I don't believe Whipple was looking at such a detailed picture at that stage. Others would do that later. One thing we can say for certain though, is that Thornhill most definitely didn't predict it. I quote from the cornucopia of crap, the orchestrated litany of lies and obfuscation, that is the 'Electric Comet' pdf file, here:
http://thunderbolts.info/pdf/ElectricComet.pdf
I have done a word search on that piece of fiction, and here are the only relevant references to the word 'dust':
and.................
Kind of strange how there is more dust as the comet gets active, isn't it? Well, no it isn't, unless you believe in Thornhill's woo, which had already been shown to be wrong, twenty years before he wrote that tripe.
So, I'm not sure why Sol wants to keep reminding us of yet another failed prediction of the loon Thornhill. However, he may carry on if he must.