Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
let me guess, it's a ... double layer

is the current helical wave going toward or away from the comet?

the field is always pointing sunward §?
A helical wave travels down the tail

Wonder how far the helical wave travels down the tail??? :confused:

Wonder if these structure/s were observed by Ulysses?
 
Last edited:
Indeed. Even as a non-plasma physicist, with more of an interest in planetary science, I could have answered that, having read enough of the RPC papers from this mission, as well as other papers from Halley, in particular. Not to mention Tusenfem's frequent explanations on here. People really should pay attention in class!

On another note, related to my previous post, another method of estimating the strength of the cometary material is outlined in this paper:

Tensile Strength of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko Nucleus Material from Overhangs
Attree, N. et al.
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1712.07508.pdf

Given the very low gravity at 67P, why would solid rock collapse, as observed? Not to mention the fact that the debris is icy. As they say in the conclusions:



My bold. Perhaps the EU geniuses could perform the same calculations that the authors of this paper have done, and substitute in the values for igneous or sedimentary rock, and see how it comes out.
Of course, we all know that won't happen. There is nobody associated with that cult capable of doing such a thing. Nor are they interested, as they have the highly scientific observation of "it looks like rock" to hang their hat on! And why would they be interested in science, when their belief system is based purely on mythology? Anybody that believes that nonsense is not going to understand the science anyway. Nope, best to ignore all the evidence, and keep on selling the books and DVDs to their scientifically challenged acolytes.

We find extremely low strengths of around one Pa or less (one to five Pa, when scaled to a metre length).
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1712.07508.pdf

The MUPUS thermal probe did not fully penetrate the near-surface layers, suggesting a local resistance of the ground to penetration of >4 megapascals, equivalent to >2 megapascal uniaxial compressive strength
Thermal and mechanical properties of the near-surface layers of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko T. Spohn,1* J. Knollenberg,1 A. J. Ball,2 M. Banaszkiewicz,3 J. Benkhoff,2 M. Grott,1
J. Grygorczuk,3 C. Hüttig,1 A. Hagermann,4 G. Kargl,5 E. Kaufmann,4 N. Kömle,5 E. Kührt,1 K. J. Kossacki,6 W. Marczewski,3 I. Pelivan,1 R. Schrödter,1 K. Seiferlin7


Results from the MUPUS instrument onboard Philae may support the existence of plates with a consolidated surface.
Close-up images of the final Philae landing site on comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko acquired by the ROLIS cameraI S.E. Schrodera,, S. Mottolaa, G. Arnolda, H.-G. Grothuesb, R. Jaumanna, H.U. Kellera,c, H. Michaelisa,
J.-P. Bibringd, I. Pelivana, A. Koncza, K. Ottoa, E. Remeteane, F. Souvannavongf, B. Dolivesf


So yeah, not totally settled yet! :D
 
is the current helical wave going toward or away from the comet?

Wonder how far the helical wave travels down the tail??? :confused:

Wonder if these structure/s were observed by Ulysses?

No it is not a current for obvious reasons.

If we would have flown farther down the tail this could possibly have been answered.

The wave is reminiscent of helical waves observed in tails of other comets, but there they were up to 1AU away and travelling much faster.
 
No it is not a current for obvious reasons.

If we would have flown farther down the tail this could possibly have been answered.

The wave is reminiscent of helical waves observed in tails of other comets, but there they were up to 1AU away and travelling much faster.

.2 Field-Aligned Currents in Laboratory Plasma In the laboratory, filamentary and helical structure is a common morphology exhibited by energetic plasmas. X ray pinhole photographs, optical streak and framing camera photographs, and laser holograms often show a filamentary, magnetic “rope-like” structure from plasmas produced in multi-terawatt pulse power generators or in dense plasma focus machines (Fig. 1.2). Often, the cross-sectional patterns from filamentation in hollow electron beams are recorded onto observing screens or witness plates. Regardless of size or current, the patterns are those of vortices (Figs. 1.20–1.21). In the dense plasma focus the vortices have dimensions of a few microns while in laboratory electron beams the vortices may be a few centimeters in diameter. This size variation of 4 orders of magnitude is extended to nearly 9 orders of magnitude when auroral vortex recordings are directly compared to the laboratory data. With regard to actual current magnitudes; filamentation occurs over nearly 12 orders of magnitude while coarser resolution experiments show that the phenomena probably transcends at least 14 orders of magnitude, from microampere to multi-megaampere electron beams. .
Chapter 2
Birkeland Currents in Cosmic Plasma
Peratt A.L

Aims. Our aim is to demonstrate the existence of cold electrons in the inner coma of comet 67P and show filamentation
of this plasma.
Cold and warm electrons at comet 67P A. I. Eriksson1, I. A. D. Engelhardt1; 2, M. André1, R. Boström1, N. J. T. Edberg1,F. L. Johansson1; 2, E. Odelstad1; 2, E. Vigren1, J.-E. Wahlund1, P. Henri3, J.-P. Lebreton3,W. J. Miloch4, J. J. P. Paulsson4, C. Simon Wedlund4, L. Yang4, T. Karlsson5, R. Jarvinen6,T. Broiles7, K. Mandt7; 8, C. M. Carr9, M. Galand9, H. Nilsson10, and C. Norberg10

You are aware are you not tusenfem?

As you say, super duper space plasma physicist, all very basic stuff!
 
Last edited:
So yeah, not totally settled yet! :D

Yes, it is. As I already provided a link to umpteen times. For the umpteen and first time:

....this velocity translates into a shear modulus of the comet material of at least 3.2 MPa. Shear modulus scales with velocity squared, so when taking into account the formal uncertainties arising from the arrival time inversion, the shear modulus may easily be as large as 10 MPa. This is still low compared to solid rock or monocrystalline ice, but is compatible with highly porous materials.

Constraints for the subsurface structure at the Abydos site on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko resulting from CASSE listening to the MUPUS insertion phase
Knapmeyer, M. et al.
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2016AGUFM.P42A..04K

It isn't rock. MUPUS says it isn't rock. CONSERT says it isn't rock. MIRO says it isn't rock. The cliff debris says it isn't rock. The crater and excavated ice at Tempel 1 says it isn't rock. The density says it isn't rock. Nobody believes it to be rock, other than a bunch of scientifically challenged loons, with a neo-Velikovskian tale to tell, and books to sell. It isn't rock. End of story.

EDIT: Methinks Sol is struggling to figure out the difference between local and bulk strength. I would suggest re-reading section 4.1 of the Attree et al paper, where the MUPUS results are directly addressed.
 
Last edited:
Chapter 2
Birkeland Currents in Cosmic Plasma
Peratt A.L

Cold and warm electrons at comet 67P A. I. Eriksson1, I. A. D. Engelhardt1; 2, M. André1, R. Boström1, N. J. T. Edberg1,F. L. Johansson1; 2, E. Odelstad1; 2, E. Vigren1, J.-E. Wahlund1, P. Henri3, J.-P. Lebreton3,W. J. Miloch4, J. J. P. Paulsson4, C. Simon Wedlund4, L. Yang4, T. Karlsson5, R. Jarvinen6,T. Broiles7, K. Mandt7; 8, C. M. Carr9, M. Galand9, H. Nilsson10, and C. Norberg10

You are aware are you not tusenfem?

As you say, super duper space plasma physicist, all very basic stuff!

If you would actually understand electrodynamics and plasma physics, then you would see that your ridiculous quote mining is senseless for a traveling helical wave down the tail.

Do you really think that I would not have thought of that, or that the referees would not have come up with that possibility?
 
Sol88: Delusion that up coming papers will change the density of comets, etc.

...Things rock as will be born out in the up coming papers.
8 January 2017 Sol88: Total delusion that up coming papers will change the density of comets as measured over at least 60 years, the detection of ices on comets, the ice in Deep Impact ejecta, etc.
 
[URL="http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12110589#post12110589"]553 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 22 December 2017 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)[/URL]

  1. 22 December 2017 Sol88: Idiotically quoting what makes an assertion of double layers in comet tails insane
  2. 22 December 2017 Sol88: Insults posters knowledge since I and other posters know what double layers are.
  3. 27 December 2017 Sol88: Lies about nonexistent, unnamed "structures" - Harri Laakso has no "structures" and names what they are looking at - current layers.
  4. 27 December 2017 Sol88: It is a repeated, deluded lie that there are double layers in the Laakso paper so there is no "contradiction".
  5. 27 December 2017 Sol88: A stupid question to derail from his comet delusions.
  6. 27 December 2017 Sol88: Idiotic CONCERT/MUPAS lie about 67P.
  7. 27 December 2017 Sol88: Repeats the stupidity of rock all the way when he cites evidence that it is not!
  8. 27 December 2017 Sol88: A blatant "Mainstream have “nothing’" lie when high porosity is what the mainstream predicts.
  9. 27 December 2017 Sol88: The utter stupidity of 87% porosity = nothing.
  10. 27 December 2017 Sol88: Lies by not citing "On the density of Halley's comet" published in November 1989
The electric comet delusion has at least 45 years without a scientific electric comet model or observations to support it :eek: !

Over 2 years and counting of fear of doing basic physics: 25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.
The parroting of the Thunderbolt cult ignorance, delusions and lies in this thread alone (continuation of a thread that is now 8 years of delusions from Sol88)
10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.
 
Last edited:
If you would actually understand electrodynamics and plasma physics, then you would see that your ridiculous quote mining is senseless for a traveling helical wave down the tail.

Do you really think that I would not have thought of that, or that the referees would not have come up with that possibility?

they did?
 
no you cannot call them what you want, each has a clear definition
nd i have seen no evidence for this chardged inner and outer sides

PLASMA ENVIRONMENT AROUND COMET 67P/CHURYUMOV–GERASIMENKO AT PERIHELION:
MODEL COMPARISON WITH ROSETTA DATA


3. OBSERVATION OF THE DIAMAGNETIC CAVITY OF COMET 67P/CG

This boundary, that was assumed to be outside of the diamagnetic cavity, was characterized by enhanced magnetic field pile-up, reduced electron densities, and accelerated water-group ions on the outside, and reduced magnetic field pile-up, enhanced electron densities, and low energy water-group ions on the inside (Mandt et al. 2016).

also,

Originally Posted by Sol88 View Post
Could you imagine if Rosetta was able to cross these current layers, double layers and plasma instabilities at a more perpendicular angle!
What does this even mean?!?!
If you would read my current sheet paper then you would see how they are crossed.
You cannot cross an instability "more perpendicular"
.

It is important to realize that these observations were made
while the spacecraft was escorting the comet and was hovering
in the flank region, unlike comet 1P/Halley’s observations
which were made during a transiting flyby. So it is unlikely that
the spacecraft is moving through the plasma boundaries, but
rather the plasma boundaries are expanding and contracting.

but

Goetz et al. (2016) suggested that the
most likely explanation for this moving/transient boundary is
the existence of Kelvin–Helmholtz instabilities propagating
tail-ward along the cavity surface. The transient nature of these
events, however, makes it difficult to compare the observations
at comet 67P/CG with other comets such as 1P/Halley.

so the diamagnetic cavity may not be as it seems!

We do note again that other interpretations of
the diamagnetic regions exist. For example, they could be
highly localized regions with high plasma pressure, displacing
the magnetic field (Huang et al. 2016). However, according to
IES observations presented in the current paper, this pressure
cannot come from the suprathermal electrons.


Interesting, other interpretations of the diamagnetic regions exist!

What interpretations I hear you say...

possible mechanism for the formation of magnetic field dropouts in the coma of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

Seems Z. Huang and C. Goetz are at odds!

In our opinion, it is possible that the observed diamagnetic region
in Goetz et al. (2016a) is not a ‘classical’ diamagnetic cavity, but
it might be a local phenomenon caused by some different process.
There are (at least) two reasons why the diamagnetic region might
not be associated with a global diamagnetic cavity surrounding
the nucleus: (i) the total gas production rate is not sufficient to
create such a large diamagnetic cavity, and (ii) the large number
and short duration of these magnetic field-free regions. As Goetz
et al. (2016a) discussed, the total gas production rate must be larger
than 3×1028 s−1 at 1.3 au to create an extended cavity expanding to
around 170 km. Hansen et al. (2016) obtained a total gas production
rate of ∼1028 s−1 at 1.3 au from a multi-instrumental analysis of
Rosetta observations, which is a factor of 3 smaller than the gas
production rate necessary to push the diamagnetic cavity boundary
out to the Rosetta’s location.

We also argue that the minimum magnetic field magnitude
is not necessarily zero, as assumed by Goetz et al. (2016a). It
can be some small field, like a few nT.

In this paper, we consider a generic process
that temporarily increases the local electron pressure in a magnetic
flux tube. Such process could involve interaction with an
energetic electron beam with the coma Gan & Cravens (1990) or
some other process.

Under these conditions,
the extra heating results in a strong electron pressure gradient
perpendicular to the flux tube (see Fig. 2). The electron pressure
gradient creates a strong ambipolar electric field that will be eventually
responsible for the development of a short-lived magnetic
dropout.


Bloody double layers ay! :D

Seems Rosetta may have been flying thru flux tubes connected to the nucleus!

JD116's argument falls on it's arse. Diamagnetic cavity always sounded a bit like magnetic reconnection! magical neutral gas holds back solar wind!!!
 
Last edited:
A possible mechanism for the formation of magnetic field dropouts
in the coma of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

Z. Huang,1‹ G. T´oth,1 T. I. Gombosi,1 A. Bieler,1 M. R. Combi,1 K. C. Hansen,1
X. Jia,1 N. Fougere,1 Y. Shou,1 T. E. Cravens,2 V. Tenishev,1 K. Altwegg3
and M. Rubin3


Note that in our simulation, magnetic dropout region is not necessarily zero, but can have a small, nearly constant value. This is consistent with the Rosetta RPC-MAG observations where the near-constant magnetic field values in the ‘cavities’ are assumed to represent a zero external field. We plan to do a more detailed comparison between our simulation results and the RPC-MAG observations with realistic solar wind parameters (including time-varying solar wind drivers) in a follow-up study to further testify our proposed mechanism. The physical picture we provide in this paper is simple: a local electron heating process can generate a magnetic field-free region due to a strong ambipolar electric field. However, due to the limitations of fluid simulations, we are not able to simulate the local electron heating process self-consistently. Finally, as we mentioned earlier in this paper, at this time we are unable to identify a specific process producing such a short-lived electron heating in isolated magnetic flux tubes. Rosetta observations do not show increased energetic electron fluxes in the vicinity of diamagnetic dropouts Madanian et al. (2016a,b); Nemeth et al. (2016). On the other hand, the spacecraft potential stays very negative during the magnetic dropouts (Eriksson, private communication) implying the presence of large photoelectron fluxes .10 eV that are sufficient for driving spacecraft potential to the observed negative potentials. Further investigation is necessary, but at this point we argue that a localized increase of thermal electron pressure is not inconsistent with the Rosetta observations and we used this process as a ‘placeholder’ for the source of observed magnetic dropouts.
 
Last edited:
Bloody double layers ay!

Nope. Not even remotely close. Look up double layer. Do not forget that diamagnetic cavities were observed at Halley and during the AMPTE experiments. People who know a hell of a lot more about DLs than you obviously do (such as Mendis, Tusenfem et al), have seen that data. None of them have been stupid enough to call them a DL. In fact, the only person on the planet, as far as I can tell, who believes it is a DL is you. And you aren't remotely qualified to understand what you're talking about. Therefore we can safely ignore it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom