Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
A growing list of Electric Sun delusions and lies parroted and written by Sol88

Repeat, ...
A growing list of Electric Sun delusions and lies mindlessly parroted and written by Sol88.
  1. The delusion that the temperature of the solar corona is not explained by mainstream solar physics.
  2. Repeated lies that the ignorant and deluded electric sun idea can explain the temperature of the corona.
    No mechanism cited. Not even one calculation of the corona temperature :eye-poppi!
  3. He is ignorant about the Sun, i.e. that all stable stars need a central heat source to be stable + the Sun without a central heat source = a white dwarf.
    This is: The true insanity of the electric sun delusion is that it makes the Sun into a white dwarf :eye-poppi!
  4. He has the delusion that the inane SAFIRE experiment will say anything about the Sun.
  5. Repeats the mainstream has no explanation lie again with a link to coronal heating problem that lists the proposed solutions and their evidence.
  6. A lie that images of magnetic braids are electric currents.
    Images of the Sun's million degree corona, including images of the magnetic braids (left hand side).
 
A repeated lie that Birkeland currents appear in comets

Including everybody’s favourite, field aligned currents. ...
Recycling his previous lies and delusions about Birkeland currents, etc.

20 March 2018: A lie that field aligned currents have to be Birkeland currents.
tusenfem: There are, as usual, various processed which produce field aligned currents

Birkeland currents are a specific case of field aligned currents connecting to the Earth's ionosphere (and maybe on other planets) caused by the interaction of the solar wind with the Earth's magnetic field and the ionosphere.

20 March 2018: A repeated lie that Birkeland currents appear in comets which have no Earth-like magnetic field.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock.
 
Last edited:
10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.

The electric comet delusion has at least 45 years without a scientific electric comet model or observations to support it :eek: !

Getting lose to 3 years of the fear of doing basic physics: 25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock.

744 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 12 March 2018 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)
  1. 12 March 2018: Lies about "Deep Impact: The first second" to derail from his many comet delusions.
  2. 12 March 2018: Lies about a M.G.G.T. Taylor quote which is not any of his comet delusions.
  3. 12 March 2018: Repeats his lie that this anything to do with his many comet delusions.
  4. 13 March 2018: A lie that a tweet title supports his many comet delusions.
  5. 14 March 2018: A lie that Cremonese, G. et al is "maybe hydrated minerals" as in his comet delusions (i.e. rock).
  6. 14 March 2018: The insanity that he can call ices and dust comets rock when his delusions include that comets are actual rock.
  7. 14 March 2018: A "M.Volwerk, M.Taylor, Jean-Pierre Bibring and others call it rock" lie.
  8. 14 March 2018: 2 more lies, stupidity and an insult to derail from his many comet delusions.
  9. 14 March 2018: Already deluded and ignorant enough to call comets actual rock so yet another rock rant is not unexpected.
  10. 14 March 2018: Usual lies about papers to detail from his comet delusions.
  11. 15 March 2018: A lie about what I wrote (write rock = ices + dust not his delusion of actual rock)
  12. 15 March 2018: Delusions on comet "bulk density goes toward 2-3g/cm3" when the measured bulk densities are < 1, etc.
  13. 15 March 2018: A lie that in Sunshine et.al. ice becomes less necessary.
  14. 15 March 2018: An ignorant rant and lies about Cremonese, G. et al again.
  15. 15 March 2018: Idiocy of not understanding "rock in the wind" + philosophical was a joke.
  16. 19 March 2018: Stupidity of imaginary charge affecting the mass of an asteroid in a thread about his comet delusions :eye-poppi!
  17. 19 March 2018: Insanity of a Thunderbolts propaganda video on delusions about the Sun.
  18. 19 March 2018: A lying because already answered question to derail from his many comet delusions.
  19. 19 March 2018: A couple of lies about the Sun and comets.
  20. 19 March 2018: A couple of lies about the solar corona's temperature: There are mainstream mechanism to explain the temperature, model, he only has ignorant delusions.
  21. 19 March 2018: Repeat of the lie of DLs at comets that only exist in his head: "imaginary double layers do magic".
  22. 19 March 2018: Insanity of papers about Ceres (not a comet) and Ceres delusions to derail from his many comet delusions.
  23. 19 March 2018: Real insanity of Comet 67P being from Mars?
  24. 19 March 2018: Lies about detected electric fields being the electric field in his many comet delusions.
  25. 19 March 2018: Lies about "ELECTRIC FIELDS AND COLD ELECTRONS AT COMET HALLEY" by LAKKSO
  26. 19 March 2018: Lies abut double layers that do "care about Debye length" as he knows from several posts.
  27. 19 March 2018: Idiocy of citing the deluded SAFIRE PDF which has the insanity of making the Sun a white dwarf!
  28. 19 March 2018: Lying solar corona question to derail from his many comet (and now sun) delusions.
  29. 19 March 2018: Unthinking parroting of the SAFIRE delusions about the Sun.
  30. 19 March 2008: Abysmal ignorance about comets is extended to the Sun.
  31. 19 March 2018: Repeated lie that coronal heating is not a problem for his deluded externally powered electric sun when the existence of the Sun is a problem :eye-poppi!
  32. 20 March 2018: Yet another lying question to derail from his many sun and comet delusions.
  33. 20 March 2018: A lie that field aligned currents have to be Birkeland currents.
  34. 20 March 2018: A repeated lie that Birkeland currents appear in comets which have no Earth-like magnetic field.
 
A general note on the stupidity of making the validity of the electric comet and sun delusions depend on each other.
Comets being rocks is just wrong since we measure their density to be not that of rock (the rest of the fairy story is what makes electric comet into an insane delusion).

Having no central heat source for the Sun and other stars is actually insane. An electric sun story stating that is an obviously insane delusion :jaw-dropp.

The insanity is understood by anyone who has read a first year astronomy textbook or can do physics involving gravity and gas. A stable star has a balance between gravity compressing it and thermal pressure expanding it. Remove gravity and you have a molecular cloud. Remove thermal pressure and you get a white dwarf (the future of the Sun when fusion runs out), neutron star or black hole depending on the mass of the star. That balance needs the increasing weight of gas with depth to be balanced by an increasing pressure and temperature with depth. Heat flows from hot to cold so there has to be a heat source at the center of stars. That increase in temperature is confirmed by physical evidence (limb darkening, helioseismology).

Maybe Scott and Thornhill have never read any astronomy textbooks. But it is more likely they are so deluded about "electric everything" that they deny the well tested laws of gravity and gas used in astronomy textbooks.
 
Last edited:
Maybe Scott and Thornhill have never read any astronomy textbooks. But it is more likely they are so deluded about "electric everything" that they deny the well tested laws of gravity and gas used in astronomy textbooks.

Deny the laws of gravity? Thornhill is trying to rewrite them! Current laws cannot have Venus doing handbrake turns around the solar system a week last Tuesday. And do not measure comet densities as being that of rock. Given that he , nor the other loon Velikovsky, can't possibly be wrong, then the laws of gravity must be wrong!
 
If it is a good book to read, than maybe you should actually READ it.
Oh okay, it's not out yet (another paper I am waiting for to appear), but try Kivelson & Russell, introduction space physics, and actually try to learn some plasma physics.
My current sheets are normal Harris current sheets, created by curl B, but as you don't seem to know Maxwell's equations, it probably means nothing to you.
And of course there are also other ways of creating currents, e.g. through the shear motion of the footpoints of a magnetic loop on the Sun..

This is all very basic and simple plasma physics and/or electrodynamics. How can you be an EC proponent when you don't even know the basics of the theories on which the EC nonsense is supposed to be based?

It's mind boggling.

Very simplified plasma physics so you can do the maths???
 
Very simplified plasma physics so you can do the maths???

Go have a look at any of Alfven's papers on plasma physics. See all those numbers and funny looking characters? That's maths. Now, please do explain to us who are the geniuses who came up with the electric comet woo, and the electric sun woo, and what their qualifications are in plasma physics, and what papers they have written on the subject.
 
Very simplified plasma physics so you can do the maths???

I don't need "simplified" plasma physics, whatever that is, I was talking about simple, basic plasma physics.
Simple as in, stuff that actually you might understand with a little effort.

Now, please answer my other questions about MHD and field aligned currents.
 
<snip>

But getting off topic sorta because as I said, ELECTRIC COMET = ELECTRIC SUN = ELECTRIC UNIVERSE....
I think you've stumbled upon a deep universal truth, Sol88! :jaw-dropp

No need for magnetic reconnection, or any mathemagical nonsense, when simple logic will do.

For example:

YELLOW DESERT = YELLOW PLANET = YELLOW STAR = YELLOW GALAXY = YELLOW UNIVERSE.

:D
 
Spot on, we agree.

The corona his hotter than the photosphere and the mainstream have a coronal heating problem.

Repeat, the is NO coronal heating problem in the ELECTRIC SUN and the laws of thermodynamics hold.

And just for a hint...Images of the Sun's million degree corona, including images of the magnetic braids (left hand side).

Maybe a current involved and it has squat to do with tusenfems Curl b.
Let me see if I can apply Sol88's amazing logic ...

The flame on my gas stove is hot, yet the pipes the gas comes in are cold; in fact, the part that's outside in the open air (next to the gas meter) was well below 0C for much of this winter.

Therefore, since magnetic reconnection is a myth, my gas stove is powered by ... wait for it ... electricity! :p
 
No, we don't. You believe in something that is thermodynamically impossible, for any solar model.
[puts EU acolyte hat on]

Ziggy, Ziggy, Ziggy, you and your mainstream thermodynamics.

Don't you know that Jean-Pierre Robi-something proved that its foundations are wrong? He even got a paper published in an esteemed physics journal (where Crothers' proofs that GR is wrong is also published) laying out in mathemagical detail just how wrong it is (yeah, I have no idea what it says, but as Crothers has endorsed it, it must be right).

Besides, he also proved that the so-called CMB is just microwaves coming from the world's oceans (or ice in the instruments, I get these two confused, they're so similar), which is solid proof that he's right.

So mainstream thermodynamics is just as wrong as magnetic reconnection, and the sooner you start studying real physics the sooner you'll realize that the universe is ELECTRIC YELLOW!!!!!

[takes EU acolyte hat off]

Sol88 logic to the rescue again! ;)
 
No, we don't. You believe in something that is thermodynamically impossible, for any solar model.

Are you saying we don’t agree that in the laws of thermodynamics? that temperature becomes cooler the further you move from the heat source?????

This not what SAFIRE have found...


Funny because the mainstream never looked, after all it is assumed the Sun is a thermonuclear bomb contained by gravity.... :blush:


On the other hand, a bunch of loons doing empirical science “at home” are showing the entrenched dogma to be lacking severely.

Like.... the coronal heating problem! :thumbsup:
 
Go have a look at any of Alfven's papers on plasma physics. See all those numbers and funny looking characters? That's maths. Now, please do explain to us who are the geniuses who came up with the electric comet woo, and the electric sun woo, and what their qualifications are in plasma physics, and what papers they have written on the subject.


Assuming “ideal” MHD?

Alfven said it would lead you up the garden path and we’ll... it has!

Where is the complete curcuit?

As shown by Decca.
 
Are you saying we don’t agree that in the laws of thermodynamics? that temperature becomes cooler the further you move from the heat source?????

That isn't a law of thermodynamics. It's often a consequence of the actual laws of thermodynamics plus appropriate conditions, but it isn't a law.

What you proposed (a solar interior cooler than the photosphere) does in fact violate the laws of thermodynamics. Even supposing the entire heat source of the sun was the corona (which is trivially disprovable by simply looking at it, because that too violates thermodynamics but for reasons I haven't discussed yet) and no heating came from inside the sun, thermodynamics would still require that whatever was under the photosphere be at least as hot as the photosphere.

Funny because the mainstream never looked, after all it is assumed the Sun is a thermonuclear bomb contained by gravity.... :blush:

Bomb? No, not a bomb. Mainstream solar theory predicts an extremely low power density for the sun. That's very un-bomb-like.

But again, we don't need to believe that to know you're wrong about the solar interior being colder than the photosphere. Thermodynamics precludes that, regardless of the heating mechanism or location.
 
There are, as usual, various processed which produce field aligned currents.

Is there any reason you can come up with why ideal MHD would (not) hold for Birkeland currents?

Do you actually know what (ideal) MHD is, and what the restricting parameters are for (ideal) MHD, and do you think that field aligned currents are affected by that?

Does your question actually make sense?

Ummm...wtf???
Of particular importance is the existence of
magnetic-field aligned electric fields, which were considered non-existent on the basis of idealized models but have proved to play a key role both in acceleration processes and in plasma dynamics.

ABSTRACT
In situ measurements in the Earth’s magnetosphere have led to a substantial and ongoing revision of our understanding of cosmic plasmas. The real cosmic plasmas behave in ways different than predicted by traditional idealized models in respects as fundamental as plasma dynamics, conduction of electric current and energization of charged particles
The Earth’s Magnetosphere as a Key to the Plasma Universe
C.-G. Fälthammar

Your idealized models are to make the maths SIMPLE for you to be able to actually do the maths!!!! but they are not reality, the plasma is too tricky for your mathamagics :D
 
That isn't a law of thermodynamics. It's often a consequence of the actual laws of thermodynamics plus appropriate conditions, but it isn't a law.

What you proposed (a solar interior cooler than the photosphere) does in fact violate the laws of thermodynamics. Even supposing the entire heat source of the sun was the corona (which is trivially disprovable by simply looking at it, because that too violates thermodynamics but for reasons I haven't discussed yet) and no heating came from inside the sun, thermodynamics would still require that whatever was under the photosphere be at least as hot as the photosphere.



Bomb? No, not a bomb. Mainstream solar theory predicts an extremely low power density for the sun. That's very un-bomb-like.

But again, we don't need to believe that to know you're wrong about the solar interior being colder than the photosphere. Thermodynamics precludes that, regardless of the heating mechanism or location.

Yeah very good.

SAFIRE don't! thru empirical science and NOT theoretical science.

If you are a betting man empirical science wins hands down EVERY time.

The core of SAFIRE is cooler than its surrounding atmosphere

http://www.safirefilm.com/science/ewExternalFiles/SAFIRE-Phase-Three.pdf

So...my moneys on empirical science!
 
A couple of lies about the mainstream and the Sun

Funny because the mainstream never looked, after all it is assumed the Sun is a thermonuclear bomb contained by gravity.... :blush:
21 March 2018: A couple of lies about the mainstream and the Sun.
The mainstream has looked at every credible power source for the Sun.

The mainstream ignore obviously insane and deluded ideas such as those from an obscure internet cult such as Thunderbolts.

A blatant lie of an assumption of a " thermonuclear bomb contained by gravity".

On the other hand we have you ignorantly parroting the Thunderbolts cult and not learning or thinking at all.
A growing list of Electric Sun delusions and lies mindlessly parroted and written by Sol88.
+ A blatant lie of an assumption of a "thermonuclear bomb contained by gravity"
 
Ummm...wtf???

The Earth’s Magnetosphere as a Key to the Plasma Universe
C.-G. Fälthammar

Your idealized models are to make the maths SIMPLE for you to be able to actually do the maths!!!! but they are not reality, the plasma is too tricky for your mathamagics :D
What’s the world coming to, Sol88? :confused:

A student of Alfven writes a paper that totally shreds Thornhill’s, Talbott’s, and Scott’s work on the ELECTRIC SUN and the ELECTRIC UNIVERSE. Sad.

I must say, though, that I’m surprised you, of all people, would cite it ... don’t you know just how devastating a critique of the EU it is?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom