Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Once again for EC notions the data needed is the quantitative values expected by those notions.

Remember you mentioned “When entering a region of different charge” making your “region of different charge" perhaps more than your ‘comet excess electron’ charge. So just the EC or EU “region” could dominate whatever they consider the charge on the comet (by virtue of its claimed excess electrons) to be, it is still just the data of excepted values for EC/EU that is lacking.

For the mainstream the sun, the solar wind and the comet are fundamentally considered neutral. The math for that is simple as SUM of charges on each of those objects= 0. Any local variations are driven by the, well, local dynamics.

EC however doesn’t assert simple local variations but instead a direct potential difference between the comet and the sun. Without that (the electric part) the Electric Comet is just, well, a comet. So it remains to the proponents of such an eclectic comet to quantify that electric part. Again the math is simple as SUM of charges on each of those objects = anything but 0

And therein lies the EC problem - they won't do the maths, but expect others to work it out. However, how can others work it out when all observation shows that there are no "regions of different charge". So, when we ask what sort of charge they are proposing, they cannot tell us. Are we supposed to make something up?
The whole thing relies on impossibilities - an electric sun, with a varying radial electric field, through which a comet, made of rock, travels picking up charge where the charge is lowest, and discharging it where the charge is highest! It relies on EDM (lol) and electric discharges, and impossible interactions between too low a flux of solar wind H+, and non-existent O-.
It's pointless even attempting the maths, as the whole proposition has been falsified. No radial electric field, no rock, no discharges, and so on. The whole thing is moot.
Which is why I refer back to my previous point; why are we still discussing this? It's dead.
 
And therein lies the EC problem - they won't do the maths, but expect others to work it out. However, how can others work it out when all observation shows that there are no "regions of different charge". So, when we ask what sort of charge they are proposing, they cannot tell us. Are we supposed to make something up?
The whole thing relies on impossibilities - an electric sun, with a varying radial electric field, through which a comet, made of rock, travels picking up charge where the charge is lowest, and discharging it where the charge is highest! It relies on EDM (lol) and electric discharges, and impossible interactions between too low a flux of solar wind H+, and non-existent O-.
It's pointless even attempting the maths, as the whole proposition has been falsified. No radial electric field, no rock, no discharges, and so on. The whole thing is moot.
Which is why I refer back to my previous point; why are we still discussing this? It's dead.

Yep, as always, if proponents of the notions aren't interested in even attempting to provide the quantitative values those notions require or simply suggest then it isn't incumbent on anyone to provide such for them.
 
A lie that magnetic reconnection does not exist when the quotes says it does

‘Magnetic’ reconnection, no.
4 December 2017 Sol88: A lie that magnetic reconnection does not exist when that is what he quotes states.
Falthammar is saying that MRx happens because the frozen field condition is violated.

tusenfem wrote Second: Magnetic Merging as it was called at the time, magnetic reconnection as it is called now....
It is a lie that this says "electric field reconnection". The physical process of MRx in plasma is a change in magnetic field topology in a medium of charged particles. Basic electrodynamics tells us that there is also a change in electric fields driven by the magnetic field reconnection. However, the textbook example of MRx in vacuum has no charged particles or electric fields.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Ignorance of basic electrodynamics

What’s happ’n To the electric fields then, one would wonder?
4 December 2017 Sol88: Ignorance of basic electrodynamics
One would learn basic electrodynamics where charged particles in a changing magnetic filed = a changing electric field!

4 December 2017 Sol88: Lies about Falthammar’s paper which is not about comets.
The Earth’s Magnetosphere as a Key to the Plasma Universe
Fälthammar, C-G.
http://www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:484042/FULLTEXT01.pdf

So, it appears that the former student of Alfven disagrees with his former colleague, co-author and friend.
The entire PDF has not one mention of comets. To people who can read this is not a surprise for a paper from the "Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on the Frontiers of Plasma Physics and Technology April 6 - 10, 2009 Kathmandu, Nepal" with the title The Earth’s Magnetosphere as a Key to the Plasma Universe

4 December 2017 Sol88: Gibberish and his persistent bedrock delusion included in his other comet delusions.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; etc. etc.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Repeated lies about a paper describing a comet made of ices and dust

Samuel P. D. Birch,1‹ Y. Tang,2 A. G. Hayes,1,2 R. L. Kirk,3 D. Bodewits,4 H. Campins,5 Y. Fernandez,5 R. de Freitas Bart,2 N. W. Kutsop,2 H. Sierks,6 J. M. Soderblom,7 S. W. Squyres1,2 and J-B. Vincent6,8 Geomorphology of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko
4 December 2017 Sol88: Repeated lies about a Birch et. al. paper describing a comet made of ices and dust.
This is the paper he lies about again B]Geomorphology of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko[/B] (PDF)
Cometary nuclei, formed in a cold environment far from the Sun, are excellent tracers of the formation and evolution processes of the solar system, making their study particularly relevant (e.g., Weidenschilling2004). Their physical nature, composition, distribution, formation, and evolution are fundamental for understanding how planets formed and evolved, and ultimately how water was brought to Earth (e.g., Dones et al. 2004; Duncan etal.2004;Hartoghet al.2011). Since the formation of the solar system, comets have been affected by collisions, dynamical perturbations, irradiation processes, and thermal alteration, which have modified their physico-chemical properties and their orbits (e.g.,Weissmanetal.2004;Bockelée-Morvanetal.2004;Delbó et al. 2014). As a result of the sublimation of ices as the comet approaches the Sun, cometary activity is expected to be th emain process altering the external layers of the nucleus .However, this process is still poorly understood, and we do not know to which extent it affects the surface and whether primordial unaltered regions still exist on the nucleus. The geomorphology of the nucleus provides key elements to address these questions.
The paper states that comets are not rocks, young or electrically machined, i.e. debunks his comet delusions.
The paper is about the surface of the comet, not its interior.

His delusion that comets are rocks means that this is the insane demand to use bedrock as in rocks, not as in ices and dust.

We will agree to use the word bedrock when he states that is for comets made of ices and dust.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Delusion and an stupid question to derail from his comet delusions

4 December 2017 Sol88: Delusion and an stupid question to derail from his comet delusions.
The delusion is that he knows anything about mainstream physics.
Someone else's understanding of MRx has nothing to do with his abysmal ignorance of MRx and plasma. Plasma has charged particles so of course it has electric fields! The M in MRx is Magnetic.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; etc. etc.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: A lie about a new paper being related to a "debate on MRx"

New data (paper) incoming that may shed some new light on the above debate on MRx!
4 December 2017 Sol88: A lie about a new paper being related to a "debate on MRx".
There is no debate. We are stating mainstream, literally textbook physics. He has both Wikipedia and a textbook to read but obviously has not looked at either.
The Wikipedia article is about MR in plasma and skips the simpler examples of MR in vacuum and air. These are both real physical, trivial processes.

We have a magnetic reconnection thread containing another Thunderbolts cult member absolutely denying even physics textbooks. This is the 'Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)' thread where I quote Somov's textbook section on MR in vacuum. He could not even understand that there were 2 sections with the titles:
  • 4.4.2 Reconnection in vacuum
  • 4.4.3 Reconnection in plasma
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section II has most of the text of 4.4.2 Reconnection in vacuum.
He is regurgitating Thunderbolts cult delusions about MRx or making up his own delusions.
 
But the crux is, ...
4 December 2017 Sol88: A lie abut a new paper supporting his comets delusions.

4 December 2017 Sol88: An idiotic demand that we agree with his "concentricly nested field aligned electric currents" delusion when he provided no credible source for them.
That would be textbooks or mainstream, well cited papers in relevant journals.
That will not be the retired electric engineer Don Scott, a deluded Thunderbolts cult author, publishing 1 obscure paper.
 
Sol88: An inane post to hide the derail from his comet delusions

I’d ...
4 December 2017 Sol88: An inane post to hide the derail from his comet delusions.
Anyone can decide to not waste time answering stupid questions given that he has over 8 years of denying basic arithmetic.

Over 2 years and counting of fear of doing basic physics: 25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.
The parroting of the Thunderbolt cult ignorance, delusions and lies in this thread alone (continuation of a thread that is now 8 years of delusions from Sol88)
10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.
 
And therein lies the EC problem - they won't do the maths, but expect others to work it out.
That refusal/inability to do math or even find observational evidence is not even recent. The Thunderbolts cult has been around for less than 2 decades (their holy books seem to have been published 2005 to 2007). A good aspect of the lying Thunderbolts web site is that there are fake "histories", including one of the electric comet idea. Ignoring the delusion that any mention of "electric" is their electric comet gives that the electric comet started with ignorant delusions from Immanuel Velikovsky in 1946 and fantasies from his follower Ralph E. Juergens in 1972.

That is at least 45 years without a scientific electric comet model or observations to support it :jaw-dropp!
 
Last edited:
And therein lies the EC problem - they won't do the maths, but expect others to work it out. However, how can others work it out when all observation shows that there are no "regions of different charge". So, when we ask what sort of charge they are proposing, they cannot tell us. Are we supposed to make something up?
The whole thing relies on impossibilities - an electric sun, with a varying radial electric field, through which a comet, made of rock, travels picking up charge where the charge is lowest, and discharging it where the charge is highest! It relies on EDM (lol) and electric discharges, and impossible interactions between too low a flux of solar wind H+, and non-existent O-.
It's pointless even attempting the maths, as the whole proposition has been falsified. No radial electric field, no rock, no discharges, and so on. The whole thing is moot.
Which is why I refer back to my previous point; why are we still discussing this? It's dead.

Then, just when you thought it was safe to get back in the water...Researchers present list of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko ingredients

When a comet traveling along it highly elliptical orbit approaches the Sun, it becomes active: frozen gases evaporate, dragging tiny dust grains into space. Capturing and examining these grains provides the opportunity to trace the "building materials" of the comet itself. So far, only few space missions have succeeded in this endeavor.

So still the dirtysnowball model even though Yu. V. Skorov cast doubt on the whole gas dragging of dust grains but well go along with it for this exercise.


"Our analyzes show that the composition of all these grains is very similar," MPS researcher Dr. Martin Hilchenbach, Principal Investigator of the COSIMA team, describes the results. The scientists conclude that the comet's dust consists of the same "ingredients" as the comet's nucleus and thus can be examined in its place

ok sounds fair enough

then...

As the study shows, organic molecules are among those ingredients at the top of the list. These account for about 45 percent of the weight of the solid cometary material. "Rosetta's comet thus belongs to the most carbon-rich bodies we know in the solar system," says MPS scientist and COSIMA team member Dr. Oliver Stenzel. The other part of the total weight, about 55 percent, is provided by mineral substances, mainly silicates. It is striking that they are almost exclusively non-hydrated minerals i.e. missing water compounds.
Sounds a bit like rock, maybe that's why Samuel P. D. Birch called it layered bedrock. Who knows

Mmmm...trouble...

I wonder if those pesky electric fields have anything to do with it, like and ELECTRIC COMET

but hang on all is saved again...

"Of course, Rosetta's comet contains water like any other comet, too," says Hilchenbach. "But because comets have spent most of their time at the icy rim of the solar system, it has almost always been frozen and could not react with the minerals." The researchers therefore regard the lack of hydrated minerals in the comet's dust as an indication that 67P contains very pristine material.

This conclusion is supported by the ratio of certain elements such as carbon to silicon. With more than 5, this value is very close to the Sun's value, which is thought to reflect the ratio found in the early solar system.

So dramas ahead for the dirtysnowball!
 
Sol88: ...is deluded about yet another mainstream paper

Then, just when you thought it was safe to get back in the water...
4 December 2017 Sol88: ...is deluded about yet another mainstream paper and lies about Yu. V. Skorov!
Lie 1: Yu. V. Skorov did not cast doubt on all of gas dragging.
Lie 2: "dirtysnowball model"
Lie 3: " Sounds a bit like rock" when quoting the analysis of dust from a comet made of ices and dust.
Lie 4: "dramas ahead for the dirtysnowball!" when what he highlights is a problem for his comet delusions :eek:!
Planets such as the Earth have lots of water. Their minerals are hydrated. That not hydrated "very pristine material" is material that does not exist on planets.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; etc. etc.

4 December 2017 Sol88: Idiocy again of just a title.
Researchers present list of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko ingredients

4 December 2017 Sol88: Repeat his delusion that bedrock on comets = rock.
 
Last edited:
418 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 24 November 2017 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)

  1. 27 November 2017 Sol88: Lies about double layers yet again with a paper on the 67P diamagnetic cavity.
  2. 27 November 2017 Sol88: Stupid question to derail from his comet delusions.
  3. 27 November 2017 Sol88: A lie that ionization has "everything" to do with his cult comet delusions.
  4. 27 November 2017 Sol88: The idiocy of just the title of a paper about comets made of ices and dust.
  5. 27 November 2017 Sol88: The idiocy that a diamagnetic cavity is empty (no magnetic field does not mean no plasma!)
  6. 27 November 2017 Sol88: The repeated lie that a diamagnetic cavity is anything to do with his comet delusions.
  7. 27 November 2017 Sol88: A lie about his irrelevant delusion of a coma double layer.
  8. 27 November 2017 Sol88: Idiotic and irrelevant citation of a paper on the diamagnetic cavity of Comet 67P (made of ices and dust!)
  9. 27 November 2017 Sol88: Stupid promise to derail from his comet delusions by returning to a previous derail
  10. 27 November 2017 Sol88: Lies about a MSc thesis being a problem for the mainstream of comets made of ices and dust.
  11. 27 November 2017 Sol88: Idiocy of highlighting the paper describing sublimating ices!
  12. 27 November 2017 Sol88: Yet another pathetic attempt to derail from his comet delusions with an irrelevant question.
  13. 27 November 2017 Sol88: Lies and gibberish about jonesdave116's post.
  14. 27 November 2017 Sol88: A lying and idiotic ("bedrock"!) )post derailing from his comet delusions.
  15. 28 November 2017 Sol88: The idiocy of citing papers on comets made of ices and dust.
  16. 28 November 2017 Sol88: The repeated stupidity of thinking that "bedrock" for comets means rock.
  17. 28 November 2017 Sol88: The utter stupidity of a uncaptioned, not sourced image possibly of terrestrial rock or an asteroid surface
  18. 28 November 2017 Sol88: Probably lies about papers showing that "quasi-neutrality is violated in this case"
  19. 28 November 2017 Sol88: Lies about a "Double Layers in Astrophysics" having anything to do with his comet delusions or probably comets at all.
  20. 28 November 2017 Sol88: Frozen in magnetic field idiocy mindlessly parroted from his cult.
  21. 28 November 2017 Sol88: His massively deluded point 14 from a post full of delusions is quoted.
  22. 28 November 2017 Sol88: More delusions about comets to add to his other comet delusions.
  23. 28 November 2017 Sol88: Lies about mainstream papers having anything to do with his comet delusions (old or new).
 
So still the dirtysnowball model even though Yu. V. Skorov cast doubt on the whole gas dragging of dust grains but well go along with it for this exercise.


Either go along with it or give an actual refutation. instead of this passive-agressive name-dropping.

Repeating your quote:

As the study shows, organic molecules are among those ingredients at the top of the list. These account for about 45 percent of the weight of the solid cometary material. "Rosetta's comet thus belongs to the most carbon-rich bodies we know in the solar system," says MPS scientist and COSIMA team member Dr. Oliver Stenzel. The other part of the total weight, about 55 percent, is provided by mineral substances, mainly silicates. It is striking that they are almost exclusively non-hydrated minerals i.e. missing water compounds.

Sounds a bit like rock, maybe that's why Samuel P. D. Birch called it layered bedrock. Who knows


45% organics, huh? Please tell us more about these organic rocks :rolleyes:. Some rocks comprise siicates but a reference to “silicates” does not mean rock, not in the context of bulk density less than the specific gravity of water. As has been pointed out to you innumerable times.

So dramas ahead for the dirtysnowball!


Who is all this targeted at, Sol? Surely not people who understand science. I guess hope woo springs eternal.
 
Dynamic molecular oxygen production in cometary comae

Abstract
Abundant molecular oxygen was discovered in the coma of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko. Its origin was ascribed to primordial gaseous O2 incorporated into the nucleus during the comet's formation. This thesis was put forward after discounting several O2 production mechanisms in comets, including photolysis and radiolysis of water, solar wind-surface interactions and gas-phase collisions. Here we report an original Eley-Rideal reaction mechanism, which permits direct O2 formation in single collisions of energetic water ions with oxidized cometary surface analogues. The reaction proceeds by H2O+ abstracting a surface O-atom, then forming an excited precursor state, which dissociates to produce O2-. Subsequent photo-detachment leads to molecular O2, whose presence in the coma may thus be linked directly to water molecules and their interaction with the solar wind. This abiotic O2 production mechanism is consistent with reported trends in the 67P coma and raises awareness of the role of energetic negative ions in comets.

Which would be of interest to jd116, in relation to he’s above assertions and my assertions on why double layers are of some importance in the cometary context.

Any low down on your paper going to release, tusenfem?
 
Last edited:
Once again for EC notions the data needed is the quantitative values expected by those notions.

Remember you mentioned “When entering a region of different charge” making your “region of different charge" perhaps more than your ‘comet excess electron’ charge. So just the EC or EU “region” could dominate whatever they consider the charge on the comet (by virtue of its claimed excess electrons) to be, it is still just the data of excepted values for EC/EU that is lacking.

For the mainstream the sun, the solar wind and the comet are fundamentally considered neutral. The math for that is simple as SUM of charges on each of those objects= 0. Any local variations are driven by the, well, local dynamics.

EC however doesn’t assert simple local variations but instead a direct potential difference between the comet and the sun. Without that (the electric part) the Electric Comet is just, well, a comet. So it remains to the proponents of such an eclectic comet to quantify that electric part. Again the math is simple as SUM of charges on each of those objects = anything but 0


This paper may lead to finding out answers to your questions?

Makes Researchers present list of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko ingredients interesting in basically finding the dust bone dry, also lends weight to the ELECTRIC COMET paradigm. :D

If the water is being made electrically, much to jd116’s utter horror, then it solves a whole lot more problems than the mainstreams model presents.

When I say electrical or it’s more along the lines of
Indeed,‘accelerated’ water ions have been discovered in the inner coma of comet 67P
Dynamic molecular oxygen production in cometary comae

Mmmm....what could be doing the ‘accelerating’ I wonder?

.......and we are back to double layers, field aligned electric currents, ‘magtagic’ Reconnection and all that wonderful plasma stuff.

Funny that, maybe there is a link.

Any chances of being able to read your new paper tusenfem?
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Lies about a paper being about his comet delusions (double layers)

Dynamic molecular oxygen production in cometary comae
4 December 2017 Sol88: Lies about a paper being about his comet delusions (double layers).
The coma of 67P has negative ions that can be energetic. Well duh :jaw-dropp!

4 December 2017 Sol88: Usual idiocy of just the title of a paper.
 
Sol88: Lies about a paper being about his comet delusions

4 December 2017 Sol88: Lies about a paper being about his comet delusions.
Dynamic molecular oxygen production in cometary comae is about real comets, not his cult comet delusions.

4 December 2017 Sol88: Lies again about dehydrated minerals supporting his comet delusions, e.g. "wet" minerals.
4 December 2017 Sol88: ...is deluded and 3 lies about yet another mainstream paper and a lie about Yu. V. Skorov!

4 December 2017 Sol88: Lying double layer, etc. comet delusions irrelevant to the molecular oxygen paper.
 
Last edited:
@ Reality Check

pinocchio-clip-art-7.gif
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom