Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted by Sol88 View Post
So Alfven's draped magnetic field model is not true in this case?
As the Austrians like to say: jein

So more yes than no?

Like we can ask the Super Duper Space Plasma Physicist?

@tusenfem

@Rosetta_RPC magnetic field data are always surprising. I don't understand the tail structure during the tail excursion. #GoPlasma (1/2)
6:31 AM - 7 Jun 2017
0 replies 0 retweets 0 likes

but you are the Super Duper Space Plasma Physicist, yeah?

@tusenfem

@Rosetta_RPC It looks like the clock angle of the magnetic field in the tail is ever increasing over 6 pi in 5 days! :-S #GoPlasma (2/2)

We are unsure on just what's going on Super Duper Space Plasma Physicist?
Not yet, thinking about the old "helical waves" in the tail, Hyder+ [1974], Ip&Mendis [1975], Ershkovich&Heller [1977], or not :-)

'cos really the plasma physics around a weakly outgassing is only slowly beginning to be understood by the analysis of Rosetta’s RPC data and new numerical modeling. This mission has opened a new window in space plasma physics , said a super super plasma physicist once.
 
Last edited:
Then, just when you thought it was safe to get back in the water...Researchers present list of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko ingredients



So still the dirtysnowball model even though Yu. V. Skorov cast doubt on the whole gas dragging of dust grains but well go along with it for this exercise.




ok sounds fair enough

then...

Sounds a bit like rock, maybe that's why Samuel P. D. Birch called it layered bedrock. Who knows

Mmmm...trouble...

I wonder if those pesky electric fields have anything to do with it, like and ELECTRIC COMET

but hang on all is saved again...



So dramas ahead for the dirtysnowball!

So dramas ahead for the dirtysnowball?????


no nothing wrong with solar insolation sublimating ices and dragging dust with it but
"To account for such a big cavity in the simulations, we would need the outgassing rate to be 10 times higher than was measured at the comet by ROSINA," says co-author Karl-Heinz Glassmeier from Technische Universität Braunschweig, Germany, principal investigator of RPC-MAG.
HERE

So yeah dramas for the dirtysnowballs me thinks!

But what would happen tusenfem, Super Duper Space Plasma Physicist, if Alfven's model of frozen in magnetic field lines draped around the nucleus is not true in this case then what for the "diamagnetic" cavity?

Not sure if quasi neutrality violations have EVER been taken into account at a comet?? Because a Super Duper Space Plasma Physicist once said the plasma physics around a weakly outgassing is only slowly beginning to be understood by the analysis of Rosetta’s RPC data and new numerical modeling. This mission has opened a new window in space plasma physics :)

but jd1116 is pretty well much settled! though too be fair jd116 is is not, a Super Duper Space Plasma Physicist. :confused: or are you, jd116?
 
Last edited:
So more yes than no?

No, that means both yes and no.

Like we can ask the Super Duper Space Plasma Physicist?
but you are the Super Duper Space Plasma Physicist, yeah?

I am, and I wrote that when I was really puzzled by the data. Now, in my paper everything is explained. So a little patience, my little Padawan. The tweet is of about half a year ago, I do actually work, you know.

We are unsure on just what's going on Super Duper Space Plasma Physicist?

'cos really the plasma physics around a weakly outgassing is only slowly beginning to be understood by the analysis of Rosetta’s RPC data and new numerical modeling. This mission has opened a new window in space plasma physics , said a super super plasma physicist once.

And it is all true!
Because, you know, that is what science is, a continuous development of knowledge. Specifically when you make measurements in an environment that you have never been in before, with a spacecraft that moves like no other spacecraft has done before.
This in total contrast to the attitude you take, keeping on insisting that mainstream has to use the original Whipple model; as well as not learning anything from what is explained to you nor keeping a critical distance from certain unproven claims (Skorov).

Science is a voyage of discovery, sometimes into the unknown like Columbus sailing to the Americas. That is what is so frakking amazing and interesting about doing (in my case) space plasma physics. For me astrophysics and space physics are an ersatz for the fact that there is little new to discover on Earth, like in the books I liked to read as a kid. To boldly go, where no spacecraft has gone before.
 
So dramas ahead for the dirtysnowball?????

no not really

no nothing wrong with solar insolation sublimating ices and dragging dust with it but HERE

And have you followed up on the papers that discuss the diamagnetic cavity, both in data and in simulations?

So yeah dramas for the dirtysnowballs me thinks!

well compared to the electric comet idea ...

But what would happen tusenfem, Super Duper Space Plasma Physicist, if Alfven's model of frozen in magnetic field lines draped around the nucleus is not true in this case then what for the "diamagnetic" cavity?

First, I am not stating that frozen in is not true, that is YOUR idea. You will not find that in my paper. Interestingly, I do not seem to use the word frozen in my paper at all!
There is draping, just not quite exactly as discussed in Alfvén's paper. And actually, I could have understood the data sooner, if I had not forgotten about one early result about the pick-up of ions, something that Alfvén did not take into account.

As the two are linked, the draping and the cavity, I guess the answer is above.

Not sure if quasi neutrality violations have EVER been taken into account at a comet?? Because a Super Duper Space Plasma Physicist once said the plasma physics around a weakly outgassing is only slowly beginning to be understood by the analysis of Rosetta’s RPC data and new numerical modeling. This mission has opened a new window in space plasma physics :)

There is need of very special circumstances for the quasi-neutrality of a space plasma to be violated, e.g. when a current travels from a region of high density into a region of low density, as above the auroral accceleration regions. In that case your beloved current carrying double layers may be created. However, there is no indication that this will happen in the coma of a comet.
 
but jd1116 is pretty well much settled! though too be fair jd116 is is not, a Super Duper Space Plasma Physicist. or are you, jd116?

Nope, but I have a couple of degrees in science, and I know BS and atrocious "science" when I see it. Which is what the EC model is. I am quite happy to believe the interpretations of plasma astrophysicists, rather than unqualified mythologists with no training nor experience in the relevant areas. One only has to look at Thornhill's suggestion for where comets come from, and how the H2O is made at comets, to realise that he is essentially scientifically illiterate. Quite why anybody takes his nonsense seriously is beyond me. I guess a prerequisite for such belief is that one must be at least as scientifically illiterate as he is. Which would appear to be the case, in my experience.
 
But what would happen tusenfem, Super Duper Space Plasma Physicist, if Alfven's model of frozen in magnetic field lines draped around the nucleus is not true in this case then what for the "diamagnetic" cavity?

Irrelevant question. The cavity IS there, so posing a question about what would happen if Alfven was wrong is just stupid. Go back and read about the cavities also seen at Halley, and during the AMPTE artificial comet experiments. It was predicted; it was observed. End of story.
 
Sol88: Mindlessly repeats a lie about dramas ahead for the "dirtysnowball"

So dramas ahead for the dirtysnowball?????...
"Super Duper Space Plasma Physicist " stupidity (it only needs a 6 year old child's arithmetic ability to know that he is deluded to think that comets are rock and high school science to understand why) and the usual lies.
6 December 2017 Sol88: Mindlessly repeats a lie about dramas ahead for the "dirtysnowball".
The observations of Comet 67P confirmed that comets are made of ices and dust, i.e. are dirty snowballs, icy dirtballs and everything in-between. Further analysis of Rosetta data will give better understanding of the details of comets made of ices and dust. There will be no "dramas" ahead.

6 December 2017 Sol88: A lie that the diamagnetic cavity at 67P means there is something wrong with sublimating ices, etc.

For others: It is the other way around - no sublimating ices means no diamagnetic cavity! Gases emitted from sublimating ices create the coma (and dust but that is irrelevant). The solar wind and sunlight ionize the gas to form a plasma. The interaction of magnetic fields forms the diamagnetic cavity.

6 December 2017 Sol88: Stupid ignorance that Alfvén had a model "of frozen in magnetic field lines draped around the nucleus".
On the theory of comet tails back in 1957
Abstract
According to Biermann's theory the repulsive force in comet tails is due to a corpuscular radiation from the sun. It is shown that some of the difficulties of this theory can be overcome if the assumed radiation consists of beams with a frozen-in magnetic field of the same type as required in the electric field theory of magnetic storms and aurorae.

The interaction between such a beam and the head of the comet produces an amplified magnetic field which determines the shape of the tail. The high accelerations, which have been observed in the tails may be due to electromagnetic forces.
(my emphasis added)

What makes the ignorance stupid is that On the origin of comets is Hannes Alfvén stating that comets are not rocks blasted from the planets as in Sol88's comet delusions :eye-poppi!

Magnetisation of comets is a suggestion that comet tails have magnetic fields.

On the Relation Between Comets and Meteoroids (PDF) from 1972 has an interesting exchange between F.L. Whipple and Alfvén. Alfvén states that asteroids, comets and meteoroids are important in the study of the origin and evolution of the solar system. He suggests that comets may form today in meteor streams. Whipple gives reasons why this is unlikely. The last comment comes from a A. Z. Dolgonov: "How could comets, consisting mainly of ice, be formed of meteor particles?"
 
Last edited:
No, that means both yes and no.

I am, and I wrote that when I was really puzzled by the data. Now, in my paper everything is explained. So a little patience, my little padiwan.



And it is all true!

Science is a voyage of discovery, sometimes into the unknown like Columbus sailing to the Americas. That is what is so frakking amazing and interesting about doing (in my case) space plasma physics. For me astrophysics and space physics are an ersatz for the fact that there is little new to discover on Earth, like in the books I liked to read as a kid. To boldly go, where no spacecraft has gone before.

Yes AND no? Sounds like a woman’s answer!

Columbus?, no, more like Batavia (the mainstream) sailing to the, then, Dutch East Indies, the trip had been done before and mostly it worked but for the lack of accurate time piece (whipples model) the Batavia floundered on the rocks (most likely double layers at a comet) and the crew are into each other over who’s going to survive (sublimating dirtysnowball).

Mean time the boat carrying the EC crew sails past using the compass of plasma physics, now in a totally new playing field (tail excursion paper), along with the super duper accurate time piece of actual hands on experimentation here on earth. The crew offer some assistance to the Batavia, only to be told, we’re right ‘we know boats’!

And off EC ship sails along the Birkeland current to our destination. ;)


Follow the rabbit hole Martin, reading those books will not have been for doughnuts. You KNOW what that tiny little weakly outgassing dirtysnowball and the solar wind are doing! :cool:

Had you stumped for awhile. You’d have to agree there are some COMPLEX plasma phenomena going on where comets are involved?

Jein?
 
Last edited:
Sol88: A lying rant about the ignorant and deluded Thunderbolts cult

Yes AND no?...
6 December 2017 Sol88: A lying rant about the ignorant and deluded Thunderbolts cult.

The Thunderbolts cult ("EC") has only ignorant delusions and obvious lies about comets. They have not published anything on comets.

6 December 2017 Sol88: A "Had you stumped for awhile" lie when his comet delusions are nothing to do with the known complex plasma phenomena in comet coma and tails.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; etc. etc.

6 December 2017 Sol88: A "EC ship sails along the Birkeland current" lie since he does not cite the Thunderbolts cult on comets and Birkeland currents.
As far as we know this is his personal ignorant delusion about Birkeland currents in comets. Google only gives the cult stupidity of thinking that research on comets stopped in 1913 with Birkeland' s speculations about comets based on his "little Earth" (terrella) experiments.
 
Last edited:
Yes AND no? Sounds like a woman’s answer!

Columbus?, no, more like Batavia (the mainstream) sailing to the, then, Dutch East Indies, the trip had been done before and mostly it worked but for the lack of accurate time piece (whipples model) the Batavia floundered on the rocks (most likely double layers at a comet) and the crew are into each other over who’s going to survive (sublimating dirtysnowball).

Mean time the boat carrying the EC crew sails past using the compass of plasma physics, now in a totally new playing field (tail excursion paper), along with the super duper accurate time piece of actual hands on experimentation here on earth. The crew offer some assistance to the Batavia, only to be told, we’re right ‘we know boats’!

And off EC ship sails along the Birkeland current to our destination. ;)


Follow the rabbit hole Martin, reading those books will not have been for doughnuts. You KNOW what that tiny little weakly outgassing dirtysnowball and the solar wind are doing! :cool:

Had you stumped for awhile. You’d have to agree there are some COMPLEX plasma phenomena going on where comets are involved?

Jein?


Hear that phone ringing? Don’t get your hopes up, it’s not the Nobel Committee. It’s the Purple Prose Acamedy calling to say you’ve been awarded the prize for Most Overwrought Metaphor In Support of Pseudoscience. But heads up-they might revoke it for gratuitous sexism; that doesn’t play too well these days.

Seriously, since you admit math is not your strong suit, why not at least try to put together a logical narrative based on evidence for an aspect of the EC idea? Not name dropping, not JAQing, but a consilient case. Probably doesn’t mean much coming from a non-expert but I’d give sincere respect to an honest effort.
 
Ok :D.
The first sentence seems a lie since there is no "we". The Thunderbolts cult has electrical discharges burning the surface of rocks implying no organics.
The real world has H2O, CO and CH4 ices + sunlight = chemical reactions and formation of organics.

The middle 2 sentences are a repeat of the lie (comets of ices and dust do form organics as above) and a stupid question to derail from the cult comet delusions.

The last sentence is his personal delusion that electrical fields can do anything he imagines. That includes taking rock and somehow forming organic components from it.


Well for simpletons that maybe the case!

Those detections are consistent with the first steps of photochemical and/or radiolytic evolution in ices—steps that could have taken place before the comet formed, in the protosolar molecular clouds or on the edge of the solar nebula9,23,24. However, there has been no detection of molecules that could be intermediates in chemical evolution, between the previously detected molecules and the high-molecular-weight organic matter reported here. These results suggest different sources for the volatile and refractory carbonaceous material in comet 67P .

Several previously reported elements16—such as sodium, magnesium, aluminium, silicon, calcium and iron—are also observed in the spectra measured on the particles. For some of them, protonated ions can also be detected. Thereby, for example, the peak at mass 29 on Fig. 1 is mainly due to 28SiH+. These elements are related to mineral phases.

Our results show that the best analogue found so far to the organic refractory component of 67P dust particles is the IOM extracted from carbonaceous chondrites. The similarities between the IOM samples and the cometary spectra could indicate a common origin of the refractory organic matter in these objects

High-molecular-weight organic matter in the particles of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko Nicolas Fray, Anaïs Bardyn[…]Martin Hilchenbach

Protonated ions? Wonder if those pesky electric fields are involved somehow?
 
Last edited:
Hear that phone ringing? Don’t get your hopes up, it’s not the Nobel Committee. It’s the Purple Prose Acamedy calling to say you’ve been awarded the prize for Most Overwrought Metaphor In Support of Pseudoscience. But heads up-they might revoke it for gratuitous sexism; that doesn’t play too well these days.

Seriously, since you admit math is not your strong suit, why not at least try to put together a logical narrative based on evidence for an aspect of the EC idea? Not name dropping, not JAQing, but a consilient case. Probably doesn’t mean much coming from a non-expert but I’d give sincere respect to an honest effort.

How long have you been following Fred burfle?

this ONE statement from a super duper plasma physicist changes the whole shebang!

Question
Originally Posted by Sol88 View Post
So Alfven's draped magnetic field model is not true in this case?
Answer tusenfem,
As the Austrians like to say: jein


Everything is back on the table! All the "it can never happen", slowly changed to "it might happen" to eventually "well of course it happens", why wouldn't it!

So here we are with charge separation back in the fore!
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Lies about what another poster wrote

this ONE statement from a super duper plasma physicist changes the whole shebang!
6 December 2017 Sol88: Lies about what another poster wrote (the answer changes noting about comets).

For ferd burfle:
This is the plasma physicist who studies comets, tusenfem, stating that the answer to "So Alfven's draped magnetic field model is not true in this case?" is both yes and no.
Well, the Germans don’t have to say ‘yes and no’, they can say ‘JEIN’!
Warst du schon mal in Deutschland? Have you ever been to Germany?
Well, yes you have, but you’ve only driven through and didn’t really see anything. Answer: Jein.
This changes nothing about comets. Nothing is "back on the table" because the answer is not about Sol88's abysmal comet delusions. What makes that into an explicitly lying post is that the answer is not about charge separation.

ETA: I think the full answer is exactly what tusenfem quoted from his paper's abstract and so what Sol88 read.
Yes, the paper shows that there is no draped magnetic field in the tail of Comet 67P at the time of analysis (late in the mission during March - April 2016) and thus there is no draped magnetic field (duh!).
And
No, the paper does not rule out a draped magnetic field in the tail of Comet 67P at other times or a draped magnetic field in the tail of other comets.

ETA: Add the little lie of not linking to the post where tusenfem quoted the abstract: Here is the abstract in the rather quaint Astronomy & Astrophysics format.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; etc. etc.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Idiotically writes a paper title and stupid question to detail from delusions

Well for simpletons that maybe the case!
Certainly the case for the simpletons of the Thunderbolts cult with their comet delusions:
His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; etc. etc.

The simpletons who have had 45 years to learn about comets and have not written any papers on their comet theory?
Or the simpletons who have had 8 or more years to learn about comets (and astronomy in general) and have not even read a basic astronomy textbook?

6 December 2017 Sol88: Idiotically writes a paper title and stupid question to detail from his come delusions.
 
Last edited:
From tusenfem
There is need of very special circumstances for the quasi-neutrality of a space plasma to be violated, e.g. when a current travels from a region of high density into a region of low density, as above the auroral accceleration regions. In that case your beloved current carrying double layers may be created. However, there is no indication that this will happen in the coma of a comet.

In that case your beloved current carrying double layers may be created
A double layer is a structure in a plasma consisting of two parallel layers of opposite electrical charge. The sheets of charge, which are not necessarily planar, produce localised excursions of electric potential, resulting in a relatively strong electric field between the layers and weaker but more extensive compensating fields outside, which restore the global potential.[1] Ions and electrons within the double layer are accelerated, decelerated, or deflected by the electric field, depending on their direction of motion.

Why would you not expect a double layer when for instance
We identified distinct cavity signatures in both the thermal and
suprathermal electron populations as well as in the ion spectrum.
The drop-outs in the suprathermal electron population is interpreted
as the result of this population being bound to the field lines. These
electrons are accelerated in the magnetic pile-up region, most likely
by a betatron-like mechanism, gyrate along the field lines, and thus
are expelled from the cavity together with the field lines. The thermal
plasma density peaks at the edge of the cavity because as the
plasma flowing from the direction of the nucleus enters the magnetized
region the field immediately traps its electron component.
These density peaks probably lead to enhancements of the electron
current charging the spacecraft, and the resulting strongly negative
spacecraft potential can accelerate ions into the detector, which is
the most probable cause of the detection of 20–40 eV ion bursts
near the edge of the cavity.
Charged particle signatures of the diamagnetic cavity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

And a double layer would not be expected because....?????

oh..MHD will not allow it and that will make the maths just too hard, so therefore it MUST not happen.
 
High-molecular-weight organic matter in the particles of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko Nicolas Fray, Anaïs Bardyn[…]Martin Hilchenbach
The presence of solid carbonaceous matter in cometary dust was established by the detection of elements such as carbon, hydrogen, oxygen and nitrogen in particles from comet 1P/Halley1,2. Such matter is generally thought to have originated in the interstellar medium3, but it might have formed in the solar nebula—the cloud of gas and dust that was left over after the Sun formed4. This solid carbonaceous material cannot be observed from Earth, so it has eluded unambiguous characterization5. Many gaseous organic molecules, however, have been observed6,7,8,9; they come mostly from the sublimation of ices at the surface or in the subsurface of cometary nuclei8. These ices could have been formed from material inherited from the interstellar medium that suffered little processing in the solar nebula10. Here we report the in situ detection of solid organic matter in the dust particles emitted by comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko; the carbon in this organic material is bound in very large macromolecular compounds, analogous to the insoluble organic matter found in the carbonaceous chondrite meteorites11,12. The organic matter in meteorites might have formed in the interstellar medium and/or the solar nebula, but was almost certainly modified in the meteorites’ parent bodies11. We conclude that the observed cometary carbonaceous solid matter could have the same origin as the meteoritic insoluble organic matter, but suffered less modification before and/or after being incorporated into the comet.
 
Sol88: Delusion that charged particles crossing the diamagnetic cavity= double layers

In that case your beloved current carrying double layers may be created...
6 December 2017 Sol88: Delusion that charged particles crossing the diamagnetic cavity somehow = double layers!
These are charged particles as exist in all plasmas that happen to cross the diamagnetic cavity.

6 December 2017 Sol88: A lie that MHD does not allow double layers and so they do not exist.

For others
Magnetohydrodynamics is the study of the magnetic properties of electrically conducting fluids. MHD does not say that double layers do not exist. MHD cannot not include double layers AFAIK because they are small scale (a few Debye length) where a plasma cannot be treated as a fluid.
The main lie: Plasma physicists and astronomers know that double layers exist. Plasma physicists have been studying double layers in labs for decades. Double layers have been proposed for many astrophysical observations. As an example, in the lab we observe that magnetic reconnection can be followed by the formation and explosion of double layers that accelerate electrons. Solar flares are powered by magnetic reconnection. We observe accelerated electron from solar flares. That acceleration may be form double layers.
 
Last edited:
Charged particle signatures of the diamagnetic cavity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko
One of the scientific objectives of the Rosetta mission is to investigate the diamagnetic cavity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko. We employed combined data of several instruments of the Rosetta Plasma Consortium to identify and study diamagnetic cavity crossing events. Using electron data from the Ion Electron Sensor to complement the Magnetometer data enabled us to work out a search criterion for the cavity crossing events based on a unique signature we identified in the electron spectrum. Although this search criterion is insufficient to find all the cavity events, we were able to find an abundance of more than one hundred cavity crossings in the data obtained in the summer of 2015. This unexpectedly high number of events allowed us to study their common features, as well as the shape and extent of the diamagnetic cavity in the terminator plane. The results suggest that in the summer of 2015 there was a cavity around comet 67P, which had a highly variable outer boundary. We present the effects of the diamagnetic cavity on the thermal and suprathermal electron and suprathermal ion content of the plasma, and also the probable mechanisms responsible for these charged particle signatures.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom