Sol88
Philosopher
- Joined
- Mar 23, 2009
- Messages
- 8,437
Noif you would actually read and understand what I am writing is that the dirty snowball was invented in the 1950s when we had NO close up views whatsoever of comets. As soon as the flybys by Halley happened in the 1980s it became clear that the nucleus looked different from what was thought in the simple model dubbed "dirty snowball" (i.e. volatile ices such as H2O and CO2, bound in a solid rocky body of meteoritic material) needed to be revised, and so it moved on and on with more observations of more comets more information about the structure is found and thereby the dirty snowball model is adapted. THIS IS JUST THE BASIC SCIENTIFIC PROCESS, YOU START FROM A SIMPLE EXPLANATION AND THEN MOVE ON FROM THERE IF YOU GET MORE OBSERVATIONS, AMEND THE MODEL.Edited by Agatha:Removed moderated content
I guess you think that Einstein should have thrown away Newton's work, and have started from scratch to explain gravity.
Easy champ

Please tell me the lurkers, in fact the WHOLE scientific community which model we are using?
Asteroid–comet continuum objects in the solar system
4. Conclusion In summary, the population of small bodies in our solar system today, including both minor planets and classical comets, is far less well-delineated into distinct groups of objects than the classical paradigm might have led one to believe in the past. These objects instead appear to occupy a continuum spanning the full range of observational, physical and dynamical properties classically attributed solely either to asteroids or comets. We now know of currently actively sublimating main-belt objects that could have originated either in the asteroid belt or in the outer solar system, and objects displaying comet-like activity that may have no volatile ice content whatsoever. We have found objects composed of inner-asteroid-belt-like material on long-period comet-like orbits, and active objects on comet-like orbits that may in fact originate from the asteroid belt. We also now recognize that dormant comets may be found in both comet-like and un-comet-like orbits. The population of continuum objects is extraordinarily diverse, with each type of object holding the potential for revealing exciting new insights about our solar system due to their unique sets of overlapping comet- and asteroid-like properties. Given this complexity and the growing interest in addressing the many questions that it has raised thus far, it is likely that many more interesting findings await us in this rapidly developing field in the coming years.
So what is a comet, Tusenfem?
in fact
how far do you "amend" the model before the model is falsified?JUST THE BASIC SCIENTIFIC PROCESS, YOU START FROM A SIMPLE EXPLANATION AND THEN MOVE ON FROM THERE IF YOU GET MORE OBSERVATIONS, AMEND THE MODEL.
it was falsified when the Halley fleet flew by in 1986!
Last edited by a moderator:

