Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Double Layers and Circuits in Astrophysics

I’m sure Alfven would be interested in the data obtained from all the latest missions e.g. Jupiter, Saturn, Venus, Mars, Pluto, Mercury, Ceres, various asretoids and comets.

In this case, comet 67P, its electrical environment is only JUST becoming clear! As said by a former student of Alfven’s.

Oh brother, tell me something new that double layers cannot be modeled in MHD, why do you think I did not use MHD in my PhD thesis on double layers?

And circuit modeling is just the long-wavelength approximation of plasma physics.

Is there any point to this mindless quote mining?

There is no need for me to explain anything to you anymore. This has been discussed in this thread and the the electric sun and other electric woo threads. Not that you actually accept anything that people explain to you. And also, you don't even take a skeptical view to the fact that your electric buddies don't even dare to touch the incredible amount of plasma data that is available from all the cometary missions that have taken place in recent history.
 
Sol88: The ignorance that the size of a magnetic field sets the strength of currents

Imagine ...
12 December 2017 Sol88: The ignorance that the size of a magnetic field sets the strength of currents.
The weak galactic magnetic field would create weak currents in plasma They might be "big" in size but that has nothing to do with the topic of this thread.

12 December 2017 Sol88: Ignorant fantasies to derail from his comet delusions.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; etc. etc.
 
Sol88: Stupid "quasi neutral" question to derail from his comet delusions

Am I misunderstanding you here tusenfem?
12 December 2017 Sol88: Stupid "quasi neutral" question to derail from his comet delusions.
Currents are a net flow of charge and thus are actually charged :eye-poppi!

For others:
Quasi-neutrality is that above a Debye length, plasma acts as If it were neutral. An exception is if charge is separated to make double layers when the quasi-neutral scale is a few tens of Debye lengths (maybe less than 100 meters on a comet coma or tail?).

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; etc. etc.

12 December 2017 Sol88: Lies about his understanding of space plasma when he is mindlessly parroting Thunderbolts cult dogma.
 
Sol88: A lying "plasma physics " post

It’s all related, jd116!
12 December 2017 Sol88: A lying "plasma physics " post.
We have never argued over plasma physics. He has regurgitated Thunderbolts cult stupidity and lies on plasma physics. We have listed plasma physics and debunked their lies, e.g. the stupid lie of ""electrical nature of well everything" when the electric and magnetic forces, the strong force, weak force and gravitation exist!
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Delusions about Hannes Alfvén to derail from his comet delusions

12 December 2017 Sol88: Delusions about Hannes Alfvén to derail from his comet delusions.
Double Layers and Circuits in Astrophysics includes Alfven stating the basic fact that MHD cannot treat double layers as we have pointed out several times. It is thus a delusion to expect DLs can be treated by MHD or cite this out yet again :jaw-dropp!

The idiocy of implying that Alfvén was so abysmally ignorant or deluded to support any of his many comet delusions. Hannes Alfvén was a competent scientist not a crazy crackpot. Hannes Alfvén would have been interested in the 22 years of astrophysics progress that has occurred since his death in 1995. He would have been disappointed in how much of it is against his opinion that double layers are widespread, especially the solar flares in his 1986 paper. Magnetic reconnection is the supported by evidence, mainstream mechanism for solar flares and other solar activity. That has been textbook physics for a couple of decades, e.g. Magnetic Reconnection, MHD Theory and Application by Priest and Forbes (2000).

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; etc. etc.
 
Last edited:
It is hard to know what exactly you misunderstand, it is so much.

Is there any reason why currents and quasi-neutrality cannot occur at the same time?



Well, I guess your understanding is flawed to say the least.




Well I guess you are going to explain why that makes more sense.

You can google how much current is flowing, which has nothing to do with charge separation and all about inductive currents (in a simplified way like Alfvén's unipolar inductor)

Well, all the above WELL known plasma physics as a direct bearing on this

Unlike the freely sublimating surface, the temperature of a dust covered nucleus surface (layer of 10 cm in thickness is depleted of ice at the equator) is significantly higher (see the two plots in figure 2 at right) and approaches the black body radiation equilibrium. This is due to the assumed low heat conduction of the porous dust layer: 0.1 W m–l K–l. However, in this case the remaining heat available for sublimation is significantly lower than in the first case, As a consequence, the outgassing rate for water is several orders of magnitude lower than in the case of a freely sublimating surface and doesn’t compare favorably with observations of comet P/Wirtanen (figure 7). The results for the dust covered case are not discussed further in this paper.
Temperature and Gas Production Distributions on the Surface of a Spherical Model Comet Nucleus in the Orbit of 46 P/Wirtanen

With the observed fact of granular plains with “dunes”, large boulders with layered bedrock and cliffs with fractal fracturing.

With the summary here of a dust to ice ration of 6

11 CONCLUSIONS The classical model of comets as dirty ice balls (Whipple 1950)has focused most models of comets on ices. The more we visit comets, the dustier they appear. With 67P’s dust-to-water ratio of 6 (and possibly larger), it is now necessary to spend much more time in modelling the non-volatile matrices with a modest content of ices inside. Jean-Pierre Bibring proposes a new word naming this stuff, ‘organic(e)s’, where the modest content of ices (within brackets) well summarizes the dominant non-volatile component. Between the sizes of 0.1 and 1 mm, 99 per cent of the dust mass is in the form of compact particles, denser than the nucleus. This implies that much of the nucleus mass is in the form of mineral aggregates (silicates and suldes), so that a better denition may be ‘mineral organic(e)s’. The balanced analysis of ices, minerals and organic matter will help us to understand these objects and their origin. The Rosetta Mission conrms that 67P is an extreme mixture of volatile ices formed in very cold regions, and of minerals partly coming from the inner hot proto-solar nebula. The observed structure of the nucleus of 67P has already allowed us to better constrain how the scattered disc wasformed.ThedustparticlesdetectedbytheRosetta Missionareforcingustoarealchangeofparadigm,regardingwhich collisions really occurred during the accretion of the Solar system in and beyond the Uranus–Neptune region.
Unexpected and significant findings in comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an interdisciplinary view

Which has to do with Argwals paper on sub surface energy powering the “jets”

Which if you follow Skorov makes the the whole above ‘dirtysnowball’ theory falsified.

Conclusions. In the framework of the presented model, which can be considered common in terms of assumptions and physical parameters in the cometary community, the dust removal by a gas drag force is not a plausible physical mechanism. The sublimation of not only water ice, but also of super-volatile ice (i.e., CO) is unable to remove dust grains for illumination conditions corresponding to 1.3 AU. Awayoutof this impasse requires revision of the most common model assumption employed by the cometary community.

Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

But on the ELECTRICAL COMET the plasma effects are just coming into focus!

So there is a point to all your work with the RPC team.


The model I’d dead right there, it can not be saved not matter how much ‘ice’ jd116 uses to justify whipple’s icy conglomerate!
 
Last edited:

Nope, I don't see plasma physics as having any "bearing" on the paper. At a quick glance it seems to be purely a thermodynamic model.

With the observed fact of granular plains with “dunes”, large boulders with layered bedrock and cliffs with fractal fracturing.

With the summary here of a dust to ice ration of 6

Unexpected and significant findings in comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an interdisciplinary view

Which has to do with Argwals paper on sub surface energy powering the “jets”

Which if you follow Skorov makes the the whole above ‘dirtysnowball’ theory falsified.



Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

But on the ELECTRICAL COMET the plasma effects are just coming into focus!

So there is a point to all your work with the RPC team.


The model I’d dead right there, it can not be saved not matter how much ‘ice’ jd116 uses to justify whipple’s icy conglomerate!


The section you quoted clearly states that particular case referenced in the quote "doesn’t compare favorably with observations of comet P/Wirtanen"

ETA: For added quotes

Unexpected and significant findings in comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an interdisciplinary view

Dust to water ratio doesn't support EC claim of a, well, rock to whatever ratio. Nor does the paper in general, citing "proto-solar nebula" as the source of the material in the comet.

Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko


Again from the paper...

"the gas drag is not sufficient to remove dust grains of sizes <1 mm"

So again that paper simply says their model of the forces involved (gas drag vs cohesion) is insufficient and then only for "dust grains of sizes <1 mm".

While EC remains insufficient at any consideration without projected values to apply to any model.
 
Last edited:
Nope, I don't see plasma physics as having any "bearing" on the paper. At a quick glance it seems to be purely a thermodynamic model.




The section you quoted clearly states that particular case referenced in the quote "doesn’t compare favorably with observations of comet P/Wirtanen"

ETA: For added quotes



Dust to water ratio doesn't support EC claim of a, well, rock to whatever ratio. Nor does the paper in general, citing "proto-solar nebula" as the source of the material in the comet.




Again from the paper...



So again that paper simply says their model of the forces involved (gas drag vs cohesion) is insufficient and then only for "dust grains of sizes <1 mm".

While EC remains insufficient at any consideration without projected values to apply to any model.


Yup, once again Sol brings the failed “asteroid-of-the-gaps” false dilemma argument. He thinks if real scientists can’t explain something yet, it somehow provides support for his Velikovskian non-theory.

Since everyone participating in this thread except Sol sees the fatal flaws in the EC idea, I’m not sure to whom he’s preaching.
 
Sol88: Plasma physics has no relevance for his many comet delusions

Well, all the above WELL known plasma physics as a direct bearing on this
12 December 2017 Sol88: Plasma physics has no relevance for his many comet delusions.

12 December 2017 Sol88: Lies about a paper on an ice and rock comet being about rock, etc.
Temperature and Gas Production Distributions on the Surface of a Spherical Model Comet Nucleus in the Orbit of 46 P/Wirtanen

12 December 2017 Sol88: Repeated lie about Skorov falsifying the fact that comets are made of ices and dust.

12 December 2017 Sol88: Repeated lie about his comet delusions including any plasma or other physics.
[URL="http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12100574#post12100574"]The electric comet delusion has at least 45 years without a scientific electric comet model or observations to support it :eek: !


12 December 2017 Sol88: Repeated 'ice' lie when he knows of the many observations of ices on comets.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; etc. etc.

Also:
12 December 2017 Sol88: Persistent idiocy of citing ices and dust comet papers to derail from his comet delusions.
 
Last edited:
498 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 7 December 2017 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)

The electric comet delusion has at least 45 years without a scientific electric comet model or observations to support it :eek: !
  1. 8 December 2017 Sol88: Idiotic and irrelevant post to derail from his comet delusions.
  2. 8 December 2017 Sol88: Lies about tusenfem's paper with "no such thing as charge separation" idiocy.
  3. 8 December 2017 Sol88: Lies about tusenfem's paper with "Nothing electrical" idiocy.
  4. 8 December 2017 Sol88: Idiocy about what he quotes and highlights (field-aligned currents is not charge separation - :eek:!).
  5. 8 December 2017 Sol88: Idiocy about what he quotes and highlights (energetic electrons is not charge separation - :eek:!).
  6. 8 December 2017 Sol88: Idiocy about what he quotes and highlights (magnetic reconnection is not charge separation - :eek:!).
  7. 8 December 2017 Sol88: Lies again about tusenfem's paper with "no charge separation" idiocy
  8. 8 December 2017 Sol88: Lies about plasma physics.
  9. 12 December 2017 Sol88: The ignorance that the size of a magnetic field sets the strength of currents.
  10. 12 December 2017 Sol88: Ignorant fantasies to derail from his comet delusions.
  11. 12 December 2017 Sol88: Stupid "quasi neutral" question to derail from his comet delusions.
  12. 12 December 2017 Sol88: Lies about his understanding of space plasma when he is mindlessly parroting Thunderbolts cult dogma.
  13. 12 December 2017 Sol88: A lying "plasma physics " post.
  14. 12 December 2017 Sol88: A lie that any of his "electric woo happened" (was detected) at Comet 67P as jonesdave116 correctly stated.
  15. 12 December 2017 Sol88: Delusions about Hannes Alfvén to derail from his comet delusions.
  16. 12 December 2017 Sol88: Plasma physics has no relevance for his many comet delusions.
  17. 12 December 2017 Sol88: Lies about a paper on an ice and rock comet being about rock, etc.
  18. 12 December 2017 Sol88: Repeated lie about Skorov falsifying the fact that comets are made of ices and dust.
  19. 12 December 2017 Sol88: Repeated lie about his comet delusions including any plasma or other physics.
  20. 12 December 2017 Sol88: Repeated 'ice' lie when he knows of the many observations of ices on comets.
  21. 12 December 2017 Sol88: Persistent idiocy of citing ices and dust comet papers to derail from his comet delusions.
 
The model I’d dead right there, it can not be saved not matter how much ‘ice’ jd116 uses to justify whipple’s icy conglomerate!

Anybody want to translate that into English for me? Sounds like crap to me.
 
Anybody want to translate that into English for me? Sounds like crap to me.
Just the usual lies.
"The model I’d dead right there" is his persistent lie that the "Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko" paper by YV Skorov et. al. means that there is no ice on comets.
Rational people know that this paper is a model of dust being ejected from sublimating ices via a gas drag force as stated in the abstract :eye-poppi. None of the authors are so abysmally deluded to think that comets are rock. If the paper is correct (a slightly big if for a paper cited once in the last year) then all it means is that other mechanisms lift up "dust grains of sizes <1 mm", maybe little things called comet jets :eek:!

Over 8 years of lying about ice being found on comets (Deep Impact was in 2005!) by putting ice in quotes.
 
Last edited:
Nope, I don't see plasma physics as having any "bearing" on the paper. At a quick glance it seems to be purely a thermodynamic model.




The section you quoted clearly states that particular case referenced in the quote "doesn’t compare favorably with observations of comet P/Wirtanen"

ETA: For added quotes



Dust to water ratio doesn't support EC claim of a, well, rock to whatever ratio. Nor does the paper in general, citing "proto-solar nebula" as the source of the material in the comet.

Again from the paper...

So again that paper simply says their model of the forces involved (gas drag vs cohesion) is insufficient and then only for "dust grains of sizes <1 mm".

While EC remains insufficient at any consideration without projected values to apply to any model.

Yeah, so we agree then the standard Whipple’s model from the 50’s is 🌵?
 
Yup, once again Sol brings the failed “asteroid-of-the-gaps” false dilemma argument. He thinks if real scientists can’t explain something yet, it somehow provides support for his Velikovskian non-theory.

Since everyone participating in this thread except Sol sees the fatal flaws in the EC idea, I’m not sure to whom he’s preaching.

Not sure I quite see it that way.

From these papers comes the general assumption solar heating can not explain the observed properties of any comet!

Forget about your fear of Velikovsky for a moment and realise Whipple all those years ago was wrong, no surprise as we had not long ventured into space but EVERYTIME we get data back from comet missions, the dirtysnowball is becoming more and more untenable!

Leaves us again with the little thing reality check and I like to call
If the paper is correct (a slightly big if for a paper cited once in the last year) then all it means is that other mechanisms lift up "dust grains of sizes <1 mm", maybe little things called comet jets !

Mmmmmm....other mechanisms you say, please tell us all more, we are all ears!
 
Just the usual lies.
"The model I’d dead right there" is his persistent lie that the "Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko" paper by YV Skorov et. al. means that there is no ice on comets.
Rational people know that this paper is a model of dust being ejected from sublimating ices via a gas drag force as stated in the abstract :eye-poppi. None of the authors are so abysmally deluded to think that comets are rock. If the paper is correct (a slightly big if for a paper cited once in the last year) then all it means is that other mechanisms lift up "dust grains of sizes <1 mm", maybe little things called comet jets :eek:!

Over 8 years of lying about ice being found on comets (Deep Impact was in 2005!) by putting ice in quotes.

Poor old Skorov not in the good books is he? ball'sn up a perfectly good story!

The official story is much the same as the mainstream have done all there modeling from!
Comets: The Basics

Comets are cosmic snowballs of frozen gases, rock and dust roughly the size of a small town. When a comet's orbit brings it close to the sun, it heats up and spews dust and gases into a giant glowing head larger than most planets. The dust and gases form a tail that stretches away from the sun for millions of kilometers. Comets may not be able to support life themselves, but they may have brought water and organic compounds -- the building blocks of life -- through collisions with Earth and other bodies in our solar system.

NASA

but

2.4 Note on literature

The dusty ice model has been frequently adopted in studies
of cometary activity and evolution,
though numerical treatment
varies greatly with different works. References can be found in
Smoluchowski (1981), Weissman & Kieffer (1981), Froeschle,
Klinger & Rickman (1983), K¨uhrt (1984), K¨uhrt (1999), among
numerous others.
It is conclusive that exposure of water ice over cometary nuclei
is limited
(Filacchione et al. 2016). The effect of this dust mantle
on heat transport and gas diffusion through the nucleus as well
as the conditions of dust activity has been studied in great detail.
On this matter, the reader is referred to Mendis & Brin (1977),
Brin&Mendis (1979), Brin (1980), Fanale&Salvail (1984),K¨omle
& Steiner (1992), K¨omle et al. (1992), K¨uhrt & Keller (1994),
Skorov & Rickman (1995), Davidsson & Skorov (2002), Davidsson
& Guti´errez (2005), Kossacki & Szutowicz (2008), Skorov
et al. (2011), Gundlach et al. (2011), Gundlach & Blum (2012) and
Keller et al. (2015),
if only for just a partial review of the immense
literature.
What some might consider to be a drastic simplification with
both the dusty-ice and dust-mantle models is the implicit assumption
that the sublimation occurs from a surface of pure solid ice, in
contradiction with cometary nuclei being porous objects in reality.

How much "ice" on the surface of comet 67P, reality check?

Does the nucleus have enough "ice/s" below the assumed "dust" mantle to sustain the observed discharging "outgassing" from solar isolation alone, even when the coma become optical thick?

If it's not the assumed "dust mantle" but
Layered bedrock units that represent the exposed nucleus of 67P/C-G are dominant at southern latitudes, while topographically smooth, dust covered regions dominate the Northern hemisphere.
say Samuel P. D. Birch,1‹ Y. Tang,2 A. G. Hayes,1,2 R. L. Kirk,3 D. Bodewits,4 H. Campins,5 Y. Fernandez,5 R. de Freitas Bart,2 N. W. Kutsop,2 H. Sierks,6 J. M. Soderblom,7 S. W. Squyres1,2 and J-B. Vincent6,8 in there paper Geomorphology of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko how does the sublimation of subsurface ice happen then?

I mean The Man totatly missed the point because he got his knickers in a knot but read it again slowly.

Also remember this was the original target for the Rosetta mission.

Abstract

A multidimensional comet nucleus model is used to estimate the temperature and gas production distributions on the surface of a comet nucleus in the orbit of 46P/Wirtanen. The spherical model nucleus is assumed to be made up of a porous dust-ice (H2O, CO) matrix. Heat and gas diffusion inside the rotating nucleus are taken into account in radial and meridional directions. A quasi-3D solution is obtained through the dependency of the boundary conditions on the local solar illumination as the nucleus rotates. As a study case, we consider a homogeneous chemical composition of the surface layer which is assumed to contain water ice. The model results include the distributions of temperature and gas production on the surface. For the chosen test case of a nucleus spin axis perpendicular to the orbital plane we found that the CO gas production on the surface is quasi-uniformly distributed in contrast to the nonuniform water outgassing. The mixing ratio at a specific point on the comet nucleus surface is not representative of the overall mixing ratio which is observed in the coma.
Temperature and Gas Production Distributions on the Surface of a Spherical Model Comet Nucleus in the Orbit of 67P/Wirtanen

and so on!
 
But on the ELECTRICAL COMET the plasma effects are just coming into focus!

Nope, there is NO ELECTRICAL COMET, unless you can show us the papers in which you and your kind clearly explain the model and the observations, including the math.
 
Not sure I quite see it that way.

From these papers comes the general assumption solar heating can not explain the observed properties of any comet!

Forget about your fear of Velikovsky for a moment and realise Whipple all those years ago was wrong, no surprise as we had not long ventured into space but EVERYTIME we get data back from comet missions, the dirtysnowball is becoming more and more untenable!

Leaves us again with the little thing reality check and I like to call

Mmmmmm....other mechanisms you say, please tell us all more, we are all ears!


QED
 
If the comet is rock how do the EC advocates get round the lack of density?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom