Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hey Sol88, is there any reason why you keep avoiding answering simple questions? This thread is to talk about the "EC/EU" theory.

Just in case you can't remember:

Sol88, In your opinion / To your knowledge ...

01) Could any principles/physics of the electric comet be wrong? ... Yes/No
02) Could any principles/physics of the electric star be wrong? ... Yes/No
03) Could any principles/physics of the electric universe be wrong? ... Yes/No
04) Could every aspect of the electric universe be wrong? ... Yes/No
05) Does gravity play any part in orbital mechanics? ... Yes/No
06) Does gravity play any part in star formation processes? ... Yes/No
07) Does electrostatics/electrodynamics play any part in orbital mechanics? ... Yes/No
08) Does electrostatics/electrodynamics play any part in star formation processes? ... Yes/No
09) Are stars powered by nuclear fusion occurring in the core? ... Yes/No
10) Are stars powered by nuclear fusion occurring on the surface? ... Yes/No
11) Are asteroids made of rock? ... Yes/No
12) Are asteroids made of volatile ices and dusts? ... Yes/No
13) Are comets made of rock? ... Yes/No
14) Are comets made of volatile ices and dusts? ... Yes/No
15) Is sublimation (i.e., a state change from solid to gas) a real physical process? ... Yes/No
16) Is eccentricity important to comet charging and discharging processes? ... Yes/No
17) Is electric discharge machining responsible for terrestrial geomorphology (e.g., the Grand Canyon)? ... Yes/No
18) Does a magnetic field always indicate the presence of an electric current? ... Yes/No
19) Do you know where the water ice line is for our star at this point in its life cycle? ... Yes/No
20) Do you know what a sedimentary tidal rhythmite is? ... Yes/No

I am so looking forward to your expert answers, and your expert predictive mathematical model! Share with us your wisdom, Sol88! Show us the value of your electric comet!
 
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12252682#post12252682

why would dust not be negatively charged, who is expecting only positive dust?
dust gets charged in two ways, electrons sticking to the surface (so negative) or by uv radiation kicking off electrons (so positive)
in the end it all depends on the balance of the (dare i say it) currents to the particles which result comes out.

Mmmm...kinetic plasma effects play a dominate role in dusty plasma environment at a comet.
 
It's like herding cats with you Reality Check!

Was I correct in my assumption that MHD does not apply at comets?

No. You obviously can't read. I linked you to a 2006 paper that explained when it was appropriate to use MHD. Why don't you read it, instead of being wilfully ignorant?
 
is if you stand far enough back!! :jaw-dropp

When we zoom in on the nucleus we see NO COLLIMATED jets but when we zoom out...booya!!!

Not a problem for the ELECTRIC COMET but for a melting icydirtball....fatal!

Errr, and the constituents of the jet include solid ice? How is that not a problem for the electric woo? How is the total failure to see any electric woo, even when the spacecraft passes through an outburst, not a problem for the electric comet woo? You have zero evidence for any of this nonsense, and zero scientifically valid mechanisms. How many missions? How many years? And you are still batting zero. All you've got is the word salad, lies and obfuscation of conmen like Thornhill.
 
From just a few pages back!!! So do the thread a favour and go read those few pages where I argued MHD does not apply and the SUPER DUPER SPACE PLASMA PHYSICIST played coy, dam well knowing what was what!

You are an ingrateful little, aren't you?
MHD: field aligned currents, flux tubes, shocks
non-MHD: double layers
With "electrostatic shock" I guess you mean a discharge?

YOU, the mainstream, including plasma EXPERTS posting on this forum, were still arguing black and blue with me on the above point

Nope, not arguing with you, correcting you, however you are unable to actually learn.

But now ohhh... it happens but so what?????

WHAT is the IT that happens?

Well chumps, that's the electric comet, bang on right there!!!

Where?

KINETIC EFFECTS: Charge separation, Applied electric fields, Particle acceleration, Plasma heating, Plasma instabilities, Birkeland currents, Force free currents, electric circuits AND DOUBLE LAYERS etc etc....!!!

As yet, there have been no double layers found around the comet.
All the other stuff is just basic plasma physics, although ...
Birkeland currents are a specific current system in the Earth's magnetosphere
Force free currents do not exist

All from MHD being total CRAP at modelling REAL plasma/s!

Oh boy, you were so happy and kind when I explained what MHD was and when it is applicable.
And now as Mr. Hyde to your Jekyll you lash out again, which clearly shows again that you are unwilling to learn anything.
To quote a famous American person: "Sad!"


What do you want? You want me to do a full kinetic calculation for something that can, without any loss of generality, be done much more quickly by MHD?
Or do you want me to use MHD when I clearly cannot do so?
What?
And by the way where are the papers from the EC gang? Should they not actually write some real papers using the data from Giotto, Vega, ICE and Rosetta, which all can be found at [ulr=http://pds.nasa.gov/]NASA's PDS[/url] and ESA's PSA. The electric comet is there for you to be found.
 
Well chumps, that's the electric comet, bang on right there!!!

Errr, would this be the evidence-free woo that states:

Comets follow their elongated paths within a weak electrical field centered
on the Sun. In approaching the Sun, a charge imbalance develops between
the nucleus and the higher voltage and charge density near the Sun. Growing
electrical stresses initiate discharges and the formation of a glowing plasma
sheath, appearing as the coma and tail.

And;

The observed jets of comets are electric arc discharges to the nucleus, producing “electrical discharge machining” (EDM) of the surface. The excavated material is accelerated into space along the jets’ observed filamentary
arcs.

And;

Intermittent and wandering arcs erode the surface and burn it black, leaving
the distinctive scarring patterns of electric discharges.

And;

The jets flare up and move over the nucleus irregularly, leaving scars typical of electric discharge machining


About time we had some explanation of why this impossible woo failed to materialise, don't you think? And why this impossible woo isn't happening to asteroids, or on the Moon? What are you hiding from?
 
Plasma – Surface Interactions with Airless Bodies in Space and the Laboratory J.Deca(PI),X.Wang

Any ambipolar electric fields around 67/P, I wonder?

As you have already discussed this, I would say yes.

When those surface electric fields become strong enough to turn rock to dust and accelerate it away in collimated jets, what would we observe?

no

Is there a need any more for J. Agarwal's fictitious requirement for some sub surface energy storage? Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03 doi:10.1093/mnras/stx2386

yes, experiments in Braunschweig in the group of Jurgen Blum have shown that the parameters that Skorov used are most likely wrong by at least a factor of 3, which means that dust can be lifted from the surface. (shown at the Rosetta SWT a few weeks ago)

Now that MHD arguments is done and dusted, we can talk about REAL PLASMA PHENOMENA that CAN happen around comets!

Now that you have shown you are full of ****, why don't we discuss anything anymore
 
MHD equations that tusenfem was very coy in explaining or kinetic plasma equations that enable kinetic plasma effects that I've been banging on about since the start of the ELECTRIC COMET THREAD!

I am not coy, I have explained EVERYTHING into detail for you, the thing is YOU DO NOT LISTEN AND ARE UNWILLING TO LEARN ANYTHING ABOUT REAL PLASMA PHYSICS.
Do you use general relativity to calculate how long it takes for an apple to fall from the tree to the ground, or do you use Newton?
 
Sol88, 2018

All from MHD being total CRAP at modelling REAL plasma/s!

(As if he'd know what a plasma was even if he fell over one!)

And, from 2006, referencing even older work:

Finally, as outlined above, weak comets may not be well described by MHD mod-
els. In order to study the solar wind interactions with low production rate comets,
hybrid models have been developed. These simulations, which treat comets in the
kinetic regime, show the effect of cycloid motion of the picked up cometary ions
and the induced asymmetries (Lipatov et al., 1997, 2002; Motschmann and K¨uhrt,
2006). A recent application of hybrid models studied the transition of the cometary
environment from a kinetic-dominated regime to a fluid-dominated regime (Bag-
donat and Motschmann, 2002b) with specific application to comet 46P/Wirtanen
(which was the intended Rosetta target before the change to 67P/CG). The study
examines cometary ion structures as they transition from the classical bow shock,
diamagnetic cavity structure of strong comets to the cycloidal tail and non-line(a)r
Mach cones typical of weak comets. In this paper, we repeat a similar study for the
new Rosetta target, comet 67P/CG

The Plasma Environment of Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko Throughout the Rosetta Main Mission
Hansen, K. C. et al. (2006)
https://www.researchgate.net/public...rasimenko_Throughout_the_Rosetta_Main_Mission

And, of course, as far as the electric comet woo goes, it doesn't really matter how they modelled it, does it? What matters is what was observed and detected. And we can safely say that none of the physics defying woo quoted upthread actually happened. Game over.
 
Do you use general relativity to calculate how long it takes for an apple to fall from the tree to the ground, or do you use Newton?

Well, in the universe that Sol inhabits, you would need to specify the charge on the apple, and the charge on the Earth, and factor that into the fact that G is a variable, controlled by EM effects. Answer? It might fall upwards, we simply don't know!
 
yes, experiments in Braunschweig in the group of Jurgen Blum have shown that the parameters that Skorov used are most likely wrong by at least a factor of 3, which means that dust can be lifted from the surface. (shown at the Rosetta SWT a few weeks ago)

The abstracts from that meeting are downloadable, here:
https://www.cosmos.esa.int/web/rosetta-swt-49/schedule

Having had a read through them, I'm guessing the presentation Tusenfem is referring to is the one by Neuhaus, Gundlach & Blum;

Outgassing of CO2 /H20-ice mixtures through dust layers - an experimental approach


There is also an abstract from Küppers, et al (incl. Skorov), which looks again at the possibilities for the dust activity:

Ways out of the cometary activity paradox
 
And by the way where are the papers from the EC gang? Should they not actually write some real papers using the data from Giotto, Vega, ICE and Rosetta, which all can be found at [ulr=http://pds.nasa.gov/]NASA's PDS[/url] and ESA's PSA. The electric comet is there for you to be found.

No, no , no! That would be waaaaay too tricky. It must have taken me all of 90 seconds to get to the position where I could download the Giotto magnetometer data! Why bother, when you can just cherry-pick and obfuscate press releases?
 
1002 items of ignorance, idiocy, delusion and lies from 6 July 2009 to 21 June 2018

A spate of lies, etc. over the last few days needs to be recorded for prosperity. But we have to thank Sol88 for emphasizing yet again that all the electric comet has is ignorance, delusions, lies and deluded lies.

More than 980 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies from 6 July 2009 to 25 May 2018
  1. 18 June 2018: A lie that a "Rosetta’s tail excursion" paper is to do with his many comet delusions.
  2. 18 June 2018: Another lying question about the "A tail like no other" paper to detail from his many comet delusions.
  3. 19 June 2018: Yet another stupid question to derail from his many comet delusions.
  4. 19 June 2018: A "It’s all about education" lie when he is spreading delusions and lies about comets.
  5. 19 June 2018: Acknowledges that the electric comet is a delusion that cannot answer reasonable questions.
  6. 19 June 2018: Usual lying question to derail from his many comet delusions.
  7. 20 June 2018: Idiotic ranting about MHD to derail from his many comet delusions.
  8. 20 June 2018: An insult and his persistent lies about his electric comet delusions.
  9. 20 June 2018: Usual lying question (his electric comet delusions do not use "MHD equations or Kinetic Plasma equations")
  10. 20 June 2018: Cites an ices and dust paper again to detail from his many comet delusions.
  11. 20 June 2018: Lies about a paper again to derail from his many comet delusions.
  12. 20 June 2018: An insane and ignorant insult of J. Agarwal, et. al. scientific paper.
  13. 20 June 2018: Adds "surface electric fields making dust from rock to form collimated jets" to his comets being rock delusion.
  14. 20 June 2018: A really stupid question to detail from his many comet delusions (the answer was in my post).
  15. 20 June 2018: A lie that kinematic effects have appear before the last week or so.
  16. 20 June 2018: An insane lie that collimated jets are fatal for mainstream comets.
  17. 20 June 2018: An insane delusion that there is a "homogenous solid rock debate".
  18. 20 June 2018: Acknowledges his lie on mainstream production of jets with but another lie!
  19. 20 June 2018: A "opens a whole new world champ" lie about literally textbook plasma physics.
  20. 20 June 2018: A lie that a "Coma morphology" paper is mainstream production of all jets (coma is not jets!).
  21. 20 June 2018: Lying ion tail circuit question to derail from his many comet delusions (no circuit in his quote).
  22. 21 June 2018: Yet another lying MHD & comets question to derail from his many comet delusions.
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.

18 November 2010: The lies, failures and successes of Thunderbolts Deep Impact predictions by Wal Thornhill
10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.
13 April 2018: A couple of the delusions in Scott's Birkeland current paper.

The electric comet delusion has at least 45 years without a scientific electric comet model or observations to support it!

Getting lose to 3 years of the fear of doing basic physics: 25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.
 
Last edited:
yes, experiments in Braunschweig in the group of Jurgen Blum have shown that the parameters that Skorov used are most likely wrong by at least a factor of 3, which means that dust can be lifted from the surface. (shown at the Rosetta SWT a few weeks ago)
This is yet more of the real world that Sol88 denies.

We observe that dust is lifted from the surface of comet nuclei, especially in the close-up images of Rosetta, etc. Thus any paper that denies that there is any dust lifted (his usual lie about Skorov's paper) is wrong. The real conclusion of the paper is that in their model gas drag cannot lift all sizes of dust grains and thus there have to be other rational mechanisms. The other possibility was that there was an error in the model (unlikely) or in the model inputs. You supplied evidence that the parameters used were incorrect.

He cites Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03. This is an outburst, not the lifting which is the subject of Skorov's paper and definitely not Sol88's "collimated jets"!
Thus we have a viable mechanism for general lifting of dust from comet nuclei (gas drag) + a need for an explanation for this outburst which is supplied by the J. Agarwal et. al paper.
 
what do you think "kinetic effects" are?
please enlighten us

In this context, comet 67 but comet in general; charged particle(inc nanodust) acceleration, beaming or jetting of particles(inc nanodust), Particle heating, energetic particle trapping, strong electric fields and electric currents.

For instance.

Fair call, tusenfem?
 
Maybe you would like to comment
Another possibility is that this lull in singing power is caused by kinetic plasma effects.

What kinetic plasma effects are you talking about in the above quote from your paper?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom