The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Can you not read?

Yes, I can. I can also comprehend, which is a skill you seem to be lacking. Steenkh is telling you the same as I am telling you; that you are lying. You invoke a model that is outdated, and totally ignore all the papers written between then and now, and how understanding of the dust:ice ratio has evolved. It is a pathetic Thornhill type tactic. And he is an idiot. As is anybody who believes his Velikovskian woo.
 

LIAR.


That is a strawman of your own making. STOP LYING. It is getting pathetic.


So what is the non 1950’s Whipple dirtysnowball model are we now using?

I’m bloody well agreeing with you, the scientific modeling of comets is progressing or if you like evolving!!!

What are comets made of? At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving progressing more toward mostly rock

From the very bloke that bloody should know the difference between MOSTLY ICE and MOSTLY ROCK.

Just because he said MOSTLY ROCK and I’ve been nearly 10yrs banging on here at jref that comets are ROCK, shouldn’t mean that I’ve got to defend if he actually meant ROCK or ROCK(that is actually just a mix of the original models ice with some dust...the DIRTYSNOWBALL)

A’Hearn made the CRYSTAL CLEAR distinction between comets being made MOSTLY Of ICE or MOSTLY of ROCK!








Although it is kind of funny to see the ad hoc excuses a few posters here have come up with in defence. Carbonates in comets???
 
Yes, I can. I can also comprehend, which is a skill you seem to be lacking. Steenkh is telling you the same as I am telling you; that you are lying. You invoke a model that is outdated, and totally ignore all the papers written between then and now, and how understanding of the dust:ice ratio has evolved. It is a pathetic Thornhill type tactic. And he is an idiot. As is anybody who believes his Velikovskian woo.

I simpleton like you might think that, easy to see how. There’s that word invoke again, is this a new kind of scientific word? If you can invoke ice why can’t I invoke the original dirtysnowball model?
The second mechanism has been already suggested to explain the outbursts observed by the Deep Impact mission on comet 9P/Tempel 1 that appear to occur near sunrise on a particular area9, while extensive subsurface sources were invoked to explain the overall ambient outgassing as the observed area of exposed pure ice has a too-limited extent2.
doi:10.1038/nature14869

No, no no the real kick in the codley’s for the mainstream is the DOMINANT plasma/electromagnetic forces involved.

Mainstream have been “surprised” though seem to be somewhat stumped by a seemingly simple and straight forward process of ice sublimating in the heat of the Sun.
 
Last edited:
So what is the non 1950’s Whipple dirtysnowball model are we now using?

I’m bloody well agreeing with you, the scientific modeling of comets is progressing or if you like evolving!!!



From the very bloke that bloody should know the difference between MOSTLY ICE and MOSTLY ROCK.

Just because he said MOSTLY ROCK and I’ve been nearly 10yrs banging on here at jref that comets are ROCK, shouldn’t mean that I’ve got to defend if he actually meant ROCK or ROCK(that is actually just a mix of the original models ice with some dust...the DIRTYSNOWBALL)

A’Hearn made the CRYSTAL CLEAR distinction between comets being made MOSTLY Of ICE or MOSTLY of ROCK!








Although it is kind of funny to see the ad hoc excuses a few posters here have come up with in defence. Carbonates in comets???

Firstly, there is no rock at comets. Never been seen. Have I mentioned that before? And nobody here has been basing their arguments on Whipple's model, from a time when we had never been close to a comet. It is your strawman, and you have been arguing with yourself. It was known over two decades ago that comets were mostly dust. The ratio of that dust has been evolving. However, it is mainly based on JFCs. The ratio for Oort cloud comets could well be different, given that they spend far less time near the Sun.
 
o, no no the real kick in the codley’s for the mainstream is the DOMINANT plasma/electromagnetic forces involved.

Idiocy. It has nothing whatsoever to do with the outgassing of volatiles.
 
How did carbonates end up in a comet? Liquid water on a comet?



Give it a real go. Theve been known about since 2006 and conveniently swept under the carpet because that is NOT how dirtysnowballs form!

You cant answer this simple question because it's not in standard mainstream cometary models! i.e the DIRTYSNOWBALL.

More lying and ignorance.

Laboratory infrared transmission spectra of individual interplanetary dust particles from 2.5 to 25 microns
Sandford, S. A. & Walker, R. M. (1985)
adsbit.harvard.edu//full/1985ApJ...291..838S/0000848.000.html

In the previous section we showed that the 6.8 μm feature in at least one (and likely all) layer-lattice silicate IDP is probably caused by carbonates. We suggest the possibility that a component of the 6.8 μm feature seen in the spectra of protostars has a similar origin.
 
Firstly, there is no rock at comets. Never been seen. Have I mentioned that before? And nobody here has been basing their arguments on Whipple's model, from a time when we had never been close to a comet. It is your strawman, and you have been arguing with yourself. It was known over two decades ago that comets were mostly dust. The ratio of that dust has been evolving. However, it is mainly based on JFCs. The ratio for Oort cloud comets could well be different, given that they spend far less time near the Sun.

Not MOSTLY DUST not MOSTLY ICE but MOSTLY ROCK!

You are arguing with yourself, A’Hearns understand was evolving AWAY from Whipple’s and toward a new cometary paradigm.

What it is no one knows yet as the mainstream Dirtysnowball model is fluid and evolving.
 
Not MOSTLY DUST not MOSTLY ICE but MOSTLY ROCK! You are arguing with yourself, A’Hearns understand was evolving AWAY from Whipple’s and toward a new cometary paradigm
.

LIE.
 
Great progress, what is the mainstream model for comets then, champ? Just a quick overview highlighting the key points.
Why? We are discussing the Electric Comet here, which as far as I understand is completely busted. It does not suddenly become "unbusted" if science has not come up with a better model; but I believe that there is a better model, but it just is not within scope of this thread.

A'Hearn understanding had progressed/evolved towards comets being MOSTLY ROCK.
You sound like a broken record when you keep bringing a quote from a dead scientist that clearly need a context (like what he means by rock), and is not even from a research paper.

We need two models to be able to compare. The electric comet may not be right, in which case MAINSTREAM need another model to compare Whipple's dirtysnowball too!
Why do we need to compare anything in order to determine if the Electric Comet has any value?
 
You sound like a broken record when you keep bringing a quote from a dead scientist that clearly need a context (like what he means by rock), and is not even from a research paper
.

Precisely. And A'Hearn referenced that statement to two papers, neither of which are talking about anything other than dust.
 
Why? We are discussing the Electric Comet here, which as far as I understand is completely busted. It does not suddenly become "unbusted" if science has not come up with a better model; but I believe that there is a better model, but it just is not within scope of this thread.


You sound like a broken record when you keep bringing a quote from a dead scientist that clearly need a context (like what he means by rock), and is not even from a research paper.


Why do we need to compare anything in order to determine if the Electric Comet has any value?

Then what is our current understanding of comets? How has our understanding progressed since Rosetta began orbiting 67p?

They’ve dustier than expected?

But more or less as Whipple had stated MOSTLY ICE?

Like what he means by rock?????? What do you think rock means???

So define “comet rock”??
 
.

Precisely. And A'Hearn referenced that statement to two papers, neither of which are talking about anything other than dust.


So your happy to discredit A’Hearns years of research because it conflicts with your world view?

Unbelievable.
 
Why? We are discussing the Electric Comet here, which as far as I understand is completely busted. It does not suddenly become "unbusted" if science has not come up with a better model; but I believe that there is a better model, but it just is not within scope of this thread.


You sound like a broken record when you keep bringing a quote from a dead scientist that clearly need a context (like what he means by rock), and is not even from a research paper.


Why do we need to compare anything in order to determine if the Electric Comet has any value?

Why indeed.

Pony up then, don’t go hide behind your mommy’s apron.

This is the thread for it,

You claim I can not use Whipple’s model yet there is NO alternative.

Good science that.

You happy to INVOKE ice as well a ‘spose? :rolleyes:

We all agree the Dirtysnowball is dead.
 
I think your are under the delusion that some great big lightning bolt from the sun is going zap the comet.
 
You sound like a broken record when you keep bringing a quote from a dead scientist that clearly need a context (like what he means by rock), and is not even from a research paper.

What is the context by which A’Hearn said MOSTLY ROCK but he actually meant MOSTLY ICE.

I’m so dense and thick I need you to give me some sort of definition of “comet rock”.

What is this comets rock that consists of ...
amorphous and crystalline silicates, amorphous carbon, carbonates, phyllosilicates, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, water gas and ice, and sulfides

What are comets made of?
At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative
model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high
as 6 have been cited [3,4].


So what if YOU can not come up with a definition of what A’Hearns comet rock actually is, ROCK is ROCK.
 
Last edited:
Ignorant, lying and even insane items Sol88 has added to electric comet insanity

Sol88's comet delusions start with the deluded Thunderbolts cult insanity. Comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks;electrical discharge machining (EDM needs a dielectric fluid!) insanity.

Then we get his touches:
21 20 ignorant, lying and even insane items Sol88 has added to his cult electric comet insanity.
4 ignorant, lying and even insane items Sol88 has added to his cult electric comet insanity
Persistently lies about what other posters write

27. The insanity of repeatedly asking irrelevant, already answered questions.
For example, Deep Impact and Stardust showed that the dust from comets made of ices and dust has carbonate minerals that formed in space, and in the early solar system. His insanity says that is impossible :eye-poppi!
I wrote So the "clays and carbonates" dust forms in the early, inner, hot solar system, migrates outward to the early, outer, colder solar system where it forms into comets.
And he replied to that post with the actually insane question "How did carbonates end up in a comet".

28. Idiotic lying "swept under the carpet" paranoia about the known and documented presence of minerals formed in the hot, inner, early solar system minerals in comets.
Sol88 being abysmally ignorant and deluded about comets does not meant that other people cannot read about and understand comets.

29. Irrelevant, insane delusions about a "Plasma density structures at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko" paper
4.3 Concluding remarks
We have shown that the localized density enhancements reported by Eriksson et al. (2017) are common around comet 67P. Further more, they coincide with enhancement in the magnetic field and ion flux. These characteristics and their distribution in space are at least qualitatively similar to filaments emanating from the diamagnetic cavity in the hybrid simulations by Koenderset al. (2015).This study leaves some questions unanswered. Among these are the following.(i) Enhanced ion fluxes up to several hundred electronvolts as reported by Stenberg Wieser et al. (2017) coincide with the density and magnetic field pulses: the acceleration mechanism is unclear.
An unclear acceleration mechanism does not support his electric comets insanity. It does not magically turn comets into rocks, etc. :eek:!
He has an insane delusion of "current flowing from/to the surface".
He has an insane delusion that this paper refers to the comet surface (the diamagnetic cavity is many kilometers above the surface).
He persists with the insane delusion that we (e.g. jonesdave116 ) do not know the composition of comets (ices and dust with 2 recent results suggesting more dust than ice).

30. Sol88 has an insane obsession with double layers and is completely deluded about them and comets.
Double layers. The Debye length of the solar wind and comet coma gives hypothetical DLs a scale of ~100 meters. That would be insignificant. DL's cannot form around comets because the solar wind and coma interact to form a turbulent magnetic field. That mixes things up so that layers cannot form. As expected, no DLs have ever been detected at a comet. Even if they were possible and were detected, they have nothing to do with his electric comet insanity.

31. "Computed Electric Charges of Grains with Highly Irregular Shapes" paper insanity.
This is standard mainstream physics not his electric comet insanity.
 
Last edited:
Usual irrelevant and insane questions to derail from his electric comet insanity

How did carbonates end up in a comet? Liquid water on a comet?
Usual irrelevant and literally insane questions to derail from his electric comet insanity.

Liquid water was not found on a comet. Clays that formed in the presence of liquid water as expected for the hot, early solar system were found.
 
Last edited:
Idiotic lying "swept under the carpet" paranoia and usual lying

Theve been known about since 2006 and conveniently swept under the carpet because that is NOT how dirtysnowballs form!
Idiotic lying "swept under the carpet" paranoia and usual lying to derail from his electric comet insanity.

I can and have answered the irrelevant question about carbonates.

The known and documented presence of minerals formed in the hot, inner, early solar system minerals in comets has been part of the mainstream model since 2006.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom