Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
15 December 2014: Electric comets still do not exist!

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, etc. etc.

The electric comet delusion has at least 45 years without a scientific electric comet model or observations to support it :eek: !

Over 2 years and counting of fear of doing basic physics: 25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.

The parroting of the Thunderbolt cult ignorance, delusions and lies in this thread alone (continuation of a thread that is now 8 years of delusions from Sol88)
10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.

618 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 29 January 2018 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)

  1. 30 January 2018 Sol88: Lies about a "change of tack" when it is old idiocy of derailing from his comet delusions.
  2. 30 January 2018 Sol88: Lies about the contents of papers to derail from his comet delusions.
  3. 30 January 2018 Sol88: The irrelevant fantasy that the Rosetta spacecraft took measurements at the comet nucleus.
  4. 30 January 2018 Sol88: Lies about his comet delusions where jets are electrical discharges, not charged dust.
  5. 30 January 2018 Sol88: A "jet" lie when we see jets of neutral gas from sublimating ices and no charged dust from the surface.
  6. 30 January 2018 Sol88: Insane charged dust question to derail from his comet delusions.
  7. 31 January 2018 Sol88: Usual lies to derail from his comet delusions.
  8. 31 January 2018 Sol88: A lie that the "anomalistic feature" paper is relevant to jonesdave116's post which is not about nanoparticles.
  9. 31 January 2018 Sol88: A lie that the "anomalistic feature" paper is about charged dust from the nucleus.
  10. 31 January 2018 Sol88: A lie about the GIADA instrument observations which are not charged dust from the nucleus.
  11. 31 January 2018 Sol88: A lie about the third paper which is not about charged dust from the nucleus (large grains being charged up in the coma and fragmenting).
  12. 31 January 2018 Sol88: A lie that jonesdave116's post is about centrifugal spin up of dust.
 
Okay, let's see what the geniuses Wallace & Gromit have to say about the dust, shall we? Particularly as this thread is about the 'electric comet';



So, I'm kind of surprised that Sol wants to draw attention to yet another failed prediction from the EC model. What on Earth did Thornie think was causing sunlight to reflect and therefore reveal the dusty coma? What was he doing when all the Halley papers were being released? Etc, etc. Looks like wilful ignorance and scientific ineptitude to me.

EDIT:
Just for clarity, can we now confirm that we are no longer discussing T & T's EC model? What we are now discussing, is Sol 88's EC model. Yes?


:( got me again jd116.

At perihelion and just after, the dust-to-water mass ratio ranges from 6 to 100 (Fulle et al. 2016).

VIRTIS observes less than 1 per cent of volume concentration of water ice averaged over the nucleus surface (Capaccioni et al. 2015), and at most 4 per cent in some few bright spots (Filacchione et al. 2016).

Alarge dust-to-water mass ratio implies that the nucleus matrix is non-volatile, so that ground-based experiments (Gr¨un et al. 1993) and thermo-physical models of cometary nuclei (Prialnik, Benkoff &Podolak 2004), assuming an ice matrix, may provide misleading results: they should be repeated assuming a refractory matrix,which has micro-properties far from ices.

Dust dust dust all dust!

(except for the well consolidated material observed in fractured and layered terrain)

But yeah looks like they ballsed it up!

My model? No still just a rock discharging in the solar wind.

Simple stupid it is.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Multiple idiocy and a lie derailing from his comet delusions

31 January 2018 Sol88: Multiple idiocy and a lie derailing from his comet delusions.

The idiocy is
  • Quoting "dust-to-water mass ratio ranges from 6 to 100".
  • Quoting the detection of water ice on the nucleus surface.
  • Quoting "a large dust-to-water mass ratio" for the nucleus matrix.
when his over 8 year old delusion is that comets are rocks.

31 January 2018 Sol88: An "all dust" lie when he quotes dust to water ratios.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, etc. etc.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Boring delusion that his comet delusions include negatively charged dust

Interesting the dust is negatively charged.
31 January 2018 Sol88: Boring delusion that his comet delusions include negatively charged dust.

31 January 2018 Sol88: A lie - it was some nanoparticles that were found to be negatively charged.
Negatively charged nano-grains at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
This of course begs the question of the lack of detections of positively charged nano-dust particles. We suggest that this is likely an instrumental effect, as particles that directly deliver surplus electrons to the instrument’s microchannel plate could more efficiently start an electron avalanche that is able to be detected.


Looks like a dumb attempt to support his latest comet delusion of "the charged dust moving off the surface in “jets” constitutes an electric current.", soon to be added to the list.
 
Last edited:
OK; Let's play a game of pretend, yes? Imagine that there was some undetectable woo, causing unobserved O- ions to leave the comet (not observed); what process do the idiots from the EU side of the divide think is going to turn this into water? Please explain, or give it up chaps; you're thick. Yes? Just admit it. We'll think nothing less of you. That is impossible :) Lern to scienz. Yes?
 
@JD116

:)

yup ballsup again

It's seems it's not O- but O2 oh well...

In a new paper, Giapis and his co-author and Caltech colleague Yunxi Yaos propose that the molecular oxygen at Comet 67P is not ancient, but is being produced right now by interactions within the comet's nebulous aura, or coma, between water molecules coursing off the comet and particles streaming from the sun.

"We have shown experimentally that it is possible to form molecular oxygen dynamically on the surface of materials similar to those found on the comet," said Yaos.

Here's how it works: Water vapor molecules stream off the comet as it is heated by the sun. The water molecules become ionized, or charged, by ultraviolet light from the sun, and then the sun's wind blows the ionized water molecules back toward the comet. When the water molecules hit the comet's surface, which contains oxygen bound in materials such as rust and sand, the molecules pick up another oxygen atom from the surface and O2 is formed.

"This abiotic production mechanism is consistent with reported trends in the 67P coma," the researchers write in their paper, "and raises awareness of the role of energetic negative ions," not only in comets but other planetary bodies as well.

This oxygen-producing mechanism could be happening in a wide range of situations.
Comet 67P Found to Be Producing Its Own Oxygen in Deep Space

Ahhh, the 'ol dirtysnowball!! :o
Hey maybe even H2O as well!

More please jd116, loving it.

Tusenfem's paper will be out soon and well.... lets see ay!

OBTW, just throw a little carbon into the mix and hey presto H+C+O and any combination of! What do we find on a comet jd116?
 
Last edited:
Sol88: A lie about jonesdave116's post to derail from his comet delusions

It's seems it's not O- but O2 oh well...
31 January 2018 Sol88: A lie about jonesdave116's post to derail from his comet delusions.
jonesdave116's question is about O- and does not state that it is the only ion or molecule emitted by comet nuclei. O2 was detected at Comet 67P in 2015 as in the article he cited (and earlier in this long thread) :jaw-dropp!

31 January 2018 Sol88: Usual idiocy of citing papers about ices and dust comets.

Comet 67P Found to Be Producing Its Own Oxygen in Deep Space
This is a mechanism for the 2015 detection of O2 being produced from water molecules (from sublimating water ices :eek:!) interacting with the solar wind + a further reaction with the surface dust.

That is the dust that his cult prophets state does not exist :jaw-dropp!

31 January 2018 Sol88: Yet another lie about his comet delusions which has that comet surfaces are burnt.
There is no ignorant "H+C+O" fantasy in his comet delusions. It is worse. There is the insane delusion that electrical discharges burn the surface of the nucleus to make it dark.

This is the first of several deeply ignorant questions from David Talbott in an 2005 interview: “Why are comet nuclei coal-black as if they have been burnt?”

We already know that Wal Thornhill is a constant liar (12 years lying about Deep Impact). But the lies are even more extensive.
A 2005 blog article has: "The burnt-black appearance of comet nuclei is the first problem for the dirty snowball model.". This is a blatant lie. The low albedo of comets is well explained by outgassing leaving behind dark organics.
 
Last edited:
Grabs RC by the nose and jams it in the trough and rubs it in

Here's how it works: Water vapor molecules stream off the comet as it is heated by the sun. The water molecules become ionized, or charged, by ultraviolet light from the sun, and then the sun's wind blows the ionized water molecules back toward the comet. When the water molecules hit the comet's surface, which contains oxygen bound in materials such as rust and sand, the molecules pick up another oxygen atom from the surface and O2 is formed.
 
31 January 2018 Sol88: A lie about jonesdave116's post to derail from his comet delusions.
jonesdave116's question is about O- and does not state that it is the only ion or molecule emitted by comet nuclei. O2 was detected at Comet 67P in 2015 as in the article he cited (and earlier in this long thread) :jaw-dropp!

31 January 2018 Sol88: Usual idiocy of citing papers about ices and dust comets.

Comet 67P Found to Be Producing Its Own Oxygen in Deep Space
This is a mechanism for the 2015 detection of O2 being produced from water molecules (from sublimating water ices :eek:!) interacting with the solar wind + a further reaction with the surface dust.

That is the dust that his cult prophets state does not exist :jaw-dropp!

31 January 2018 Sol88: Yet another lie about his comet delusions which has that comet surfaces are burnt.
There is no ignorant "H+C+O" fantasy in his comet delusions. It is worse. There is the insane delusion that electrical discharges burn the surface of the nucleus to make it dark.

This is the first of several deeply ignorant questions from David Talbott in an 2005 interview: “Why are comet nuclei coal-black as if they have been burnt?”

We already know that Wal Thornhill is a constant liar (12 years lying about Deep Impact). But the lies are even more extensive.
A 2005 blog article has: "The burnt-black appearance of comet nuclei is the first problem for the dirty snowball model.". This is a blatant lie. The low albedo of comets is well explained by outgassing leaving behind dark organics.

Was this predicted in the dirtysnowball model RC?

Instead, interactions between water, particles streaming from the sun and grains of sand or rust on the comet’s surface could generate the gas. Those interactions could explain the surprising abundance of O2 detected in the fuzzy envelope of gas around comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko in 2015 (SN: 11/28/15, p. 6), researchers report May 8 in Nature Communications. Such reactions might also reveal how oxygen forms in other regions of space.

Much how uncle Wal said WATER would be produced!!

Again the mainstream with the cart before the horse...contradicting yourselves... again.

So now water blowing in the wind makes O2 :boggled: :rolleyes:

:p

Next please :rolleyes:
 
@JD116

:)

yup ballsup again

It's seems it's not O- but O2 oh well...

Comet 67P Found to Be Producing Its Own Oxygen in Deep Space

Ahhh, the 'ol dirtysnowball!! :o
Hey maybe even H2O as well!

More please jd116, loving it.

Tusenfem's paper will be out soon and well.... lets see ay!

OBTW, just throw a little carbon into the mix and hey presto H+C+O and any combination of! What do we find on a comet jd116?

Nope. The EC fantasy mentions nothing about O2. And that paper has been discussed before. They are likely very wrong. The mechanism is very iffy, and their numbers don't add up. By a long way. In my opinion, it should never have been published. The authors have no previous papers on comets. The lead author is a chemical engineer. He never explains how these ions make it past the piled up magnetic field at the cavity boundary. In short - it ain't happening.
As for the H2O - please provide the numbers of H+ions required to form the observed amount of H2O. What are the energetics of such a process? What is the H+ combining with? Where has this been seen? Numbers, please. Not to mention some viable physics/ chemistry!
Like I said, pure woo.
 
Last edited:
Was this predicted in the dirtysnowball model RC?

Yes, as has been pointed out to you numerous times. Read the bloody Whipple paper. It has been sitting around for nearly 7 decades, and is free access. What colour do you think 'meteoritic material' is? Huh? What do you think was seen at Halley in 1986? 20 years before Wallace & Gromit came up with their scientifically illiterate nonsense. How could those two idiots 'predict' anything, when it had already been seen two decades earlier? Like RC said - liars.

ooHMC_BEST_H1.jpg


For the hard of thinking, that is Halley ^^^^^
 
Last edited:
Much how uncle Wal said WATER would be produced!!

Lol. No, he didn't! Here is what was described by Thornhill, as he displayed his ignorance of a number of scientific concepts:

When astronomers view the comas of comets spectroscopically, what they actually see is the hydroxyl radical (OH), which they assume to be a residue of water (H2O) broken down by the ultraviolet light of the Sun (photolysis).

Wrong. What they actually see is H20. As has been known since the Kuiper Airborne Observatory first definitively detected it in IR in 1985 at Halley. So I guess that goes down as another lie. Further:

In the electric model, negative oxygen ions are accelerated away from the comet in energetic jets, then combine preferentially with protons from the solar wind to form the observed OH radical and the neutral hydrogen gathered around the coma in vast concentric bubbles.

Wrong again. Where are these negative oxygen ions? How are they combining with H+ at ~ 400 km/s? How much H+ is available, and how does that match up to the observed H2O production? Sorry, it is complete gibberish. Nothing to do with science.
 
Last edited:
Interesting the dust is negatively charged.

And ...
What is the definition of a current?

J = Σm nm vm qm

So, unless you can show that the ions and electrons are doing something completely different than the dust, the possibility is quite high that in the end you will find that J = 0.
 
Regarding the paper mentioned upthread by Sol:

Dynamic molecular oxygen production in cometary comae
Yao, Y. & Giapis, K. P.
https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms15298

I have e-mailed Prof. Giapis regarding their mechanism, and asked for clarification on a) the quantities of observed O2 compared to what their model predicts, and b) how they are proposing that the ions get beyond the piled up IMF at the cavity boundary. It'll be some ungodly time of day in California, so it may take a while to get a reply. I will report on the reply here, should I get one.
 
Last edited:
@JD116

:)

yup ballsup again

It's seems it's not O- but O2 oh well...

Comet 67P Found to Be Producing Its Own Oxygen in Deep Space

Ahhh, the 'ol dirtysnowball!! :o
Hey maybe even H2O as well!

More please jd116, loving it.

Tusenfem's paper will be out soon and well.... lets see ay!

OBTW, just throw a little carbon into the mix and hey presto H+C+O and any combination of! What do we find on a comet jd116?

that paper was so full of nonsense, and there should be a rebuttal paper that shows that it is completely impossible what these peeps proposed, but I am not sure about the status of that paper. Just thinking out a mechanism that works in the lab, does not mean that you can just willy-nilly apply it to cometary dust, without looking whether the actual ingredients for the mechanisms are available.
 
Sol88: Idiotic "rubs it in" lie about a quote to derail from comet delusions

1 February 2018 Sol88: Idiotic "rubs it in" lie about a quote to derail from his comet delusions

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets,, etc. etc.
Add the latest ignorant delusion of imaginary "jets" of charged dust from the nucleus being electric currents.

The quote is from the Comet 67P Found to Be Producing Its Own Oxygen in Deep Space article
Here's how it works: Water vapor molecules stream off the comet as it is heated by the sun. The water molecules become ionized, or charged, by ultraviolet light from the sun, and then the sun's wind blows the ionized water molecules back toward the comet. When the water molecules hit the comet's surface, which contains oxygen bound in materials such as rust and sand, the molecules pick up another oxygen atom from the surface and O2 is formed.
The highlighted text is water ice sublimating to form water vapor as it is heated by the Sun :jaw-dropp!
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Totally idiotic question to derail from his comet delusions

Was this predicted in the dirtysnowball model RC?
1 February 2018 Sol88: Totally idiotic question to derail from his comet delusions.

1 February 2018 Sol88: Stupidity of citing the documented liar Wal Thornhill.

1 February 2018 Sol88: Stupidity of emphasizing that Wal's fantasies are just water magically appears and not how or how much!
N.B. No citation for his "uncle Wal" suggests the cult's insanity of imaginary electric discharges somehow producing water from a delusion of rock.

1 February 2018 Sol88: A lie about the mainstream contradicting itself when every paper he has ever cited is about ices and dust comets.

1 February 2018 Sol88: The repeated and abysmal idiocy that any issues with the mainstream is support for his comet delusions.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom