Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
For information on the presentations of the current Rosetta SWT meeting follow @Philae_MUPUS on twitter.

knee slapp'n hilarity there my friend!

absolutely got them by the short n curlys this "sub-surface energy storage" from solar heating and sublimation!

or

That gives at least 3 physically credible mechanisms to blast dust from comet nuclei.

Pressurized gas bubbles venting via existing vents.
Exposure of stores of ice.
Collapsing surface layers forming sinkholes releasing volatiles and exposing ices (a combination of the above 2 mechanisms).

Ummmm......:blush:
 
Usual idiocy and gibberish as expected from someone who has persisted with 8 years of the ignorant delusions that comets are rocks, etc.
315 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 9 October 2017 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)
  1. 11 October 2017 Sol88: An insult that tusenfem has "a bit a paper somewhere" saying that he is a smart cookie.
  2. 11 October 2017 Sol88: Irrelevant idiocy about gas drag + gravity + dust + dusty plasma + a plasma stream.
  3. 11 October 2017 Sol88: Abysmal ignorance about his comet delusions which have nothing to do with this post.
  4. 16 October 2017 Sol88: Usual inane attempt to derail from his comet delusions.
  5. 16 October 2017 Sol88: Repeats 8 years of the insanely ignorant delusion that comets are rock.
  6. 16 October 2017 Sol88: A lie about any scientists believing in his comet delusions.
  7. 16 October 2017 Sol88: The idiocy from the last months that the descriptive name of a model is the model itself.
  8. 16 October 2017 Sol88: Usual inane attempt to derail from his comet delusions with a random quote and highlight

Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03 by Agarwal, J. et al
7 November 2017 Sol88: The idiocy that Agarwal, J. et al. need to mention "charge, plasma, electrostatic" in a dust jet paper.
7 November 2017 Sol88: The idiocy of "Dusty Plasma" needed in the Agarwal, J. et al paper.
7 November 2017 Sol88: Lies about the Agarwal, J. et al. paper and "absolutely got them by the short n curlys"
 
Last edited:
knee slapp'n hilarity there my friend!

absolutely got them by the short n curlys this "sub-surface energy storage" from solar heating and sublimation!

or

Ummmm.....

I am sure we can expect a paper from you and your electric friends explaing it all. Surely the thunderpeeps are busily writing papers with the available data from PSA and PDS?
 
Ahhh I see the problem!

I am sure you do.

have the authors of the above paper talked to the authors of these papers?

which "these papers" ??
The ESA press release is about the Argawal et al. paper ...

No mention of charge, plasma, electrostatic just SUBLIMATION

and ????

Shakes head, again.

Dusty Plasma, people, look it up.

Maybe you should edumacate us on dusty plasmas, as you seem to be the expert on it???
 
No mention of charge, plasma, electrostatic just SUBLIMATION

And how, pray tell, does any of that provide an explanation for dust and ice grains being ejected from the surface?
 
No mention of charge, plasma, electrostatic just SUBLIMATION
Missed this lie!
Sol88 replied to
Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03
Agarwal, J. et al
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/arti...idence-of-sub-surface-energy-storage-in-comet

So, they are essentially saying the same as Skorov, in a paper mentioned upthread, that freely sublimating ice from the surface cannot have shifted so much dust into the coma, and there has to be something else powering the outburst. This mechanism has always been seen as a likelihood at comets, but obviously isn't the only one.
jonesdave116 describes what the article and paper state which is nothing to do with "just SUBLIMATION" as in the Skorov paper :jaw-dropp!
The proposed mechanisms are not in the Skorov paper.
  • sublimation forming gas bubbles that escape through existing vents,
  • exposure of pockets of ices
  • some other unknown, physically possible mechanism (i.e. not Sol88's delusions about comets)
 
I am sure you do.



which "these papers" ??
The ESA press release is about the Argawal et al. paper ...



and ????



Maybe you should edumacate us on dusty plasmas, as you seem to be the expert on it???

DUSTY PLASMA EFFECTS IN COMETS: EXPECTATIONS FOR ROSETTA
D.A. Mendis1 and M. Horányi2
 
And how, pray tell, does any of that provide an explanation for dust and ice grains being ejected from the surface?

Really JD116?

Really?

Negatively charged nano-grains at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

T. I. Gombosi1, J. L. Burch2, andM. Horányi3

Com'n mate, fair go! :rolleyes:

Now where is the extra energy coming from....
 
DUSTY PLASMA EFFECTS IN COMETS: EXPECTATIONS FOR ROSETTA
D.A. Mendis1 and M. Horányi2

Well that seems to be a nice homework project for the weekend for you.
Please use the expectations paper together with the Argawal paper and tell us all about that complex dusty plasma thingy and outbursts.
 
Really JD116?

Really?

Negatively charged nano-grains at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

T. I. Gombosi1, J. L. Burch2, andM. Horányi3

Com'n mate, fair go! :rolleyes:

Now where is the extra energy coming from....

Subsurface dusty plasma?
 
They magically levitate or they are blasted by fairy magic

Ummm...you do know the mainstream have no plausible explanation unless it includes the grains are charged and act like a dusty plasma!

Unlike the outbursts of volatile gas observed by Alice on multiple dates around perihelion (Feldman et al. 2016), no gas emission associated with this event is detected.
Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03
J. Agarwal V. Della Corte P. D. Feldman B. Geiger S. Merouane

Conclusions. In the framework of the presented model, which can be considered common in terms of assumptions and physical parameters in the cometary community, the dust removal by a gas drag force is not a plausible physical mechanism. The sublimation of not only water ice, but also of super-volatile ice (i.e., CO) is unable to remove dust grains for illumination conditions corresponding to 1.3 AU. A way out of this impasse requires revision of the most common model assumption employed by the cometary community.
Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Yu. V. Skorov1, L. Rezac1, P. Hartogh1 and H. U. Keller2

So there you have it, sublimating gas can’t do it and no gas emissions observed for this event! But we see dust??

How does a dirtysnowball achieve this feat of cunning?

Oh, I see “dark gas” :rolleyes::blush:
 
So there you have it, sublimating gas can’t do it and no gas emissions observed for this event! But we see dust??

How does a dirtysnowball achieve this feat of cunning?

How can it be a dusty plasma? Plasma means ionized gas. As you say, there is no gas! More likely there was gas, but ALICE didn't detect it for some reason. You could always e-mail the author to query why that might be. Given that the outburst included icy grains, and came from a circular feature with a bluer spectral slope (indicating ice), then any sort of electrostatic explanation is very unlikely. Why restricted to that small, circular area only? Why so sudden? Why the ice grains?
Still, a weekends' worth of research should be able to let you figure out if instant levitation is possible.
A quick look at the Nordheim electrostatic paper sees them suggesting levitation of grains from the sunlit side at <50nm. Possibly larger on the dark side, but still sub-micron. A look at the dust data from the Agarwal paper shows far higher dust sizes.
Therefore, in my view, electrostatically charged dust cannot have been responsible for this outburst.

Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity
Nordheim, T. A. et al.
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S003206331500238X

Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03
Agarwal, J. et al
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/arti...idence-of-sub-surface-energy-storage-in-comet
 
Last edited:
Ummm...you do know the mainstream have no plausible explanation unless it includes the grains are charged and act like a dusty plasma!

Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03
J. Agarwal V. Della Corte P. D. Feldman B. Geiger S. Merouane

Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Yu. V. Skorov1, L. Rezac1, P. Hartogh1 and H. U. Keller2

So there you have it, sublimating gas can’t do it and no gas emissions observed for this event! But we see dust??

How does a dirtysnowball achieve this feat of cunning?

Oh, I see “dark gas” :rolleyes::blush:

Well, I just heard a talk by Skorov, basically what he is saying is that dust cannot be gas dragged according to HIS model. The fact that we see it happen anyway means that his model most likely is wrong.
 
Well, I just heard a talk by Skorov, basically what he is saying is that dust cannot be gas dragged according to HIS model. The fact that we see it happen anyway means that his model most likely is wrong.

There is always the chance that it is difficult to model certain things in almost zero G, when one cannot replicate zero G in the lab. Certainly, it needs more thought, and modelling. However, to say that x is not possible due to y, is overstretching the mark. IMHO.

ETA: IOW, I'm agreeing with Tusenfem.
 
Last edited:
Well, I just heard a talk by Skorov, basically what he is saying is that dust cannot be gas dragged according to HIS model. The fact that we see it happen anyway means that his model most likely is wrong.

And that is why YOU (mainstream) have a problem Tusenfem!!!

A better way to look at the same problem is, we SEE dust “leaving” the surface but, as in this “outburst”, we saw no increase in neutral “gas”???

Why?
 
How can it be a dusty plasma? Plasma means ionized gas. As you say, there is no gas! More likely there was gas, but ALICE didn't detect it for some reason. You could always e-mail the author to query why that might be. Given that the outburst included icy grains, and came from a circular feature with a bluer spectral slope (indicating ice), then any sort of electrostatic explanation is very unlikely. Why restricted to that small, circular area only? Why so sudden? Why the ice grains?
Still, a weekends' worth of research should be able to let you figure out if instant levitation is possible.
A quick look at the Nordheim electrostatic paper sees them suggesting levitation of grains from the sunlit side at <50nm. Possibly larger on the dark side, but still sub-micron. A look at the dust data from the Agarwal paper shows far higher dust sizes.
Therefore, in my view, electrostatically charged dust cannot have been responsible for this outburst.

Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity
Nordheim, T. A. et al.
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S003206331500238X

Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03
Agarwal, J. et al
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/arti...idence-of-sub-surface-energy-storage-in-comet

See the above post JD116.

Why was your ‘ice’ not sublimating (releasing neutral ‘gas’)?

ALICE didn’t measure gas because there was NO gas! Why don’t you email the authors? There was no increase in gas emissions.

But all that “ice’...
 
Last edited:
But you’re still stumped
It seems therefore highly unlikely that a freely sublimating surface of crystalline water ice can have caused the observed dust plume.
Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03

And

Grains in the vicinity of the spacecraft are likely too optically thin to be detected against reflected sunlight from the surface, so we cannot determine if they are water ice. Unlike the outbursts of volatile gas observed by Alice on multiple dates around perihelion (Feldman et al. 2016), no gas emission associated with this event is detected.

But go on to say

4.2 Outflow from a pressurized sub-surface reservoir

An alternative model to explain elevated gas production rates is a pressurized sub-surface reservoir that vents into vacuum through a small opening, such as a crack formed in response to thermal stress.

Ummm...wtf??

Cliffs collapsing? Cracks getting bigger? And vents or orrifices?

Flogging a dead horse.
 
And that is why YOU (mainstream) have a problem Tusenfem!!!

A better way to look at the same problem is, we SEE dust “leaving” the surface but, as in this “outburst”, we saw no increase in neutral “gas”???

Why?

why would I (mainstream) have a problem, there are other groups modeling gas and dust and they can replicate the observations, as was shown during the EPSC meeting in Riga (although I cannot remember the name of the woman presenting it).

About the Argawal event, I do not agree about the gas. Wehn I look at the Rosina data and the MIP data I see a clear increase in density already starting the day before the event (3 July 2016, 07:50 UT) and actually peaks at noon. I would have to read the Argawal paper again to see what they claim about gas. And actually we are working on a dusty plasma physics paper.
 
Last edited:
See the above post JD116.

Why was your ‘ice’ not sublimating (releasing neutral ‘gas’)?

ALICE didn’t measure gas because there was NO gas! Why don’t you email the authors? There was no increase in gas emissions.

But all that “ice’...

The ALICE spectrometer's slit was over the outburst for 3 seconds. It doesn't measure H2O and CO2 'directly', as I understand it, unlike MIRO and VIRTIS. What happens is:

Sunlight scattered by the nucleus, and probably background interplanetary H I Lyman-α, will be absorbed at a detectable level by water and possibly by other molecules such as CO2.

Alice: The rosetta Ultraviolet Imaging Spectrograph
Stern, S. A. et al.
https://arxiv.org/ftp/astro-ph/papers/0603/0603585.pdf

Given that the column was optically thick, and the slit was only over the column for 3 seconds, then that is probably why they got no detections. And is probably why Agarwal et al have no problem in modelling scenarios that do involve gas release. Basically, because there are no other possible scenarios.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom