by radiation pressure with approximate radii of 30-80 nm. In addition to gas drag and radiation pressure, we also examine the role of the solar wind induced motional electric field, and its possible role in explaining the intermittency of the detection of a nano-grain population arriving from the solar direction.


So there we have it!

The dust on comets is charged!
 
Last edited:
reckon your onto it cobb!

Dust charging and transport on airless planetary bodies
X. Wang1,2, J. Schwan1,2, H.-W. Hsu1,2, E. Grün1,2, and M. Horányi1,2



question is then, is the dust on comet 67P charged or not? :confused:

GIADA: shining a light on the monitoring of the comet dust production from the nucleus of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
V. Della Corte1, A. Rotundi1;2, M. Fulle3, E. Gruen4, P. Weissman5, R. Sordini1, M. Ferrari1, S. Ivanovski1,
F. Lucarelli2, M. Accolla6, V. Zakharov7, E. Mazzotta Epifani8;9, J. J. Lopez-Moreno10, J. Rodriguez10, L. Colangeli11,
P. Palumbo2;1, E. Bussoletti2, J. F. Crifo12, F. Esposito8, S. F. Green13, P. L. Lamy14, J. A. M. McDonnell13;15;16,
V. Mennella8, A. Molina17, R. Morales10, F. Moreno10, J. L. Ortiz10, E. Palomba1, J. M. Perrin12;18,
F. J. M. Rietmeijer19, R. Rodrigo20;21, J. C. Zarnecki21, M. Cosi22, F. Giovane23, B. Gustafson24,




also

SIMULATION OF THE ELECTROSTATIC CHARGING OF PHILAE ON 67P/CHURYUMOV-GERASIMENKO AND OF ITS INTERACTION WITH THE DUSTS.
S. L. G. Hess1, P. Sarrailh1, J.-C. Mateo-Velez1, J. Forest2, B. Jeanty-Ruard2 and F. Cipriani3



along with my old favourite

Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity


Observation of charged nanograins at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
J. L. Burch1, T. I. Gombosi2, G. Clark3, P. Mokashi1, and R. Goldstein1



Negatively charged nano-grains at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
T. I. Gombosi1, J. L. Burch2, andM. Horányi3




So there we have it!

The dust on comets is charged!

Great so given such considerations the addition of gas drag can be sufficient to lift and separate the particles.

So you knew this was BS...


Sublimating super volatiles can NOT remove dust at any distance from the Sun! :jaw-dropp

And you've got it happening at 23.7au :blush: :rolleyes:

But it MUST fit the dirty snowball model or..... :blush:

Plenty of evidence that the dirtysnowball model has been falsified!

A new model is required as stated by Skorov :D

There is no viable mechanism for the removal of dust by gas sumblimating on or near the surface.. BUT WE SEE 'jets" of dust, how Reality Check?

when you posted it or you found out later?
 
Sol88: A spate of idiotic citations of papers on comets made of ices and dust

reckon your onto it cobb! ...
Followed by the usual idiocy and lies.
9 October 2017 Sol88: A spate of idiotic citations of papers on comets made of ices and dust.

9 October 2017 Sol88: Irrelevant question to derail from his delusions about comets.

9 October 2017 Sol88:A lie that Hess et. al. is about charged dust on comets.
SIMULATION OF THE ELECTROSTATIC CHARGING OF PHILAE ON 67P/CHURYUMOV-GERASIMENKO AND OF ITS INTERACTION WITH THE DUSTS with the truthful highlighting:
Conclusions We performed simple simulation of Philae on 67P/Churyumov Gerasimenko using generic parameters for the comet composition that would have to be re.ned using the results of the ongoing experiments to accurately model the environment of Philae. Nonetheless, our purpose was to investigate the effect of the electrostatic charging of the dust grains on their interaction with Philae. We showed that even if the dominant dust production mechanism is the ejection of neutral dust caused by the sublimation of volatile material in the soil, the subsequent charging of the dust increased the dust collection by about an order of magnitude. This is an important effect that should be taken into account to interpret Philae's dust measurements.
This is a comment about neutral dust being ejected and then charged as expected and measured.

9 October 2017 Sol88: An irrelevant lie that "The dust on comets is charged".
His delusions do not include a prediction of charged dust.
Nothing he cited states that the dust on comets has been measured to be charged. The measurements are of charged dust grains in the coma. There are models of surface charging of ices and dust and its effect on dust, e.g.
Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity is a simulation of surface charging of ices and dust when 67P was far from the Sun (low activity).
 
315 items of ignorance, idiocy, delusion and lies from 29 Aug 2016 to 4 Oct 2017

How's the list coming along RC?
You have been throwing out a spate of more idiocy and lies for the world to read, so very well:
298 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 4 October 2017 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)
  1. 5 October 2017 Sol88: The idiocy that a list of 298 items of ignorance, delusions and lies from him is a list of questions.
  2. 5 October 2017 Sol88: A lie that there is no list of questions when it is on the now previous page.
  3. 5 October 2017 Sol88: Irrelevant and stupid question to derail from his ignorant comet delusions.
  4. 5 October 2017 Sol88: Insults tusenfem by implying that a researcher on comets does not know what a comet is !
  5. 5 October 2017 Sol88: The idiocy that amended models become falsified.
  6. 5 October 2017 Sol88: A lie that the Halley's Comet flybys falsified the ices and dust comet model.
  7. 5 October 2017 Sol88: A lie that everything we are observing [about comets] is plasma related.
  8. 5 October 2017 Sol88: A lie that mainstream do not accept that plasma related things are plasma related!
  9. 5 October 2017 Sol88: The idiocy of an irrelevant to his comet delusions paper about complex plasma.
  10. 5 October 2017 Sol88: Lies about comets being rocks and charged.
  11. 5 October 2017 Sol88: Repeats his delusion that comet descriptions are models.
  12. 5 October 2017 Sol88: Lies about the mainstream comet model not using the various instrument on the probes we've sent to visit comets.
  13. 5 October 2017 Sol88: Lies about the comet descriptions which do not include "loose rubble piles, sand piles".
  14. 9 October 2017 Sol88: A spate of idiotic citations of papers on comets made of ices and dust.
  15. 9 October 2017 Sol88: Irrelevant question to derail from his delusions about comets.
  16. 9 October 2017 Sol88: A lie that Hess et. al. is about charged dust on comets.
  17. 9 October 2017 Sol88: An irrelevant lie that "The dust on comets is charged".
Two years and counting of fear of doing basic physics: 25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.
The parroting of the Thunderbolt cult ignorance, delusions and lies in this thread alone (continuation of a thread that is now 8 years of delusions from Sol88)
10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom