Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, i’d start by giving this paper a good going over, tusenfem.

Apossible mechanism for the formation of magnetic field dropouts in the coma of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko doi:10.1093/mnras/stw3118

In our opinion, it is possible that the observed diamagnetic region in Goetz et al. (2016a) is not a ‘classical’ diamagnetic cavity, but it might be a local phenomenon caused by some different process. There are (at least) two reasons why the diamagnetic region might not be associated with a global diamagnetic cavity surrounding the nucleus: (i) the total gas production rate is not sufcient to create such a large diamagnetic cavity, and (ii) the large number and short duration of these magnetic eld-free regions.


‘Classical’ is that secret code for we assumed and we were wrong?

Bit like ‘classical’ draping, ay?


The physical picture we provide in this paper is simple: a local electron heating process can generate a magnetic eld-free region due to a strong ambipolar electric eld. However, due to the limitations of uid simulations, we are not able to simulate the local electron heating process self-consistently.

Could a STRONG ambipolar electric field also be called a double layer, tusenfem?
 
Last edited:
Well, i’d start by giving this paper a good going over, tusenfem.

Apossible mechanism for the formation of magnetic field dropouts in the coma of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko doi:10.1093/mnras/stw3118

That paper has been discussed already, and it is a dud.
When asked, the authors do not know where their hot electrons come from.

'Classical’ is that secret code for we assumed and we were wrong?

No, classical means the the ion-neutral drag model creating the diamagetic cavity by Tom Cravens.

Bit like ‘classical’ draping, ay?

No, not at all.

Could a STRONG ambipolar electric field also be called a double layer, tusenfem?

No, an ambipolar electric field is generated actually to slow down the electrons which want to escape faster than the ions.
So, no an ambipolar elelctric field is not a double layer.
And again no, because a double layer would accelerate electrons in a beam and would not heat them like those that the authors put "not self-consistently" into their simulations.
 
Last edited:
  1. Per the ELECTRIC COMET model, all comets are rocky. However, not all rocky bodies are comets. (let's put aside "ice/s" for the purpose of my clarification question). How come?
I don't know? lets investigate shall we?

Sure.

Let's start with something pretty fundamental: what do you mean by "comet" (in the ELECTRIC COMET model)?

I think there's some subtlety you may be missing, which may be highlighted by some history.

Consider "planet".

Before telescopes, people in many parts of the world (cultures, societies, traditions, whatever) independently recognized what we today call Mercury, Venus, Mars, Jupiter, and Saturn. In some, Venus as a morning star was different from Venus as an evening star; in some, Mercury was not noted (dense forest, cloudy conditions, etc).

Before telescopes, these five could be classed together (as "planets") because they were "stars which wandered" (or something similar).

So too with "comets".

Perhaps not as many peoples recognized them as recognized planets (again, before telescopes), but certainly many different ones were observed. They could be classed together because they were "fuzzy/hairy/tailed things in the sky which moved (with respect to the "true" stars)" (or something similar).

With telescopes, planets could be seen as disks, some with phases (like the Moon), more were discovered, and one had rings. And the case for the morning and evening appearances of Mercury and Venus being the same (two) objects strengthened.

For comets, telescopes brought (many more) discoveries, tails of different kinds (several visually distinguishable, others require spectroscopy), a better handle on their variability (in "brightness"), ...

... and one thing very different, yet very similar, to planets: some comets "return" (the same "comet" re-appears in the sky, after ~87 years, or ~23 years, or ...). This is a little like evening star Venus = morning star Venus, but also not, because how a particular comet appeared, with each return, could be very different.

So why are the different returns of periodic comets (as we call them today) regarded as the same object (a comet), rather than different ones?

I would like you, Sol88, to have a go at answering this question. How you answer will - I expect - be very important for how we continue to discuss the ELECTRIC COMET model.

  1. OK. However, I think you need to quantify "a different potential" and to better define "the surrounding plasma". After all, 10-99 V could be such a difference, as could 1099 V. And "surrounding" could be as far away as merely 10-6m, or 106m.
The potential difference is anything you want except zero and the plasma surrounding the comet starts at the surface and ends at the heliopause.

Something for later ... :)
 
Typical response from an uninformed and apathetic mainstreamer.

I'm apathetic to your nonsense, yes. And how can I be informed about your model when your model contains no information? You're the one who said the voltage could be anything, not me.

Right, so obviously up to speed on double layers then. :o

I'm up to speed on basic electrodynamics, which double layers have to obey.

So they most probably are majic to the ignorant.

That's unintentionally ironic.
 
2) You think currents drive some significant processes here, mainly current carrying double layers! including the formation of water from rock. How can that happen at an arbitrary voltage? It cannot. There's got to be some minimum threshold voltage to make it happen, and there's got to be some voltage that's too large (ie, it would do MORE than what's observed).

My bold

[qimg]https://i.imgflip.com/28mhz5.jpg[/qimg]


Perhaps you can tell me why you doubt the double layers can not exist at/around a comet?


OT
Lol. It's ironic you would use this meme to make an assertion. Giorgio Tsoukalos is regarded as a charlatan and/or idiot by most people who can count beyond 10. The meme makes fun of his habit of making claims by allusion rather than declarative statements, so he can deny them if necessary. Hmm...
/OT
 
Yet another lying question to derail from his many comet delusions

Sorry RC, was that a yes or a no?
24 April 2018: Yet another lying question to derail from his many comet delusions.

23 April 2018: A stupid demand for a yes/no answer to support his delusions about comets and DLs.
You have documented lies and delusions about comets and DLs. It is up to you to be honest by producing scientific evidence (a paper stating the detection od DLs around comets) or saying that you were wrong.

Not that honesty will ever appear:
881 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 23 April 2018 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!) includes delusions about plasma.

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.

18 November 2010: The lies, failures and successes of Thunderbolts Deep Impact predictions by Wal Thornhill
2 December 2014: Sol88 does not notice that Wal Thornhill narrates an ignorant and deluded video about 67P!
18 December 2014: The bad science and delusions in Newton’s Electric Clockwork Solar System by Wal Thornhill.
5 January 2015: Wal Thornhill makes up fantasies about comets
10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.
13 April 2018: A couple of the delusions in Scott's Birkeland current paper.

The electric comet delusion has at least 45 years without a scientific electric comet model or observations to support it!

Getting lose to 3 years of the fear of doing basic physics: 25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.
 
Last edited:
I'm apathetic to your nonsense, yes. And how can I be informed about your model when your model contains no information? You're the one who said the voltage could be anything, not me.



I'm up to speed on basic electrodynamics, which double layers have to obey.



That's unintentionally ironic.

And Whipple gave you a quantitative model to work with? :blush:

Just so simple, Whipple said comets are icy bodies sublimating in the warmth of the sun. Electric comet says they are rocky bodies discharging in the solar plasma.

That’s it.
 
.

So why are the different returns of periodic comets (as we call them today) regarded as the same object (a comet), rather than different ones?

I would like you, Sol88, to have a go at answering this question. How you answer will - I expect - be very important for how we continue to discuss the ELECTRIC COMET model.



Something for later ... :)


Are you talking about Whipple non gravitational forces?
 
OT
Lol. It's ironic you would use this meme to make an assertion. Giorgio Tsoukalos is regarded as a charlatan and/or idiot by most people who can count beyond 10. The meme makes fun of his habit of making claims by allusion rather than declarative statements, so he can deny them if necessary. Hmm...
/OT


Not saying it was the aliens but it was the aliens!!!!


Classic!

Good on ziggurat putting a bit of light hearted fun into the conversation.
 
That paper has been discussed already, and it is a dud.
When asked, the authors do not know where their hot electrons come from.



No, classical means the the ion-neutral drag model creating the diamagetic cavity by Tom Cravens.



No, not at all.



No, an ambipolar electric field is generated actually to slow down the electrons which want to escape faster than the ions.
So, no an ambipolar elelctric field is not a double layer.
And again no, because a double layer would accelerate electrons in a beam and would not heat them like those that the authors put "not self-consistently" into their simulations.

Ahhh...the electron beam or “jets” of a comet, thank you tusenfem.

Not just electrons sport but also negatively charged dust.

Think we are making head way here tusenfem.
 
Are you talking about Whipple non gravitational forces?
Why do you ask?

Here's the question again (you can re-read the preamble if you like):

Why are the different returns of periodic comets (as we call them today) regarded as the same object (a comet), rather than different ones?

ETA: the working out of how to match a newly observed comet with one that had been observed before (i.e. not two different objects, but just one, no matter how different the appearances were) - or not - was done well before 1950. Indeed, well before Whipple was born.
 
Last edited:
Why do you ask?

Here's the question again (you can re-read the preamble if you like):

Why are the different returns of periodic comets (as we call them today) regarded as the same object (a comet), rather than different ones?

ETA: the working out of how to match a newly observed comet with one that had been observed before (i.e. not two different objects, but just one, no matter how different the appearances were) was done well before 1950. Indeed, well before Whippler was born.


I don’t understand your question. How do you know they are the same object?
 
I don’t understand your question. How do you know they are the same object?
Thanks Sol88.

The fact that you need to ask this question tells me a great deal about what you know, and what you do not know, about comets (as the term is used by most people, including astronomers).

The first periodic comet to be recognized (in some sense anyway) was Halley's comet, a.k.a. 1P/Halley; the WP article on it may help you to find an answer to your question.
 
That paper has been discussed already, and it is a dud.
When asked, the authors do not know where their hot electrons come from.



No, classical means the the ion-neutral drag model creating the diamagetic cavity by Tom Cravens.



No, not at all.



No, an ambipolar electric field is generated actually to slow down the electrons which want to escape faster than the ions.
So, no an ambipolar elelctric field is not a double layer.
And again no, because a double layer would accelerate electrons in a beam and would not heat them like those that the authors put "not self-consistently" into their simulations.

A dud, in a peer reviewed paper?

What's K. Altwegg's take on the dud paper she's co-authored?

It's only a dud paper if comets are dirtysnowballs and they use MHD.
 
Yes. And it's quite quantitative.



But not in a way that you can quantify, apparently.

Giotto provided the first evidence in support of Fred Whipple's "dirty snowball" hypothesis for comet construction; Whipple postulated that comets are icy objects warmed by the Sun as they approach the inner Solar System, causing ices on their surfaces to sublimate (change directly from a solid to a gas), and jets of volatile material to burst outward, creating the coma. Giotto showed that this model was broadly correct,[49] though with modifications. Halley's albedo, for instance, is about 4%, meaning that it reflects only 4% of the sunlight hitting it; about what one would expect for coal.[54] Thus, despite appearing brilliant white to observers on Earth, Halley's Comet is in fact pitch black. The surface temperature of evaporating "dirty ice" ranges from 170 K (−103 °C) at higher albedo to 220 K (−53 °C) at low albedo; Vega 1 found Halley's surface temperature to be in the range 300–400 K (30–130 °C). This suggested that only 10% of Halley's surface was active, and that large portions of it were coated in a layer of dark dust that retained heat.[15] Together, these observations suggested that Halley was in fact predominantly composed of non-volatile materials, and thus more closely resembled a "snowy dirtball" than a "dirty snowball".[16]
[55]

EC postulated that comets are rocky objects immersed in the solar plasma of the Sun causing a charge differential as they approach the inner Solar System, causing dust to be electrostatically machined from the surface and form highly collimated jets of charged dust and neutrals to burst outward, creating the coma.


Just as quantitative as Whipples?
 
Usual insanity of irrelevant papers to detail from his comet delusions

A dud, in a peer reviewed paper?
24 April 2018: Usual insanity of irrelevant papers to detail from his many comet delusions.
Especially since we have seen this paper before.
18 January 2018: Double idiocy of insult and a paper irrelevant to his comet delusions.
18 January 2018 Sol88: Inane post to derail from his comet delusions.

 
Last edited:
Lies about the electric comet delusion yet again

EC postulated ...
24 April 2018: Lies about the electric comet delusion yet again by missing out the blasted from planets insanity.

24 April 2018: A "postulated" and "quantitative" electric comet lie.
His Thunderbolts cult took the fantasies of a Bible scholar and used them to make up comet delusions with no quantitative predictions for over 45 years (see below).

24 April 2018: A Whipple postulated lie.
He has an unattributed quote which states that Whipple was broadly right and does not highlight that :jaw-dropp!
Postulates in science are used to create a scientific theory and its testable, falsifiable predictions.
Giotto provided the first evidence in support of Fred Whipple's "dirty snowball" hypothesis for comet construction; Whipple postulated that comets are icy objects warmed by the Sun as they approach the inner Solar System, causing ices on their surfaces to sublimate (change directly from a solid to a gas), and jets of volatile material to burst outward, creating the coma. Giotto showed that this model was broadly correct,[49] though with modifications. Halley's albedo, for instance, is about 4%, meaning that it reflects only 4% of the sunlight hitting it; about what one would expect for coal.[54] Thus, despite appearing brilliant white to observers on Earth, Halley's Comet is in fact pitch black. The surface temperature of evaporating "dirty ice" ranges from 170 K (−103 °C) at higher albedo to 220 K (−53 °C) at low albedo; Vega 1 found Halley's surface temperature to be in the range 300–400 K (30–130 °C). This suggested that only 10% of Halley's surface was active, and that large portions of it were coated in a layer of dark dust that retained heat.[15] Together, these observations suggested that Halley was in fact predominantly composed of non-volatile materials, and thus more closely resembled a "snowy dirtball" than a "dirty snowball".[16]
[55]


881 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 23 April 2018 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.

18 November 2010: The lies, failures and successes of Thunderbolts Deep Impact predictions by Wal Thornhill
2 December 2014: Sol88 does not notice that Wal Thornhill narrates an ignorant and deluded video about 67P!
18 December 2014: The bad science and delusions in Newton’s Electric Clockwork Solar System by Wal Thornhill.
5 January 2015: Wal Thornhill makes up fantasies about comets
10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.
13 April 2018: A couple of the delusions in Scott's Birkeland current paper.

The electric comet delusion has at least 45 years without a scientific electric comet model or observations to support it!

Getting lose to 3 years of the fear of doing basic physics: 25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.
 
Last edited:
EC postulated that comets are rocky objects immersed in the solar plasma of the Sun causing a charge differential as they approach the inner Solar System, causing dust to be electrostatically machined from the surface and form highly collimated jets of charged dust and neutrals to burst outward, creating the coma.


Just as quantitative as Whipples?

Not even close. For example, what voltage is necessary to machine the surface? What current is needed to produce the amount of observed dust? How does this machining produce water, and how much water can it produce?

You have nothing quantitative at all. In contrast, even the short summary of Whipple's paper contains multiple quantifications, and his full paper contains many more.
 
And Whipple gave you a quantitative model to work with? :blush:

Just so simple, Whipple said comets are icy bodies sublimating in the warmth of the sun. Electric comet says they are rocky bodies discharging in the solar plasma.

That’s it.

but your electric friends have bezillions of in situ data, which whipple did not have
so your friends need to up the ante and show their proof instead of just assuming
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom